Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

Animal Rights: what's your stance?
Find answers to your legal question.





Animal Rights: what's your stance?


Additional Details
yes, it was vague. brought up some interesting issues.


    




Pickle
I believe that animals should be given the same rights and respect as humans. I wouldn't subject a human being to pain or suffering so why I would I subject an animal to pain?

I haven't eaten animals for 16 years, I don't buy or wear leather and I make a conscious decision to not buy products that I know are tested on animals.

I don't agree with medical testing on animals as there are a whole host of scientifically validated alternatives (just look up the John Hopkins Centre and ECVAM). I have to say that I hate people who turn to me and say "How can you not agree with testing on animals for the benefit of finding cures for HIV/Cancer etc etc?" I tell them "How can you support testing a drug on an animal when it may not harm the animal but may have fatal side effects when given to humans?"

The problem with animal testing is this:
All drugs are tested on animals first. If the drug passes the animal tests then it is taken to phase I clinical trials. If the drugs fails animal tests it is still taken to phase I clinical trials. So whether the drug is passed as safe or not in animals, it is still essentially given to humans at some point down the line. Would you be prepared to give your child a drug that had killed several hundred animals but scientists decided to pass it as safe anyway?

That aside, this doesn't mean to say that I am supporter of extremist groups such as ALF (Animal Liberation Front). Most animal lovers and vegetarians vehemently despise such groups.


Robert D
There are no such things as 'animal rights' only human responsibilities.


Millie M
we shouldnt hurt them but there not nearly as important as people and people shouldnt get their panties in a a twist over them


Sassy Diva
They have the right to be treated humanely, not cruelly. But I'm not against eating them or anything like that.


Proud to be an AMERICAN
Rating
Animals should not be caused unnecessary, gratuitous pain. But we should use them (and eat them), in each case wisely and with due respect for what nature has provided us.


Jeff M
I agree with more or less all the other responders.

Animals are animals. No inherant rights, simply human responsibilities.

Do not cause undue suffering or harm.
Ok to eat them.
Ok to use for research (humainly)


friends4eva
Rating
We can eat them just not hurt them for no reason.


Bill H
Rating
Some have the "Right to be dinner"


hunter
Generally people recognize cruelty when they see it. Slaughtering a cow for butchering = not cruel. Cutting its leg off to watch it limp = cruel.

Swatting a fly = not cruel. Pulling its wings off = cruel.

See what I'm getting at.


Alteredstatemate
Rating
tiger style


Kevin B
Rating
Just depends on how deep animal rights laws go. You shouldn't abuse animals. That is really the only right I think we need to give them. Lest we forget. We eat them! So too many rights would be contrary to our very survival. Before you say just eat vegies. Tell that to the poor and starving in the world.


I can haz cheezburger
Rating
i think animal cruelty is unnecessary and its not fair to the animals. i strongly believe the people who take part in animal cruelty NEED to be prosecuted. I was watching animal police and someone dumped acid on their dog and the dog had over 45% of its body burned! thats ridiculous!

however, i will NEVER pass up a nice juicy steak!


E.B. Jacques
Rating
What about it ? You need to be more specific. The rats, mice, snakes have no rights whatsoever to get into my house and scare me to death. And eat my food and chew on my clothes. The chickens have no rights when it comes to "sacrifice" them for the dinner table. Neither do the turkeys when Thanksgiving day comes.
Fishes are the most abused animals on the planet.
Wild and domestic animals should not be abused and killed just because...for fun.We humans should respect nature. Or nature will come after us ...in the form of wild fires, tornadoes, hurricanes, floodings, earthquakes etc.etc. Mother earth will be very angry at us for abusing its creatures and failing to protect them.


CLIVE H
Rating
I agree with Bill H - animals are food and those animals who are in direct competition with us for food, should be shot dead on sight - rats, mice, squirrels etc. Oh yeah, not forgetting birds such as crows, magpies etc. Vermin and yes pigeons, we should eat more of them, less crap on our streets here in London.

One final - the fox is a vermin - kill one today. . . .


Ryan F
I like what Robert D said...


rogerglyn
The only Rights animals have are those given by Humans.

A bit of a paradox.


Lela A
Rating
that is why there is the SPCA for animal rights for abuse and neglect issues


Hosey
Rating
Animals have no rights when they are in season and I have my trusty 12 gauge...

Anyone who is against hunting is ill-informed, uneducated and needs to go to a wildlife biology class.

That being said, animals should not be tortured or hurt just to torture or hurt. But I have no problem shooting them while hunting them and eating them.


