Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law Enforcement & Police

Is it illegal to give a police officer "the finger"?
Find answers to your legal question.





Is it illegal to give a police officer "the finger"?

could you get arrested or ticketed for flipping off an on-duty officer? if so, under what law? this is just an in general situation, not during being pulled over or anything like that. just like in passing. answers from officers or from people that know the law are appreciated. i have never done this or plan on doing this, by the way.
Additional Details
hmm, well i've received many answers. thank you to those who completely read my question and legitimately answered.

i feel like most people answering don't know the law and are just answering based on what they "think" and not what they "know". this does NOT help me find my answer, but congrats on your 2 points.

i also have different people claiming to be officers answering, but with different results. who to believe, i am not sure. i can't find any information online, searching with several paramaters...


is there no ONE LAW in the UNITED STATES which governs this question? is it truly different state by state, county, city, town, neighborhood???

if not/if so can anyone link me up to a site that can back up your answer?

and as i formerly stated, this is not something i have done or would do to an officer. i am doing research. thank you.


    




martin b
Rating
It may be depending on what state or municipality you are in and what obscenity laws they have on the books.

Just a note: Bad idea even if there is no such law. A police officer can always find a reason to arrest someone. Some officers may laugh it off, but most will not.


helene
no


FRAGINAL-NOYPI
"The finger" is an affront against the Police Officer constituting as Disrespect to An Authority and it is punishable under the Penal Code.


redlizzard1121
Rating
Yes. I believe this falls under harrassing an officer, and it can at least get you taken down to the station, if not arrested and fined.


sexxymexxy926
Rating
Yep, we can write you for disorderly conduct under our ordinance:

Disorderly conduct to wit: did knowingly display a vulgar or obscene gesture in a public place.


Soul Rebel
I think it's known as insulting an officer.


Joey
Nope. It just eggs them on though. They are supposed to be professional and ignore it.


mikeysco
Normally, I read all the answers to a question before I answer it, but I'm just not going to do it this time.

In California, the answer to your question is no.


GeT fAmIliAr
Rating
LOL, probably


rhymingron
Rating
No, but if you are dumb enough to do it you will probably regret it.


acharz
Why would you do that anyway? Are you childish? I guess so. And people who do that wonder why the police dont come in time...


alienform2003
it's illegal because it's indecent and he can charge you with public exposure


slicktop80
The courts have ruled that this is protected under "freedom of speech". In Texas, this used to be a misdemeanor charge of public lewdness. That law was struck down, and it is not a crime any longer. It now falls into a non-official group of offenses that are included in the P.O.P. (Pissing Off Police) category. You might not get pinched for "expressing" yourself, but you may very well get "scrutinized" for any number of other infractions. Just because it's legal does not mean it's smart. Hell, you can drive nails with a wrench, but that does not make it a good idea. Save yourself the trouble and just curse under your breath.


cantcu
Rating
I think they do arrest some people for it, though I think it is unconstitutional!
This is what Colorado says about it!:
Harassment
A person commits harassment if they do any of the following with the intent to annoy or alarm another person:

"* strikes, hits, kicks, shoves, or touches a person or subjects him/her to physical contact
* uses obscene language or makes an obscene gesture to or at someone in a public place
* follows a person in or around a public place"

"S.D. high court: Teen's obscene gestures weren't protected speech

By The Associated Press
06.15.02
PIERRE, S.D. — A teen-ager who flipped up his middle finger and mouthed the f-word several times at a school official was properly convicted of disorderly conduct, the state Supreme Court majority ruled June 13.

But two dissenting justices said the boy, identified only as S.J.N-K. to protect his identity as a juvenile, was within his free-speech rights.

S.J.N-K. made the obscene gestures to Yankton Middle School Principal Wayne Kindle"

"This was not merely the use of one profane word or one obscene gesture, it was an ongoing aggression that falls outside free-speech protection," wrote Chief Justice David Gilbertson.

The encounter with Kindle and his family was prompted because the principal had refused to allow S.J.N-K. to skip eighth grade. The boy later managed to skip the grade and start high school by transferring to Vermillion.

"S.J.N.-K.'s act of retaliation against Kindle for not letting him skip the eighth grade and advance to high school is not political speech," Gilbertson added. "It was an unprovoked form of harassment, done but for no apparent purpose than to incite a violent reaction in Kindle. S.J.N.-K. is not relieved of guilt simply because his attempts to provoke Kindle were unsuccessful."

Former Acting Justice Max Gors, who dissented with Justice Robert A. Amundson in the 3-2 ruling, said S.J.N-K.'s conduct was rude and obnoxious but did not amount to disorderly conduct, especially in a confrontation involving a seasoned school principal.

