Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law Enforcement & Police

Is it police harassment if a cop pulls me over for a tail light he says is burnt out even though it does work?
Find answers to your legal question.





Is it police harassment if a cop pulls me over for a tail light he says is burnt out even though it does work?

I've been pulled over 3 different times in the last 6 months and been told that I have a burnt out tail light. After being issued a written warning / fix it ticket I have driven home and found that the tail light is in fact working. It seems like this is a method to see if I've been drinking or smoking? Is this considered harassment? I am tired of getting pulled over for this bogus reason and if I was to ask to get out of the car and see it for myself, he'd probably beat me like Rodney King. I've never even had a speeding ticket or any infraction of the law, but I am getting tired of being pulled over for no reason.


    




Tyler Durden
Rating
you may have a loose bulb, electrical wire loose , or loose terminal. Your light may work fine for example until you hit a bump then there's your problem. check it out before jumping to conclusions


sam
Rating
tell the next officer who does this that you need to see it because you keep getting pulled over for it but when you check it, it's fine. that way you have the accusing officer right there to check it with you.

it is possible that you have some sort of short in your tail light.


El Scott
Rating
I really doubt three random Police Officers stopped you (for the exact same violation) over a six month period for a light that was in perfect working order. You probably have some sort of short or wiring problem. If you get pulled over again respectfully tell the Officer that you have been stopped for this before and that when you get home all the lights seem to be working. Then ask him/her if they will show you the light they are talking about. They will not beat you like Rodney King if you get out of the car with permission.

If you feel like the stops were made under false pretense then file a complaint. I really doubt they were but you can always complain.

Also, the person that posted that you have a right to get out of your car and look at your taillight doesn't know what they are talking about. The US Supreme Court has ruled that the Police may make you stay in your car during a traffic stop and that if you fail to comply with their orders you could be charged with a crime. Like I said, just ask the Officer to show you the light they are talking about.


Ashley O
You really think 3 cops randomly used the same "lie" to pull you over?? Did you ever think that when your actually driving it goes out for some reason? Stop trying to get pity..


David H
Rating
"I have driven home and found that the tail light is in fact working."

Are you absolutely sure about that. Perhaps it is the brake light that's out. Did you check your brake lights? If their is nothing wrong with your car, I'm surprised they are pulling you over to check you out. A drunk driving case can be thrown out of court if the reason for the traffic stop isn't legitimate. If they wanted to lie to pull you over, they could just say you were driving erratically. You can't prove that you weren't, but it's easy to prove your taillights were working.

"...and if I was to ask to get out of the car and see it for myself, he'd probably beat me like Rodney King."

Actually, I don't think they would hold it against you. I was pulled over for a taillight once and I got out and opened the trunk. The socket popped out of the filter. I popped it back in and he sent me on my way with no ticket.


biga87718
You have a right to get out and see the burnt out taillight for yourself right were your stopped. He will look like an idiot on his camera and sense his probable cause went up in smoke you are free to go. Don't hold a conversation with him just let him know he was busted and file a complaint. You should always keep a tape recorder in your car cause theirs always seems to malfunction.


Watch IT!
Your car hates you and wants you to lose.


ST0MP3R
Rating
Just to narrow it down...Can you prove that? If not remember that 60's song? I fought the law and the law won..Buy new tail lights and keep the pesky porkers off your back....its better than a fine and possibly jail


B B
Hi,
I don't think it is harassment because you can't really prove that the light wasn't working at the time they pulled you over. If you actually got out with them and found the light to be working, then maybe it could be harassment. If you don't have proof, and go and report them, they could easily say that it wasn't working when they saw it/pulled you over.

Good Luck!


poggles789
Rating
just say "could you show me which one please? I know they were both working when I left home"

if they won't show you it can be harrassment


Joe E
Rating
I ve had a similar experience with the local cops too. Only their excuse was they were looking for stolen vehicles. That my kind of vehicle (Toyota FJ Cruiser) is reported stolen often. That I failed to use my turn signal more than 150 from the corner where I turned. I told him ("are you telling me I can`t change my mind and decide to go another way") to my destination. Then they ask if they can search my car I tell them NO. You ll need to wake up a judge and get an order. Then I`ll let you search. (I do this cause I know I dont have anything). They like to use any traffic violation to pull you over and they will always call it PROBABLE CAUSE. Anyways if you are clean..mess with them too like me. I like to pull the race card out too. I`m like "what just because I`m a Mexican means I cant be driving a Toyota. I think another factor is that I drive late at night to the local Wal Mart about 2 or 4 in the morning because I work nights so this is like noon to me. Anyways good luck.


