Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

Can we make the police use only rubber bullets to fell the opponent and not kill him? Why this is not thought
Find answers to your legal question.





Can we make the police use only rubber bullets to fell the opponent and not kill him? Why this is not thought

Why this is not thought of in a democratic, civilised world. The aim is to capture the wrong-doer. Whether such a solution exists or not ?


    




constant
Yes, it is possible & is being done to quell the mob which is unarmed & is doing peaceful demonstration or using non lethal means.
This question must be asked to 12,00,000 Indian army armed with automatic weapons in disputed territory Kashmir which opens indiscriminate fire on even women & children which has killed 7,00,000 innocent persons & raped over 60,000 young Muslim girls by order of Federal Government since 1989. Imagine, Kashmir valley has only 70,00,000 people(Govt of India's record shows it to be 50,00,000 people only which people reject) i.e., Indian tropps has killed 14 % population(UNSC resoltions dated % th Jan., 1949 has not allowed any external army to kill local people at all. Indian army is external as the territory is DISPUTED). USA asked Indian Govt in 1990 itself to use non-lethal weapons to quell mob there. On 21 st Jan. , 1009 Indian Troops killed 700 persons & on 21 st May, 1009 , army killed 300 persons again. In both cases, dense peaceful funeral procession was going to a graveyard. On 2nd Oct., 1991, a children school in Anantnag district with all 250 students was burn't alive by Indian army. Many similar things happen there in entire valley.


m
Rating
Because one, I believe rubber bullets at close enough range CAN penetrate and cause bodily harm (I BELIEVE, may be thinking of another non-lethal weapon). Two, some times you need to put a person down. If you're a victim being held a knife point, I doubt very seriously that you'd care if the suspect get shot with a live round or not.


pepe
Rating
Because, we can't make the opponent to use that too always.


hdean45
Good idea if you could get the criminals to use rubber bullets too.


Jenny Kim
Rating
No, because if an "opponent" is "felled" but not killed, he/she can still kill the police officer if he/she is armed.
.


SGT V
Of course we can just ask the sociopathic/psychopathic criminals to play nice and put their automatic weapons down and stop going into schools, stores, restaurants and shooting up the place killing people who just happened to be there. No offense but you really need to take the "rose colored glasses off" and move out of the Cinderella's Castle at Disney World.


Colin M
Rating
Because the "Opponents" have real ones.


~Anwesha~
Rating
Bcoz if the police would capture them and just keep them behind the bars and will be another plane hijack and there will surely be a loss of life and money! So criminals who do grave offences should be shot dead the moment they are captured!


Juli
Rating
Some security guards have rubber bullets however most that can carry guns of any form have real bullets. OK would you feel safe with the POLICE using rubber bullets when the Criminals are using REAL BULLETS? Why not turn it around have rubber bullets for sale for the general public to purchase and the Police have the real bullets?


parkin 4 life
Rating
that is just stupid if someone was robbing a bank you would not shoot them with a rubber bullet would you


politcalgeek
Rating
sure sweetie and after we arrest them we should put them up at the nearest 5 star hotel


Ravan2nd
Rating
If they catch a person, he will be released by his boss or some politician within next half an hour.

It is an useless act. Catch a criminal. Take photographs. Display them in Public places and release him to do further crimes. What kind of stupid system we have.

Instead cut the hand of a thief. Every body knows from the hands. Lot of others never dare to steal anyone else's property.


smarty_o1
Rating
rubber bullets are in use. they are often used effectively to disperse out-of-control demonstrations.


laughter_every_day
Police already use a system of escalating force and only use deadly force when deadly force is required. (the rare exceptions make the news and often result in prosecution of the cop). Adding another step is not necessary and would be impractical as cops would essentially have to carry a second gun, along with mace, a baton, a tazer, and all the other non-deadly things they already carry.


all good
Not all Police officer shoot to kill any Police is there to protect and serve and they do not shoot anybody to kill. Police use all the sources they have to save life dose not matter who the person is, they are professionally trained to control any situation and they only use there guns when they do not have any other option and there or somebody else life is in danger.
There are some good Police officers and some bad Police officers.
Do not judge someone if you do not know the fact.


