Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law Enforcement & Police

Parked while drunk?
Find answers to your legal question.





Parked while drunk?

My brother was driving home last night and relized he was a little drunk and pulled oer to the side of the road to sleep it off. He left the car on and it was after mid night. One of the neighbors on the street called the cops bc his car looked suspecious. They hand cuffed him and took him to the drunk tank after he blew a .09 (.o8) is illegal. They also removed his license plate and replaced it with a paper one. They didn't tell him at the time what he was being charged for. This mornign my dad picked him up and he left with no ticket and the officers on duty did not know what he was charged with if charge at all. He didn't at any point recieve a ticket for anything. Do you think he was charged wtih anything?
Additional Details
we Just called the jail and they couldn't tell him either. So he left a message with the officer and I guess we will see what happens. I thought it was odd he wasn't given a ticket or anything.


    




Robert D
No, I think they talked it over and realized he probably did the right thing and decided to let it go. It probably wouldn't fly in court. It is possible that he never drove the car while drunk, He was just sitting in it getting warm. If they had charged him, he would know. They just made a good old fashioned judgment call, hopefully he is a bit wiser.


Dee
Yes more than likely he'll be charged with a dui... even though he was parked, he left the car running, and / or if the keys are in the car and he's parked, he is still behind the wheel... it's borderline.. it just depends on the laws in your state... in Ca.. they will arrest you and charged with a dui..


Mickey Mouse Spears
Rating
He was probably charged with DUI. If you're in your car and your keys are in your ignition, you're considered to be in control of the vehicle (driving).

Correction to previous poster's comment:
You don't have to be read your rights unless you're being questioned, and they won't throw his charges out if he's questioned without being read his rights -- they will only throw out any statements he made prior to being Mirandized.


Joe
That sounds a bit ambiguous, but it seems like your brother just caught a break there.


Joseph M
Rating
The DA can take their sweet time. I have heard that you definitely can be charge with drunk driving even if you are in your own driveway sleeping. From what I have heard, there are so many fine lines that have to be crossed for it to stick. If you ever are in that position, I've been told to remove the keys from the ignition and crawl into the backseat. It's all about intent. If you are behind the wheel, that could be construed as intent, even with the car off.

The way to tell if he was charged was to call them up and ask.


stefstudy
Rating
if he had no ticket and the officers didn't know than no he wasn't charged with anything. they just wanted him 2 sober up


Walter C Vaughn III
Best thing to do is to wait until Monday and go from there. Over the weekend there is so much going on. Thou if your brother was parked, he should of had the car off instead of on. That shows neglect on his part and maybe even DWI.


fayem7
He was in the car with it running good luck


From Yours Trully
Rating
Did you dad have to post a bond?

Sounds as if the officers just slipped up or they were trying to do your brother a favor by getting him off the street. He could have been charged for DUI even though he was sleeping in his car. Do you live in a small town where everyone knows everyone?

Interesting about the tag though. I've never heard of this happening. Did they have the vehicle impounded?

Sounds to me like someone got pretty lucky.


W
He was probably charged with a DUI. You don't have to be driving but in his case he obviously showed signs that he had been driving, car running, keys in the ignition. I'm sort of suprised that they didn't read him his rights although I might question if he remembers it. He might be lucky enough so that they figure a night in jail was enough to scare him but I think a DUI citiation and a court date will be coming soon.


Gary W
He could have been arrested for public drunkenness but it appears that he was not. If he was charged with anything obviously no one wants you to know.


Sami V
Rating
He will be eventually!


shorty
Rating
If his keys were in the ignition he could be charged with dui. have him call the police station tomorrow to ask if there are any pending charges against him.


KneeDeep
Rating
if he was held he would have to be charged with somthing if he wasnt charged with anything and still held in the tank its considered false imprisonment wich can lead to a law suit in your favor.


Kevin F.A.R.T.
Rating
I think they just taught him a lesson...harshly


dpilipis
Operating a motor vehicle is illegal. What "operating" means, can vary a bit, but since the car was running, he may be on the hook.

However, to lawfully charge someone with an offense, some notice that you are being charged (and with what) is required. Typically, a ticket, or being arrested and brought down to to jail.

Something here sounds fishy.


B Z
Rating
Very strange if he did not receive any papers, or even told him what he was being arrested for. I'm not sure if all that's even legal police procedure. Especially if they were tampering with his license plate (took it) and his vehicle.

Sounds to me like the poor guy is a case of unfortunate police harrassment. Even if he had been driving and was near to home.. cmon after midnight, the guy blows a 0.09 and not a 0.08 and you can't give him a break, even if it's just to rest a bit. Sometimes cops can be real aholes.

