Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law Enforcement & Police

What does it say about a person who is against police stop and search?
Find answers to your legal question.





What does it say about a person who is against police stop and search?

I know a jazz saxophone player who walked from Soho to Waterloo station at 5AM several times a week. He was stopped and his instrument case inspected by police he said "about once every 2 months for years “ and never complained.
Oh yes and he is a balding red haired caucasian northerner from Manchester.


http://uk.news.yahoo.com/rtrs/20080130/tuk-uk-britain-police-fa6b408_4.html
Additional Details
If you see this Derek, you know who I am , you blow a mean sax.


    




jamand
Rating
If you have nothing to hide - it should not be of concern.

Only those that have something to hide or are up to no good tend to complain.


rdnck
I have nothing to hide and I am totally against police stop and search.If they have a reason I have no problem with it ,but otherwise it's an invasion of my right to privacy.The police would be better public servants if they would go after known criminals rather than search for new ones.For example,,I do not use drugs but I'm positive I could find any number of dealers in a short time,,,,why can't the police?


alan h
Surely it would depend on the manner and motivation of the search.
But, broadly, I have no objection.


ste73
They feel they have something to hide


Veston Pants
Rating
Stop and search powers are under PACE 1984 and allow the Police (with good reason) to perform a stop and search without resorting to arrest. A bit over-simplified but that's essentially it.
People do get a bit miffed and there are allegations that it is being ethnically targeted. I wouldn't have any objection if the officers followed the guidelines (polite, explanations etc.) I have nothing to hide but it is an inconvenience if one feels "picked on"

xxFJ


Diamond.....1 M/C ~*~*
I dont think its fair for a police officer to stop you and search your belongings unless they have probable cause. I would never just let them go through my stuff unless they had a legit reason.


oldpepy
Rating
They are against it, perhaps because some police abuse it!
The way things are today I think it has to be done to protect us from dangerous people who wish to do us harm!
The benefit outweighs the risk we could be facing without it!


BekindtoAnimals22
It says that if there is no cause to search a person, this person has been made to look like a criminal who is under suspicion even though they have done nothing. It makes it intimidating to walk down the street minding your own business. It makes you feel like your privacy is gone, which it is.

I guess people don't value their privacy anymore. I find that to be very strange especially when its obvious that to continue this practice for years against the same person amounts to harassment. Maybe a new boon to the economy would be see-through cases so you can just hold it up and let everybody see what is in the case. Maybe our clothing should be transparent. That would make it so much easier for law enforcement. Right?


st.abbs
Rating
I think stop and search is fine as long as there is a valid reason why the person is being stopped and searched and this is explained to the person beforehand.


allen555
Rating
If you have nothing to hide you have nothing to fear. In my experience of policing you get used to the Night Owls when you are on the beat. It's good to see them because it means the end of the shift is coming and you have someone to speak to. I'm surprised he was searched so regularly as the shift system in use means the same guy was stopping him.


Fashionmanic
Rating
I have no problem with being stopped and searched, highly embarassing if the police officer goes through my bag and find personal things like ladys tampax etc.

However, i wouldnt feel appreciated if i was targetted because the colour of my skin, the clothes i wear or the gender that i am. Even the accent or nationality that i carry

Like most governmental industries reports are taken and carried out to see what colour race or background have been targetted. It would be of concern to me if they kept on stopping me, simply because. I hope their sensitivity of not picking on people because they decided to wear a hoody or wear a hijab will effect this?!?!

I find that my other half gets picked on alot by police and bouncers simply because he has red hair. Hes a nice and well behaved bloke, so i never quite understood why him?

I suppose thats what the complaints commision board is for....


Sherilynne B
Rating
I'm in the US so it is not the same rules but I never allow any search. We have rights here and if you know them you can refuse almost any search by police without a warrant. Here's a link explaining how to recognize illegal searches and how to refuse them.


Nate W
Rating
It says you are against it


Andy
Rating
They have something to hide in my opinion.


Sahara
Rating
It could be that the person is about principles or feels like the police are accusing him of something, which is not justified in his or her estimation.

It wouldn't bother me but I would start to feel guilty unless it was commonplace. But I would wonder about the kind of place I'm in where this was acceptable. I have nothing to hide. But it would feel like a violation of personal space and privacy.

If the police were searching everyone then it wouldn't bother me. It would bother me if they were singling me out though, especially when I have nothing to hide. I don't know if I would complain but I might say, is this really necessary after the first time or so? I don't get into trouble. I would question the police's motivation. I can see why people think someone who is guilty would complain loudly. That is what is making me think of another side because there is another side.


cosaxteacher
Let it go. This is such an old story.


