Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law Enforcement & Police

If violence doesn't solve anything then what is the purpose of capital punishment?
Find answers to your legal question.





If violence doesn't solve anything then what is the purpose of capital punishment?


Additional Details
TKD, the road to Hell is paved with good intentions.

Nice try, though.


    




rockinjesusfreak03
Given the nature of capital punishment in America, it can hardly be called violent. But capital punishment serves to let people know that capital crimes will not be tolerated.


diobalikal
Sure it solves things, the person executed will never kill or harm again will he?


hyelife99
Rating
VIOLENCE SOLVES ALOT OF THINGS

it solved one of my problems :)

........self..................
defense...............


Biker
justice


iraqisax
Obviously capital punishment stops the person being executed from committing more crimes.


John Hightower
It ensures that the ciminal will never do it again.


rhenry501
Rating
Makes room in the prison for the next group of **** heads.


BrutalBaby
Rating
I never said violence doesn't solve anything. If that were true we would be speaking with British accents and sipping tea. :0)


Chester's Liver
Rating
Capital punishment isn't violent. Raping, torturing and then killing someone with a brick is. Its simple. Kill a fellow man and you die. Its very basic and very simple. Its anything but violent.


Stupid Marxist
Rating
"Violence solves nothing" is a myth. Violence can solve plenty.


mike b
to get rid of garbage


tearsofthemoon00
Rating
It stop that person from doing the same thing again.


scruffycat
Capital punishment isn't violent. It's a very peaceful way to die... Capital punishment is simply euthanasia.

Violence is: (according to American Heritage Dictionary)
vi·o·lence (vī'ə-ləns) Pronunciation Key
n.
Physical force exerted for the purpose of violating, damaging, or abusing: crimes of violence.
The act or an instance of violent action or behavior.
Intensity or severity, as in natural phenomena; untamed force: the violence of a tornado.
Abusive or unjust exercise of power.
Abuse or injury to meaning, content, or intent: do violence to a text.
Vehemence of feeling or expression; fervor.


Libkillah
Rating
A person who has shown the propensity for killing others should be removed from the planet in order to assure that innocent law abiding people are safe to live their lives. I bet you think its OK to abort a baby though huh?


goodtimesgladly
Who says violence doesn't solve anything? It got rid of Hitler and a bunch of other loose-rs like Saddam?


POLARIS
Rating
To insure that the animals who commit heinous crimes never have the chance to escape from prison and commit more heinous crimes. Good riddance!


Natalie
Some people no longer deserve their lives or taxpayers' dollars to keep them properly nutritioned and air conditioned, etc.


blondie
Rating
their has got to be some law to take the killers ,rapist &robers out of the population or they will keep on doing the crime the biggest mistake is when the stoped the parents from disipilaning there children.and envinted violant vidoe games.it foges there mind and they don,t know what they are doing wrong.


TKD540
Those are two different forms of violence with different intentions. You can not compare the two. Nice try though.


Rich F
Rating
Your first statement is flawed. Violence does indeed solve things..permanently.

But the purpose of capitol punishment is simply to remove any further threat posed by that individual. People see no problem with putting a rebid dog to sleep because it can never be "cured"...same theory with serious criminals..


bellatrix27
Rating
who decided that violence doesnt solve anything? there is a difference between killing an innocent person, and killing someone who has committed a crime. the purpose is to deter others by making them afraid of the penalty, and to save the unaffordable amount of money it costs to keep someone living in jail with food, books, tv for 50, 60 years. it keeps the worst criminals from having a wife visit them in jail, from writing books or meeting people in jail who they could influence or inspire. and their deaths are not violent. they get to sit in a nice bed and get some injection and go to sleep. obviously not the nice death their victims probably got.


ROBERT L O
Rating
It is just a form of vengeance. It deters or solves nothing.


rhamm618
Actually, it is not violence,
violence is an act against the society, or community prohibited by law.
Force, is an act to right a wrong. So pulling the switch is using extreme force. A cop can wrestle you to the ground to put cuffs on you, that is a force to enforce a law prohibiting an activity, for example. A cop can use a sheild and a weapon, if necessary too, and that is a force to right a wrong.
Death sentence is a force...extreme force used to right and extreme wrong.
Vigilanté Justice is unauthorized force, which is still not violence.


freebird
Rating
Wrong premise. Violence does solve things. Otherwise, no-one would use it, not even the bad guys.

We all have clear examples of how violence is deterimental to society, so no need to recount them here. But we tend to forget (somewhat conveniently) cases where violence is a good solution (and therefore does solve something).

