Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

Why should we care?
Find answers to your legal question.





Why should we care?

I'm seeing a lot of post where people are saying that illegal immigrants want to come here because they want a better life and how would we feel if we were in their situation. I want to ask them, why are we expected to care? Why should we deal with Mexico's problems? America has their own set of problems to worry about and I think it's time to just give them the cold shoulder, what do you think?


PS: These immigrants from Mexico are in no way living as poorly as the poor people in Africa.
Additional Details
That's the point woody we don't care to give them jobs any more either. You have overstayed your welcome.


    




Mz. America
Mexico is trying to rid themselves of their poor people. Trying to send them all up this way for us to take care of them. They even have the nerve to be hypocritical about our laws.


Tony S
My grandparents came here over 100 years ago. Just like today's immigrants, they wanted a better economic future for themselves and their families. But... here's the big difference.. my grandparents wanted to become Americans. Forsaking the life they were leaving for dreams that went beyond their economic betterment. They wanted to contribute to their new country, in addition to taking from it.

I don't hear much of that kind of talk any more in the current discussions.


RM
Sounds to me the Mexicans want to claim back their land.


Zoe
Rating
I just wish Mexico would worry the same way they do here about their people in Mexico and make a sincere effort to fix their problems but as it is Mexico gets a free ride. It's time for Mexico to confront their problems and fix them sending people here only allows the country to ignore any problems it has . Yeah it is time to shut off Mexico and force them to address their problems instead of their wallets


Double 709
Rating
We can´t possibly take care of the entire world´s poor, but many people refuse to accept that reality. We can feel sympathy for these people but there is nothing we can do in most cases, and if we can do something it is only at a small level. We have enough of our own problems and need to solve them first before looking abroad. Everyone thinks the US is the richest country in the world but we have a multi-billion dollar deficit and countries like Switzerland and Austria are richer. Why isn´t anyone on their cases?


chris
Rating
The answers to these questions aren't that simple. Imagine that you work in a hospital in Central California. People come into the hospital, many injured, some are having children, others are sick. You know that they aren't legal citizens because they can't provide any real proof of it. You also know that it is highly unlikely that they can pay for the healthcare because of the sheer price and the fact that illegal residents don't have insurance.
Would you seriously turn down aid to these people? Even if you would, that isn't how our hospitals will ever work. Read the Hippocratic Oath for proof of that.
So even if you don't care, somebody still has to foot the bill when the hospital is nearly bankrupt.


jake
The U S A, sends poor countrys $$$$$$$$$$, and are they thankfull, oh no they ask, how much more can we get. Maybe its time to stop caring so much, and high time we cared about our own poor. I wish I knew why those from Mexico have this, how much can you give thing. ---------- mendi, did you just in a way tell all of us that, the rich in Mexico do not read or live by the Bible ?


marieandlucaspape
Right on! I'm not in their situation so why should I care. it's those danm bleeding heart liberals. The lot of them make me sick! Mexico has done it to themselves!


Yukaza
Rating
Out of all the nations in the world,there are 83% that have more poverty than Mexico.
I can no longer be swayed by the oh poor me BS and the sob stories the media pushes at us with their tales of woe.
The bias media has tried its lying best to change public opinion about illegals with this nonsense.I for one am no longer impressed or concerned.My compassion,my respect,my efforts and my tears are for my nation the USA and its legal American people.


Crazybird
I agree. We are not the saviors of the world and it's not our sole responsibility to fix it at our own demise. With the amount of graciousness we have received from this group.....I'd be more inclined to load up a few ships and bring them in from Africia while some of these guys were on a bus back south.


I.M.
How about we should care what goes on in Mexico and its development so not as many Mexicans would cross the border into ours?


rubudown67
Rating
I for one,am sick of it!! I applied for a state job the other day and passed all the criteria except for one:I don't speak Spanish! When is this **** going to end? Mexicans can scream about discrimination all they want and get anything they DON'T NEED.

Why should I be forced to learn another language to get a better job?


jazzcid
you should not care, let the INS care about it.!


mattinhoustontx
Another word out of you, and you'll be hanging upside-down with a fork in your ***!


