Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law Enforcement & Police

Can the police get a reading from an airplane then allocate this reading to your car ?
Find answers to your legal question.





Can the police get a reading from an airplane then allocate this reading to your car ?

I've heard that the police have been known to point a speed gun at an aeroplane above in the sky, record a speed of say 70mph then they record this speed as your speed and there's nothing you can do about it. I heard this from a taxi driver.


    




Ian UK
Have you any idea how ridiculous that sounds?

For a start there aren't many planes that travel that slowly. Your average small planes only do that kind of speed when someone is about to parachute out of it (been there several times) and your average passenger planes travel at around 500 miles an hour.

Aside from this, to be able to get a reading from something that's travelling above you at a few thousand feet would require a VERY steady hand.

At the end of the day, I can't see why your average cop would want to risk losing their job for integrity issues just to catch one speeding driver by falsifying a speed gun reading when the majority or drivers speed at some point. There are that many drivers who are likely candidates for a ticket that they don't really need to falsify readings.

As for being told this by a taxi driver, in my experience, they are one of the worst groups of offenders. The majority of taxi drivers I stop are either for speeding, parking wherever they like (junctions, pedestrian crossings, the middle of the road), jumping red lights or for having defective vehicles. They are not always the most reliable of drivers on the road.


?
Rating
Because taxi drivers know soooo much...


"isitme"
your taxi driver is talking tosh!

However, there was a story from Wiltshire constabulary where officers were on radar duties. They saw a low flying Harrier and pointed the radar at it, it registered a speed of 300mph.
About half-hour later they received a call from their control room who informed them that the RAF had been on.
The Harrier, as it turned out, had just been on a live bombing exercise over Salisbury Plane, the weapons system was still on, and it had picked-up their equipment as a hostile radar and, had it still been armed, the internal defence system would have let a missile go at them!

Try explaining that to your Sergeant!


carswoody
I can see it now......
A...What speed is the defendant accused of doing?
B...You worships I recorded the defendant travelling at 290mph in a 30 zone!


Bear
Rating
Absolute tosh!!!!!! How many planes fly at 70mph!!!!!!!!

For one why would any officer want to do that???? If an officer committed perjury they not only risk losing their livelihood, but also risk a stint in prison too.

There are plenty of people speeding excessively for the police to deal with. Those that are not speeding would not be targeted maliciously as suggested.

I think speeding is an issue and is strongly linked to road-deaths, however I think the government have jumped on this excessively as a way of generating revenue.

From what I have seen of many taxi drivers and the speed in which they drive, they have the most to fear.


jamesdean2002uk
Rating
thats like saying that you believe what the papers say -


arfenundred
Rating
as aircraft travel at several hundred miles per hour i
find this very doubtful...
it must be a thick taxi driver...


nolongerhere
Ye, they do it to people walking


Jeff M
Rating
That's pretty funny, Now besides the fact that most of the time Air Planes are going faster than 70 mph, how short of a supply of speeders do you think there are to make an officer risk his job to frame a random driver?


Marxsparx
Rating
I think the police have looked at recording speeding motorists from planes, but the scenario you describe is not for real!


Imagine the ticket coming through.... You have been caught doing 500mph in a 30!


Lurch
Rating
I don't see much truth in that. Even small planes travel faster than an average car.


joan k
Rating
What rubbish. This person was having you on.


chilebreath
That you would even pose this question speaks volumes.


old fuzz
Rating
In the small town I worked, I once was working traffic at the edge of town. Suddenly my radar picked up an 85 mph reading. But there was no vehicle in sight. Then I realized I had picked up the crop duster plane in the field across the roadway.

A low flying crop duster is about the only thing a traffic cop could use to falsify a traffic radar reading. Most aircraft fly much faster than most cars go, and, being overhead a couple thousand feet, they are too small a target for the traffic device to read. Your taxi driver yanked your leg off with this one.

Most officers will not even show you the traffic radar read out. This is because you are a threat to the officer's safety once out of the car. Furthermore, the officer is responsible for your safety, wandering along the side of the road, going back to the patrol car is a good way to get hit. Ask a few highway patrol officers. . .

Since there is no requirement to show you the read out, there is no necessity to fake one.


whitefangz1
The range on the radar gun isn't more than 100 - 150 yards so that plane would have to be flying awfully low.

If the plane is flying 70 mph, then it is stalled out and in the process of crashing. This could explain why it is flying so low.


edd_the_fed
The laser lti 20-20 that I use at work only has a range up to a mile away, dont think it would work at 33000 feet!
Theres that many speeders on the road that I dont have to fix the figures.
Hope he didnt pull the wool over your eyes when it came to the fare


tilac
Rating
Hh ha ha ha .... but saying hat, nothing shocks me in this mad country anymore. xxx


CLARABELL
Rating
To be able to convict you of an offence they would need to prove it. If an aeroplane sets off a speed trap (highly unlikely as it would be much to far away) that is what image would be recorded. You do have the right to view the image and they are often shown if you attend a driving course instead of having points put on your licence.