Bill and Carey S
Nice idea conceptually.

Unfortunately, it will not work in the real world. All those rubber bullets do is sting and make a welt. They are more for controlling crowds and to push people back in a riot situation. They will not stop a criminal who's about to go to jail for a long time... nor will they stop a criminal from turning around and firing a real weapon at the officer.

The police forces are coming up with lots of non-lethal weapons, but in most situations, a real gun with a real bullet is what they have to use... for their own safety.


my avatar's hot!
Rating
They actually don't work that well at a distance, and they certainly don't stop someone 100% of the time. :)


nish
you have a creative thought,but rubber is an material which cannot tolerate such amount of heat which is produced during the emerging of the bullet,
thats why metals are used





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Both the Taliban and the GOP endorses torture do you ?
...


 Peas to all illegal immigrants?
hello everyone i jus wanna ask if the illegal immigrants are gonna be given papers, i think they deserve them especially those who are working and never commit crime? most of them work and pay tax ...


 Should i lie about my marijuana use for a job as a detention officer?
...


 Skunk,weed,marijuana...wh... your want to call it.....Do you??
First of all do you smoke it?I have done for a while now and I'm still alright! I think..... :/ Second of all why the hell are they trying to make it a Class B drug now!? Do you think they ...


 Would you break a law that you considered to be immoral?

Additional Details
Taking drugs is one example; taking part in an unlawful demonstartion is another.

What about comitting euthenasia as per the wishes of a loved one who was ...


 If you get an attorney on a contigency basis are you most likely to win a lawsuit?
...


 When will it be ok to sue a woman co-worker for harassment?
I've had situations in the past where I was treated poorly by women. I was harassed by a co-worker on two occasions, but was not able to get any support from HR because I'm a white male. ...


 Why is it our right to judge the octomom.?
we don't judge kate and jon or the lady that just had her 18th child and probably pregnant again. i think we need to help her and her children and not judge her. if she not crazy already,the ...


 When do you think weed will be legal in the U.S.?
Right now in America marijuana is in a legal gray area, and every day more and more learn the real reasons USA criminalized it in the first place. Across the globe where is was once illegal it is ...


 Retirement age?
Should the government raise the age that men/women ...


 How do I get God back in public schools?
God,Prayer,& bold christian confession allowed in our public schools and ...


 Why do license plates expire?
what is the point of a license plate expiring? If milk expires it tastes bad. If your drivers license expires it means you need to be tested since you may have become a worse driver. Why though would ...


 Can my boss legally tell me that I can no longer wear high heels to work?
He just refinished the floors at our office and has told me that I can no longer wear the style of shoes I've been wearing the entire time I've been employed with him beacause he fears that ...


 Do you support the death penalty why or why not?
...


 What should we do if we catch an illgeal immgrant?
...


 Legalise Weed??! yea, or no.. x?
my anwsers a definate yes!! x
Additional Details
ohh btw no i dont take or smoke any other drugs, getting stoned every now and then if fine and it keeps me and my friends inside (:...


 Do you think Marijuana is more destructive to society than Alcohol?
Alcohol-related traffic fatalities accounted for 39% of all traffic
fatalities.

25 to 40 percent of all patients in U.S. general hospital beds (not in maternity or intensive care) ...


 What would you do in this situation?
Okay. Let's say that there was this person (or group of people) who was for years eating away at your very sanity using mental torture methods that no one would ever think about. Not only that, ...


 With the rise in crime today do you still not suport the right to?
carry concealed wepons for the citizens of the USA...


 Can i still become a nurse if a have a charge of second degree assault and reckless endangerment?
I was a victim of domestic violence and abuse for eight years with my sons father.In 2008 my sons father beat and choked me, to defend myself i grabbed a weapon to scare him off. Therefore, out of ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.054