Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

Why should we give rights to illegal Mexicans here when we suffer the same abuse when we travel to Mexico?
Find answers to your legal question.





Why should we give rights to illegal Mexicans here when we suffer the same abuse when we travel to Mexico?

Honestly, how many of us have gone into Mexico and have been robbed by local police?? I can't own property, if I stay to long they will forcably kick me out of the country. If I do become a Mexican National I can never become a Judge or hold any kind of offical office. So why do we bend over backwards for such a crappy trade off??


    




sharkinthewater
Rating
Here's my friends idea, and I really like it so I am adopting it.

For every hard working, illegal mexican in the country with an underpaying job that no one else wants we take two otherwise healthy, physically capable american citizen adults who are wasting my tax money by being too lazy to be employed and just surviving on welfare, or crime, or something else nonproductive and ship them to Mexico as an exchange. I think thats a really fair trade.


ducky
I have been to Mexico many times and have Never been robbed by anyone.
I know people who have bribed police to get out of trouble they caused themselves - but that's not the same as being robbed.


Emm
I've been to Mexico several times and let's just say there is nothing to complain about. Maybe you should just stop going and stop complaining about it.


Sergio D.
first off, i've been to mexico on vacation a few times and i have never been robbed once. the same goes for my family, my cousins, and everyone that i know that has ever visited mexico.

second, that sort of corruption you are referring to is the same sort that the immigrants want to escape. i thank you for acknowledging it. some might deny it.


dont know much
Rating
You think you have problems with imigration try living in Britain


LeighAnn D
If you don't like it, then don't go!Btw ,2 wrongs don't make a right!


Siervocal
Rating
Waaaaaaaaaaaaa whiny American, get a life.


RicMon87
Then don't go, and then, don't complain about it.

It amazes me that people actually use their brains to put two different things/ideas together to ask a pointless question.


B.Kevorkian
Rating
Two wrongs don't make a right. America, at least, to the degree that it stick's to it's Constitution, is committed to equal protection under that law. You don't get to abuse someone simply because of thier ethnic background, nor even thier legal status. While illegals can and should be deported, thier human rights are still protected, as least as long as they're here...


Bob Lahblah
Rating
You should see how horribly Mexico treats their Southern border illegals. Mexico has nothing to complain about us. Their government is the epitome of hypocrisy.


Eagle1 Fox2
Rating
First off, I can respect your opinions and I am sure that you have a just reason to feel this way. I would probably feel indignant too if I was robbed, though it should be directed at the individuals who did it rather than a nation as a whole.

Aside from that though, it is not really a "trade off" as you put it. It is the fact that we as Americans have a duty if you will to be humane. In Iraq, they are cutting off the heads of our citizens and soldiers as a practice, but aside from a few bad eggs, we do nothing in comparison to what they do. They do not follow the Rules of War and many feel that we should not either because of it, but you know what... we are bigger than that. We are a people who feel that it is better to be doing the hard right over the easy wrong.

In other words, it is our obligation to help out those less fortunate than us. Not trying to be rude, but just saying that by your logic, we should rob and treat inhumanely every illegal that comes across the border that we catch?


Agent 99
Rating
Mexicans come here to work, and Americans go to Mex. to lay on the beach. big difference.
plus, no one is forcing you to move to Mexico. apparently you hate Mexico. so why are you complaining?


allusian_fields
Rating
actually, you suffer MORE.

If you are a Mexican citizen, but non-mexican born - you'll still be a 2nd class citizen when it comes to property, jobs, etc.

And god forbid you take part in a rally or a protest.

For the life of me, I have never been able to figure out why the USA seems to bend over backwards for Mexico. They aint sharing that oil with anyone...


AveGirl
Rating
I just think everyone should realize that ALL countries have immigration laws that are to be followed. I don't get why they come here and think they don't have to follow these laws. We as citizens have to do some of the same sort of things. Like paying fees or fines for everything, getting state IDs, getting fingerprinted if you apply to government jobs, getting shot records for your kids, etc. That is the way it is here and if you want to live here, you have to do it too.


El Chile
that is a bunch of lies I personaly know at least 10 couples of gringos living in San Miguel De Allende ,Guanajuato,Mexico, and they bought houses there and live under their retirement checks and No they are not Legally in Mexico , and no one cares , if you got robbed in Mexico there is a little office called Embassy, I hope you know what that is , you file a complain in that said office . and why do you want to become a judge there , if you can not even solve your own problems here DUDE. good day.


Daniel F
I have seen Americans desrespect Mexican law, And bribe their way out of it. then call it corruption, I have seen your daughters actions that they do not respect themselves, If you do not like it don't go.


xcelix
Seems to me like you really looked into becoming a Mexican. Cool.


foreveri<3atl
Rating
right on, and why should i press 1 for english?


