Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law Enforcement & Police

Try answer this, the right answer gets the best answer for 2 points....?
Find answers to your legal question.





Try answer this, the right answer gets the best answer for 2 points....?

You have two guys, they are neighbors. Lets call them Jack and George. George leaves for the summer to go to his cottage house. Jack goes into his garage and takes Goerges Lawnmower, Jack uses the mower for the whole summer and returns it before George returns from the cottage home. The person across the street notifies the police that Jack took the mower. Jack is questioned and admits everything. Jack cannot be charged with Burglary, why? What will Jack be charged with? Give it a shot! Ill put the answer up in about 20 min.!!
Additional Details
No right answers yet!
Jack DID NOT have the permisson to use the mower. What is the highest crime that Jack can be charged with, its rather simple, not breaking and entering or trespassing.


    




stewbiscit
Becuase jack is went to his own garage to get the lawn mower.


rayh46224
Conversion


?
either the men lived together or jack had permission or he was only charged with brbreaking and entering


pet stylist
Jack cannot be charged with burglary because he returned the lawnmower before it was even discovered missing. Jack can be charged with treaspassing for going onto/into Georges property without Georges consent. Btw....that's something my neighbor would do.


Emily!
because George told Jack that it was okay for him to use his lawnmower


lovesbordercollies
trespassing or unlawful entry


railcar_exp
Jack can't be charged with theft since he returned the mower. Jack can be charged with B & E (breaking and entering) and trespassing.


desdemonas2
I am sorry that you didnt get any answers, but I am glad that you posted that information for us to read. It was very interesting and good knowledge to have. Thank you for doing that for us!


kurticus1024
Rating
Because the lawnmower is not missing, Jack can't be charged with burglary. Maybe he would be charged with borrowing the mower. A good sentence would be to have him mow George's lawn for a year or so.


C H R I S T I E
Trespassing and unlawful entry


queenmaeve172000
George said he could use the mower before he left for his cottage.


webjnke1
trespassing

btw ... I already got the 2 pts lol


ranger_girl
if jack had georges permission he cant be charged


bkbarile
Rating
for stealing gas

but should something be done for the depreation of the mower, instead of a new mower, it is worth much less


yourdoneandover
Just because he returned it before his neighbor got home doesnt mean he took it without permission. he could have been returning it before he got home out of consideration, no? For all I can tell from the info here is that the only thing for sure that he did wrong was not let the nosy neighbor know what he was doing. Otherwise if the neighbor whose lawnmower was removed is feeling violated I guess he could file trespassing charges on him, and surely there is something about illegally using someones possessions even if there returned. I mean Im not a lawyer but thats got to cover about all of it.


reese7675
There are no charges...not only does he reside in this home and has access to everything there, possesion is nine tenths of the law?


macy5
Rating
the mower was already in his garage with the permission of Gearge


hot stuff
Rating
jack will not be charged with anything because george left it in jacks garage


drdemento61
Rating
no burglary because he didn't steal anything....but could be charged with B&E but more then likely just tresspassing


baby
Rating
george told him to use the lawnmower to mow their yards. to bring in the mail, newspaper and all that.


alltheanswersgirl85858
breaking an entry


Roadrunner58-79
Rating
George told Jack that he could use the mower while he was gone and Jack will not be charged with anything.


The Indispensable Chris Cameron
Because burglary involves the intent to commit theft. Jack did not intend to commit theft, and this was shown by the fact that Jack returned the mower.


tonalc1
You didn't say if he broke into the garage. I'm assuming he didn't, so he couldn't be charged with burglary, especially since he put it back.

He could be charged with trespassing.

Unless, of course, he was mowing George's lawn.


noitall147
Rating
Jack will be charged with breaking and entering. If he cannot be charged with burglury, it might be because he brought it back.


momma2more
Rating
George asked Jack to mow his lawn while he was gone for the summer. George also told Jack that he could use his mower for the job and to cut his own lawn too.


