Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law Enforcement & Police

Do you think children under 10 should be prosecuted in the UK?
Find answers to your legal question.





Do you think children under 10 should be prosecuted in the UK?

3000 crimes are committed where the child is too young to be prosecuted. These kids are rampaging around our streets causing misery & mayhem. What is the solution?


    




EdgeWitch
I think if they are under 10 the parents should be made accountable. After all they shouldn't really be left running around without a watchful eye at that age.
Perhaps if the parent thought they were going to face prosecution they might take their responsibilities more seriously.
The children should not go without some punishment, but the onus should be placed at the parents feet too.


mandy s
no, but courts/police should put the parents in the dock as if they did the crime.


st.abbs
Charge the parents for their childrens behaviour, it's the only way to stop this crime wave by children.


Gone Fishing
Criminal get younger every day. They know damn what they are doing. Children of 10 or under should be taken into care and very strictly supervised. They should also be looked after in a way they probably are not at home. Violent children over over 10should be treated as adults.
Children are maturing physically much younger than they were even 30 years ago. If they are old enough to rape and kill they are old enough to be locked up for a long time. These brutes are nothing like what used to be called 'juvenile delinquents. It might be a good idea to bang their parents up with them.


sammie
Rating
Yes i do as children need to learn by example ...

Many children know the laws inside and out and know they are untouchable

If they were caught young then there is a chance to change that behaviour and hopefully curb any more criminal behaviours ..

That way more children would be brought to the attention of the authorities and may benefit from intervention from social services and so on


confucious says
Rating
make a new law, whatever the child does under the age of ten charge them with the crime and charge the parents with the same crime.
Or charge the parents with conspiracy to allow the children to commit the offence they have committed, IF THEY ARE FOUND GUILTY 200 hours mandatory community service, serving the community in which they live


Imogen M
These kids are NOT "rampaging around our streets". The crimes thay commit are usually very minor, they need social help and guidance (as do thier parents).

If a ten year old around here damages something.... it's not mailce it's because they've been lead on by older kids, or thier parents are not looking after them and are not teaching them the difference between right and wrong.

I unashamedly blame the parents, and the mass media for almost all antisocial behaviour in modern society.


shitebird
No they are to young to really understand. it is the parents who need the justise system to straighten them out..

we also need to stop listening to the idiots who think that if we disapline our kids we are being violent and cruel. a good spanking does wonders. once in a while and done with proper restraint it is a very very good thing.

Thanks to the system we now have we can not disaplin our kids , if we do we go to jail so now we have a load of youth running the streets doing as they please and no one can stop them, especially us parents whom are not allowed to kick thier backsides when it is appropriate to do so.

All i can say is if this nanny state wants to controll our lives to the point of raisieng our kids then let them be responsible for the trouble and crime they cause.

let parents parent our kids and we will have a more obedient to the law country of youths


PATRICK
yes and the parents
bring back the birch


Ghost Boy
so, an 8 year old kills someone. what happens? not common i know, but its possible. treat them the same as adults (obviously not an adult jail).


trucker
here is exactly what i would do with a case where a ten yr old shot somebody. I would arrest all those directly responsable for corrupting the hearts and minds of the british, the rich money makers of video games that affect the mind the judges that lgalise them, so that they can laugh all the way to the bank and put then behind bars and wipe the smile of their faces, remove from public view all negative things, and replace with the positive, demoralising the people is big businessand its old business, its got to start there no ten year old should face jail alone without his accomplises.


retaliationisnow
The smacking ban should be removed.
That way if a kid gets out of line they get a belting, simple as that.
Then they wont do what they do.
When they started the smacking ban years ago, thats when things started to go wrong.


kreiss
Rating
yes they should be prosecuted, i think it is wrong to say a child under 10 does not know right from wrong, if you catch a child young, and try to break the cycle of crime and teach them that what they are doing is not going to give them a good life, then we might get somewhere.The only other solution is...have you seen the film Battle Royale....think on


frankturk50
Yes and when you say 3000 crimes they are just the ones where the police recorded them there are numerous where nothing goes on paper because of the child's age.


You ask, I answer
Rating
if you do an adult crime, you should get tried as an adult.


Catwhiskers
perhaps a good solution would be to convict the parents of the offence, that way they might just keep better control of their child in the future.


Shakespeare
Rating
No, but the parents should be taken out at dawn and shot.