For example:

Cops shoot an armed robber
Wars stop despotic dictators (WWII)
Arrests (many of which are violent) get bad guys off the street
Fighting back against a school yard bully
Wars for independence or against slavery (ie American Revolution, Civil War)

So now the Death Penalty decision cannot be based on whether violence CAN solve something, because it can and does. Now the decision is whether the Death Penalty is a form of violence that is beneficial to society. But that's an answer to a different question.

But given that the last person DP'd in California was put to death after organizing the deaths of three people (two teenagers) while serving a life sentence (commuted from a previous DP sentence), I'd say the death penalty serves a purpose.


Linkin
You're assuming that violence doesn't solve anything. Once you understand that's not the case, then you'll have the answer.


izzy
Rating
Whoever said that violence doesn't solve anything is denying a very basic fact of life. Violence puts food on the table (hunting & fishing) protects life and property (shooting the armed robber who has a gun in the bank), and accomplishes things that diplomacy cannot (American Independance, Preventing the secession of the Confederate States of America from the union, etc.)


karen v
to show everyone what will happen to you when you commit a crime against someone.


Lou B
Rating
You are right, capital punishment doesn't solve anything. It's purpose, therefore, is based upon "Wishful Thinking". Some day, in the future, better, more civilized ways to prevent violence and crime will be found, and it will not be "Capitol Punishment".


tina
Rating
I totally agree with you. they contradict themselves i would think they only put to death da people who they cant seem to know how long to put them in prison for.
some crimes, are just aweful and sentencing them for life is too minor a punishment.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 What can I do to help my daughter?
My daughter is going through a dangerous divorce and I don't know how to help her. Her husband is stalking her, beating on her, and threatening to take their 2 small children and leave with them....


 Will i be over the limit?
ive had 2 shots of bailys irish cream tonight and what i want to know is will i be ok to drive in the morning without being near or over the DD limit might sound a silly question but i dont usually ...


 Give a SINGLE WORD answer to, what do you think of the british police?
Remeber, just one ...


 Is it pointless to file a police report over a stolen bike?
since the chances of getting it back are so small?...


 Can a Police Officer make me pull up my windows?
I have my front windows tinted at 20% which is pretty dark but in the day time you can see through it. My question is if my windows are always down and when a cop stops me can he make me pull my ...


 Can my boyfriend plead not guilty for DUI?
My boyfriend got a DUI last Saturday night and he's also being charged with underage drinking and having an open container but it wasn't his bottle it was his friend's who was sitting ...


 If you egg someones house, can you be arrested?
...


 How much time would a 15 yr old female get in jail for comiting murder??
...


 Do you like cops?
The people, NOT the tv ...


 What will be my punishment for doing 110 mph on an A road!?
was the middle of the day, open road, unmarked car got me? gotta go court, now what!! first offence?? what will i recieve!!
Additional Details
A road is a duel carrageway!...


 Do you feel more, less, or relatively unchanged regarding your safety since 911?
Please explain your answer....


 Owner of dog that killed the little girl?
Should the owner of the dog that killed that little girl be tried for manslaughter because he had already had warnings about the ...


 If you are stopped by the Police in your car for any reason, and they ask you to get out of it are you legally
entitled to refuse?
Additional Details
Thank you for your answers, I notice some are from our American friends, I have seen some of their police heavy handedness on TV which is fast ...


 Would you lie to stop your child going to jail , even if you knew he/she was guilty?
...


 What is the best way to argue a speeding ticket?
I recently got a speeding ticket on I-95 in Newbury, MA. I was going 22 mph over the speed limit according to the officer. The boxes "LIDAR" and "Estimated" were checked. The ...


 I am 16 yrs old and I am on 6 months probation for shoplifting at wal mart and just not to long ago I got ?
caught again not to long ago with a friend of mine that is not a minor and we both did not get put in jail or anything but i know there will be a court date for both of us I just want to know what ...


 Do the public care a police officer has been shot dead? (UK)?
For doing his duty in protecting the public?
He has paid the ultimate price.

Do the Briish public appreciate this?
And will it make them realise the REAL dangers our un-armed ...


 My ex-boyfriend wants the stuff we bought together??
I just recently broke up with my boyfriend. Yesterday I had packed all his clothes and things that he had left here and gave them to him. While we were together we had bought DVDs together and a ...


 Do women in prison for long terms go gay?
...


 Parking ticket?
My sister just got a parking ticket for being 11 mins late back to her car. Do you think she's got a good chance of getting it cancelled if she can think of a good reason for being late back....




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.014