Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law Enforcement & Police

If being arrested do the police have to tell you what your being charged with.?
Find answers to your legal question.





If being arrested do the police have to tell you what your being charged with.?

If someone has been arrested do the police have to tell that person when being arrested what they are charged with.


    




Easy
1 ARRESTED?


Being arrested can lead to bail, court, a fine, a criminal record, prison and difficulty in getting a job. Being arrested by the Police means that you are a "suspect" of a crime and will be taken into the hands of the law. You lose

freedoms, but still have rights.


The Police must tell you what you’re being arrested for. If you’re not being arrested, you are under no obligation to go with them or answer any of their questions.


If you’re arrested, you don’t need to say anything at this stage. You have the right of silence. Any conversation or comment has to be recorded by the officer in their notebook, and may be used in evidence against you. If you’re arrested with a warrant, the Police should take you to court or release you on bail as soon as possible. If you’re charged you’re usually released within 24-hours,

although this is not necessary by law.


tucksie
Rating
Just because you are arrested it doesn't mean you are going to be charged but they should tell you why you are being arrested. They will say *it's on suspicion of* If they think they have you banged they usually bail you to appear at the station at a later date. Of course this does not apply in serious cases where you will be remanded in custody.


MarkEverest
There are some very silly and unhelpful answers here, and one or two sensible ones. I did my training as a police officer in England, so I can only answer for England and Wales.

If a person is arrested they must be told that they are under arrest and why they are under arrest, unless it is impractical to do so, for example the person being arrested is too drunk to understand what is being said to them. In such a case the person must be told as soon as it is possible. Normally a person being arrested will be cautioned at the time and then anything they say after that caution, including any admissions, can be tendered in evidence in later proceedings. If after arrest a suspicion is formed that the arrested person has commited other offences, they must be told that they are also under arrest for those matters.

Don't forget that you can be arrested for any indictable offence, and not just by police officers, and the person making the arrest may use reasonable force to make sure the arrest is successful.

Arrest is totally different from being charged. In all but very minor cases nowadays the Crown Prosecution Service must look at the evidence before it will aprove a person being charged with an offence, and this is why more people are released on police bail nowadays than used to be the case, in order to allow time for a charging decision to be made.

Once a person has been charged, then a court appearance date will be set for the case to have its first hearing.


Angry Daisy
Rating
They only have to have probable cause to arrest you (more than suspicion of commission of an offense). They don't have to tell you what, but they do have to read you Miranda. Usually, you'll figure it out in questioning. You don't have a right to know the charges until arraignment, technically.


A R
arrest and charge are different.

1) you are arrested (and told what for)
2) interviews etc
3) if sufficent evidence, you are charged with the offence and told what you are charged with.


joeanonymous
Rating
Everyone who is arrested is not necessarily charged. You can be arrested and released with no charges (or charged at a later date).
The officer is supposed to (at least in Canada anyway) tell you what you are being arrested for.


commercium1
Arrested and charged are two different things.When arrested you are informed of the reason for the arrest.The person is only then charged after the investigation is complete.


Bobby B
No they have to tell them what they are being arrested for but not what they are being charged with as charges do not always follow arrest. Somebody could be released without charge


salvationcity
No.

You can be arrested without charge, but you have to be told why you are being arrested, e.g drunken behaviour, suspicion of having drugs etc.

The decision to charge you with an offence can come months later.


Butt
Rating
No they're told after questioning.


Loo
Rating
No they don't have to until they charge you as being arrested is not actually being charged, you could be later released without charge.


THE BULB
The police have to tell you why you are being arrested. A charge is different to an arrest though. You could be arrested for one thing, but on investigating the offence they find that you actually will be charged with something else. eg, you could be arrested for Theft, but charged with Handling stolen goods! It's the CPS who give the authority to charge, so regardless of what the police arrest you for, they will authorise a charge which best fits the evidence.
It is quite normal to be charged for something which you weren't initially arrested.
The arrest is made in order to allow you to give your explanation in a taped interview and also for the police to investigate. What transpires out of that dictates what charge if any is brought against you.


Donna M
Rating
They have to tell you what your being arrested on suspicion of. If they fail to do that, then you may have a case for accusing them of false arrest.


Christopher
Rating
You can be arrested without being charged. However, if you ARE charged with something, they have to tell you.


Briar
Rating
Habeas Corpus. Habeas Corpus.

Oh wait--Bush killed that.


beanie
Rating
yes they do and they have to make sure that you understand the charge.


migdalski
Rating
I don't know, but would have thought so.


CT
Yes, but if you need true answers about the police and civil rights, go to this site.

www.askthe.police.uk

It is a brillant site.


rick_wenham
Being arrested and being charged are different matters,

When you are arrested the Police & Criminal Evidence Act states that a person MUST be informed that they are under arrest and the offence they have been arrested for, unless it is not practicable to do so (fighting, drunk or not understanding english) then they must be told as soon as possible.

