Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Immigration

You think the Minutemen are vigilantes? Well, ok, granted, but I support them. What do you think of this group
Find answers to your legal question.





You think the Minutemen are vigilantes? Well, ok, granted, but I support them. What do you think of this group

http://www.nctimes.com/articles/2006/08/10//news/californian/12_01_208_9_06.txt

"The Private Police Force is threatening to actually detain illegal immigrants.

"They will be handcuffed to the Oak Trees," according to the group's Web site, so they can be picked up by authorities.

"Don't treat this website lightly," the group states. "We will make Citizens Arrests on Illegal Aliens. We will File Criminal and Civil Complaints if you Hire or House an Illegal. If you have sold a vehicle to an illegal, we will prosecute you under the DMV law too. If you house an illegal, we will also prosecute you under the Zoning Laws."

"The names and photos of those who oppose the group's efforts will be posted on the Web site, www.privatepoliceforce.com, according to a statement on the site. The names and photos of known illegal-immigrant workers will also be posted, the statement says.

Also, arrests will be recorded on video and offered for viewing on the Web site..."

What do you think?
Additional Details
I think I confused people. These are not the Minutemen it is a separate group that is hiring private police, apparently.


    




Sashie
Rating
Sounds good on paper ... but I'd really like to know more about them before I can judge ... so let's say I'm sitting on the fence on this one until I learn more ....


lucyanddesi
Rating
I support them 100 percent. Only with groups like this will we get those nosepickers in Washington to DO THEIR STINKING JOBS!


Berzerker
Rating
The Minute Men do the job that the cowardly politicians are afraid to.


Angels Raising Hell
Rating
somebody has to protect our borders. why have borders if they are not protected ?


luvcowboys
this is the start. this is what happens when you piss off armchair americans. small groups with simple rules that folow the letter of the law. oh and I have a box of snickers and coke ready for the viedoo. oh and this is not vigalantism, this is Americans who REALLY care about your future.


ChrisJ
its about time someone does something.


ole_lady_93
Didn't go look at the web site. But sounds good.Maybe more people ought to make citizens arrest for more crimes than that !!!


Heinrich Himmler
Rating
I think the Minutemen are true to there name. and "ancestory.". They are standing up to a problem our government is having problems with seeing. They are upholding their rights set forth to the American people. More power to them. Let them do the job others can't and let them publiclly humiliate those that oppose the popular concensus. Vigilante justice is not a new form of justice, just a different form that is more down to earth with the people they swear to protect. They have interests for themselves, their familys, their prosperiety, And I commend them for it.


1hunglo
at least they are doing something to try and stop the flood of criminals into our country...............


socalrogueling
I've actually read reports that this entire group is bogus and not a real group at all.


Hold em Rox.
I have checked out their site before and let me just say I was impressed !! They (citizens) will have to watch every move they make, but I like how they are trying to take back their city/town !! I said it before and will say it again.... These people ROCK and it makes me want to move there !!!!!
I love this part of their site !!...............

Shame on You

Americans talk about being a Nation of Laws. We’re becoming a nation of law breakers! Shame on America. Shame on George Bush who won’t enforce the law. Shame on the Border Patrol.

Soon America may be in chaos as those illegals import their corrupt ways and their culture which is nothing more than dog eat dog stealing and payola. Do you want to pay for their multiple childrens education, free healthcare at our hospitals, etc. They have no work ethic and they hate Americans. Do you want a Socialist State where no one cares and there is no pride with Americans forced to live like third world countries. Mud huts are next - garage your truck, because it may soon be in Mexico.

If you don’t see it that way, shame on you for being naive. Shame on you for being complacent and doing nothing; it’s destroying America.


uscitizen a
Rating
I think they are a reaction to so many illegal aliens entering the US and they will probably grow or more groups like them will spring up.From what I hear they have caused no one harm, only pointing illegals out to authorities. the real problem is Mexico for the most part. Mexico is a corrupt state as the recent elections show, I know many mexicans and they know there is no hope that the government will ever represent the people. Its all about the money in Mexico and getting more that way here in the US.


coragryph
I don't mind private individuals or groups keeping tabs on the border, or looking out for illegal border crossings. That's no different than the average neighborhood watch.

The question is, what do they do when they see someone. The actions described above in your quote more reflect a group that intends to take the law into their own hands, and that doesn't understand how the law actually works. Add weaponry to that mix, and it's a potentially dangerous combination.

Not having met or talked with any individuals, I'll reserve judgment on how much of their platform is bravado, and how much is fanaticism.


hexa
This kind on stuff always happens when the government doesn't do their job, they don't bother with the illegals in San Diego, in fact they find them places to live. The Border Patrol no's exactly where they are, but they don't do anything, I like the minute men, but I don't no anything about this group. Are they acutally police officers moonlighting. If they are police officers then they can arrest them. But then they will probabley let the illegals sue the police officers, like the illegal that is sueing the 2 Border Partol officers.


