Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

Can you copyright unfinished parts of a multitrack sound recording?
Find answers to your legal question.





Can you copyright unfinished parts of a multitrack sound recording?

A drummer who was fired from a band, registered just the drum tracks of 6 complete recordings with the us copyright office. Since these are not separate songs, but parts of complete sound recordings, can this be legal?


    




Jacob Librarian
Rating
Yes, unfinished parts of a multitrack sound recording are automatically protected by copyright., as long as they are original and fixed (recorded). Is the Drummer's actions legal? Maybe. Read on.

Music is considered two separate works, each equally protected under copyright. There is the completed song (lyrics and notes written out) which as a whole work is protected automatically once it is composed (fixed). And the second work is the recording of music, which is a copyright owned by the musical artists who performed the song and recorded it.

For example, your band wants to record a cover of a Aerosmith song. The complete song's copyright is owned by Aerosmith, and you will have to pay a license fee to play and record that song. However, your band will own the copyright of the recording. (the drummer owns the copyright of his contribution, the guitarist owns the copyright of his, etc) And, if Aerosmith wanted to put together an album of recorded covers of their songs, and wanted to use your recording, they would have to get permission from you (possibly paying a license fee) to use your recording of their song.

And this ownership of copyright is automatic as well. It doesn't have to be registered to be protected, but by registering the copyright the drummer has an easier time in a future copyright infringement law suit.

However, if the drummer was performing work for hire, that is if the drummer signed a contract with the band, preferably one that stated that all the copyrights of his work produced while under contract with the band is property of the band and not of individuals, then the recorded drum track copyright is owned by the band group as a whole and not by individuals. If this is the case, then the drummer did not legally register his drum tracks, as he/she did not own the copyright of those recordings. If the drummer starts a copyright infringmenet law suit, this argument, that it is a work for hire, may be the best defense. (please note that I am not a lawyer, although I have recently studied this issue for a masters degree)





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 My husband has been detained by ICE?
I was talking to him on the phone and he said Immigration was pulling him over,I heard the officers speak to him when he got to the car and then I was hung up on. I called back and I heard the ...


 Just when I thought I heard all the craziest conspiracies goin, along comes this one?
THAT ADDING FLOURINE TO WATER, MAKES US LESS INTELLIGENT SO A NEW WORLD GOVERNMENT CAN TAKE OVER!, Since when did people begin believing everything they hear and not looking into the facts before ...


 The UAW will own 50% of Chrysler after the bankrupcy. Do you see anything wrong with this?

Additional Details
Don M-the american tax payers will have no steak in Chrysler-we gave them billions and will lose all we gave them. UAW, Canada and Fiat will own Chrysler....


 Can i still become a lawyer?
Well since i was 15 ive been interested in laaw and my uncle (now a judge) gave me all his old college law books and ive read through them all. im so serious about this. im graduated from hs now and ...


 What is the worst crime you can be charged with if your going to prison?
...


 If you find pot plants on your property how do you notify the police without getting in trouble?
Also, what if the police just happen to find it, when you didn't know they were there?...


 What does "a statutory right" mean in this sentance ? (I am French)?
" The Bill would also include A STATUTORY RIGHT for every suitably qualified young person to obtain an apprenticeship"

Thank you so ...


 Workplace Safety Videos?
Alright so I am doing a presentation on workplace safety. I am wondering...Can anyone find me any videos on workplace accidents or workplace safety?

Thank You!...


 How long will it take (if it does, which i doubt it will!) to kill the 750,000 people in the UK?
???
Additional Details
I mean with the "swine flu", no, i am NOT planning anything.. dont worry :P
I'm just very worried thats all!!! :(...


 Does Virginia law require GYNs to give ALL women a pregancy test?
When I received a bill from my GYN for a procedure she performed, I was upset to see a pregnancy test on there. My husband died a couple of years ago. But even if I were seeing someone - my last ...


 If you want to run for a local public office, who do you contact? city hall?
if you want to run for city council.....

Who do you go to get the paperwork from? city hall?


What if you want to run for state congress? does city hall have the paperwork ...


 Are morals simply a society's way of defining right and wrong conduct?
...


 What public policy issue do you think can be solved Through Reasoning?
...


 PC runs over 16 y/o. His life is ruined for 3 years as that's how long he's been jailed?
What about the girl who he ran over? Her life was ruined forever? I read that she'd been drinking, but it didn't say she was drunk. Also, the person whom the PC was chasing was driving ...


 Can an arrest warrant be issued if one doesn't appear in court for a lawsuit?
Let's say you sue someone for slander or defamation and that person doesn't appear in court on the date they're supposed to.

Can that person be arrested for failure to ...


 How do tabloids such as TMZ get away with reporting damaging information on celebrities costing reputation?
Why don't they get sued?...


 Can someone sue or press charges against a blogger who posts damaging or negative stuff about another person?
There's a bully who writes damaging info and it's making me live in stress. Are there any laws to stop this guy? Let's say the info is true but still damaging and he has no evidence to ...


 Has the The Child Soldier Prevention Act of 2007 been passed?
was have the results been?...


 Can an employer involuntarily hold you late after your scheduled shift in Washington state?
my boss is holding me late every day without warning, how much time should I give him?...


 Are governments obliged to take care of their people?
...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.044