Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

A postmaster is refusing to serve his customers unless they speak English - is this wrong?
Find answers to your legal question.





A postmaster is refusing to serve his customers unless they speak English - is this wrong?

he "told his customers at Sneinton Boulevard Post Office in Nottingham that it is imperative they speak English otherwise he cannot understand them."

I think it's fair enough, do you?

http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/feedarticle/8409724
Additional Details
He also said "We have a situation now where British culture is going down so I decided it's time somebody had to put it right."


    




Theo S
Rating
they should be able to do something like use the internet to help but this is not a question of fairness the guys just saying i cant understand you thats perfectly acceptable


Ruby M
well how can he serve them if he doesn't understand them


Jess
Rating
good on him!!
1. he is from sri lanka and rahter than trying to change britian, although he isn't british he is trying to keep the british culture alive.
2. Well, you wouldn't go to sri lanka and expect to be spoken to in English, so fair play to him.
And yes, all immigrants who come here to live should be able to speak English. Do they think we will learn their language(s) for them?


susie x ♥♥♥
Rating
Good for him, I quite agree.
I was sat in A & E with my son this morning and nobody could understand the nurse who was calling out the patients names...it all got very confusing. You'd think a nurse would be able to speak English.


kimbow82
English is the native language, if you can't speak English we shouldn't have to cater to you. If we went to another country and couldn't speak thier language you know they wouldn't serve us either.


Tres
Well, I get his point why he does this.

And honestly, in my own country, I would wish that foreigners would try to learn our language instead of us trying to learn theirs


Stanley
Rating
Yes, they should speak English if they move to England.
If they dont want to speak english, they shouldnt come to the country.
Simple as that^^^

Unless they are tourists, then we should make an acception.


AL G
Rating
He is exactly right, and the beauty of him doing this is that he's from Sri Lanka so nobody can claim racism!


Jelly Bean
Rating
If they cannot speak English, how the heck is he going to know what they want? That doesn't take too much intelligence to understand.


Crow
Rating
Quite right. Its these individual little stands that add up to common sense and reason being re introduced into Britain. The labour party, who's greed and Arrogance caused this problem in the first place, haven't got the guts to put it right. and in their cowardice have left the people them selves to do their dirty work.. i applaud the man. I wish there were more like him, and the sooner we get rid of the gutless labour party, the better.


MR SCEPTICS ALTER EGO
Not joking now my local postmaster is an Indian chap and he told me the other day he is sick and tired of spending half his day with people who do not speak a word of English.


Ello Guv
Seems logical, if they dont speak English how can he know if what he's given them is correct.


Killer Queen
I imagine he is trying to limit the mistakes made from a communication barrier.


scooter
Rating
It is but no doubt someone will use the race card. He could try and communicate with them but if he genuinely cannot understand then he has a point. How do other post offices manage though?


Gay Obama on the downlow
Rating
Sounds good to me.


Sam☮
Fair do's if they dont speak english how is he supposed to know what the want. he has every right


danor
Rating
At my doctors clinic, which is predominately Asian due to the area it is in, there are patients who cant speak English trying to explain themselves and the result is often long queue's of people waiting because of them. I say they should have someone who does speak English accompany them or learn the language before coming here


Dafydd
Rating
Unless he is multilingual himself, he is unable to serve anyone who does not speak his own language. This is a practical consideration and not one of discrimination.


Scouse
Rating
I see where he is coming from and I am glad he is not white because if he was the roof would fall on him from the PC crowd. I notice the article is in the Guardian.

If this happened a little more often I think we would see a great reduction in certain people playing the "me no spika da inklish game"
I have every sympathy for those in a strange country and society not being able to speak any English when they get here but i do expect that to rectify itself as they live here. I feel the same way about Brits who go to live in Fance Italy or Spain who mix only in ex-pat circles


Sweetharttt
Rating
Way to go.


Marin Vielli UK
He is quite right even if he is of a foreign race himself , he shouldn't have to have to try to cope with a large number of other languages ,
I know australia and New Zealand had a rule that european migrants had to be articulate in English.even the papuans had Pigeon english.
This also applies in schools as teachers in some areas have to cope with nearly all of a class of children who have no knowledge at all of English because their parents don't speak it ..
My eldest daughter who was very strong on no discrimination as a teacher soon changed her mind when she was presented with 15 children and 5 languages only 2 of whom spoke english .
She got out and went teaching private .


Clive Reborn
Absolutely right. It is ironic that this action hs been taken by a man of Sri Lankan origin; presumably a white person would have been charged with implicit racism. Interestingly, one of the most vocal supporters of English traditions and culture that I am acquainted with is a Chinese Lady. I think many immigrants from the more civilised countries happily acknowledge the cultural rights of the indigenous population; it is the public employees with Internationalist Agendas that are the most serious threat to dear old Blighty.


