Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

Can I have somebody arrested for making a racist remark?
Find answers to your legal question.





Can I have somebody arrested for making a racist remark?

Would I need proof or would the police accept my statement? What if it is gestures aimed at me, that could be construed as being racist?

Could I get compensation?


    




purplepadma
Rating
Depends on the remark, but it could come under Public Order Act Offences of threatening/insulting words or behaviour, or maybe harrassment if it's repeated behaviour. If any offence is deemed to be racially aggravated, this automatically makes it more serious and the penalty imposed would be harsher.

Generally speaking, if the victims perceives that the behaviour was racist, it is deemed to be so.

Compensation could be awarded by the courts if the case came to prosecution, although in practice compensation orders are not made that often.

Talk to the police, they have a remit to deal with all forms of hate crime and should take your complaint seriously. Whether the perpetrator is ever taken to court depends on whether they can obtain enough evidence for a charge and prosecution, but you should still report it anyway. That way the crime statistics for reported crimes give a better picture of how widespread a problem this is.


Feeling Mutual
Rating
I don't think so. There is no law against it.

It just proves that they are an idiot.

Opps, Sorry,I apologize to idiots everywhere for comparing them to racists...


Piztaker
Grow up.


Junto America
Rating
No. Racist speech is protected speech under the First Amendment of the Constitution of the United States.

You would have to prove that a), the person made threats to harm or kill you, and b) that it is credible that the person might actually carry them out.

If just used a racial slur, you have nothing be free speech.


Avondrow
The police would be obliged to investigate your report, but with no proof other than your statement, it is unlikely that charges would be brought. Gestures certainally do count.


beardog4314
No, it's not illegal to be stupid. If they've threatened you in anyway, you can press charges for that, but there is no compensation.


greencoke
Rating
Freedom of speech


porn again
Rating
Sure, maybe if you live in Cuba. You can maybe try harassment, but arrest is doubtful.


shelcom
Rating
Compensation? For being called a name? You should be ashamed for even asking. Why do so many people think there is a Constitutional right to not be offended? Life isn't fair. Live with it.


SABADO GIGANTE
Rating
No!! What kind of country would this be if people were arrested for simply making a remark that you didn't like, regardless of the fact was it racist or not. You could file a civil law suite if you wanted but that would be frivolous in my opinion.


LEO53
Rating
Not necessarily. If it is a continued thing it could be considered harassment. If they commit an actual crime against you (assault) while yelling racial slurs, it will be considered a hate crime. Just to call you a racial slur, not gonna be able to prosecute. You want to sue? For what damages? Your feelings were hurt? Good luck with that.


steve m
Rating
you want money for someone calling you a name.. i dont think so!!!!


Jeremy A
Rating
Freedom of speech, no matter how hateful, is protected.


Annie Oakley
Rating
Sorry, but no. I wish we could receive compensation every time an ignorant butt head opens their stupid mouth, but we can't. What a great law that would make though, huh? I mean, what if everyone who made a comment to us that was insulting, got fined 10 bucks for it. I would probably hope people would insult me because then I would get rich!

Unfortunately, "free speech" seems to include "hate speech" towards our fellow friends and neighbors. I think people should be fined for being hateful.. . . . . the money will go to the poor.

It would be nice if making a racist comment were a crime, but free speech destroyed any hope of making people behave in a civil manner. There is too much freedom in this country.

If you feel that your life is threatened in any way by the people who made the racist remarks, by all means, report it to the police. But, so far, from what you have said, no crime has been committed yet.

I am sorry that you had to experience this incident.
I pray for the ignorant, that God will touch their hearts and minds.


CAUTION:Truth may hurt!
Rating
"If anyone speaks badly of you, live so that none will believe it."
-Socrates

If it were possible to have people arrested for unacceptable remarks, Fred Phelps would be on death row.


vdv_desantnik
the police would take a statement and decide but probably not if it your word against another. As for compensation, you werent injured so probably not


boglin
From the comments of (freedom of speech ) i can tell your not from the UK, we gave that right away, as here you can be arrested for racist comments which may insight violence.


Mr_ektingyue
You guys are always tryin to get money for nothing, and you wonder why he did it. The answer is no, freedom of speech


Bear
No you wouldn't get compensation.


galyamike
Rating
Unfortunately, yes. It only needs a denuciation from one (preferably ethnic) "witness with no corroboration required. I am assuming that you are white, if not, things might be easier.


junction 19
Rating
Its the compensation that worries me, are you in it only for the money ?


