Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law Enforcement & Police

Why do the police in my area only pull over minorities?
Find answers to your legal question.





Why do the police in my area only pull over minorities?

I live in central NJ (a somewhat rural - read: caucasian area) and see minorities pulled over much more frequently than white people.

Do police target minorities in predominently white areas, or do all of these minorities get pulled over for legitimate reasons (not just for being black or mexican or indian)?
Additional Details
I should add that I've noticed this with one township in particular. Oh, and I'm white, honkies!


    




Panacea
Rating
New Jersey actually ran a rather intensive study on this because of all the complaints.

Do you know what was found?

1. Minorities are pulled over at the exact same rate as they are represented in the population. In other words, on average over the state, minorities are not pulled over more frequently.

2. In those areas where minorities are pulled over with high frequency, the population of minorities is, in fact higher. In other words, more minorities are being pulled over simply because the concentration of them is higher.

3. Crime rate predicts the rate of being pulled over.

4. This is the important part. The ratio of times being pulled over to the number of times there is a REASON to pull the person over, is the same regardless of race. If a minority is pulled over, the reason is simple. He is committing some sort of action that leads to being pulled over. What is definitely not happening is minorities being pulled over when they have done nothing wrong.

Your chances of being pulled over, if you are not engaging in something that would obviously result in you needing to be pulled over (ie speeding, drunk driving, erratic driving, expired plates etc.) is exactly the same whether you are white, black, hispanic, whatever.

Your perception is simply wrong (and probably racist)....end of story.


FozzieBear
Often people see what they want to see. If the area is predominantly white, they probably pull over more white people. You are just noticing the minorities.

.


pink_angel
Can you say racial profiling?


JBean B
It's probably because Mexicans are always causing trouble, and breaking the law.


italianchic1606
Yes! although they should not be biased that some group of people is more prone to breaking the law... they do. I'm studying psychology right now and it's definitely a major issue. I've heard the same situation of minorities being pulled over for no reason many times as well as from teenagers... that we're actually not breaking the law. P.S: I live in northern N.J. The community is mostly caucasian with a few acceptions.


JAMES
Rating
For psychological reasons, Probabily..................................


Fries
Yes, I live in South Florida, my dad had a friend that lived in a mansion by the beach, he was driving slowly looking for his friends house and was being followed by 2 cops the whole time until they pulled him over for no reason. My dad was in a new explorer wearing a suit dressed in work clothes. You cant tell me he got pulled over because he looked like he was a theif... this has happened several times to my family and myself


?
Rating
If they didn't do so much crime, they wouldn't get pulled over as much.


katjha2005
Rating
I have faith in our police forces.. my guess would be they are probably be pulled over for legitimate reasons- I mean you gotta think with the way cars are made now a days.. and with so many cars with tinted windows it would be hard for a cop to know if someone is of a different race until they actually pulled them over


Cpl Coop
You are looking at the situation all wrong. Don't get me wrong...there are bad law enforcement officers out there but the chance that it is a whole department is impossible nowadays. You might see 2 to 3 traffic stops in a day if its a bad neighborhood. But in actually in a 24 hour period 30 to 40 might get pulled over. The only way to find out is go to the Clerk of Courts in your area and find out. Also the local PD keeps that information on record. I could save you the time and say no, its not just one race.


Catherine E: VT
Rating
You would need to check the records in the department to confirm that minorities are pulled over more frequently. Most of the time, the departments themselves keep very close track on this kind of thing. Officers can get in a lot of trouble if there's a discrepancy in the number of people pulled over by race.


songndance1999
Rating
Who knows? Why don't you ask the police dept.


BILLIELYNN H
Rating
cuz their trying to get a date


kywolverine44
Rating
They are playing the odds.


Balthazar
Rating
Not the race care again.... If you believe it...sue them.


strike_eagle29
YOU'RE ONLY GETTING PULLED OVER IN NYC WE GET SHOT 50 TIMES.