The boy was protected by the Constitution's free-speech guarantee, Gors wrote, adding that S.J.N-K.'s behavior did not amount to provocative "fighting words" that are outside of the constitutional shroud."


Though I think it is not something one should do, flipping off a seasoned police officer does not constitute a violation of law and I believe protected freedom of speech under the !st Amendment!


Draco
I seriously doubt it but, I would advise against it as it would most likely provoke the officer to take a closer look at your car and try find the tiniest error to fine you.


Debi K
not illegal, but not wise either.


elliepatchouli
Rating
My friend got a disorderly conduct ticket for calling a cop a pig.


hollywood71@verizon.net
Rating
hand signals have been considered under the freedom of speech. they could pull you over and try to ticket as a obscene gesture, but many have not held up in court. if they pulled you over, they could find something to give a traffic ticket for or see something in a car to give reasonable searches.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 What happens if when you are asked to go to a police station?
About three months ago, myself a two others were dismissed from our bar job for drinking after a shift and breaking some glasses. It appears the owner of the bar has informed the police, on friday a ...


 Would you class this as harassment ?
Over a 3 hour time span. 15 text messages. answer machine full with messages and unable to record any more. and about 30 missed calls. other ocassions following.
Additional Details
no ...


 Are American police allowed to use a taser on someone pinned to the ground?
I just wanted clarification. Someone told me that they can use a taser if someone is resisting arrest despite being held on the ground by 4 or 5 officers. That just does not seem like appropriate ...


 Is it true you can't go to jail if you steal something under $20?
just ...


 I was arressted for missing a court date, when I go back to court.. will i go to jail?
In feb. of 2006 I was pulled over because I worked over night and was feeling sleepy on the way home, so when the cop pulled me over I was hit with wreckless driving. I never went to court for that ...


 Why do criminals always have tattoos?
All the wanted posters and news bulletins identify crimials by their tattoos.

If you wanted to be a criminal, shouldn't you avoid getting tattoos so noone can identify you?...


 Why do parents tell their kids to stop doing this or that or I'm going to have that policeman arrest you?
Im a police officer, and when I'm in uniform I hear this all the time. Parents should encourage their kids to speak with us and trust us, not be afraid of us.

I know what some of you ...


 I am going to court for a speeding offence. The NIP was over 4 weeks old when I received it. Win or lose?
The law states that a speeding fine has to be issued within 2 weeks of being caught. I recieved mine after 4 weeks therefore it should be invalid. I refused to pay and opted to go before the ...


 What are would happen if someone stabbed me in the back of the head?
3 or 4 times...
Additional Details
i feel fine though

it is bleeding profusely?@$^%!...


 Are police tasers more deadly than police guns?
I would like to know what people think about tasers being used instead of guns. Any studies to back up your answer would be great!!!...


 If you killed someone who killed your cousin?
would you go to jail? or what will happen cause im about to do it
Additional Details
and also they didnt find him ...


 My fiance is a police officer, what can I do for his birthday?
My fiance and I have been together for almost 4 years now. He recently graduated the police academy in July and is working as a cop for 2 different areas.. Any ideas what might be a good present for ...


 Why do so many cops smell like pig sweat?
Haven't they ever heard of showers?...


 My friend got cuaght stealing does anyone know what her punishment might be?
she was 17 when she got caught but now she's 18 and the court date is tomorrow and she doesnt know if they will punish her as an 18 year old or 17 or what might happen to her does anyone have an ...


 Chris Langham - The Judge should not have been so judgemental?
The judge said that Chris Langham "will be shunned by many in public".
I think he has gone too far there - it is one thing for him to pass sentance, but to make those comments is using ...


 How can a pellet gun kill someone?
There was a news story that said a home owner shot a man who was stealing his Mary Jane; he shot the guy with a pellet gun and the man died. How is this possible?...


 If you are having a party at your house can cops enter without a warrent?
They shouldn't be able to right? If its a private party on your property!
Additional Details
Wow Jenny June, you really aren't a nice person are you? I am sorry I made a typo ...


 Do you think this country is too soft on crime? Are prisons too much like camps and should the death penalty?
...be restored?....I think that prisons are too much of an easy option-pool tables,colour TVs,gyms,available tobacco and drugs,nice meals..no wonder offenders re-offend they don't mind going ...


 HELP ive had a letter from stanford & green bailiffs,?
ive made a arrangment with the boss called mr stanford to pay them £20.00 every month. i pay this through recorded delivery but they said they didnt recieve the giro, i phoned royal mail up and they ...


 Police records on some thing that happen over 25 years ago is it still on files?
...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.044