Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

Would you like to see a law making English the country's official language ?
Find answers to your legal question.





Would you like to see a law making English the country's official language ?



    




scarlettt_ohara
Rating
Yes I would. I was born and raised in Europe and my first language is French. I do not expect administrations to provide me with documents in French nor do I expect them to provide me with translators if I have to go to court or to city hall.


argawarga
It would be interesting to see President Bush required to learn the language.


zes2_zdk
why not?
When someone immigrates here and refuses to learn the language..
what they are saying is....
"why should I learn English?...I can demand they put up signs that I can understand."
AT SOMEBODY ELSES EXPENSE....of course.


? Dirty Martini ?
I move approval.

Second anyone?


The Nikki
Yes, I think it would solve a lot of problems. I realise that America is a nation of immigrants, but there's a lot of wasted paper because forms have to be printed out in 2-3 languages. I know in Michigan for example, all government papers are written in English, Spanish, and Arabic by default. I wouldn't mind English being the official language, and if someone wants to speak in a different language, more power to them. I just think it's dumb that Americans are being prosecuted because they make signs in their stores that say 'please speak only English' I mean it's their store, if someone has a problem with that, go to a different place.


Racist Answer Man
Rating
Yes! Yes, yes, yes! Silly? Remember, we didn't think we needed a law to define marriage as a relationship between a man and a women. Even former Sen. Inouye (sic) from Hawaii supported this. If we're going to make Americans out of these illegals slopping over our borders we can at least start with forcing them to learn English.


maydaybaby
I don't think a law would be appropriate, however visitors/residents of other countries should not expect us to speak their language as a primary means of communication in our country. Many places already cater too much to foreigners, by offering bilingual services- such as in our public school system.


eldude
Rating
Yes. People think that an official language means that is the only language people are allowed to speak. People sometimes make me feel sad when I hear these things. Anyway, the reason I want to see an official language. is to defend the rights of people who work with the public. Like, police officers who do not speak the native language of every single person in the USA. So when someone comes here and wants to start trouble and doesn't understand the words "stop or I'll shoot" the cop doesn't get in trouble for shooting someone because they didn't understand him. The burden should be on the person who does not take it upon himself to learn the language and the customs. Not the person defending the public to learn the language of places he is not even at.


Kawaii
Most nations with official languages also take into account indigenous languages and larger minority languages. I don't think we need an official language. Heck, the US managed to make English the 'unofficial' language of the world.


emenbensma
What difference would it make? It already is. The additional languages to help new immigrant citizens participate comfortably in our society are part of what makes our nation great.
Note the words inscribed on the Statue of Liberty:
The New Colossus

Not like the brazen giant of Greek fame,

With conquering limbs astride from land to land;

Here at our sea-washed, sunset gates shall stand

A mighty woman with a torch, whose flame

Is the imprisoned lightning, and her name

Mother of Exiles. From her beacon-hand

Glows world-wide welcome; her mild eyes command

The air-bridged harbor that twin cities frame.

"Keep ancient lands, your storied pomp!" cries she

With silent lips. "Give me your tired, your poor,

Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free,

The wretched refuse of your teeming shore.

Send these, the homeless, tempest-tost to me,

I lift my lamp beside the golden door!"


RedWhite&Blue
Rating
It is the official language, only 300 million people speak it


Dee N
It's too bad a question like this should even have to be considered. English has always been the unofficial language. But, unfortunately we have to put into law what has always been to protect what America is. Just think of the billions of dollars that will be saved not having to print everything in so many different languages.


?
Rating
Not only yes, but HELL YES!!!!!


Raiden
Rating
yes i would love to see that


ProUSA2
Rating
It doesn't matter if you made "pig latin" the "official" language of the United States. It would be merely be a formality.

Our business affairs are conducted in ENGLISH. Our common language is English. We have millions of immigrants in the country, whose native language is from dozens of different countries. The common denominator is English. It would best behoove all immigrants to learn English so as to be able to communicate with the majority of the population.
American citizens will not learn THEIR languages to communicate with them. That would literally be impossible.


hansblix222
Rating
No, I'm not threatened by people speaking other languages.


luckydog
Rating
Of course, but only if I was living in England, or the U.S.A. but not if I was living in Spain, or France.


