Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

Can someone please explain to me the difference between a 17 year old and 18 year old?
Find answers to your legal question.





Can someone please explain to me the difference between a 17 year old and 18 year old?

?
Additional Details
why is there a variation? If you are subject to the same penalty's under the law. 17 year olds should have the same rights.


    




mark j
The only difference is one is allowed to buy tobacco products, vote, and buy lottery tickets. That's it. Mentally, they are about the same. Even though 18 year olds are of legal age doesn't make them mature adults. All 18 year olds are either seniors in high school or have just stepped into the world of working full time, college, and paying bills. With age comes wisdom, which ultimately resorts to maturity.


rabbi0230
365 days around a giant ball of gas...


chris n
Rating
jail


Texan
1 year............


PoliticallyIncorrect
Rating
a 17 yo would ask this....an 18 yo knows the answer


krimla2000
Rating
About 10 years and a tossed salad.


Ripper G
Rating
1 year.


Kenneth C
Rating
The 18 year old can vote.


Reported for insulting my belief
Nothing at all. You are just able to smoke legally. Well not for long.


poopfairy
At 18, the law says you are an adult. At 17, the law says you are a minor.
But the only real difference is 1 year.
It's a legal matter.


Suzy
Rating
12 months?


Jo
A year.
Supposedly the 18 year is an adult.


PointHo
Rating
Statutory rape vs. freedom.


Proud to be an AMERICAN
It's a bright line test which is generally thought to be a good standard and easy to apply - just check the birthdate!

But it may be arbitrary in practice.

I've known some 22 year olds who were not as mature emotionally and mentally as some 16 year olds.

But society has decided in general that once you're 18 you are mature enough to sign contracts, etc.

Nothing magical happens on your 18th birthday. But neither does anything special happen at midnight on New Year's Eve! They are both purely "legal" events, but with far-reaching consequences.

Again, the line has to be drawn somewhere.

Emancipation procedures are available for special cases.


Ronin
Rating
1 revolution around the sun.

What I think you are getting at is, do you really want judges to try to understand each and every one of the millions of 17 and 18 year olds in the country to determine if they are mature enough to be adults? Or is it a lot quicker and cheaper to assign a number as a cut-off?


lovingclementine
Rating
being tried as a minor or an adult.


Beautiful_nightmare
Rating
An 18 year old is a 17 year old with one year experience.


lynsey
an 18 year old will go to grown up jail. so will a 17 year old if tried as an adult. you are responsible for your actions and if you get in trouble with the law, they wont call your parents.


Someone
you know, you magically get responsible and mature when you turn 18, duh!


Marty B
Rating
legal and not legal


Pete S
one year


wont_this_be_a_hoot
12 months and your local laws


Am I. Incognito
Rating
The United States government does not declare you "legal" until age 18. Therefore, 17 is still considered a minor while 18 is an adult.


lifesajoy
Rating
1 year- and it's a big year -many things aren't legal to do at 17 that are legal to do at 18.


AW
nothing b//c age ain't nothing but a number


PraiseBob
A few years in the slammer with a 350 pound bank robber as your "roommate".


brock
Rating
there is no difference at all...


reno_tony_casino
at 17 you are minor a at 18 you r are a adult per most state regulations


Pamela K
Rating
Depending on what you do - how long you go to jail and what type of facility.

Depending on what someone else does - if they go to jail!


PJ
17 year olds can't wait to get out of the house and go on their own. 18 year olds are dicovering it isn't so bad at home after all.


Lil lady
an 18year old can go to jail and a 17year gets to call mommy





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 If i get found guilty for the murder of some1 and got jail for it,if they turn up alive can i then shoot them?
in broad day light(DOUBLE JEPORTY) is ther such a ...


 Would you make an anonymous call to a police dept?
Suppose a stranger online offered to pay you (via paypal) to call the police and report a crime anonymously. The person claims that if he/she reports the crime (relatively petty- say drug posession ...


 What do you think about this if it was a law?
Like a lot of folks in this state, I have a job. I work, they pay me. I pay my taxes and the government distributes my taxes as it sees fit. In order to get that paycheck, I am required to pass a ...


 How can i stop people parking in our private car park?
We only have 5 spaces in work & it is clearly marked private parking only. The parking spaces are about 1 metre away from my window & people have the audacity to park right outside then walk ...


 Do you think the age increase to 18 to buy cigarettes on 1st of October is a infringement of liberty?
This won't affect me but I believe that we should have the CHOICE to do such things because I am a true believer of liberty except murdering, stealing etc (obviously). Please don't keep ...


 I cut my foot in my neighbour's garden as I was looking through her window watching her change?
Can I sue her for having broken glass in her garden?...


 What are your veiws on abortion?
I have an R.E project on abortion so it would be nice if people left what they thought of it any ideas of things to put in it will be ...


 My Secretary told me she`s pregnant. Legally, how soon before i can sack her?
...


 CAN A 15YR OLD BE CONVICTED OF CRIME FOR JUST HAVING A KNIFE ON HIM??
I know with the news nowadays i do not agree with my son for getting the knife in the first place, and i do sympathise with anyone who has just lost a dear one through knife crime.

my 15yr ...


 Why do people commit hit and runs?
Persons fleeing the scene of an accident
Additional Details
In Canada Hit and Runs have a maximum penalty of 10 years, I have researched hit and runs for 3 years and no driver has ever ...


 Are you for or against the death penalty?
Do you think the death penalty is something society needs?

My personal opinion (I'm from the UK where there is no death penalty) is that it should definitely be a form of punishment ...


 Why are polygraphs not allowed in court?
Don't say 'because they could be wrong'. Witnesses could be wrong. Evidence could be wrong. Lot's of things could be wrong. From what I've researched, polygraphs are as ...


 Is this illegal to do?
i found nascar racing 2003 on thepiratebay.org and it said you could download the limewire torrent to get it and im wondering if this is illegal which i think it is and what are the chances i get ...


 Should torture be used to extract information from prisoners of war / detainees?
...


 What do you think of this--Dad threw 4 children off a bridge?
BAYOU LA BATRE, Ala. - A day after reporting his four young children were missing, a shrimp fisherman broke down and confessed that he threw them off an 80-foot-high bridge to their deaths, ...


 I am going to court for fraud . . . advise, comments?
I'm going to court for ripping ebay customers off - about 8 for a total of £3000. I have no convictions but was charged with meal fraud 18 months ago. I told the police all of the truth and was 1...


 Can a woman have her 18 year old child arrested for living with another family?
if so, on what grounds?
Additional Details
wow people its not my kid...im a kid myself...was to make an assumption...ugh...gross......


 My daughter is being bullied at school what can I do ?
The school isn't doing anything, and my daughters grades have dropped, not to mention the effect this is having on her on a personal level. If I were to mentally and physically abuse an adult in ...


 When you hear the word terrorism, what are the first words that come to your head?
Please be honest, this is an experiment that i am doing at school so i need the truth. Don't bother writing something if you don't truly mean it. Thanks.

(P.S. I hope everyone ...


 Should convicted paedophiles be tagged with a tracking device?
In the light of a local community succeeding in the forced eviction of a convicted paedophile ( who will end up God knows where....) Do you think they should be permanently tagged?...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.054