Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law Enforcement & Police

Do you think the police used excessive force on the two bank robbers today?
Find answers to your legal question.





Do you think the police used excessive force on the two bank robbers today?

or do you think they were justified in taking down these criminals


    




GoreyAlan Fáilte
Why bother trying to arrest such scum. The courts will only be lenient , they'd probably only have got 8-10 years for attempted armed robbery and would only have done half of that then been eligible for parole. This way no messing about, no stupid judges and no cost to the tax payer. Shoot the lot of them I say.


Beer Advocate
Completely justified.


D B
there is no such thing as excessive force on bank robbers.


As Real As It Gets
Looked clean to me.


j.pee69
The police used reasonable force. One of the robbers had a gun at the security officer. A beer for the police officers involved barman please.


Mab
No. Saves us the cost of a trial, and 100k each a year to keep them in prison. Well over 1.5 million. Worth shooting them. Hats off to the flying squad.


BlackSheep
Rating
No....you can't tackle armed robbers with harsh words anymore... too many police have been gunned down in recent times.


bugaboo
Not if they were armed with sawn off shotguns..


harry
Rating
the criminals went with guns and must have been prepared to use them they deserved what they got good on the police


Rommel
yess i do!!! and about bl**dy time too.


phlada64
Rating
I dont know. Do you think they used excessive force on the carjacker who shot four officers, one of whom died ? When you put a badge on and go after a crook, you tell me how you would handle it.


emiss
for once absolutely NO


Smoochy Poochy
they were armed so no the force was correct.


LEONARD W
Nope.


beerforjay77
Very justified. Someone needs to let them know the police arent messing around.


njn001
Rating
Where the robbers armed? or appear to be armed? If yes, then the robbers must have to expect to be met with with armed officers and the possibly pay the ultimate price. Shoot or be shot what would you do?


Animemadness
Rating
How come the police can shoot two bank robers and no one cares but when they shoot someone who they suspect to be a terrorist who is going to blow up hundreds of people everyone throws their arms in the air. In my view both cases were justified.


confucious says
Rating
yes off course they were on the face of it. as heard on the news they were allegedly holding a gun to a hostages head


jillybird
Not at all, its time our police got tough on the scum walking our streets.


Frank
No

even if the police were waiting, they had to act and prevent the robbery.

A previous answer said they could have just shot and injured them, well anyone who gets shot, even in arm, leg etc could die from the trauma. You need to understand, if the police wound someone they could still shoot back, killing the security guards or the police officers attending,

this was not excessive force, The robbers went with the intent to use or scare using guns and they met their match this time... maybe if we had capital punishment for murderers etc brought back then it may prevent this type of crime and the police would not have to deal in this way.


LawGunGuy
Nope and this wasn't excessive either:
http://youtube.com/watch?v=8yoUaH6wGLs

Any clarification of why the police treat bank robbers harshly can be seen below.


Mr Sceptic
I can't say. Unlike the rest of you, I wasn't there and I don't really know what happened.

But in general, if these men were armed and a danger to those around, it was entirely proper to shoot them, dead if necessary, if proper warnings were given.

But the motivation must always be protection of the police officers and the public, not vigilanteism.

It is also entirely proper, that since two men are dead, a full investigation is carried out, hopefully leading to the complete exoneration of the officers involved, if the incident was as described on the news.

Mathilda: Trials are such a nuisance in our legal system, aren't they? I don't know why we bother wth them, they're all guilty anyway. (NB this is irony)


Copgirl
Rating
They were ARMED. What do you think the officers should have done? Let themselves and other innocent be shot? No, totally justified. To all of you that answered yes, what if you were in that bank today?


CLIVE H
Rating
No. The Flying Squad acted correctly. The bank robbers [ruthless criminals] were armed. At least one fully loaded hand gun was found at the scene, possibly dropped by one of the villains.

The police have a duty to enforce the law and maintain good order. Their job is to protect life, limb and property. They did exactly that.

For once, the fuzz did an excellent job. Ten out of ten.