Hopefully they had smartened up and decided to let him go.


pinkyismygirlfriendniluvhur
I'm pretty sure if they didn't actually observe him driving, they can't charge him with DUI

25 years ago I got a PUI, pushing under the influence, was out of gas and pushing the car to the gas station


nanna
Don't sound like it,Whats the deal with the licenses I wonder,Ya'll must not be in arkansas,if it would have been me they would have charged me with DWI and put me in jail and I would have had to stay untl I found a bondsman,they would suspend my license until I went to DWI class and it costs 150$


Crazy lady
Rating
They will charge him for DUI he had the keys in the car and running it. Stopped or not that is DUI.


Jan
Rating
He could be charged with DUI. Doesn't matter if the car was moving or not,he was in possession of the keys AND the car was running. Considering they took his plate,I would think he may be charged with something. A friend of mine did the same thing,she pulled off the road,had the car off and was still charged with DUI. They figure,you did drive while drunk if you got where you are.


c1980lloyd
maybe we could print this out and give it to the police as a confession of drunk driving if you want? your brother is an idiot.


Thomas Paine
If you can prove you've been living in your car for the last 24 hrs. you're safe.


?
Rating
when they arrested him was he read his rights? if not you can get it thrown out


Laura Duh
Rating
No, He Shouldnt Be Charged With Anything.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Should We Bring Back The Death Penalty?
This is my RS homework... More answers on the against side would be great... But any opinions are great!!
Thanks!...


 Please any advice needed.. Major problems with a tenant....?
i am living in an apt. building, here in cleveland ohio and i have a neighbor that is constantly harrassing me and my family.. she has called my daughter names and uses racial slurs.. yesterday she ...


 If someone breaks the law, should the officer be required to let them go if they have a sad story?
Say someone ran a stopsign - and the person said "Yeah, I did it, but I gotta go somewhere"? Should the officer let them go?
At what point do we let people with a sad story go? How ...


 How are we suppose to be "law abiding citizens", in the U.S. when we are never taught 'laws' in school?

Additional Details
Good answers so far, but there are thousands of them. not just a few, nor does the 10 comm cover ...


 Why would a cop ask for a passengers ID?
Why would a cop ask for a passengers ID? I got pulled over about an hour ago (it was at like 11:15pm) and the cop asked my friend for their ID. I'm 17 years old, have had my license for almost a ...


 Should a 14 year old be behind the bar of the local pub?
Surely this is encouraging young people to drink and become accustomed to alcohol.
Additional Details
Hi Joshua, this was in my local village pub in Devon....


 How do i rob noodles from a shop?
i want noodles with out paying for ...


 Should inmates in prison have things like television and other entertainment for their stay?
...


 Caught shoplifting?
15 years old got caught shoplifting
no police called
they said nothing would be on my record
i signed no papers
they took no pictures..just asked for my name,adress,phone number<...


 Is a crime committed if a nurse goes into a hospital pharmacy and gets drugs to give to her friends?
The drugs are not narcotics but they are only given by script....


 Do cops get paid extra for giving tickets?
...


 How do you stop a robber?
There's been a gang of robbers around where I live. They look at names in a phone book (they only steal from people of my ethnicity) and then go rob the house. Do you think these robbers would ...


 I'm being fined for flicking a cigarette butt out the window. Should I (or can I) fight this?
I was traveling down I-77 South near Brecksville, Ohio an hour ago and was pulled over for flicking my cigarette butt out the window. This is, apparently, punishable by up to a $100 dollar fine. C...


 How to deal with police incompetence?
it's too long a story to tell but i received a phone call 4 week agofrom someone who said they we're paying for someone to kill me.I reported it to the police who came immediately and took ...


 Are you afraid of criminals...??
this is one of those philosophical questions, I guess....


 Have you heard of the Green River serial killler?
Do you know how many ladies he killed?

( I heard he confessed to 48 murders)
Additional Details
Pleaded guilty 48, the exact number might be greater, he can't even ...


 How many of you who agree with bringing back capital punishment in the Uk, would take the job of executioner?
...


 Are the UK police racist?
...


 Would you rather have Paris out than have her in jail just to end the media circus?

Additional Details
dedeskinner I can think of one good thing she has done for society. Let the general public feel better about their lives?...


 Can a police officer ask for someone's social security number during a traffic stop ?
the police have pulled you over for a traffic violation . can they ask you for your social security number ?...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.024