MARTIN B
Rating
perhaps cos he returned the item it isn`t burglary.
Maybe he can be charged with borrowing something without asking the owners permission.


grim reaper
Rating
I understand where your answer is coming from, but burglary is defined differently in different states. SO, at least in CA, IF Jack entered the garage intending to use the mower without replacing the gas, he DID commit burglary.
BUT, if he entered intending to replace the gas and then just didn't, your answer would stand. I like the twist that if he had intended all along to replace the gas and then DID, there wouldn't be any crime, only civil actions. Cool question.


PoPo's Ho
Rating
George would have to be the one to press charges. Otherwise Jack has done nothing wrong.


Stoned Bosco
He can only be charged with Larceny. Although he took and used George's lawnmower and used it, he returned it. However, the gas that was in the mower when Jack "borrowed" the mower was used up when Jack mowed his lawn. Jack therefore, stole George's gas. Jack could be arrested for theft.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Do you think the police used excessive force on the two bank robbers today?
or do you think they were justified in taking down these ...


 What would happen if i shifted into reverse while speeding down the highway?
...


 Do you think guns kills people or people using the guns kill people?
If yo uthink about it, guns are fairly safe, they can not just shot them selves, so i am just a lil curious....


 What would happen if we DID put a total ban on guns in this country?
i'm guessing that gun crimes statistics go way, way down and the incidences of murder by some other means goes way, way up...

what say you?......


 I accidentally ran over a swan, so I took it home and ate it - can I be hanged for treason?

Additional Details
It was quite gamey. I roasted it but it was a bit overpowering so I made a huge stew - that was much nicer....


 Can police come into a house without knocking first?
the police come to my home last night to arest my nephew that lives with me. for a minor assult.that we didnt know anything about.thay just come in opend my kitchen door then souted hello. didnt have ...


 I was pulled over by the police, asked to step out of the car, and instead I drove away. what willl happen?
I was pulled over for no turn signal, but wasn't written a ticket. I was in a known drug area, and the police wanted to search my car which I refused. This happened 2 counties away from where I ...


 I have used someones credit card details, and they want to press charges.?
what is the procedure of the investigation? when will the police come for me? what is the likely punishment?...


 Do you agree with all these people who claim quotas and revenue generation as the only reason for tickets?
Seems like someone is always claiming the police have quotas, and the reason for tickets is to generate revenue. Of course, I know both are false, but am I the only one that knows this?

H...


 If my dad hit me can he go 2 jail?

Additional Details
my dad has an angermanegment problem and he gets mad easily but we have had our problems lately with my boyfirend and stuff b/c my parents dont like him and told me ...


 Is this appropriate behavior for a police officer?
I was pulled over by a state trooper for speeding in Wisconsin just between Madison and Milwaukee around 1:00am last night. Unfortunately, I'm guilty as charged. But when the cop approached my ...


 Is it legal for a minor child to be arrested at home without informing a parent first?
police came into our home and got my son out of bed and told him they wanted to talk outside once outside he asked to talk to his dad and they(police) told him no. We found out 3 hours later where he ...


 Are police officers above the law???
Yesterday i seen a cop take a red light & the camera flashed but his exempt license plate wont be getting a ticket. He wasent in no emergency as on the next light i waved hi to him & he ...


 Hi I'm really scared I gave a report to the police of 5 years of domestic violence?
Now what im scared what will happen to him he`s been told keep away for a week. I want him back home they say its allso out off myhzands and a domestic violence police officer will be calling and a ...


 If I'm naked in my own house and someone outside sees in, can I be arrested for indecent exposure?
I should add that I'm only curious....


 Statutory rape questions?
Is it Legal to have a girl pregnant at 16 and your 18? no comments just facts please
Additional Details
New Jersey my ...


 Do you feel guilty if you see a police officer, even if you've done nothing wrong?
If so, why?...


 Can I be taken to jail if I?
take my dad's car out for a joyride and get pulled over because i don't have a ...


 Will i get caught?
i stole a candy bar from brooks today and almost got caught, im only 14 and stealing is the only crime i prabably ever committe, but they asked me to empty my pockets and i had concealed the candy ...


 Do you own a firearm?
and if you do what kind of firearm do own and was it hard to get one and can you use it ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.084