Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law Enforcement & Police

Are we too soft on crime? Should prison sentences be longer ie. Life means life?
Find answers to your legal question.





Are we too soft on crime? Should prison sentences be longer ie. Life means life?


Additional Details
Gromit801:- Actually this is England!


    




Ian UK
Rating
An actual prison sentence at all would be nice!

The problem we have now in this country is too much emphasis on civil and human rights and seemingly no consideration for the victims of crime and the law abiding citizens. The results being that most criminals are given 'another chance' and a community rehabilitation order resulting in them going straight back to the communities that they wronged in the first place thus allowing them to continue to commit crime, which most do.

I personally think that if prison sentences were longer, prisons were less like holiday camps and more people were put in prison, then crime figures may fall.

I'm not suggesting that we should treat people badly, that would obviously be wrong but if we make the punishment an actual punishment then criminals might think twice about committing crime.

I would suggest a plain prison cell with a bed, toilet and washing facilities. Basic entertainment and exercise facilities and basic food. This would certainly be cheaper than most of the facilities that prisoners get now such as state of the art gym equipment and Sky TV etc.

As for human rights, they should be forfeit when the prison terms starts.

Let's consider the human rights of the victim for a change such as the burglary victims right to privacy and family life which is breached when their home is desecrated by the burglar.


Darcy
Yes for many situations. For example, It disgusts me when murderers or rapists are let out of jail and they commit murder or rape again. Life should mean life!


bobswiming
Rating
They are not hard enough at ALL

THE JUSTICE system is a JOKE and any Way ppl are only serving 10% of their sentence,U have to take the law into yr hands, But face it This world is OVer all ready


stickadiddle
Yes we are too soft on crime, proven by the fact that it is running out of control with ferrel yobs running wild. Neighbours from hell getting ASBO'S after fifty warnings and then being evicted and moved on to torment others. More knife crime. More gun crime.I could go on and on.
There is a simple answer but nobody, least of all the government, will do anything about it.
Solve this statement to find it?
THERE IS NO DETERRENT !!!!!!
We are all doomed!


eayrin
Rating
yes life should mean life
if u get a life sentance u shud neva come out of prison (unless of corse your l8r found innocent)


MA_Cop
Rating
In a liberal state such as mine (read my name) we have tons of repeat offenders doing all kinds of crimes that never see any jail time. I honestly just don't get it.


cassandra_sd
Rating
Yes. They blame a lot of it on prison overcrowding. Fine. Then if that's the case, we should be building more prisons . . . not giving fluff sentences.


Admiralsmurf
Rating
Our courts are a joke. They think more about the criminal than they do about the victim. Life should mean their natural life with no parole. Use these rapists etc as guinepigs for medical research. They remove themselves from the human race by their acts.........


♀Sweet ♥
Far too soft on genuine criminals, but too tough on non-criminals, meaning people who don't pay their Council Tax, etc.
Yes, life should mean life, not just 15 years, or sometimes less. If prisons are too full more should be built, and I can't understand why that isn't happening. If holding centres for innocent immigrants can be made available, why not prisons for guilty prisoners? It doesn't make sense.


kelbean
Yes Life should mean life. If you do the crime - you should do the time. And I also think the sentences should be stricter. People get off too easy. The prisons should also be a terrible place to be so that there would not be so many repeat offenders who actually like jail.


¸.•*¨)Sweet Sinner¸.•*¨)
Yes we are too soft! My step dad was jailed for life in 1998 for killing my mum. He will be out next year and is already getting weekend release from prison to rehabilitate him!!!! How is that a life sentence? It's the victims and the victims family that serve the life sentence :'(


moose
Prison should be like real prison. No TV, no cable, no video games. do hard labor. So yes we are too soft on crime.


ladydi_1987
Rating
Yes, we are. Unfortunately the system is broken. Too many people are released early.


