Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

Why is it black people/african-americans can call themselves black or african-american, but...?
Find answers to your legal question.





Why is it black people/african-americans can call themselves black or african-american, but...?

...when a mexican-american calls themself mexican-american, people get so offended? except black people/african-americans are free to call themselves black or african-american.

is everything people have been saying about this wrong? because if what you all say is right, then a black person calling themselves black means that the color black comes before america or that they have some special alligance/loyalty to the color black.
Additional Details
i call myself mexican-american and no one where i live has a problem its just the people on this site that have to be such ******* about it.

its my right to call myself whatever i want! it won't make me any less of an american.


    




DAR
Rating
Don't worry about it.

African Americans are not expected to wave the African flag, note. Most wouldn't know which one to wave. They are Americans and that is what they choose to call themselves. If you want to call your self Mexican American, fine. In this board I think people are just trying to take your pulse to see if you think you are American, with an honored Mexican tradition and background, or are a Mexican who just happened to be born here, but considers himself Mexican.

Mind you, it is none of their business either way.

You are not going to please everyone on this. Just please yourself.


lusaisthebest
Rating
people should be people.....

either you are an American or not....

my two cents.


Captain_Crunch
I truly dislike the word "African-American". Even the blacks hate it. They're just fine being called black. Like, "I'm a BLACK man, I have pride!" But...it's such a generalization. You don't hear about African Europeans, or African-Mexicans, or African Russians.


Laura D
I refer to myself as:

American of Mexican descent


Baby
its the same for every one, black don't mind being called black or African- American.only true with the ones that think they know it all. every one needs to get a life.nb


stealth_n700ms
Didn't you just ask this question? I believe I gave a book for my answer....

Chill out.. African-Americans did not choose to be here in the very beginning-- so it's only respectful to be specific. However, many and most prefer to be called American...

I know I didn't state that fact, and I'm sorry I left it out the first time, but, we did not ask for millions of Mexicans to come over here to introduce them to slave labor. They volunteered for it-- as they still are doing it...

--Rob


T
Relax pal, I've never known of anyone to get upset when people refer to themselves as Mexican-American. Where do you live?


Valerie
Rating
Oh, well, I'm a Mexican-American and nobody's offended.

I never even heard of anyone being called, Irish-American or Italian-American, or Mexican-American and getting offended by the title.

The only thing I can think of that may offend people is when someone calls themselves Mexican-American and they're here Illegally.. If they are here illegally then they aren't Americans.. You can't call yourself a Mexican-American until you're an American citizen.


JuJitsu_Fan
where in the USA do you live? First, I don't think one person would be 'offended' by Mexican-American. You must be hanging around inbred fools if that offends them.

Second, what does the term African-American have anything to do with you? That's comparing apples to oranges.


Mommalady
I'm mixed with black, Mexican, and white but I refer to myself as black because its who accepted me first and most of my family is black and we call ourselves black because we have never been to Africa and calling yourself black or African American has to do with religion as well as ancestry


Bad Kitty!
I've never heard of anyone getting offended by a Mexican-American calling themselves a Mexican-American. And I live in Texas, with lots of Mexican-Americans, as well as Black/African-Americans. My husband is a Puerto Rican-American (though he doesn't call himself that because all Puerto Ricans are already Americans), I'm an Irish-American, and I work with a Polish-American and a German-American. It's an ethnic and cultural roots-thing, has nothing to do with putting the ethnic group before America (who made that up?) and people just need to lighten up about it!! After all, the only people who didn't come here from somewhere else are the Native Americans ... and in some cases, the former Mexicans who lived in this area before America.


catzrme
Rating
I like Mexican-American. But, you know, why don't we all just call ourselves Americans? I do not call myself French American.


SmartyArty
There's nothing wrong when a Mexican citizen of this country calls himself Mexican-American. It's when illegals do that I start to wonder.


sassyk
Look, call yourself whatever you want. Just quit whinning. How would you react if I called myself a white-American. You then would call me a racist, I'm sure.
In other words take a break, would ya?


Common Sense
You are unfortunately correct...
They seem to want to be "black" before they are Americans..
I don't know why..
It isn't like we don't know what color they are...
As long as they continue to call themselves "black-Americans"
they will continue to be second class citizens...


S.A.M. Gunner 7212
Rating
I think the whole issue is a load. You are an American citizen or you're not. Categorizing yourself by your ethnicity is a form of separatism and lends a hand to racism.


P*Kitty
how about just saying "human beings"? and "black" people dont like to be called black because they arent, they are brown


Justsyd
Rating
I think you're stereotyping. You can't assume that all people do that. If you are a citizen of the US you are an American.


Yukaza
I too don't know why we don't all refer to ourselves as Americans,but it doesn't bother me to call people what ever they prefer to be called.I am American from German ancestry but I don't call my self German-American,I know my history and why would others care.I don't understand the hyphenated Americans identification but as I said if that makes all people happy I will do it .I respect all people and its their right as it is yours to be called what ever you feel best about
Back in the US history people were called derogatory names by stupid people,those names became synonymous with bigotry,so when African Americans gained their full civil rights in 1969 the people threw away those names and used black as a proud new unity name,Black Power,Black Pride etc,as time passed and people changed the symbolic names changed and now the term is African American,that may change as the years pass too .Again I am just an American,but I respect your rights as to your name of choice.
I just want the illegals to get out of this country and come in the legal way get legal or don't come here.


yoohoosusie
Cause most black people are just anal about their names...I don't get it! American is American

Illegal is Illegal
Legal is Legal


volleyballchick
Rating
I don't care what you call yourself. If you are here legally, then call yourself a Mexican American. Call yourself "Ishmael" if you like. I don't care. Just make sure you follow the laws of the land if you would like to be called an American. . .