Aleksandr
Rating
This is an armed group of reactionaries. If they point guns at people, it is a crime. If they shoot, it is murder. Under Bush's wide definition, they are definitely a terrorist group, and I would not be surprised if, assuming they are competent enough to find any illegal aliens crossing the border, this could end in murder.


fact checker
these are not the people on the border and i want illegal immigration stopped right now but hate groups shoving their noses in will have the opposite effect oppression doesn't go over well with Americans ( We need the government to get off their ****s and ACT ) AND i don't take any web-site seriously if you can't stand up and be counted you are cr*p in my eyes )


scott n
Rating
These people are frustrated. When a wrong is commited, a reasonable expectation is our law enforcement officials will right it. When the wrong continues...and the answer is our law enforcement is overwhelmed......some people say......I will volunteer to help you......


red dragon
Well that might be what it will take to wake up Washington, but on the flip side of it ,I don't want anyone on either side of it to be injured during this. I really pray this can be done peacefully.


Daisy
Rating
I find this sort of thing a little bit possibly scarey, but I can understand it happening in light of the government not doing their job properly. I think I will also watch a bit and see how it goes.


actionsinglemale
Rating
I support them 100% but I also think that they should be able to defend our country to with fire arms. All they are doing is protecting our country unlike our government.


GrimReaper1546
Rating
Well, considering the fact that they're mostly made up of either racist people, blue-collar workers, and or people of immigrant ancestry *cough* Hispanic Americans *cough*...

I think I'll comment by saying: These people have the right to protect a land that is theirs (even though they stole it back when the first people were from Europe)... and the Minutemen are technically vigilantes who believe their work will actually cause a movement...

While little Minutemen and complaining Americans (I'm American by the way) say this and that about this situation...

It'll never end.... As long as people need cocaine, heroin, and marijuana... then there will be illegal immigration... it will NEVER stop.


Justsyd
Rating
It's just not true. I've lived on the border. People are making this up. The Minutemen are simply not acting like this.


Love America
Rating
da minutemaid is a working ppl. no like some ppl here, who only cry & cry & don't move da azz to do nothing


Stomp
Rating
When Bush learns about it he will declare them 'vigilantes.' If it's real, we'll see how far they get in the real world! There are too many computer tough macho sites. I find it amusing that the same ones who criticize those illegally crossing the border, will endorse breaking the law in this instance. Funny how that works!

Sashie, smart call!


PANCHA
Rating
I don't agree with vigilante justice.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Surely the shortage of housing & lack of job vacancies in the UK is largely due to the number of immigrants??
...


 Why r some Americans hypocrites?
i mean some people say that illegals are against the law etc. its not like they are perfect and have never done something illegal. "now you respect laws right", how pathetic. others say ...


 Do you think that its OK for illegals to be here?
...


 Immigrants!!!???
if your culture and customs are so great!!! why do you all want to come to my country (canada) and when you come here- why dont you learn OUR languages and adopt our customs and cultures?? instead ...


 If Canadians were crossing the border to find jobs, would it bother you like it does when Mexicans do it?
...


 Do you think mexicans are going to be the majority in the U.S. in 100 years?
Do you think english is still going to be the official language?...


 Why is it so bad to support undocumented immigrants?
why is it so bad to have illegal immigrants to live on US land. Dont you think its good to have of all kinds of race to live on our freedom of land? Why is so not allowed why does it have to be ...


 Should the border fence be electrified?
Why not? They just go under or climb over, electrifying it would stop this immediately. Why does this country always seem like it's being run by a bunch of p*ssies. We should be hard like R...


 How do you think a man Like Jesus Christ will handle the immigration Debate?
...


 Proper grammar and punctuation!!!?
Why can't we all please write in grammatically correct English? English is not my first language, but I make an effort to spell correctly and construct coherent sentences. Please use your ...


 Why is it SO hard for some of you to understand the DIFFERENCE between?
crimes committed by American citizens, and those committed by ILLEGAL aliens????
Come on!!!! It's not rocket science!!!

AMERICAN =CITIZEN A citizen has the LEGAL right to be in ...


 Are people aware of it when they are being spiteful and mean?
I have been reading questions and answers on "immigration" and people are making comments about immigrants that make my skin crawl.

When somebody suggests shooting Mexicans at ...


 Can a Mexican immigrant get disability from america?
...


 Why dont Mexicans stay in their own countries and fight for a better government there?
Is it because the government is so corrupt, and they are conditioned by a country of wishy washy law enforcement- to where they have no respect for laws and government....


 Do conservatives believe in 'immigrants rights'?
http://news.yahoo.com/s/
In the middle of this article the writer says "Giuliani, who backed gun control and immigrant rights as mayor of ...


 How can I become a beefeater?
...


 How do I get my neighbors to turn their music down?
I asked this question before and got some interesting answers but the problem is still happening. I live in a largely illegal immigrant neighborhood, I recently moved back to take care of my ...


 What is your strongest argument for illegal immigration?
meaning a pro-illegal stance
Additional Details
i haven't heard anything besides,,,white people are racist,, and this is 'our' ...


 Why do they want to deport me ?
I sneaked back across the boarder and got knocked up, so I could have a child that is now a legal citizen. The U.S. goverment wants to deport me.... where isthe justice in that ?
Additional D...


 I have a feeling America is...?
Screwed? Who else thinks so with Barack Obama and John McCain as our runners? America will fall into a depression if either of them win the election... God can only hope in 2012 we get decent runners....




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.024