Christina K
For certain crimes, particularly those where the victim suffered greatly, life should mean life. I am thinkng in particular of that awful case where the father had his daughter raped and murdered as an 'honour' killing. He should never be free and he should have some sort of punishment which reflects the agony that his daughter suffered in her last hours on this earth.


sudsbud9er
Rating
Yes. And Death sentences should be carried out more rapidly in California. Just look at scum like Richard Ramirez,
"The Night Stalker" who killed, maimed and raped almost twenty people. Since his conviction, he has had his teeth fixed, gotten married, etc.


nataliexoxo
Rating
i think we are too light on punishment
i think we should start making more jails like the one in the middle of the dessert (can't recall where it's been in the news a ton)
make prisons a place that's not a candy walk - a place you don't want to go to- from juvie on up to lifers
make them wear pink, make them eat bologna sandwiches or cheese sandwiches, make the tv only show 2 channels- weather and disney. etc...
let them learn a lesson not want to go back again.

i also think we need to be tougher on juvie offenders-
i love when judges sentence kids to stand outside or at the mall where they stole from with a sandwich board - written out with what they did-
i stole bras from jcpennies
i stole sneakers from foot locker...
embarass them and see if they do it again.


denco26
life should mean life or even hang them,we should make there life hell, forget human rights forget the play stations etc. in prisons, make them sleep on straw on the floor , and bring in chain gangs


sharon b
Oh gosh life should mean life but this is England let a prisoner say the right thing in front of a parole board and that's it they are out to start all over again
there should have been more prisons built many years ago
then we wouldn't be were we are now letting trouble walk the streets to terrorise Innocent people
after they do there little community service
makes me sick what i see come out them courts brimming there teeth knowing they have been let of stuff to go do it again
think we should have the 3 strikes
sorry if people don't agree but that's what i think
Respect
shaz


rico3151
There is only one answer to your question, and that is, we allow ourselves to be victimized in this country. In countries where people have their heads on straight, they do not tolerate the victimization of their population. Criminals are treated very harshly and rightly so.


Bruce J
If you have never been incarcerated (and I assume that you haven't), you don't really have a feel for this issue. Many felons don't feel as if they have done wrong. Many don't view prison as a deterrent, but rather as a consequence of getting caught (getting caught, mind you, not actually doing wrong, but getting caught). An overwhelming percentage will tell you that they are in prison because they had a bad lawyer, or someone ratted them out, etc., etc., but rarely will they take responsibility and say "I'm here because I broke the law."

It's a game to many people, and why shouldn't it be? We have sub-standard public education in most of our poor areas (and, IMHO, in most of our upper and middle class areas as well), we brand our citizens as felons and take away thier rights...why shouldn't they commit more crime?

America has the highest percentage of incarceration of ANY industrialized democracy. Something is broken in our system, and it goes well beyond the length of prison sentences.


devonrivvers
Rating
if we all had enough there would be no crime


nc_hull
Rating
Yes life should be life and if the offender admits his guilt and wants to be put to sleep then that should also be allowed.


Matt M
Rating
Yes. In my opinion the justice system in the US does a great job of being fair across races, classes etc in determining guilt the sentencing is not really fair nor is it long enough in general to deter, or punish crime.

However, ex-cons point out that once sentencing is done, almost all prisons have early release programs based on good behavior which is supposedly the only incentive for inmates to exhibit good behavior. However, in cases of extremely good behavior a sentence can be reduced by about 40% which is too much for me. There have been many many criminals who exhibited perfect behavior while in prison only to become repeat offenders while in public.


Mr Abba
In my opinion prision sentences are not fair, i think people who do small crimes get big punishments and people who do big crimes, such as rape and murder get very soft punishments. That is why criminals never learn.


Rob
Rating
No, having worked in a prison I realised that few people have a full idea of how much a punishment it is. It is all too easy to talk about people serving "only 5 years" or "only 10 years". A colleague of mine put it best - imagine spending 10 years when the only decision you make each day is chips or mash. I witnessed first hand the psychological damage that the loss liberty has on people and the corresponding neurosis and psychosis that it causes. Depression is epidemic in prisons even in in prisoners severing relatively short sentences.