Ian UK
I've been accused of using excessive force myself by members of the public who have caught the aftermath of an arrest/incident. With this is mind, I wouldn't really like to comment on the level of force used without knowing the full facts of the incident. Not that I'm suggesting that's what you are doing of course.

At the end of the day, its down to the relevant officers to justify their actions.


steven e
they did well.


Keith
I think the question should be would YOU have wanted them to use less force if you were a bank employee or customer who was there during the robbery? I wouldn't have.


vdv_desantnik
Rating
justified


Chief
It's always better to be tried by 12 than to be carried by 6.


kindred5eeker
Between two armed parties, I think it was reasonable force.

My take on it is that if you play with guns, and you get shot, don't be a baby about it.

And that would go for the armed police too !





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Is it legal for a minor child to be arrested at home without informing a parent first?
police came into our home and got my son out of bed and told him they wanted to talk outside once outside he asked to talk to his dad and they(police) told him no. We found out 3 hours later where he ...


 Are police officers above the law???
Yesterday i seen a cop take a red light & the camera flashed but his exempt license plate wont be getting a ticket. He wasent in no emergency as on the next light i waved hi to him & he ...


 Hi I'm really scared I gave a report to the police of 5 years of domestic violence?
Now what im scared what will happen to him he`s been told keep away for a week. I want him back home they say its allso out off myhzands and a domestic violence police officer will be calling and a ...


 If I'm naked in my own house and someone outside sees in, can I be arrested for indecent exposure?
I should add that I'm only curious....


 Statutory rape questions?
Is it Legal to have a girl pregnant at 16 and your 18? no comments just facts please
Additional Details
New Jersey my ...


 Do you feel guilty if you see a police officer, even if you've done nothing wrong?
If so, why?...


 Can I be taken to jail if I?
take my dad's car out for a joyride and get pulled over because i don't have a ...


 Will i get caught?
i stole a candy bar from brooks today and almost got caught, im only 14 and stealing is the only crime i prabably ever committe, but they asked me to empty my pockets and i had concealed the candy ...


 Do you own a firearm?
and if you do what kind of firearm do own and was it hard to get one and can you use it ...


 A police officer is coming into my class tomorrow, I need 5 questions, any ideas?
I'm in law class and can't think of any......


 Can police enter a home without consent if they believe underage drinking is occuring?
I had like 50 people at my house this weekend and the cops showed up at 5am cause the neighbors complained (those *******, thats the 4th time they've called on us, the other 3 for having fires......


 Some kids deliberately squirted water in my eyes as I drove past the garden they were in?
They are aged between 11 and 13 and should know better. I had my 15 week old son in the car and feel that they could have caused an accident. I spoke to the mother of the lad who's garden they ...


 Have you ever dialled 999?
If so why? Was it a real life and death emergency or could it have been dealt with on a general line?
Additional Details
Sorry guys i am in the uk.. we dial 999 for police , ambulance ...


 If there's more than 6 gunman outside my house, what should I do?
I need to know ASAP!...


 Do you think muslim women should be made to take their veil's off in public?
I think a law should be passed to make them take them off while living in britain they should be made to live by british laws, with the high risk of terrorism and suicide bombers, it could be anyone ...


 How do you get little kids to stop playing knock a door run?
now the weather is warmer the neighbours kids and a couple of there friends are out and they keep knocking on my front door then running away...its doing my head in and they are very cheeky when i ...


 What to do to become a police officer?
Do you need qualification etc?
and how long does it take to become one, also what is the basic pay for a new ...


 With 14 points on a licence and now driving without insurance what will happen?
Not for me, but for my husband. He has a total of 14 points on licence for driving without insurance twice about 2 years ago. He has now been pulled over again for same reason although he did have ...


 Should marajuana be legal?
Should weed be legal, as opposed to alcohol & other drugs......


 Do you believe Karr killed JonBenet or just wants to be known as the killer?
Since he knew details of the crime no one knew but the killer, is that proof positive he did it?

Or does he know who really did kill her and corresponded with them to get those details?...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.024