JERSEY IS THE HOME OF RACIAL PROFILING THEY HAVE GOTTEN IN TROUBLE FOR IT BEFORE AND WILL NOT STOP THEIR HATRED OF MINORITIES.


bcre8iv
Rating
If your such a concerned citizen why don't you go to the townships prosecutor and register a complaint instead of posting it on the internet? Could it be your just bored and don't like cops so you decided to fabricate a story. Are others in your town enraged like you are. Maybe the stupid answer to the stupid question is "the cops pull over minorities because they have a better shot at making an arrest, therefore enabling them to get back to headquarters where the really good donuts are" You have no concern for whats going on so why waste peoples time!


LadySable
Rating
Police normally pull people over for breaking the law. Race isn't an issue since everyone does break the law on occasion whether they realize it or not.

You do not have to be speeding or racing to be pulled over. If you have a tail light out, too much wear on your tires, thump a cigarette but out of the window, etc. - you are breaking the law.

If you are breaking the law, expect to be pulled over!


Roadrunner58-79
The police probably had a good reason to pull over
the minority!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 How would you improve a (our?) crime ridden society?

Additional Details
and how would you justify your choice?...


 Why do you people in the US like to have guns ?
Dont guns cause more harm then good !
Additional Details
Yes we do have gun crime in the UK. Thanks for every ones answers, you made understand why you got guns now....


 Partner charged with gbh section 18, criminal damage and affray.?
refused bail by crown court.remanded in custody.cctv shows him throwing some cans of beer around a local shop.he was verbally attacked (no sound on cctv).apparently seen with a knife or bottle but ...


 Police Officer Taser Use?
Why do you think police officers are using their Tasers to control people so much these days. They have other choices like pepper spray, and batons. Tasers are only supposed to be used when it is not ...


 Who do i talk to when a police officer wont pay his dept?
...


 Can somebody please help a brother out?
Okay I may not be your brother but I am someones brother. Anyway I keep getting these calls about renewing my new car warranty because it's going to expire. They never tell me what company they ...


 I recently recieved a police caution for poession of weed. do i need to inform the nhs (i work for nhs)?
im a dentist, got caught having a spliff by undercover cops and got away with a warning/caution. just wondering if i need to tell my boss about this caution?...


 When you are driving your car, and you put your seat belt under your left arm, is this legal, or illegal?
Is it considered not wearing a seatbelt at all? But you are wearing it, but just like a lap belt?...


 Do you think it is dangerous to have a glock 22 in your house?
My boyfriend moved in. He used to be a police officer and is trained to use guns safely but I still worry that if anyone else knew it was here , guests or even someone who would break in and steel it?...


 Decapitating yourself?
Just reading a news article and a man has apparently committed suicide by decapitating himself. Can anyone suggest how this may be possible as im confused? x
Additional Details
i think I ...


 Can cops beat people up off duty ?
i was dating this stuck-up chick for about a week, she broke up with me cause she said i pick my nose in public and pass gas at the dinner table. this is total crap.. i only done that maybe 3-4 ...


 Do you appreciate if George W. Bush invades Pakistan to capture Bin Laden?
...


 What Causes traffic?
...


 If you knowingly purchase stolen goods, doesn't that make you a thief too?
...


 What crime is a serious problem in your state or community?
...


 I want to play a practical joke on people in the mall is this ok?
ok i wanted to. like the title says, play a joke on the mall. It in no way includes vandalizing or hurting others it only involves me pretending to be hurt and fake blood will be involved. Is it ok ...


 We used to have the safest roads in Europe. What can be done to make our roads safer?
http://www.timesonline.c "A decade ago Britain had the best road safety record in Europe. By 2006 it had fallen to fifth place behind Malta, Sweden, S...


 Only like the police when you need them?
Why do people only like the police when they need us? When people go to the polls or dont and the city and states budgets get cut time after time people are so happy cause they have lower taxes. T...


 Can a university police officer take my keys out of my car if I left them on the seat?
I left my car unlocked and my keys on the seat a university police officer took my keys I had to goto there police station to pick up the keys. If the answer is no what actions can I do to get the ...


 Is this the correct way to be treated when arrested. We are all juveniles.?
I was a passenger in a car with another passenger and a driver.
We were stopped by the police after a short car chase because the car was stolen.
They quickly grabbed us and handcuffed us ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.044