Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Insurance & Registration

Who is in the right/wrong?
Find answers to your legal question.





Who is in the right/wrong?

The car in front of me braked suddenly, I braked suddenly and then heard a crunch at the back of my car.

The only car that got hit was mine.

This happened with UK registered cars in the UK.

Who is at fault, the guy in front of me for stopping abruptly, me for stopping too quickly or the person behind me for smacking me up the backside (and not in the good way ;)

All answers welcomed


    




nosdda
The car that hit you is to blame for any damage to your car. The Highway code tells drivers to drive behind a nother vehicle with a safe distance between you in case the other car in front has to brake in an emergency. it horrifies me when I see cars driven in the fast lane of a motorway being tailgated by the driver behind them. Do they ever think what can happen if the car in front had a tyre blowout or his engine suddenly cut out.


rycally00
Rating
the bloke at the back was in the wrong for being to close to you


Miss Motor Mouth
Rating
Usually the car in the back is at fault because they are supposed to pay attention to what is going on ahead of them (even though we all know that isn't always possible).


KJ
Rating
As it states in the highway code, you should leave yourself enough space between you and the car in front to be able to stop in the event of an emergency. The car following you obviously didnt. It doesnt matter what you did, the car that rear ended you was in the wrong. Alot of insurance scams take advantage of this and purposly get rear ended to claim for damage and personal injury


old know all
Unless you braked deliberately to cause the accident, the bloke behind is at fault. You should always allow enough space in case the car in front brakes suddenly.

I had a similar accident years ago. Everyone skidded except me.


The Saint
Him that hit you from behind.Down to the driver to be able to stop in time,no matter what he's confronted with.


mickie
Rating
Here in the US, you are in the right and the dunce behind you is in the wrong for being too close...Good luck with this one!


Max Power
if for example the person in front braked to avoid hitting a kid you were far enough behind to stop the person behind you should have also being able , he was not so therefore at fault. keep a safe distance behind the car in front to be able to stop in an emergency.


sherpa_jones
Rating
I would say the guy who hit you, but that is just based on the interpretation of my local laws.


Newgran
Rating
The person behind you should have been far enough away from you to stop safely. He is in the wrong.

you were a safe enough distance behind the car in front of you to stop without hitting him, so should the car behind you have been


anybody
Rating
the person behind you is at fault. the person in front made an abrupt stop (emergency?) and well doen to you, you noticed and stopped in time. the person behind you didn't though so 90% of the time the insurance will say it's their fault.


dot_on_the_horizon
Rating
The answer to this one is....
The car behind you was too close and didn't have time to brake. Insurance wise he will be the one in the wrong!!
You are NOT the one in the wrong.....you stopped in time and didn't hit the car in front, so obviously you weren't too close. If you had have been you would have hit the car in front.
You don't say what made the car in front of you brake suddenly....but that doesn't matter, the only one in the wrong out of the 3 of you is the car that hit you!!
Hope this helps.......xXx


ccosj
Rating
the one who hit you he was driving to close or not concentrating


Topher M
In the USA it defaults that the person who hit you from behind is always at fault. I donno about the laws in the UK.


andy F7
the car at the back is to blame because he was too close and drove without due care and attention, that's what the charge will be if the police are involved, you done nothing wrong, don't worry.


wizzywig
Rating
you were obviously driving at a safe distance from the car in front...the one behind you wasn't.
Hope you weren't injured.


JB
Rating
i think its the person behind you who is in the wrong - even though you and the car in front stopped abruptly, it was the person behind you who actually caused the accident. unfortunate for the person behind, but that's life.


Leu
Rating
The guy that went into the back of you is to blame - he was clearly either driving to fast to react or he was too close...or both!

Any whiplash? Injuries? Possibly a sprained wrist....? :o)


The One
Rating
The car behind you was at fault thats a fact.


Tim C
Rating
The person who drives into you from behind is always at fault in the UK as he/she should have left sufficient stopping room. Unfortunately, there is a tendancy for people who run into the back of other people, to claim, dishonestly, that they were REVERSED into. If they can find a witness to back them up, sometimes the insurance company will accept their claim. In an accident, always get a witness, even if it appears clear-cut.


sweetness
Personally i think ur in the right. ;0)


golden
If you hit someone up the ar$e your in the wrong full stop


sailor
if you had run into the guy in front of you your at fault only exceptioni know of i am pretty sure about is if other cars brake lights are not working so its the guy behind that was at fault for not leaving enough space for brakeing





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 How often do other drivers aggravate you on the road and what annoys you most?
...


 What are the biggest things to remember for a driver's licence test?
I have my behind the wheel test in just a little bit and I'd like to now bout what I'm in for. Thanks a lot!

I'm a ...


 How long does a provisional driving licence last?
...


 What's the average insurance cost of a 17 year old just strating to drive?
1.) In a 1.0 engine car
2.) In a 1.5 engine car
2.) In a 2.0 engine car
Additional Details
Sorry I meant *starting

The car I'm considering getting is 1996 VW G...


 How Much did your Driving lessons cost when you were learning to drive ?
I think mine were about £3.50....


 My daughter had an accident at tescos. she got her fingers caught in an escalator. can i make a claim?
we were shopping in tescos in gallions reach and my daughter whos a year and few months old ran towards the escalator that was coming up. we were on the second floor and she tripped whilst she was ...


 Whose insurance is responsible for the auto accident?
Ok, long story but I recently got into a car accident and had no insurance. My car was paid for, but I had no insurance on it. I live in Michigan which is a no-fault state, but I hit a building and I ...


 Please can someone take my speeding points? I will pay! (UK)?
...


 I offered to pay for a fender bender out of my pocket, smart move?
the other driver agreed to let me pay damages on a fender bender his car 87-88 datsun, then he calls me up and says he is going to fix it himself (the driveshaft is bent, even though he drove it all ...


 My wife thinks she may have been caught on a speed camera. 40mph in a 30mph zone she thinks, ban?
she passed last june so will she have to do her test again? united kingdom....


 Can anyone give me advice? PLEASE!!?
I have been working at a car dealers for a few months now, but i never told them i had no car licence they thought i did but im getting abit scared now in case i get stoped by the police when im out ...


 Driving - Insurance claim who's fault?
I stalled on a roundabout and a taxi ran into the back of my car - who is at fault?...


 My car has been stolen :( What do I do next?

Additional Details
Oh crap, I'm sure I had some letters with my home address on in the car. And my sunglasses. Crap crap crap....


 Accidentally scratching someones car then leaving the scene without giving details?
if someone is coming out of a car park space and scratches the persons car who is in the spece next to it, but then leaves without leaving any details of name, insurance etc, what can be done about ...


 Drink Drive Accident, insurance valid?
If you had an accident in your car whilst you were over the drink drive limit, would your insurance still be valid for the repairs if you were fully comp?...


 Did you fail your driving test first time? What happend? How many times in the end?
I failed for the first time yesterday, share your stories....


 Car accident whos to blame?
My partner was reversing his car out of our drive on sunday thre was a car parked half on the pavement opposite our drive and my partner reversed and hit it .There wasnt alot of damage apart from a ...


 How come men always claim that women are bad drivers?
Men always complain that women are horrible drivers and that we don't pay attention but, our insurance is a whole lot cheaper then theirs.......


 I have to go to court for driving without insurance what can I expect?
I was pulled over for speeding & did not have insurance. I now have insurance and have to go to court on xmas eve. I dont have any sort of record (maybe a speeding tix in the past 3 yrs.) S...


 Is it worth getting full comp insurance if your car is only cheap?
...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, May 27, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.014