Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

Can you get in trouble for drawing a swastika on a sidewalk with chalk?
Find answers to your legal question.





Can you get in trouble for drawing a swastika on a sidewalk with chalk?

Freedom of expression, right? And if I could get in trouble with that, I should get in trouble for drawing a Star of David, since Israel has committed immense atrocities and displaced millions of people.
Or even a christian cross in chalk on a sidewalk, because christians killed plenty of people themselves, in the crusades or even modern wars or whatnot. So either yes for all or no for all.
What is it?
Additional Details
It's a hate crime only if you think it is. It is my right to draw whatever symbol I want. Whether it be a six-pointed star or a rectangle.


    




cwstufff
Rating
yes
A sidewalk is public property.
A swastika is a hate-symbol
So to apply a swastika to public property is a crime,


diva
yes, considering the sidewalk is not your property, but the city property


Blue Steel & Lace
Rating
Well, you are guaranteed free speech by the Constitution.
However, drawing a Swastika on the sidewalk in front of a synagogue could be classified as a hate crime; just as writing the "N" word on the sidewalk in front of Jesse Jackson's house could be construed as the same thing.
The hate crime laws are meant to supplement the broad interpretations of the First Amendment.


plhudson01
yes you can get in trouble. it is called de-faceing public property


Hazza
Rating
Depends where u live if in germany its considered evil an u get arested pretty much the same every where else except india cos its a hindu sighn backwards an you could say u drew it the wrong way round


Ocean
no(as long as its chalk)

if u did somethin perminant than you could get into trouble with the law

im not saying its right to draw it because that is very WRONG!but u cant get introuble if u were going to be that low and draw it!


KND
Rating
yes, it is true you can draw whatever want. But the sidewalk is public property so you could potentially get into trouble for defacement.
I would like to note that the swastika was, I think, an egyptian symbal before it was a Nazi symbol. It all depends what a symbol means to the person viewing it.


Ms Angel
Rating
Drawing a swastika may be considered a hate crime. If local law forbids it and you're caught doing it, then yes, you could be in trouble. A Star of David or a cross is not considered hate speech. Your question cannot be answered all yes or all no.


Cardinal Fang
Rating
I think it depends WHY you're drawing a swastika. If you're doing it as part of a representation of your (bigoted) belief that whites are superior to others, then yes you may.

However, remember that the swastika is a widely-used sacred symbol in Dharmic religions (Hinduism, Buddhism and Jainism).

You often see swastikas with a dot in each quadrant in Hindu decorations. It is often imprinted on religious texts, marriage invitations, decorations etc. It is used to mark religious flags in Jainism and to mark Buddhist temples in Asia. If you are using it in that context, it would be difficult to see how the authorities could act against it.

Bear in mind though that you could still get in trouble for drawing it on the pavement simply because that constitutes grafitti.


Sarge
Poor taste but a crime in present day Germany.


Munya Says: DUH!
Do you want fries with that?


sciencegeek+
it maybe vandalism. but why a swastika? are you that low in self esteem.


Guess Who
Rating
Have you heard of Hate crime?


Suchness
swastika was used by fashist and they made terrible crimes. no other sign of religion was more wrongly used than swastika. so it lost its positive meaning and therefore it could not be used anywhere.
why don't you draw Lotus Flower that is always pure, positive and good?


i pack a 44
no for all................





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 I'm a tall thin white guy who is good at math...was i born to be an investment banker?
...


 Should i feel guilty?
a while ago my bestfriend *we hang out like everyday* called to hang out so i said sure. like a half hour later a different friend who i don't hang out with often said wanna sleep over and i don&...


 Uk is bursting at the seams, is it time to stop the thousands of people who flock here for our jobs?
i know it is. i am disgusted that one can so easily leave his own country in ruin for a quick buck over here. if they feel that patriotic about their own country, then how can i accept they will ...


 Is this a legitimate arguement?
Say that a company works its employees to midnight or aorund there, and then they have to turn around and go back to work 6-9 hours later the next day.

Is it a legitimate (and legal) ...


 When is it legal to runaway from home?
...


 I've been paid with cash for an item I sold on eBay, but I have a moral dilemma...?
Ok...here's the deal.

I sold a high dollar item on eBay ($1,500) to someone overseas. He paid me via WesterUnion, so I have the cash in hand, AND, he has already left me positive ...


 What's your stance on Abortion?
I'm doing a project considering Debatable Issues. I am passionate about the topic of abortion (not that I'm telling you what I think!), but I need both sides of the issue. I'm pretty ...


 I handed in my notice - which should be a week as stated on my contract and my employer asked me to help a lit
tle longer - four weeks - im now two weeks into my notice and my car breaks down. my employer calls me and says get a taxi - which i cant afford and tells me im not filling my contract and that im ...


 Is it legal if I'm getting a divorce that my wife changes the lock on the house...?
I was told I had to move out and find an apartment and she would pay the entire mortgage on the house. I signed the lease and then she changed her mind and said I had to pay half the mortgage ...


 Why does our court system allow so many frivolous lawsuits to be successful?
I can't believe so many people get away with suing over such petty stuff like emotional damages and punitive damages for the most absurd stuff like the lady that spilled hot coffee on her lap ...


 Is Nancy Pelosi guilty of sedition or treason, using these definitions:?
Treason. A breach of allegiance to one's government, usually committed through levying war against such government or by giving aid or comfort to the enemy. The offense of attempting by overt ...


 I have been sacked over an allegation that was not true, they had no proof if allegation is true but sacked me?
i was accused of smoking weed in my van, I smoke in own time but not my company's, I smoke nearly every day but only a little which i admitted to employer, They sent me to a medical doctor where ...


 The cat is mine and has accidentally been locked in. if i break in i may be in trouble or not i dont know?
...


 Is the Death Penalty more costly than life in prison?
Check the title....


 How many People No the Law other than smoking Pot,and speeding~?
...


 Have you ever been to Hell, Michigan?
I got lost yesterday going to my granddaughter's Cheerleading Invitational and drove thorugh Hell at 7:00 a.m. Let me tell you that the road to Hell is REALLY bumpy. For real....


 What if one half of Conjoined twins commits a murder?
If a conjoined twin was to pick up a knife and stab someone and there were witnesses present would the innocent twin be forced to go to prison, or would the guilty twin get away with it? - Are there ...


 How can you get the government (Homeland Security) to tap your telephone?
I have heard a tape running sound on my home telephone service many times. Sometimes I hear a clicking noise. I have even heard it sound like someone was hitting keys on another line when I KNEW no ...


 Why is alcohol legal but cocaine isn't?
One initially assumes its obvious why drugs are illegal - they are bad for you. But how is this any worse than alcohol?
Acohol and cocaine both have huge social impacts.
They both change ...


 Is it illegial to be at a party with underage drinking and drugs or just to participate in them?
please only for sure ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.024