Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law Enforcement & Police

Do you support profiling at airport checks?
Find answers to your legal question.





Do you support profiling at airport checks?

Media have reported the government is discussing with British airport authorities a system of profiling -- where security staff focus their search efforts on people they regard as suspicious on grounds such as ethnicity and religion.


    




Wurm™
President Bush selects Norman Mineta as Secretary of Transportation. Although all of the terrorist attacks were committed by Muslim men between 17 and 40 years of age, Secretary Mineta refuses to allow profiling. Does that sound like we are taking this thing seriously? For the duration, we are going to have to give up some of the civil rights we have become accustomed to. We had better be prepared to lose some of our civil rights temporarily or we will most certainly lose all of them permanently.

And don't worry that it is a slippery slope. We gave up plenty of civil rights during WWII, and immediately restored them after the victory and in fact added many more since then.


don45123
yes....if only arab muslims are blowing up airplanes then they should receive more scrutiny not 60 year old grandma's


Village Idiot
No, I don't... but not for the obvious racial reasons...

When racial profiling takes place, in the case of terrorism, it exposes a weakness in security. All you have to do is NOT fit the profile, and your odds of making it through security increase.

And, if you don't think that groups like Al Qaeda and such aren't already training (grooming, whatever) people to NOT fit the profiles laid out... then you're sadly mistaken.


squashpatty
I will support anything that keeps another 911 from happening again!


Lindsay D
If that is needed to save lives, then yes, I support it...


pops
Rating
Yes.
Walks like a duck,looks like a duck,must be a duck.
Certainly needs to be investigated.


McClean
I fully support it. For obvious reasons.


jkc6229
Rating
Absolutely.


bsure32
Rating
Yes! I support the idea.


Tricia P
Rating
Profiling is fine. Keeping all of us safe is the main concern!


overseas and broke
Rating
Yeah, probably means faster average check-in time for guys like myself.

Wouldn't say it's fair though.


mike g
yes, they may be a terrorist


drumrb0y
Rating
It's sad but true; profiling would not be politically correct or fair, but it would be efficient.


Kenneth H
You can be assured that this is happening right now. It is just not being said that it is happening.


joshcating
I approve.

I have trouble believing the 90 year old Christian grandma in the wheelchair is plotting to blow up the plane. Why slow her down any further.

However, the 35 year old arab "student" might be trying something. Let him be checked. If he's law abiding, he has nothing to hide.

BTW, if the terrorists were fair-skinned, brown-eyed people in their early 30s, I'd expect to be checked out.


soar
Rating
Let me see, who is responsible for all of the terrorist acts? Yes, we should profile.


frozenfun
Yes. Strip everyone and put them in a paper jumpsuit for the flight. All bags are to be sent in the hold only...
Hey it's a wacky idea...that is all :0)


Walter Ridgeley
Rating
Yeah, and it's a no-brainer, too!


kja63
I know I'm going to get slammed for this one, but yes, I support it. I'm sorry, but I'm just not going to get on a plane that has arabs on it. I know, that's very racist of me. And I feel bad about it, but I prefer feeling bad to dying.

Have the airlines have flights that only arabs can travel on. That way, if they want to blow themselves up, have at it!

And what pilot is going to fly a commercial plane with arabs on it? This world is out of control right now with the terrible hate in the middle east. If they are so fanatical, then it's time to treat them in fanatical ways.

I never thought I would feel this way, but I do.


turboweegie
Yes. It is very effective. And it makes more sense than if they screened Posh Spice, don't you think?


It'sMe23
Rating
YES I DO!


TrayDiva
Rating
Did you see the movie Siege with Denzel Washington, Annette Bening, Bruce Willis & Tony Shalhoub? Well that is what racial profiling can do in an extrem situation. Do we really want to go there?

I know we need to be more caustious of potential terriorists but they can look like anybody...Who would have suspected Timothy McVeigh & Terry Nichols? Look what they did in Oaklahoma City.