Taf
In the 1990's on holiday in California, rented car, driving from L.A. to San Francisco, on a long straight lonely road in the middle of nowhere a Police car pulled me over as a Police aeroplane had recorded me speeding.

Unless it was a lie? I paid the fine.


Sarah E
Rating
No they can't. The link below details the cruising speeds of commerial jet aircraft. The standardised result is between 100 m/s (metres per second) and 260 m/s (about 570 mph). Military aircraft are much faster, with many capable of breaking the sound barrier (between 762mph at sea level and 660 at 40,000 feet). Even a large, propeller-driven plane such as a Hercules cruises at 336mph.


anjana t
Fairly typical psychotic symptom, it is delusions of persecution. The cabby was ill





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Why is it that when we have a school shooting, people automatically call the shooter a 'nut' and...?
demand more stricter gun laws--than the ones that are already on the books?

I find it a bit disturbing how we can brazenly *assume* that people who have killed these students--are such a ...


 Can i go to jail for this?
stealing from someones locker at school?
Even one thing, or money?...


 POLICE officers are not appreciated enough for what they do its the most thankless job ever!?
I appreciate what you guys do....


 How can I get a civil restraining order on my ex-girfriend in orlando FL?
...


 If someone say they are going to kill you will they get in trouble,that what my brother in law said to me?
...


 Do British criminals worry about the fact that mindreaders and remote veiwers are assisting the POLICE?
But are not allowed to have the evidence they collect used in a court of law. But GODS honest truth is allowed....


 If you are arrested......?
If you get arrested but are later de-arrested does this mean in effect you never got into trouble and there won't be any record of this whatsoever? And would this mean that you wouldn't ...


 I passed a DUI test?
i was slightly intoxicated and sleepy after leaving my friends party. i was driving on a curvy road and had cops pull me over. he said it took me a while to react to a green light and that i was ...


 I have taken loan from a very rich friend, by signing in a piece of paper. without any term atached. that is?
i have taken loan from a very rich friend, by signing in apiece of paper. without any term attached. that is i keep the loan amount as long as i am able to / willing to pay interest.
now though ...


 Can a cop still get you for DUI even if you're pulled over on the side of the road sleeping and resting?
my bf was intoxicated friday night. drove home and realized the freeway was traffic due to construction on the road by caltrans. he then pulled over on the median to sober up and rest because he was ...


 Why would someone break into a car and not steal anything?
Someone broke into my car in the middle of the night. All they did was rummage around, moved the seat back, pressed a bunch of buttons, left the brights on, and left the door slightly open. As far as ...


 For all you lawyers and legal people: Can I refuse consent for a (car) search?
'IF' (notice the big 'IF') I was pulled over for some reason and he/she had some reason to ask if they can search the vehicle, can I say no and not have any legal backfire?...


 Who thinks those cops on the tube made the right choice in shooting that bloke.?
The Brazilian on the tube. With millie seconds to decide they did the best they could I believe....


 Why do people who resist arrest by running and fighting with the cops not expect......................
to get pummeled?! ( o _ 0 ) I'm like hello?! Albeit excessive force is just wrong. Using the "appropriate" amount of force usually works? I guess that various amongst the ...


 When you get pulled over by a cop, is it better too...?
When you get pulled over by a cop (for say speeding) and they come up to your window and do the notorious "Did you know that you were going 15 miles above the speed limit?" Is it better to ...


 Who is in the wrong?
hello good people
my girlfriend been hit by another woman the other woman start it first and my girlfriend said the other woman hit her in the face hard as can be and now my gf has to go to ...


 Did Mark Fuhrman plant evidence in the OJ Simpson case?
I personally think OJ was Guilty but did the police try to frame a guilty man?
Additional Details
One of the things that always annoyed me was that Fuhrman never gave a satisfying answer ...


 A cop lied to me and my Dad; I need advice?
I got search by a cop illegaly in wich I did not consented and he found 2 grams of pot on me. The officer told me that if I told him where I got the pot he would drop the charges and let me go. I was ...


 Summonsed to court to be a witness?
i have been summonsed to court to be a witness is there any way at all to get out of it please ...


 Cutting through a Parking lot..?
If you cut through a parking lot to aviod a traffic light could a cop pull you over for a traffic violation? I'm just curious, I do it all the time at a certian light near my home....




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.034