Sean F
Rating
I am not sure that you could, I think that an awful lot of proof would be needed. P.S. your Avatar is very strange why have your got whitish marks round the edge of our face? Is it one that your have constructed yourself.


kilton boy
Yes if he`s or she is white, contact the PC brigade,they will be down on them like a ton of bricks especially if the are indigenous white .Go for it Brother, use the system. milk it, use the race card,but i guess you already do .


Lisa T
Rating
I get called white trash all the time but no-one takes me seriously when i complain about being people being racist, but then when the boots on the other foot, that is a whole new story.


Ahcho N
Rating
Nope, "freedom of speech".


katy
nice little earner eh ? fat chance


Joker 1
Rating
No, I'm sorry to say you're probably out of luck.

When my first wife was alive, she used to get it all the time. She was part black (grandfather) and the whites were the worst at making remarks at her. And me being a white guy, would get it also.

We would have people drive by, like in a mall parking lot, say something stupid and they'd drive off.

This didn't happen when we were by ourselves, just when we were together, holding hands and such.

People can be such *******.


Kekionga
Yes you can....

That teacher who dared call you"student" to which you took so much offense should be hauled into the nearest pokey!

If you are offended, it must be racist, so let's stop people from saying anything to anybody or you can say....

"I'm telling!"






g-day!


Sweetpea
Rating
You will need proof. Are you that thin skinned that you can't take a racist remark or two? Remember the sticks and stone rule and be an example of what not to be.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Why do people post legal questions on yahoo answers?
They need to go out and hire an attorney. It's not that difficult. They need to quit cheaping out and trying to steal information that shouldn't come without a cost. Also, how do they know ...


 I need your help. My wife left me two years ago and took my son with her. I have tried everything to find her.
My wife just up and left two years ago and took our son with her. She moved to a military base (although she's not in the military, just dating someone who is). I miss my son so much. I want to ...


 Why aren't lie detectors used in murder cases if they are so accurate?
One would then know if the accused is guilty/not ...


 How do I beat a polygraph?
I'm taking a poly tomorrow and there are a few things i'm worried about not telling the whole truth on. Is there anyway to beat a polygraph exam?...


 How can i stop my neighbour opposite throwing his cig end in our street and on our drive?
he stands on his drive smokeing them chucks his cig end at the road like a dart sometimes it lands on our drive , the road is narrow sometimes i think he is trying to hit the ...


 How do people who download music illegally through Limewire or BearShare get caught?
Or do they?...


 If you get your neighbor's mail by mistake do you..... take it to their house, drop it in a mail box or throw
...


 Do I have any rights?
Im actually crying now. I know it sounds really stupid but in february ive got to have the MMR injection. Ive never been so scared. Im 14 and ive got to have two injections (one in each arm) and id ...


 A policeman followed me home, can i keep him?
...


 OK I don't mean to be disrespectful..?
and I dont expect you to agree with me. But enough with the Diana conspiracy theories already.

Do you think if you thought someone was trying to kill you by faking a car accident you might ...


 I've had a jury summons, but I can't afford to miss two weeks of my university course - is that a valid excuse?
...


 Death penalty yes or no?
in england we dont have the death penalty, just in case the decision is wrong and we kill an inocent person, in america they do that means evil poeple die deservedly, which is right and should they ...


 If you were about to die for a crime you commited, what method of death would you prefer?
Firing squad, lethal injection, hanging, eletrocution, etc.......
Additional Details
Also, what would you want to eat at your last meal?...


 Is it morally wrong to abuse pain killers?
...


 Do you trust your neighbors to help you in an emergency?
...


 Lets hear your opinions on these punishments for crime?
Ok what you think of these punishments as a way to deal with crooks.

House breaking-First offence 2 years hard labour ,any further burglaries and then they break your hands with a large ...


 Is there anybody out there who dare admit to being a racist?
Seems to me that having an opinion that might offend others is likely to become a hanging offence. Surely we cannot ALL love one another, and what is wrong with saying you don't like somebody ~ ...


 Would you kill people if it were legal? Do you kill people anyway? What kind of people?
...


 Can you put a restraining order on your mother even if you are under 18?
...


 Was she wright or wrong?
women goes into a pharmacy to get the morening after pill,but the women behind the counter refuses to sell her it,becaus of her religon....




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.074