RedThread
Rating
Many people who support "Animal Rights" (being against animal cruelty is something different) believe in evolution.

If you believe in evolution, you believe in two things: (a) Survival of the fittest, and (b) We evolved from animals (monkeys).

If we are a higher evolved species who came from monkeys, then we have evolved into the dominant species.

That means animal rights do not exist. That means we're all animals and if we (humans) decide to eat certain animals or merely kill them for sport, that should be our right as the most highly evolved species.

I, however, believe that God Created the Heavens and the Earth, and Created people to rule over the earth (Genesis 1). I don't believe animals have inherant rights, but that we should not be cruel to animals. It is okay to kill them for food, or when they are a nuisance, etc.


Lou-Lou
Rating
Top of the food chain...If given an opportunity, there are a few that would eat us in a heart beat...Outside of that....as for animals that "we" do not eat....example...cats, dogs, or pets in general that are not for food purposes....cruelty is absolutely without a doubt wrong. I think that crimes against animals...should be punishable to the fullest degree of the abuse....especially for those that find it amusing to torture animals to get their jolly's.....just my animal lovin opinion! Now please pass the steak! :)


Jimbo T
I'm w/ soda pop


felinefan
Rating
I am absolutely against hunting. There is no place for hunting in the 21st century. I also believe there needs to be tougher laws against animal abuse.


pot_sex_beer
Rating
DUH? have any of you ever seen what goes on in a slaughter house? does'nt get much crueler than that.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 If in a business partnership of two people one dies is the remaining partner the sole owner?
...


 Should Death Row be eliminated?
It's a fact that it cost more to keep an inmate on Death row than in the general population prisons....


 Why do american's think they should decide if women are allowed to have n abortion?
isnt it supposed to be a democratic country?
its a very private issue n i dont think any country should tell it's ppl wheather they can go through abortion or force them to have a ...


 HI i REALLY need some help here on Underage drinking. Can you help me?
I am 18, I do not go to parties but i was convinced to go to one and a friend got me to try his beer, I had 1 sip. (hated it)... anyway the cops came and I told them that I had one sip. They gave me ...


 In your opinion, is freedom of speech a right or a privilege?

Additional Details
Of course it should be a right, I don't disagree with that aspect.......


 My girlfriend's exboyfriend is thretening us, can we file a lawsuit?
this person is out of his mind...where do we have to go? and what kind of protection can we get?...


 Are you for or against the death penalty.?
...


 Is there some kind of law against opening letters that are not addressed to you?
I've heard mixed opinions on this. My Mother is constantly opening my letters. I live at her address but I am always the last person to know I have post and by the time I do know, it has already ...


 If you were allowed to, would you...?
...walk into a china shop and wreck up the place?
Additional Details
well, i won't ask any of you to join me on my next trip to the high street ...


 I havent gotten payed since before christmas! is this legal?
Well, i have been working in an office for about 8 months already, few times before i have had trouble not getting my paycheck on time, howver now its just anoying. they have not payed me for 92 ...


 Is it time now in the UK to seriously consider bringing back flogging?
Nothing else seems to be working - so how about a good public flogging?...


 Why do the British people not stand up for themselves and their rights a lot more?
The MP's should be forced to bring in stricter laws towards these young hooligans.Increase age limit for alcohol,make them join the forces.If they insist in killing people let them kill the ...


 Can i brake in his house...he is in out of town?
I am still on the lease, no restraining order. I had been calling the police to go with me in (our)apartment. I left the important papers like birth certificate, my 1 nice pair of shoes, and car ...


 Do you think we (USA) should raise the minimum wage? If yes then why?
what do you cosider yourself to be, libreral conservative ect.?...


 What rights does an 18 year old have if still living at home?
does the 18 year old have to listen an have there parents control who they can hang out wit or wat they could do outside of the ...


 Something strange is it a con??????????
tody i received an email from someone saying they work for natwest bank, he told me how a considerable amount of cash was left floating in a bank account of a deceased man and that as the man has no ...


 Human Rights?
When somebody gets convicted and sentenced for a crime should they lose their human rights? Do you think they have it too easy inside?...


 Why do so many people criticize pot when alcohol is America's real drug problem?
How do you feel? Whats the big deal about smoking pot? Why is drinking yourself "stupid" ok in our society? Will America ever change its stance on Marijuana?...


 Do you think unborn babies should have human rights?
In the UK they do not, in the US I believe there are rights in place for unborn babies and this has led to some pregnant Women being prosecuted for drug taking and the like in pregnancy-(quoting my ...


 Does Freedom of Speech still exist in the UK?
Or does it only exist for certain groups and religions?...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.044