Mr. P
Rating
Searching for concealed weapons is ok if warranted.
What I do object to is the providing of fingerprints or DNA just because they ask.
I am being treated as a criminal even if I am not charged.
I do not agree to the state knowing exactly where I am every second of the day, who I talk to, the books I read and the stuff I buy.
I went to town yesterday. In my short trip to the shops and petrol station, I was recorded on CCTC 22 times by cameras I can see, and probably more I cannot.
I object to this level of serveilance as an inocent citazen


James M
Rating
I do not want to be stopped or searched by the police whatsoever, and I carry no weapons or controlled substances.

If and when the time comes I will object on the basis that the police are an emination of the state and the state has no fcuking right to put it's hand in my pockets or bags.


MrsFidge
Rating
nothing to hide - no problem. It's probably the same people who don't want ID cards





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 WOULD CARRYING A NINJA STAR BE A CRIMINAL CHARGE ?
My step son got arrested for the cops finding a "Ninja Star" in his pocket. What would the criminal charge be? How much trouble is he in?...


 Should gun control be more harshly in forced in the US?
Some people say that guns hurt more then help people in homes. Others say that it is for protection and it is in the bill of rights that we have the right to bear arms. If a robber attacks u and u ...


 How come we can stop all these new attacks but we couldnt stop 9/11?
...


 What if you witnesssed a murder? THEN WHAT?
what if you witnessed a murder and you know the suspect saw you while he was doing it. now you are in hiding. you hide yourself..but worried this person will catch up to. (which i'm sure thats ...


 Shoplifting question?
ok me and a friend have stolen from this store Allot of times and never got caught but yesterday we almost we had to run from the clerks so i was wondering if we go in their and fake theft can we get ...


 How do POLICE make friends? Are they all douche bags?
Are the only people that defend pigs, cops? If you read my other question where a douche bag pig threatened me you will see what I mean. The only stupid people that defended him was other piglets. LOL...


 What do people think of police community support officers,no stupid answers please.?
...


 Do juries always believe cops when you are up against them on assault charges?
Do I have much chance in trying to get off on a ABH charge against a cop. I am charged with 2 counts of ABH - the second was a cop when I was being arrested. I pushed and shoved him but that was it ...


 When A Police Officer Says, "Anything you say can and will be used against you in a court of law"?..
what does that mean exactly. used against you how?...


 What's the crime committed most?
Is it rape? Theft? Burglary? Murder? Assualt?
Tell what you think and why....


 Should The Speed Limit On Motorways Be Abolished?
Most cars can do well over 100 mph and accidents can happen at 20 mph, so it seems that all we do is create a 70 mph traffic jam most days....


 Underage, I'm not drinking at a party with alcohol, still illegal?
My friends wanted me to go to a party with them this weekend. People who are say 21 and up will be drinking, people who are underage said they wouldn't drink.
I don't drink, but I'...


 Time to teach the police a lesson again?
I was young in Liverpool when the uprising occuered in 1981 and also Brixton and Moss side.The way the police are harrassing people and killing them today(this time mainly whites)informati I have ...


 Can cops leagally call the dogs to search your car without a warrant?
All in the title. Can the police (after they have pulled you over for speeding) call a K-9 unit to search your car without a warrant or your consent?...


 You answer the phone. A stranger says she's just been raped. What do you do?
I'm asking this as I've got a police communications officer test coming up soon and i'm bound to have someone say something like that.
What calming things can you say?...


 Does a SILENCER lesson the impact of the bullet?
does it slow the bullet down? or is it the same impact? thanks!...


 What do i do about a guy sneaking around my house?
ok this is very weird..but.... It started saturday night,but there is a guy who is sneaking around my house(and other houses)looking in windows,but the police can't get the idiot. he seems to ...


 Does an employer need your permission to run a background check on you?

Additional Details
I got a job and they did not have me sign anything. All the sudden they rescinded there offer for something that happened 5 years ago....


 Why are so many young black and Latino men in prison?

Additional Details
I makes me so angry when i see a young black or latino man commiting crimes when he could probably find a cure to cancer or AIDS it bothers me how they don't ...


 I need serious advice to do with drugs.?
I think my fiance is doing and/or selling meth. We have no money, yet he makes about $25 an hour. With the little bit that I bring home from my part time job, that should be well enough to pay our ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.024