One part of the solution would be to get more men back into our schools to instill a bit of discipline into the little brats.


HUNNYMONSTA
Rating
The solution is to remove the obstructions, put in place by the PC Brigade, to educating children in the difference between right and wrong. There was a proven effective method for doing this for centuries prior to the PCBs involvement.

We should, as a society and until those obstructions are removed, hold those who put them in place responsible for every single crime committed and either jail or sue whoever signed the original proposal and ratified the law in each case.


amsterdam
No, prosecute the parents


Aravind
Children should not be prosecuted...
because the objective of any criminal law made must be to stop the crime.and in case of children,especially to stop the cause of these crimes.Children below 10 years of age are in no way to differentiate between right and wrong.Its the present social conditions that make them do these crimes.So what needs to be rectified is the the social conditions prevailing.this is indeed a longterm approach..As a short term approach to these matters,juvenile homes can be set up and even a psychological approach can be used to rectify the mindset of these children.
every generation designs and is a role model for the next..So lets not blame the children alone for all these..Take it as the responsibility of each and every citizen to build to healthy society!!


Michael z
Rating
if they are old to enough to do a crime they are old enough to die. if they enforce the death penalty to everyone - crime will drop....





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Could The Police Charge Me With Anything?
Me and my friends like doing something...

Everytime we see a cop car we point at it and quickly run away and the cops think that we hav done something bad so they chase us. We pretty much ...


 Why is there so few Female Dogs used in Police K9 Protection work...All I ever see is the Male Dogs?
Why is this?
And if the reason is that they need the females for good breeding stock ...can't she still work and breed?...


 Should there be more gun freedom?
If we have more gun freedom will it cause more crime or less crime?...


 Why are the cops corrupt?
I know many people who have a little badge or card given to them by a cop. The cop is usually a relative. With this card or badge, they simply wave it whenever they get pulled over for a trafic ...


 I'm 6'5 and 333lbs, if a cop is in your face talking and you tell him his breath stinks can he ticket you?
I told him this in front of a crowd people and his partners. How can he ticket me and what would be the charge?
Additional Details
I did not accept the ...


 Who are you voting for president?
i can't because i'm not old enough but i do know who i want for president. and i would tell but i'm afraid of being attacked because someone on here doesn't agree so i'll ...


 Who does a policeman stop if 2 or 3 cars are all speeding together...?
If there are 2 or 3 cars all speeding, either vertically in a line right after the other, or horizontally across several lanes on an expressway lets say... who does the policeman stop??...


 How do i remove a restraining order on my boyfriend?
...


 If I wanted to say Skrew everything and Live off the land could I LEGALLY DO IT?
could I quit my job and start living off the land anywhere could I legally do that if I owed nothing to no one....


 If you hire someone to kill a person, paying them or returning a debt.....?
Do you the person giving the orders but not commiting the act face life in jail...

what happends.

Dont get worried, just having a debate with friends about it....


 At the age of 17 if you committ a criminal act, are caught, and arressted, can you be tried as an adult?
Going to be 18 in 5 days........
Additional Details
They were caught smashing some girls windshield out on camera..... how bad is this crime?...


 Have you ever been stop by a Police Officer for NO REASON?
I am not talking about expired tags, broken lights, or car weaving. Looking suspicious is not reason neither, I beat that in court. No reason
Additional Details
Mr Dog Lover

I...


 Just had a TV delivered. Will it get stolen?
I desperately needed a television and I bought a good LCD one. I was burgled at Christmas and as the burglars weren't caught, I'm now worried that someone may have seen this new TV ...


 Does anyone know the fine/ban someone would recieve for doing 91mph in a 70mph zone, on "A" road in the uk
...


 Todays laws on self defence?
...


 Why do men get a bum deal if they report a woman raping them?
A man who reports that he was raped by a woman seems to get made out to be a joke.
Additional Details
I remember this issue being addressed in a crappy 1980's sitcom. A man got ...


 Have you ever been in a gun fight?
If yes, what happened?...


 What's the stupidest law you know?
...


 Wondering if police violated my rights?
so about two years ago my dad took our family out to eat at reno and we were coming back from a trip from reno. on the way back my dad pulls into Uhal to and then goes to walgreens, well all of a ...


 Very true don't you agree?
The classic police attitude blend of arrogance, smug superiority and know it all would be criticized as being damagingly out of place and over-authoritarian if it were how a parent treated their ten ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.014