Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

Why do americansthink that illegal immigrants are taking their jobs?
Find answers to your legal question.





Why do americansthink that illegal immigrants are taking their jobs?



    




afrochocobbw
There are no jobs that Americans won't do if they are paid at least minimum wage and are protected by American labor and employment law.

Cheap labor allows businesses to not hire naturalized americans and to outsource jobs. within a generation there will be no jobs for actual american citizens and then the economy will tank because no one will be able to buy anything.

Why do people assume that illegals are only doing the manual jobs? They are doing restaurant, hotel, construction, childcare, and any other job they are offered....not just produce pickers.

if Dynacorp can hire someone for 1 dollar, why would they hire you? or your son? or daughter?


sqwirlsgirl
Rating
I gotta go with Pancha on this one.....man I love her one liners!


Mandi
Because they are... I'd say the main (if not only) reason illegal immigrants come to America is to get a job.


Hot Pants
They are taking our jobs, working under the table, not paying taxes, but expect special favors.


JEFFBEV
Rating
Your question is phrased wrong. There are absolutely no jobs that Americans won't do. Americans however are not stupid enough to take jobs for pennies a day. Americans will not do the jobs for the wages that illegal Mexicans will accept.


PANCHA
Rating
It is an excuse for someone on welfare.


joeandhisguitar
who,s would it be if an illegal wasn't there?


♥ ♫ chancun à son goût ♥ ♫
The Americans who think that are, in most cases, wrong.

Illegal immigrants are taking the jobs that no one else wants to do, are not insured, and if they get killed on the job it's possible that no one would even know about it.

Blame the companies and corporations who hire the illegals--they are the ones who don't want to pay a decent salary or give any benefits.


roughlover4u
Rating
Come here in a legal manner and apply for citizenship. There are immigration laws, albeit not enforced, for a reason.


Linny
Rating
What part of "illegal" immigrants is so controversial!?

Naturalized Americans, even if they are from another country, I have no problem with, if they have something to offer this country. Other countries expect the same!! We as Americans need to care for our families through jobs that we need permits to have and taxes to pay. Illegals get all of our freedoms and rights with none of the sacrifice. That's wrong.


____kiss____ *AKA* lllkiss_of_deathlll
Rating
do you live here in mississippi evidentally not!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!... it isnt we dont want work it is because the employers see a way of hiring these people without paying them what they are required because thier not citizens and ofcourse the mexicans are going to do it for money to send back home.....those of you who dont think it is happing come live here for a month ok......then you wont be singing the same song...lol...


Mona
because they are!


barefeet561
Ummm, in your own words they are "illegal" therefore they are stealing from Americans if they are here working.


Breanna
Rating
I don't think they are.


DAR
In states that have few illegal immigrants, the same jobs are performed by Americans. Americans can't compete against illegal immigrants because not only will the illegal immigrant work for less, if he is being paid under the table the employer too is not paying employment taxes and benefits they have to pay for legal workers.

The people most upset about illegal immigration are the poor who would take the jobs if they paid what Americans consider a living wage.


saul_herandez
Rating
look at me am an illegal alien iam working at the ibm corporate headquater my brother pedro is the spoke person for verizon comunication also the chihuaha for taco bell is an illegal but since he was cheaper than the golden retriever he got the job


scottFL007
Because Americans have swallowed too much socialist propaganda. There is not a set, limited number of jobs. When more people come here, more jobs exist. It's silly to think of new immigrants (legal or illegal) taking jobs away from someone else. When new people come to the country, they also buy stuff here, which creates manufacturing jobs, food service jobs, healthcare jobs, etc. In a free enterprise environment, growth leads to more jobs. What is hindering growth in the illegal alien communities is that they can't create legitimate businesses because of their status. That's something that needs to change if we're to find a prosperous future. More freedom, not less...that's what America is all about.

I have the greatest respect for the people who are coming here for jobs. The ones I'm concerned about are the ones coming here for welfare handouts. However, I'm not keen on the idea of illegals getting here before the people who have applied to come here legally. I have no problem with deporting all the illegals (although it would be a logistical impossibility), but i would only support that if we simultaneously allowed the same number of thousands of new LEGAL immigrants to come in and replace them. Otherwise, we'd probably end up shutting down a good segment of our economy. You simply can't uproot millions of people and expect it to have no real effect. The only reason why the socialist-inspired Mayday protest had such little effect is because most immigrants are not blind followers, and the value their jobs and their families more than they value the confused protest movement.


victoradixon
I do not think Americans think illegal immigrants are taking their jobs since illegals do low-paying jobs; it's the opposite view that is prevalent as the feeling is that they do jobs that Americans do not want to do and thus they are an economic necessity.
There is another view that they are oversupplying the market with labor and thus driving down wages which is hurting American workers.
Different people have different views about this and therefore these views are only expressing different schools of thought.


country_boy1975
Rating
Its not the fact that there taking our jobs.Its that there doing it illegaly.Any human being should have the right to provide for his or her family.But doing it in a fashion that under minds the way of the country thats providing that job aint right.Do it right,pay your taxes,spend some of that money you made in that country in the country it was made as to keep its economy thriving so the next man or woman has the same opprotunities that was bestowed upon you.And by all means do it legally


always working
I lived in California for a long time and found that for the majority of the time illegal immigrants work jobs like picking fruits in horrible hot weather. Did construction jobs for about $1 an hour with no benefits. Basically the job really nobody would want to do. I feel they are not taking the jobs, But that they should not cheat about coming to this country. All I know is that I have alittle Native American Indian in me and I thought they were here first. So that makes most everyone in this country immigrants, right? Maybe everyone who says that they are taking the jobs should go out and get a job like they get, get paid nothing, try to feed their family and give their families a better opportunity. You know with out them doing jobs like they do alot of things that you like you just would not have.


caitie
Because the immigrants are working for an illegal wage. Like a normal trash collector earns a good wage, but illegals can work on half the wage easy. They are happy being paid. Here in America we want benefits and good pay; which is another reason jobs like telemarketer ar being outsourced.