Additionally, it is much misunderstood what a life sentence means. When sentences to life, a prisoner does come under the remit of the Home Office for the rest of their life. They may not spend all that time in custody but if released, they are released on licence. This licence may be revoked at any time and for any reason. Any condition may be places on the licence. Once sentences to life a person is never at liberty in the same way as you and I are.

Prison is a very serious thing. Best avoided.


godron_wookie
It depends on what you think the purpose of prison is. If its punishment only then fine, lock 'em up. If its rehabilitation perhaps we need to make prisons better. They need to teach inmates job skills and how to live a normal life. Sure there are some criminals who should be locked for our safety but there are many more need direction and focus in their lives.

I think we don't look closely enough at the causes of crime.


MIGUEL N
it is not about being soft on crime, can to manage a large number of people that have nothing to look forward in this life there will be no motivation for that person to be in their best behavior sense he or she will complete their sentence day for day. there will be nobody that will work in that type of environment


gromit801
If you want absolute laws, then move to North Korea.

This is the United States, with a constitution. If you don't like that, then you're an unpatrotic fascist.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Do you hate cops pt.2?
no not everyone that hates police are 'criminals". most people i know that hate cops arent "criminals" and have never been arrested, myself included. its their lack of respect ...


 What is the point in having the right to remain silent when questioned by police...?
when, when you appear in court, you are sworn under oath to tell the truth....


 Is it legal for a compnay to not hire an individual because they are a smoker? Is that discrimination?
...


 Do you think alcohol and drugs are the biggest culprit for the problems we have in society as a whole?
...


 Why don't a lot of youth today have any respect for law enforcement officers?
Is it their parents or just society as a whole? I see a lot of the kids that I deal with are disrespectful to the law. Most of their parents stick up for them (although calling us a week later when ...


 Should Guns be banned in usa ? R they the main source of violence ?
...


 Do you think that the police should be given powers to ban youths from town centres?
...


 Recently i got arrested for Shoplifting.?
I'm a Juvinile and i have no Previous record of Anything.
What kind of punishment do you think the intake officer could come up with?...


 What is the fine for driving without a sealbelt?
...


 My wife rapes me what can i do ?
...


 Just got a speeding ticket through the post, if i cant remember who was driving me or my wife, who should pay?
or do the police have to prove who was driving, both of us are registered to drive the car and insured....


 This cops been...?
This pig has been watching me for a while now..all ive been doing is standing on my block at the corner..and its makingme nervous....what should i do?:

dont go out there
or
...


 Can a mother report her child as missing/runaway if she gave her permission to move out?
My niece(will be 18 in 3 month's) was given permission BY HER MOTHER to move out last Jan. On the 5th of April she reported her as a runaway/missing child. There has been nothing but animosity ...


 I feel realy guilty but am i a bad person?
i work as a security guard at a locan shopping centre... two young guys were hanging around outside smoking i asked them to leave and they said they were waiting for there parents so i continued on ...


 Isn't it better to Limit ownership of GUNs to police/security officers?
...


 Can you get in trouble for fliping off a cop?
...


 Better to hit-and-run or pull over if you get into a car accident while intoxicated?
I know what the moral answer is, but I'm wondering which will get you a lighter sentence. I'm trying to settle a bet with my friend....


 Im going 2 college soon, but i've changed my career plan and want to be a police officer. should i still go?
im studing media, history, crictial thinking and english language, but i do really need to go to college or not? if so, what should i study in order to join the police?...


 How many seconds after driving through a red light are you allowed before you get caught by the camera?
I received a letter saying I committed the offence of failing to conform with the indication given by a red traffic signal. The time into the red was stated as being 1.5 seconds. I have been led to ...


 If your sentenced to life should it mean life like until they die i think so do u?
...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.074