I also refer to everyone as a person. The color of their skin is irrelevant. People are people. That is it.


nuclear farter
Rating
next year it'll be illegal to call yourself a white hispanic of undecided gender with a preferance for rap music. you'll have to call yourself or oneself a minority in the majority with a liking for rap but in no gender ranking prioity of spanish american extraction. d'ya know what im a paddy and feckin proud of it.


Charisma
Rating
As long as your a legal citizen i don't care if you call your self and A Mexico African American. And I'm not raciest, i look at it like this i hate all of you motherfuc*ers equally, white, black, purple green, People are annoying!!!


maxima
Why are we afraid of true terms? Black,white,yellow and brown are colors that describe skin. "Black" American should only further describe an American. If you were born in Ethiopia and became an American citizen, YOU'RE AN AMERICAN.. these hyphens are a bunch of divisive garbage.


It'sMe23
I don't get it, ur talking in circles. Who cares what anyone is calling themselves. Get over it!


it was awful
are you a mexican/american???..... I don't get offended.. and yes, you got a point there, ............ don't know what else to tell you!


tripledigit
Rating
They are not African Americans, what the hell is wrong with you? Did the toilet seat hit you in the head when you were getting a drink?


The Rock
Rating
I consider myself a American first of Mexican ancestry. People will always look at your skin and judge you. In my situation I am an American whom does not speak Spanish. So it is twice as hard. I am disseminated by two cultures. It's exhausting!


caysdaddy04
I've never been offended by someone referring to themselves as a Mexican-American, as long as they are the American part. If they're here illegally, they are most certainly NOT an American.

However, most ethnic groups self-segregate by putting their race or national origin in front of American. For example, I am a Korean-American (or Asian-American, if I'm being more general). I don't use that term very often, as in my personal opinion, I am simply an American. But I am proud of my Korean heritage as well, and I have no problem with any Mexican who is an American citizen being proud of their Mexican heritage.


ShanniC
I have never known anyone to get offended at hearing the term Mexican American. I don't see anything wrong with it. The reason why we call ourselves black because this term is much less offensive than colored.


Juicy.Couture
Rating
i'm not sure i fully understand your question. but i think you should call yourself whatever you want. what did you mean "when a mexican-american calls themself mexican-american, people get so offended"? which people -- 'mexican' people or 'white' people.

p.s. if it makes you feel any better i would't get offended if you referred to yourself as mexican-american





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Should I rob a bank because it is easier that work?
So if it is too hard to come here, why do illegals break the law?
We all got troubles, no excuse to break the law.
Shameless....


 Can I live in Britain and claim asylum and get lots of money, free house, free everything, without working?
...


 As an english person, do I have any right to protest against the amount of immigrants in my country,?
I want to start a campaign to say Enough is Enough. I do not want any more immigrants in this country. We cannot afford them, we don't want them. I don't care what has happend to them in ...


 What fun signs would you like to put at the border?
to keep would be law breaking criminal illegals out?...


 What can we do to stop racism aginst mexicans.?
the white devils hate us and want us to leave. what can we do to make them understand they arewrong and make us leave our northern land they stole from us ?...


 What's the first thing that comes to mind with the word 'immigration'?
...


 Do you think that as citizens of the US we should have to deal with the stupidity of mexicans?
...


 What would you do if you had 2 children and a wife and you only made $50 a week?
working 9 hrs. a day? If your child gets sick, you might run the risk of him/her dying because you cant get any sort of medical attention. But then you try to apply for your legal permit to work ...


 What do you think when you walk past people in the street speaking polish?

Additional Details
sorry. Polish!!!!!!!!! what is this a punctuation exam or sth? jokes about Mr Sheen are just not ...


 Why do white people think this is THEIR country?
I AM WHITE! I am ashamed of what my ancestors did to the Native Americans who lived here thousands of years before we came here only a few hundred years ago - mostly as ILLEGAL immingrants I would ...


 Do you relly think illegal immigrants come here thinking "I want to break the law"?
or is it more like "I'm going to find a job!" and give me and my family a better life. I really don't think they come here to purposely annoy us and I think they would do it the ...


 Should immigrants pass a basic english test before being granted citizenship?
so many immigrants seem to have little or no understanding of the english language,should the government bring in statutory classes for non english speaking immigrants?...


 Why are immigrants are stealing our jobs?
that is soo ...


 Do you agree, only those with an absolute loyalty to America should have the right to be here?
Many on this site feel an entitlement to be here. Something that they falsely believe...a fairy tale of sorts. The truth is there is NO entitlement to be here...none....if you are not legally here ...


 Why do people hate Immigrants SO much!!!!!?
Why is there so many hateful people why can't we just get along!!!...


 Jobs British people won't do?
So according to the pro-open-borders crowd, we "need" mass immigration because British people "won't do" certain jobs.

We are, supposedly, either all highly ...


 Illegal immigration:whos responsible?
whos responsible; if illegals are working to support themselves who do you hold responsible and what,do we do? when do we start/?/?can we go back and start arresting congressional members for failure ...


 Fellow Americans; what is your view of all these British immigrants coming over here?
Honestly, these Brits seem to think that because they can't look after their own nation, they can come over here and feed off our country. We let people in that are genuinely persecuted (...


 Why as an english person,do i feel second class in my own country?
anyone know that feeling? im all for multi-culture but not when they are getting so much out of our country(benifiets,housing etc...) that we have worked and paid taxes for....


 What country has the most ignorant people?
state your answer and the country your ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.084