Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law Enforcement & Police

Hypothetical bank robbery question.?
Find answers to your legal question.





Hypothetical bank robbery question.?

If an armed man goes into a bank and robs all the customers without robbing the bank itself, and is arrested when the police arrive.
Is he charged with bank-robbery, as the offence took place on bank premises, or is he charged with plain armed robbery as the money he stole did not actually belong to the bank?


    




mollyflan
Rating
Since he didn't rob the bank he would probably be charged with plain armed robbery but I'm sure there are some lesser federal crimes associated with doing it in a bank that would also be tacked onto the armed robbery charge.


codemax77
I believe he would be charged with armed robbery of the customers and the bank . The district attorney would charge him with arm robbery of both the bank and the customers by figuring that they will prove intent later concerning the bank. Logically, how many people will rob the customers in the bank and not rob the bank itself? May be if the arm robber is retarded or insane. In either case that might make a good offense.


California Street Cop
Its armed robbery no matter where it takes place. Instead of the bank being listed as the victim, the individuals would be and you would be charged with 20 counts of robbery if 20 folks were present and robbed. Plus all of the other charges they could lay on you.


thethingzuneed
Rating
I'm sure robbing a bank is called armed robbery.

Not "bank" robbery. The charges would likely be identical.


g_arienti88
Rating
Off the top of my head I dont think the crime is called "bank robbery" i believe they call it grand theft.

It would depend on how much money he/she stole.


Mr. Happy
Well i would charge him with burglary because he entered a structure with the intent to commit a crime and then i would add on armed robbery. Both burglary and robbery is a felony so whether it qualifys as bank robbery or not the guy is doing some jail time.


Anpadh
Bank robbery. He is robbing bank customers and/or potential customers. Plus, he is ruining the reputation of the bank. Also, considering that the robber was in a bank, robbing people, the bank could clearly show intent to rob the bank. Otherwise, why rob people in the bank instead of robbing them on the street? Most important: What are the odds that the robbers have not stolen SOMETHING belonging to the bank while they are robbing people?


justinbowen2003
wow.. thats actually funny. it would be armed robbery


yenrib@sbcglobal.net
Rating
interesting


libbay
Rating
i would say armed robbery, but they would probably charge him for bank robery because he was "in" a bank and the law enforcers screw ppl over like that all the time.


ironjag
Rating
Most likely just robbery of the individuals, but there may be some other issues.

I don't think you have bank robbery. What makes bank robbery a federal offense is that you are taking money from the bank and the bank operates in interstate commerce (hence bank robbery being a federal crime). So, if you don't take the bank's money, you are't within the criminal jurisdiction of the feds.

That's a nutshell version...don't rely on it in real life, because you asked a finite question about bank robbery, not ALL the possible crimes you could go down for.


space chimp
Rating
id have a good plan b4 you rob anything........... Get 2 get away cars 1 with fliping licence plates for the initial get away car from the scene, then a faster car for the long term get away. Then go straight to mexic


sabrinaroz
Rating
I think it would be classified as a hold up.


Audrey S
I think he should be charged with armed robbery and for aggravated assault as I am sure it was very aggravating to the customers


bittywrap
Rating
Probably bank robbery.


dwmatty19
It depends on the laws of that state. In most states, there is no such crime as "bank robbery", just as there is no such crime as "store robbery" or "gas station robbery". It's just plain "robbery".

If someone robs 9 people, then they are charged with 9 counts of "robbery", along with a host of other charges.


remoserjr107
Armed? Federal Bank Property.......He'll get his 3 meals and a bed for quite a while!!!!!!!!!!!


stephanie
Rating
plain robbery


B
Rating
plain armed robbery, because he didn't steal from the bank.


GG
good question. probably just armed robbery, though the bank will press charges along the lines of endangerment,tresspassing, etc.


George N
Rating
Great question. I would say that it is still considered a bank robbery because most of the money on the customers is probably going into the bank or came from the bank, plus it is in a bank. Try it out and let me know how it goes!


xx_kim_xx
Rating
uhh...why are you asking?!


April
good question


sarah f
Rating
im a blonde sooooooooooooo i d k





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Can the police do this?
I was stopped today by two cops for no reason and they started searching me. I was wondering if this is allowed?...


 Is my mom going to jail?
my step dad claims my mom threw boiling water on him and he has the wounds on camera. she is charged with assualt in the 3rd degree. do you think she is going to prison.. i looked it up and it is a ...


 Which Do You Think Is Worse?
Which Way Is The Worst Way To Die Out Of These?
Being Beheaded, Getting The Electric Chair, Or Being Gased With Poison Gas?...


 Since when did it become so popular to hate your local Police Official?
I'm feeling pretty mean today, especially after reading all the hate and anger directed against those who have taken an oath to serve and protect you. I know it comes with the territory of the ...


 What if I commit crime before I go on vacation?
I mean supossedly hypothetically I comited a crime and then I left for vacation to like for say Asia, who is gonna get me?...


 I'm in Mexico for vacation and 2 yrs ago i wrote bad checks im coming back to US, will i get arrested?
i know i have a misdemeanor warrant for the bad check, i want to take care of it but im afraid i will get arrested crossing the border....


 OK, you're in a movie gunfight, what pistol would you pick and why?
Mine would be one of the following:

Para Ordnance p-14 (.45)
Sig 226 .40S&W
Sig 226 or 229 in .357 Sig
FN Five-SeveN
Smith and Wesson 327 (eight shot, .357 revolver)...


 Can one be committed to peace even while supporting war?
...


 Can you stop someone taking you to court?
My ex is obsessed with making my life hell and has taken me to court EVERY YEAR since we split - wasting the courts time and upsetting the children each time. He has now sent me a letter saying he is ...


 Driving while using a mobile phone?
if you see some-one driving & using mobile phone at same time, then report it to the police they'd take you serious & do sometime about it
Additional Details
so if everyone ...


 Should hanging or the electric chair be brought back for murderers and the birch for muggers, burglars etc?
...


 I keep stealing from shops?
Every time I go out shopping I steal things ie: dvd's, cd's, cloths ect ect, I am currently working as a special contstable for the met police and I am very worried I will get caught. The ...


 Why are undercover policemen so rude?
...


 Some of my best friends do drugs and i am a Police cadet and i wanna turn them in but at the same time the
i could always find out who they get the drugs from before i tell anyone what should i do
Additional Details
hey i am just trying To keep drugs out my town and out of my ...


 Do I have a case for an illegal search of my vehicle?
Ok so a week ago my friend and I were sitting in my car down the street from her house. After an hour or so two cop cars pull up behind mine. One officer comes up and asks us basic questions like ...


 I was caught by police for drunk driving they take my blood test?
i want to know that if the reading comes less than 85mg according to uk law wthat they will do and if more than 85 whhat will happen or they will again arrest me and what is the panelty becase i work ...


 Can an officer stop you for saying something?
i was walking home last night and i was talking to my friend next to me about the saying "don't bring a knife to a gun fight". unfortunately an off duty police overheard me from about 2...


 What is the best solution to get rid of firearms/guns?
...


 Can a Police officer arrest you for pushing him.?
...


 What do you do if you find your (UK) passport right after reporting it lost to police?
...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.034