Mendi8a
because we are supposed to care about others, i think its in the bible. we should help Africans too. Country lines should not seperate us as much as they do.


Mary g
Rating
You sound very hard....I really can't believe you are.

Yes, we do have a lot of our own problems but weren't
we put on this earth to help as many as we can and not hinder

The Mexicans are not presenting a real problem as are the
threats from the middle east. 9/11 was not the fault of the
Mexicans and this to me is the biggest pain I have felt ever.
My fellow Americans being murdered, and those trying to prevent
the same situation from happening again being highly criticized.

My grandson in Iraq trying to protect our homeland and yours
worries me. This is only the beginning of some of my rhetoric.
of course, I expect someone writing to this that I am this and
I am that. That's another problem, everybody demands respect
but offer none to other. Thanks for listening.


Zapata
Rating
YOU should not, Mexicans are only asking for jobs and not handouts like you or most Americans on welfare.


SittinPretty
Rating
People are saying this because for most illegal immigrants it is true. However, you dont have to care. Nobody is asking you to care about their plight, the reason you are reading this though is because you obviously care about the illegal issue. You pick and choose what you care about, you choose to care about Africa, I choose to care about Mexico for obvious personal reasons.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 If people move to the U.S should they have to speak english?
Do u think that people from other countries should have to speak clear english when they move to the U.S??...


 Carlos Mencia is opposed to illegal immigration. Is he a racist?
...


 Honestly dont lie what is the first thing you think of when you see a Illegal immigrant?
IT wont hurt to tell the truth????...


 A question,Do Americans see whats happening to our country yet?......?
Swift meat packing plant is a joke really,if you can see the rest of the picture? Hello,we got Americans loosing rights to their land to their freedoms,to our children.If you want to wait for ...


 Would Chip implants for people getting deported help slow down illegal immigration ?
SafeGuard: it would only active if those criminal illegal aliens try to re-enter the U.S....


 Wasn't this country built on immigration ? Now that im in the military I feel sick I fight for racist people.
...


 Will i get in trouble for marrying an illegal immaigrant?
i want to get married to someone who is illegal and we have our marriage license but we don't want to get in trouble. can we do this and be okay?...


 Do you think immigrants (illegal) should get EQUAL rights as American citizens?
First lets look at contributions...tax wise, we american citizens (native or temporary) pay taxes and dump are share into the crack pot system we live in LOL Money circulation wise, we legal ...


 What do you think He thinks about illegals?
I have a question for all believers in this matter of illegal immigration. What do you think God (whatever denomination/belief you are) thinks about illegals? Is there any place in the Bible or your ...


 Who would pick all the crops if the undocumented workers are deported ?
...


 Can you believe that a Mexican doesn't mow my lawn????
Yep, I do it myself. I even pull the weeds from the flower beds.
Additional Details
Mazzygrl you obviously failed to see my point about the whole "jobs Americans wont do."...


 Compare early immigrants to recent immigrants?
can you guys help me to describe how the early and the recent immigrants differ with each other? or maybe the differences and the similarities of their experience from then til now....


 All of you anti immigrant advocates are idiots, you keep saying that illegals take more than they give?
Have you actually looked at the real facts;

Millions and Millions of illegal immgrants pay taxes and the unacounted for ones using someone elses ss card are too paying taxes, what you ...


 Am unemployed, no job on site Thrown out of house due to rent alias. have hungry family at had ,pls advise,?
Am unemployed, no job on site Thrown out of house due to rent alias. have hungry family at had ,pls advise,?
I ...


 Your views on illegal immigration?

Additional Details
let me add some details.

my boyfriend and his family are from iran and came to the US "illegally." we are both FOR illegal immigration (whether ...


 What is mexico's biggest import?
...


 Can we buy land legally in Mexico if we are American citizens?
Maybe they just need some leadeers down there. S...


 Please read the job that i was offered.. Doesnt this sound illegal or like money laundering?
We have found your resume at Monster.com and would like to suggest you a "Transfer manager" Njli Nj

vacancy. We have studied your resume and are happy to inform you that your ...


 What is an American to you?
...


 As a republican who stands strong against illegal immigration who would my ideal presidential candidate be?
...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.034