So it can go both ways. Then again you might end up with a lot of civial unrest and law suites and protesting for all the people who get profiled.

Racial profiling for the "Good" of the people can be a double edged sword and the governmemt should be very careful how they proceed...


freedom
Rating
i no in today's world it seems wrong some how to profile but i think it is are best line of defense as it does seem to be certain religions or ethnic origins, but we do still need to keep an eye on the rest, but what i do think is wrong is the public are profiling and doing a lot of harm to Innocent people just because of their religion or ethnic back ground 2 wrongs don't make it right.


mason x
Rating
clean cut middle eastern men 18-35
and women, especially pregnant women
hell yes, stupid not to





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Is it time for Megans law in the uk?
The paedophile who is suspected in Glasgow murder had new identity supplied by social workers to protect him.Who protects our children.
Additional Details
mr sceptic read megans law its ...


 What do I do when a policeman commits perjury?
Earlier this year I went to court to fight a MINOR traffic ticket. There was a small trial and during this trial the policeman that pulled me over lied. I later noticed that his testimony was (of ...


 First time DUI?
I got a DUI last week. It is my first and only offense, I've never even got a ticket for any traffic violation before. I know I've made a mistake and very sorry about it. What should I ...


 Can i get out of being a witness in a trial?
I have been notified i am a witness in a trial, i cant do it firstly because i go to University with the mother of the girl being prosecuted. Secondly i am have had 3 panic attacks just thinking ...


 How can i escape from the prison?
...


 My step daughter who is police officer has taken the contents of the matrimonial home which my late husband?
left to me in his will, she is also an executor of my late husbands will, is this theft?...


 Do police always handcuff you when you are arrested?
I've always been cuffed - different times in front and sometimes behind. Why does it be different? If you are being co-operative do they need to cuff you at all?...


 Women can't be Cop!?!?!?
I don't hate women or anything, but they can't be cop. I mean, they are not tough as men, they cry easily, they're afraid of breaking a nail, come on. They use excessive force, and ...


 Does the USA treat prison inmates no better than animals?
here in the UK we see a lot of programs about prison life in the USA...........the conditions and treatment of prisoners as well as the length of sentences seem overly harsh also there seems to be a ...


 Arresting Drug Pushers?
My friend OverDosed because Mr Plod arrested his usual supplier and the stuff we got from a different source was cut much less than usual. He could only afford enough for himself or I might have O/D ...


 How do you make a citizens arrest?
According to British law?...


 Is anyone with me that cops should be able to beat?
I think that it is really stupid that cops get in trouble for hitting someone with there club, or tazering someone. I think that cops should be able to whatever they want, I mean the people getting ...


 Why the racist cops gotta pull me over for?
i just came back from lunch and a damn cop pulled me over for going 56 in a 55
and he gives me warning but he had a hard *** ...


 Police officers...how does it feel to take someone freedom away for smoking a plant?

Additional Details
Actually I meant freedom like being able to not be imprisoned behind steel bars....


 If you were asleep and someone has broken into your home...?
and its dark, no lights, would you shoot first and just clean up the mess the idiots body made or say that you have a gun and that you WILL shoot and risk the possibility of them still coming at you? ...


 Can i press charges????????
i was driving home this evening when a man on the side of the road. booted my car with his foot (no damage that i can see of), i stopped the car as i thought he walked into the car, i opened door to ...


 Should prison be strictly for punishment?
What are your thoughts on the prison system and how can it be greatly improved if not just for punishment?...


 Can you find out who called the cops for a complaint on you?
get a police report?
Additional Details
it was over something sooo stupid. Thats why I want to know who cause we never have complaints on us ever. Someone called the cops cause our dogs ...


 What do you do when police keep killing blackmen?
Greetings,

Something teriible is going on. In my city two Blackmen have been killed by polie officers using tasers(50, 000 volts per charge). After investigation, the fist murder was ...


 Should male officers be aloud to strip search female prisoners?
...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.014