DebbieP
Rating
I used to live in Mexico and if you didn't speak Spanish you were out of luck with any government agency. You either brought an interpreter or you didn't get helped. Period.


Neil T
No - more power to his elbow. As for the race card not being "played" because he is from Sri Lanka - give it time.


nicky119119@ymail.com
Rating
problem but he's dong his job , and he has a long day ahead of him , so why bang your head against the wall due to the condition.


Tapsy
Rating
I think he is right. I get so tired of " no speak English" but you better believe people know where to sign and ask for benefits. I think it should be law that anyone wanting to live here in the UK should have an understanding of the language and practice it


Cocoa Dusted Love
Rating
Its okay if he's never met or spoken to a certain person before in his life. But if its his friends or relatives, or people he has spoken in sri lankan to before, it seems a bit stupid to suddenly decide not to serve them anymore unless they speak english. Many people who speak english refuse to do so to people who they share a language with, because it seems silly. I will not speak to my relatives in english, it feels like I'm putting on a play or something, its really weird.


Julie
Rating
well what about all the people who move abroad from the UK you wouldn't like to be on holiday in spain and somone refuses to serve you because you can't speak the language.


Christine
Rating
Just likethe ex pats in Spain!!!! It really annoys me when I visit Spain and I see signs up in English asking people to 'tidy up after pets' etc, and before you go on, i'm not talking about package resorts, but places where normal Spanairds live, but where a number of other non Spanish people have bought property.

I agree with your aguement, but next time you go abroad learn their language, or at least attempt it.


laughter_every_day
Rating
Damn. I am mute and cannot speak any language. Still, I need his services. I wonder if no language is OK.


Ryan O
Rating
Private businesses can discriminate, government cant.

Thats how scholarships can only give money to black/latino/etc..

Besides, if he wants less customers that is his problem..





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Does anyone have License To Kill in this world?
...


 Should smoking be banned in all public places?
I know smokers hav a right to smoke, but non- smokers also hav a right not to breathe their smoke....


 Life without the possibility of Parole. How would you cope with this sentence?
...


 What is the legal age?
what is the legal age to drink alcohol in pubs in turkey and i mean like larger not Alcopops (eww) im 16 and well i love booze but im not an alcoholic i just like it every now and agen
A...


 Why cant i smoke if i want to?
with the exception of safety and health issues..

why should i not smoke because some anti-smoking Nazis (usually an Ex smoker)says so.

if the only person I`m endangering is ...


 Can you be arrested for meeting an underage girl on the Internet, if you thought she was really 18 years old?
Lets say you meet a girl on a dating site, and she says shes 18 or 20 years old. Lets say if the girl is really only 16 or 17, can you be arrested and prosecuted just for meeting her. Can dateline ...


 Why is the drinking age 21, and draft age where you can be shot & have to shoot 18?

Additional Details
I didn't say there was a draft, I said the draft age is 18, where you can be shot and killed if drafted, yet the drinking age remains 21. Indeed you do register ...


 My friend says that shoplifiting from major companies isn't wrong?
He's been caught shoplifting several times and each time he justifies himself by saying that major companies aren't going to miss the things that he stole so it isn't really wrong. W...


 What would be an acceptable reason to stab an attacker?
...


 Can an 18 year old open a bank account without parental consent?
...


 Should weed be legalized
should weed smokers have the same freedom as tobacco smokers
what do you think and ...


 That woman that drowned her 5 kids in a bath tub, do you think she should get the death penalty?
I not found of the dealth penalty, but if there going to have it, then be it. I can bet you if she was a man, it would happen. She should have stopped having kids after 2, she should have used birth ...


 If you wake up and find a man in your child's bedroom how much "appropriate" force can you use ?
I mean without infringing his "human rights". Please note paedophile knife wielding child killers have "human rights" according to my understanding of this.
Additional D...


 In your opinion is it fair for a convicted murderer to choose a last meal and method of execution?
...


 Do you hate muslims?
as a church going black cristian i find you lot who answered my if i put bacon on a muslim rather over protective isit not muslims who are forever blowing them selves up in the name of god so i only ...


 Why do I have to pay for all the lazy people on benifits?
They just take and take because they can and I am sick of it! I work on av 72 hours a week, i get nothing free, i have even had to resort to buying my precription drug from suspect places!...


 Why should abortion be legal?????
Why or Why not
Additional Details
I'm actually all for abortion, and i think it should be legal, I'm just wondering what others think . I guess I should have asked why should ...


 Prisons don't work, what do you think would be a good alternative?
I was going ask if prisons work, but it had already been asked a few times, and I have a big suspicion that they really don't work. So what would be a good alternative? Bearing in mind a ...


 Why is abortion an issue that can never be solved?
...


 If I get pulled over for DUI, should I refuse to take a breathilizer?
I know that it's stupid to drink and drive... and I'm not plan on do it... but in the event that I were to ever get pulled over after I've had a few, I've heard that it's ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.084