The Killer Tomato
Because many americans can't think.

It is not as simple and just taking jobs. What jobs are being taken? How may people want to work on farms? How many people want to clean toilets?


camrynsdad2001
Personally Most don't (the ones that are educated anyway) I feel that this country is capable of allowing someone to start somewhere and provide for their family and prove themselves and become more stable and make a difference. If someone is willing to work for a wage than more power to them.


narrativeknight
Illegal immigrants are taking jobs away from Americans by not only working for lower pay but also by not working on the tax roles which can save business owners tremendous amounts of money in FICA taxes, health benefits and other things which hiring someone who is a legal resident does not allow them to do. The devalue the work of the lowest paying jobs which continues up the line so that all other jobs also pay less.


liracotten
Rating
Americans are lazy. dont want to do jobs that the Mexicans would do.Mexicans are hard workers for little pay to support their family's.and no I'm not Mexican my boyfriend well ex was Mexican.and he stoled my car last Sunday.point is Mexicans are hard workers.And need to let work





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 What do you think of this?
This is information was retrieved from INS/FBI statistical report on illegal immigration.

62% of all "undocumented immigrants" in the United States are working for cash and not ...


 When Hispanics take over will they make white people work in the fields, and be maids, etc?
...


 Why do people think someone hates America just because....?
they point out things that are hypocritical? I don't hate America, I just think that people are making a huge deal over Mexicans comming over. This country was built on immigration. I don't ...


 Don't you hate it when...?
when people who were born in america say that they deserve it and others don't?

i believe that people born in america are just plain lucky and thats that. they do not actually "...


 Uh-huh, and illegals aren't dirty?
If illegals pick all of our produce as you pro-criminals say, are they poisoning our lettuce and spinach supply?

E-coli breakouts.

There was a study done on Mexican food ...


 Can you see a time when Britains born in Britain are in the minority?
In a story about how the Government failed to plan for the impact of immigration on public services, particularly in relation to immigrant births, the following statistics are posted:

LIVE ...


 Is the undocumented workers only sin to want a better life for their families?
...


 Dose any one else have this problem,i am so attracted to Mexicans from Mexico i cant resist them i always?
stare at them if you have the same problem ,how do you deal wih it SERIOUS REPLYS ONLY PLEASE...


 At work a couple of my co-workers frequently speak in Spanish to one another. Would you consider this rude?
I work in a front office for a medical office where everyone works in an open environment, meaning we aren't in cubicles or individual offices - everyone can hear everyone speak. I'm not at ...


 Anyone tried the 'Britishness' test???
wow....i was looking at some of the questions on the 'life in britain' test and I can't answer the majority of them let alone someone who's applying for british nationality! and i ...


 Who is the problem? Illegal immigrants coming by the thousands daily, or is it the illegal employers of usa?
Oh I am sorry I meant legal employers, [illegal what a joke] can nobody see this?...


 Mexicans say that if it were not for illegal aliens like them, we would have no fruit or vegetables on our?
table. Do you agree? I think we could survive without all these illegal freeloaders, and we don't need them to pick our fruit and vegetabables. That is such a lame excuse, but I guess it's ...


 Why American think illegal immigrant don't pay taxes??
...


 I suspect my gardner is an illegal mexican. What should i do?
His name is ambrocio and hes a really good guy. I know he has family so i dont feel right about reporting him. We drink together sometimes and hang out after he fineshes my landscaping. thats ...


 Why do migrants pass through some of the most beautiful countries in Europe ie France, Spain, etc to get to ?
Britain? They risk their lives running through the channel tunnel, smuggle themselves inside lorries in death defying temperatures, they travel through the channel on boats in freezing temperatures.<...


 Do illegal aliens really believe that this country needs them for their hard work?
WE NEVER ASKED FOR THEM!
Only corrupt agricultural and livestock giants like tyson and natural foods will use thier labor as a way to increase profits to the big men..CEOs etc.. In reality there ...


 It mass immigration affecting our housing, education and social services?
http://uk.news.yahoo.com Details
I mean the overcrowded UK...


 How can illegals come here break our laws get amnisty welfare,housing,medical,s... and we pay more taxes?
my taxes keep going up, our schools keep getting overburdened with children of illegals ourcountry allows it and yet the cost of it all is paid by you and me.the working, tax paying, law abiding ...


 Nationalities?
what is your race....


 How the heck can legal immigrants who are NOT citizens vote?
I'm told that the current immigration bill would in the republican party because the legal immigrants would vote democrat so they get their free money (entitlements like welfare).

HOW...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.044