Bobby D
Because many Americans have no back bone, and would sell out the whole country. It's not going to get any better anytime soon either.


jenniferjohnson2008
Rating
Ask your Republican government, who claims to be against illegal immigration.


Bottom Contributor
Rating
we should also do genocide since some countries do that. your a genius.


inferno_queen001
Rating
Well firstly don't call them illegals because they are people just like us.2.Its our fault they are here in the first place.Some time ago the us opened the border for the Mexicans could come through now they are closing the borders because they are stupid.3.Have you ever wonder who are those people working on the fields you pass by?Mexicans!!!!They are the ones who pick our food and without them where will we be?hink about that.


Robert M
We should not, but not just for that reason.

Who is going to pay for all of them that are here now???
We feed them they get schooled and medical with out paying for it.

So I say have them warm up those strollers pack the kids and make them walk home.


Yafooey!
Mexico is probably holding a long vendetta, because they gave up Texas to save a Mexican Army leader's life. Sorry, I don't remember his name. Anyway this goes back to the days of the fight over the Alamo.


FREAKZILLA
because the liberals dont want anyone to feel uncomfortable , regardless of the consequences


Mando
You just answered your question. The abuse is not the same. It is going to be alot worse.


ana
Rating
This is a good question that I don't have an answer to


bobby u
Rating
I would not go to Mexico anyway. Why should you vacation in a third world country? It does not matter anyway. We should not give rights to any illegal alien whether they are from Mexico, Russia or anywhere else.


Kitty, Kitty Cat
Rating
here, fuucking, here on the that! I totally am picking up what you are throwing down...in other words, i agree whole heartedly with this question.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Mexicans are always saying that they were here first.............?
No they were not....the native americans were. The mexicans as we know now were not even in Mexico first... the native Mexicans indios were. The Mexcians as we know now are all mixed blood . The ...


 Canada or america?
Hi please can any one give me genewine reasons about if canada is better than america or is america better than.canada.am confused.whcih 1 ...


 Should illegal immigrant workers get legal working status in the U.S.?
...


 Why are anti illegals trying so hard to prove they are not racist?

Additional Details
Some of you need to learn to read, I didn't say anti illegals were racist....


 Why the american hate the mexican?
...


 Would you be in favor of a Nationwide ID card program?
I would imagine that there would always be those people who forget theirs, lose them, etc.

I think that would cause headaches, but anything to help end illegal immigration....


 I'm sorry if my question offended you. Please will help tell me why it was offensive so it won't happen again
I just recieved a violation for inciting hatred and violence. I did not realise that my question did that .. So I make big apologies for all those I offended. It was not my intention to upset anyone.....


 United Statesians, you say to Mexicans "get out of America", but Mexico is in America, where should they go?
Europe? Africa? Asia?
Additional Details
Did I said to someone that I am an immigrant?...


 Why is it that every other country can come to america but mexicans can't?
people have a problem with illegal immigration, but what you dont realize is, there wouldnt be a problem if they didnt have to fight for the same opportunity that everybody else has. mexicans are ...


 Would it be a good idea for the US to do to Mexico what it has >?
done in Iraq?The more I think about it the better it sounds.A major problem in Mexico is infrastructure.Alot of places don't have running water or decent roads.Why don't we go help out M...


 Should we grant conditional legal status to undocumented workers with good moral character and 5 years in US?
...


 Why do minorities make up the majority of prison populations?
Yeah,you can call this panchas stupid question of the day....


 Why the minuteman are so coward, and why do they refuse to love Democracy and learn a second language?
What kind of retograde ideology to this project called minuteman have?
Who pays them?...


 What are your views on illegal immigration?
most people dont offer up opinion because they dont want to deal with it at all. I feel for the people who have to cross the border, but when they send non taxed money back to their country it doesnt ...


 If someone is against illegal immigration does that make them a racist?

Additional Details
I'm torn on this issue because how could someone not want someone else in there country without being racist. If it were white people coming to this country from ...


 Why are some people hating Mexicans so much but they love our food?
It dont make sense to me. if u hate us so much then stop eatin and buyin the things that we make....


 What state has benefited the most from having undocumented workers?

Additional Details
Wow, I'm getting honest answers, did the racists take Friday off from the site?...


 Whose with me?
well done to Nick Griffen and the BNP,today you won a victory for free ...


 What are the criteria for being British?
...


 No illegals are you willing to pay $ 100 for lettuce $500 lb oranges $200 lb tomatoes $600 lb strawberries?
...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.074