Gerry
Rating
I don't think that three law enforcement officials would stop you unless there was a problem with your taillight. If your light is burned out, then they do have PC (probable cause) to stop you.

Some cars have a light in the back window. Could the officer be referring to that light instead of the taillights? In some states, the back light in the window does not have to be operational. However, with respect to both of your tailights, you probable should give them a test.

Have someone sit in your and put the brake on the pedal; see if the red taillights come on;
Turn on your lights, and your back lights should be working; and
Test your turn signals and 4-way blinkers.


Diablo
Rating
The cops in the town I live do that all the time, they love no tail light, no front liscenst plate, burnt out liscence light etc. Petty issues to get you to pull over. People now were I live get out and make the cop show them which light was burnt out and what not.


ToRn Single M/24
I had one Bust a U to follow me because I had shaved my head.


tdubstyle
are you black?


drew
its happened to me 2 x on 95 in virginia and jacksonville fl both times they made up a lie about my lights in va i paid the ticket in jax i got searched and they brought the dogs to snif my car.......i got a warning he claimed my tail lights were dim yet for 4 years i have been driving all over the e coast with no stops for dim lights ??? its obviously a ploy they use..... i understand they may have to use some tricks to check people out but they had 5 sherrifs and 2 dogs waste alot of time with me and they had to let me and my ny plates go..............the only one with any sense was the dog he knew i was ok in 3 minutes while the 5 sherifs took half an hour





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Can i register a un in my name if i have felonys?
...


 PETIFILE moved into my courtyard. We have children living here.?
His prison term was many years ago. Is he still required to be registered. His last nine year prison stint was 9 yrs. for impersonating an FBI agent, CIA agent, and a physician. Still says he is ...


 How much jail time do you get if found with Crystal Meth?
Thanks in ...


 How much money do police officers make each year?
...


 What are the majority and the dissent in Herring v. U.S.?
what page(s) have info on the ...


 Can you beat a polygraph test?
...


 What do laws look like?
When a law is first introduced in front of a committee, what does it look like? I've looked all over the Internet and can't find any examples, could you guys find any for me?...


 Applying for police and i have record Expunged?
How can they go about finding an expunge record when your applying for the police. They claim they have some technical system to finding this stuff..but i dont believe it. For the background ...


 Arkansas Sentencing Grid?
Hi there. How do they use the grid for sentencing? If you have no previous felony history, and you commit an offense thats a level 3 and another one that's a level 4, do they put them together ...


 Does anyone know how much jail time they give for?
Possession of a controlled substance II, possession of a weapon, and possession of weapon while having a controlled substance II????
Additional Details
It was in Louisiana and it wasn...


 2nd Degree forged instrument?
How much time do you get for 2nd degree of forged instrument if you got a check in the mail from a frodulant bank & the person that cashed it wants to drop all charges even though you are summons ...


 Should I be worried about this?
I live in an upper middle class neighborhood and I'm beginning to believe that the house behind mine is either a grow house, or has some other type of suspicious activity going on. There has ...


 Why do you think the police were at this house? (i'm scared)?
ok, so today at 8:00 pm police started banging on the house across from us (i don't really know much about the people that live inside but i know it's rented)
There were at least 10 ...


 Can a student driver be ticketed?
In California
Additional Details
If so, how likely is it that a cop would do that and not just give a warning?...


 Federal police agency goes overboard and terrorizes kids?
I read a recent story(in an L.A.-area newspaper) about a group of schoolkids from California who were on a tour of the White House grounds, but they didn't expect the Presidential limo to drive ...


 Juvenile correctional problems?
What are some problems with juvenile correctional?

how did you think it could be improved?...


 I hate fl..I need some advice?
So these two tickets is like 8 tickets in like 3 weeks. The tickets i got i already paid them. But these two i got today is for $211.00 for running a red light ( but the light was yellow ) so i dont ...


 Does anyone know the charges for graffiti?
i was caught drunk at a park, cops had searched the highschool and found graffiti all over the school..found red texter all over my hands.. do you know what charges ill get
Additional Details


 Who has the authority to search without a warrant?
under the fourth amendment there is no illegal search and seizure, but who has the authority to perform a warrantless search?...


 Help !!! I Lied to the police about my shoplifting record.?
I was caught stealing twice from H&M. The first time they let me off the hook with a warning but they wrote down all my information so they could have it on their records. Then today i was ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.064