FOA
yes


Sweet Tea & Lemons
Heck YES


▪ώhiteÄırl▪®
Rating
Yes.


ebmid2
Yes. But I don't care very much.


bakerman516
No Habla inglés


summermoondancer2004
I don't think it would be constitutional since one of the rights of the bill of rights is freedom of speech not only that it fails to recognize other dominate languages and indigenous languages that have been around longer in this country than English.
Cajuns, Indians and generations old Hispanics probably would disagree I know I do.
After all what would it accomplish? Nothing.


MEX+USA
Rating
Why whats the point!!!!!!>>>>>>>>>Everything is in English already !!!! Why do we need it to be Official!!


Ohio State for ever
Rating
I would like to see all the right wingers go away, so things that are really important can be discussed.


Sergio D.
Rating
no. that would completely devastate some people's lives just for the sake of convenience of english-speakers.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 The issue is "Having"to learn Spanish not as a choice?
I speak 3 languages fluently.And am learning Spanish.But that's my CHOICE.Do you think you should HAVE TO learn Spanish?

That's the point I think I see people trying to make on ...


 Has anyone seen this?
The majority are "just here for a better life?" What about the ones like this? Am I supposed to feel sorry for these menaces?8/3/2006

by William Gheen of Americans for Legal I...


 Do you think a wall on the border is really going to work to stop illegal immigration?
I think we should close off our borders with Mexico too. I mean we should have both things, borders closed and border fence. That's really going to stop illegal immigration!...


 Will a border fence and an increased gestapo border patrol actually solve the immigration problem?

Additional Details
In a country that prides itself in an ideology that all men are created equal and that strives to protect the civil liberties of individuals throughout the world, it ...


 Is it still a crime if you murder or harm an illegal immigrant?
It seems like it wouldn't be since they're tresspassing anyway. At least not a crime here in the USA....


 Why did white people choose to come to America instead of going to China?
...


 I have overstayed for 9 years in UK. what should I do?
...


 Don't you think Mexicans are the native americans?
If so, should they have the right to live in the U.S?...


 Why some Mexicans prefer Germany, France, Spain, Australia or Yemen as an Immigration destination?
They are welcome in their adoptive countries. Europeans admire Mexican Culture.
Americans do not understand the meaning of Culture.
It's sad... Americans need educational Reforms....


 Whats going on in are country,america,did you hear what happened in california yesterday i believe.?
yesterday a group of illeagal mexicans were having a rally again,and they took an american flag off a post office flag pole,stomped on it and raised a mexican flag,i don`t care about the details,this ...


 The "illegal immigrant" Karma?
I am a Native American...(Mohawk Indian, and Cherokee)...and it seems so funny to me how white people are complaining about how the illegal immigrants are coming here without permission, but which C...


 "Give us your tired, your poor...."?
“Give us your tired, your poor, your hungry, your huddled masses yearning to be free” What ever happend to this saying that is carved on the Statue of Liberty? Why isn't the United States ...


 Do you think the USA put a fence across US/Mexico border?
Should Mexico cough up some of the cost?

This is what I think. The US should put a 80 ft solid concrete wall (10 ft under ground and 30 ft above ground). Then a mine field on the US side ...


 In the last 18 months has any 1 had 2 change the way they WORK DUE 2 FOREIGNERS TRYING 2 TAKE OUR JOBS?
...


 Why is the government going to build such abomination, the wall of shame with my taxes?
...


 What really boils your tomato?
For me it's illegal immigration.
Additional Details
FYI - I'm not small minded. I'm just honest....


 Dose any belive england has a very serious problem with imagration and drastict measures need to be taken rapi
...


 When will England become islamic republic?

When will England become islamic, dont take this the wrong way I think it will be good for you all your goverment is corrupt and evill seeking out oil and war for america without the peoles ...


 What are the contributions of Hispanics to the United States?
...


 Should the government deport an illegal immigrant even if they are married to a U.S. soldier?
http://www.cnn.com/2007/
This story is very interesting. I can't stand illegal immigration, but I believe (and this is just MY opinion) that if ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.034