When you are charged with an offence this is where the investigation is complete and you are cautioned in the police station and the charge is read out to you formally, this does not have to be the offence that you were arrested for, but this is the offence that you will be prosecuted for in court.


cuteshowgrl01
Rating
no they dont have to do anything!! usually since their cops they think everything is there way (example they can speed, not buckle up, etc) but if u ask they should tell you and theres a law saying they have to tell you...so yes they do have to tell you!!


CLIVE H
Rating
In both UK and US it is normal practise to inform an arrested person of the charge and also to tell them their rights in respect of being arrested.

A person's rights in UK depend upon laws set by Parliament as well as rights set by the European Parliament.

Not sure exactly what these are.

In US, citizens have rights under the Constitution as well as The Bill of Rights.

Any infringement of a person's rights, could result in a person not coming to court.

If you are arrested - do NOT make any statement without the presence of your lawyer. If a statement is forced from you, this is duress and an infringement of your rights.


douglas y
Rating
Yess, the reason is so you understand what is going on andyou can take action on that .If they did not then how would you be able to defened your self in court


Fredo
Rating
They have to. The have to let you know why your being arrested or else it would be against the law.


Mrs G
No - not until you have been roughed up a-bit - and they have tried to find something they can get you for - they don't want to waste their time (& yours) .. getting you down the nick for nothing,


chutney
Yes they do. i.e. I'm arresting you on suspicion of blah blah blah, you do not have to say anything but it may harm your etc etc.


L D
Yes, it is a requirement for them to give a reason.


Gilly
Yep I should hope so last thing you want is to think you being charged for not paying for a parking ticket,and finding out you being charged with murder.


Norm
Yes they do


Clare S
yes


foggy
Rating
yes as im sure that theyre legally obliged!!





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Capital punishment for these b,s who abuse and kill children who cannot protect themselves. Its too often now?
I have just been reading the news and all it is children being horrifically abused and killed. This country has got to get a grip. Our forensic and DNA is sufficient nowadays to make sure nobody gets ...


 Who pays my landlord for a new door that the cops kicked in?
Last week I was sitting at home minding my owns business and here come the cops with six cars, a paddy wagon, a helocopter and two dogs. They come up on my house and kick down my door, throw some ...


 Why have so many people lost faith in the police?
...


 Why do you believe that the crime rate of African Americans is higher than other groups?
Coincidence or do you have a theory....


 If i refuse a Breathalyzer test could i lose my license?
...


 Do you think the police used excessive force on the two bank robbers today?
or do you think they were justified in taking down these ...


 What would happen if i shifted into reverse while speeding down the highway?
...


 Do you think guns kills people or people using the guns kill people?
If yo uthink about it, guns are fairly safe, they can not just shot them selves, so i am just a lil curious....


 What would happen if we DID put a total ban on guns in this country?
i'm guessing that gun crimes statistics go way, way down and the incidences of murder by some other means goes way, way up...

what say you?......


 I accidentally ran over a swan, so I took it home and ate it - can I be hanged for treason?

Additional Details
It was quite gamey. I roasted it but it was a bit overpowering so I made a huge stew - that was much nicer....


 Can police come into a house without knocking first?
the police come to my home last night to arest my nephew that lives with me. for a minor assult.that we didnt know anything about.thay just come in opend my kitchen door then souted hello. didnt have ...


 I was pulled over by the police, asked to step out of the car, and instead I drove away. what willl happen?
I was pulled over for no turn signal, but wasn't written a ticket. I was in a known drug area, and the police wanted to search my car which I refused. This happened 2 counties away from where I ...


 I have used someones credit card details, and they want to press charges.?
what is the procedure of the investigation? when will the police come for me? what is the likely punishment?...


 Do you agree with all these people who claim quotas and revenue generation as the only reason for tickets?
Seems like someone is always claiming the police have quotas, and the reason for tickets is to generate revenue. Of course, I know both are false, but am I the only one that knows this?

H...


 If my dad hit me can he go 2 jail?

Additional Details
my dad has an angermanegment problem and he gets mad easily but we have had our problems lately with my boyfirend and stuff b/c my parents dont like him and told me ...


 Is this appropriate behavior for a police officer?
I was pulled over by a state trooper for speeding in Wisconsin just between Madison and Milwaukee around 1:00am last night. Unfortunately, I'm guilty as charged. But when the cop approached my ...


 Is it legal for a minor child to be arrested at home without informing a parent first?
police came into our home and got my son out of bed and told him they wanted to talk outside once outside he asked to talk to his dad and they(police) told him no. We found out 3 hours later where he ...


 Are police officers above the law???
Yesterday i seen a cop take a red light & the camera flashed but his exempt license plate wont be getting a ticket. He wasent in no emergency as on the next light i waved hi to him & he ...


 Hi I'm really scared I gave a report to the police of 5 years of domestic violence?
Now what im scared what will happen to him he`s been told keep away for a week. I want him back home they say its allso out off myhzands and a domestic violence police officer will be calling and a ...


 If I'm naked in my own house and someone outside sees in, can I be arrested for indecent exposure?
I should add that I'm only curious....




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.074