Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Insurance & Registration

If a rock from a truck hits my windshield and breaks it, can i file a claim against the truck insurance compan
Find answers to your legal question.





If a rock from a truck hits my windshield and breaks it, can i file a claim against the truck insurance compan



    




fighting saints
Rating
Since there are two different ways that a rock can hit your windshield I'll answer from both perspectives.

1. If the rock is kicked up from the roadway by the tire of the truck you have little or no chance of collecting. In order for the truck to owe you for the windshield they have to be negligent in some manner. If the truck drives over the normal size (quarter size) rock and it hits your windshield that is not negligence. If the truck runs over a basketball sized rock then that SHOULD be considered as negligence.

2. If the rock comes from the box of the truck then your have a better chance, although not guaranteed, of collecting. If the truck is carrying a load of rock and it is not secured in the box of the truck and some rocks come out then that should be considered negligence.

Either way is a tough claim to make. If you have comprehensive coverage on your policy consider using that coverage. Then you company can try to collect back your deductible from the trucks insurance company.


Briteblueize20
If a rock flew off your car and broke a windshield would you want that person to file a claim against your insurance company?
---well i dont think you can file a claim unless there is proof that it happend and the truck doesn't have the 'tire blockers'(those rubber things) -- but if you really can then there would be a lot of claimes due to rocks and gravel being everywhere on the roads
--- BUT your insurance co. may offer a plan that if by chance the window does break because of the rock you pay a very low deductable and they will fix it for you


pretty_brn_eyed_gurl
Rating
Unfortunately no not with the trucks insurance company. They will claim that you can not prove the rock came from the truck, and the truck had mud flaps etc etc. It's quite a hassel and not worth the time. The same thing happened to me a while back and I ended up filing the claim with my insurance company.


la428282
Do you have a witness besides yourself who saw the rock fly off the truck and hit your car? Do you have a police report that says the truck company was at fault?

If not.. your outta luck. Without proof.. they arent paying anything.


oklatom
Sure. But unless the truck was not properly maintained and was missing the "mud flap" on the tires you would not collect. If the truck is properly maintained and equipped and you caught a rock, you were following way too close, and it's your fault.


Starfall
I think it depends on the company. I have seen trucks with signs on the back saying to keep back because the company will not pay for windshield damage from debris off their trucks, which I think is a crock. I've had those kinds of trucks cut in front of me and throw debris, so how is it my fault if I'm not back far enough to avoid debris.

Anyway, if you would file a claim, make sure you have the truck's license plate number or operator number if it's listed on the back of the truck, and also be able to tell them exactly where the incident occurred. Witnesses would also be helpful, if possible.

Good luck.


Prickly
Rating
Unfortunately no, it's considered road hazard.


redblade20xx
Yes you can but you need proof.


Omkar
Rating
yes witha an appropriate proof





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Car accident....who should pay????
so i got into a car accident with a honda pilot that was either an 05' 04' or 03' i was following as close as everyone else was unaware of how close i should be....i was following ...


 Are black and silver licence plates legal in the UK.?
There are a number of cars here in Warrington with Black Number Plates, with Silver lettering. This looks like the very old style plates (60s and earlier).

Is it legal for any car to have ...


 Im 20 years old, clean driving licence,will i be able to get insured on my dads range rover sport (4.2 litre)?
my dad has a range rover sport, 55 plate, 4.2 litre engine, i was wondering whether or not i would be able to get insured on it - as a named driver (not insured as owner of car)?
im 20 years old,...


 Is Progressive Insurance any good?
I found a good quote with them, but i want to be sure if they are anygood and backing up their quotes....


 What does revoked mean on a driving licence?
...


 Anyone know any good car insurers?
Does anyone know of a good car insurer in the United Kingdom for someone who has just passed their test?...


 My car was in an accident, value is 4100.00, estimate of 2500 to 3000.00 damage, is it totalled?
What percent of the value of the car is it before they total it?...


 Is Uhaul responsible for the damage to my car?
Two weeks ago I went to a local Uhaul lot and rented one of their uhaul trucks. After signing all the paperwork and before taking off in the truck, I was asked by one of the sales associates to move ...


 My neighbor's painter's ladder fell on my car damaging the car. Should I report to my insurance company?
My neighbor's painter used the heavy duty ladder, the one that can be extended. However, my wife said it fell on my car and damaged my car and windshield. The guys tried to get my home owner'...


 What is the cheapest 1st car to insure?
I am 17 and looking to buy my first car in the near future. And I was wondering what is the cheapest (half decent!) first car to insure?...


 My Boyfriend gave me his car. i need to know how to transfer it to my name?
What documents do i need to take to the tag agency.. i have my license plate from my old car. so do i just need to tranfer the info?? do u know how much that cost?and how abou the insurance. how does ...


 Who pays up when a drunken driver kills someone in a traffic accident?
As I understand it your Car Insurance becomes null when you drive under the influence of alcohol.
Who would pay the damages to the victim's family?
These are usually high amounts but ...


 A man that believed I cut him off, cut me off at a stop sign, in a school zone, forced my car to the side of?
the road, until I heard my car start to crunch beneath his truck. He then exited his vehicle, approached my car, and since it was July, and early evening, I scrambled to roll up my window, as I am 10...


 What is the car rental company that you can request what kind of car you want?
...


 How much will car insurance be?uk?
i am 16 andd saving for a car for when im 17. I hope to spend about £900 on the car. Can anyone tell me an aprox amount pleease :)...


 Car insurance for 17 year olds in the UK?
How could i get a cheap car insurance and what would be the cheapest price? every site i have been on it said about £3000 and that would be more then what the actual car costs.
Additional D...


 A friend of my friend hit my car she said that she was going to pay so we didnt file a report?
She hit my car said that she was going to pay so we didnt file a police report. Now she wont pay. I want to take it to court but I dont know if I will have any chances of winning because we didnt ...


 Why does bad credit affect my auto insurance when i have a clean mvr?
so i have a bad credit score. but i have a clean mvr and pay my insurance on time so why are my rates credit has nothing to do with the way i drive?...


 My 2 yr old son was hit by a car at a acura car dealership, whos fault is this? can i sue for medical cost?
i live in oklahoma,My 2 yr old son was hit by a car at a acura car dealership, whos fault is this? can i sue for medical cost?
my son and i were looking at cars at a acura dealership as we ...


 Does my son need car insurance?
He is 16 and learning to drive. Since he is underage, does he not need it, or do I put him on mine? He wants his own insurance policy since he earns a lot at his job. What do most parents do for 16 ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.034