Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

Do human rights allow me to kill the person who kills someone I love?
Find answers to your legal question.





Do human rights allow me to kill the person who kills someone I love?



    




Aless
Rating
No


retox
It's so tempting - especially with the British justice system as it is - most murders get downgraded to manslaughter which leads to about 18 months in prison and they are out again. The irony is that if you then killed the criminal you would probably get done for murder and face about 20 years in prison - out system rarely favours the victim.


footballplayer#14
Rating
no id this was real a murderer would die from the mudered family then the murdered family member will die from the murdered murderers family
This will continue


pr1nceofpersia
Rating
No but it should


Richy is f0cking awesome!!!!
No. they protect the guilty, not the innocent.


25discs
Rating
no,
but if u kill him and no one finds out, its OK =)
lol joke!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! seriously, human rights dont let any1 kill any1


Ozz
Rating
No. You do not have the Human Right to do that. Here is where it gets interesting. You DO have the MORAL RIGHT to take justice into your own hands. One could argue that you even have the MORAL RESPONSIBILITY to execute the individual.


billnzan
no, but if that really happened to you hurry! do it quickly and you can probably copy a temporary insanity plea. Otherwise, take deep breaths, warm baths and try aroma therapy. Consult Yahoo Answers for further advice.


Ollie
Rating
That would make you has bad as the killer.


Tara ツ
Sadly, no.
Don't do it.
You'll just get more angry when you have to serve time.

x


Matthew D
Rating
No. However, if you kill the person who kills someone you love either RIGHT after they did it or RIGHT after you found out you'll get a much lighter sentence. 'Temporary Insanity' is when you bug out and kill as a reaction that you didn't (arguably) have sufficient time to think about the consequences of your actions.


dirtystarfish
No they don't! but if someone killed someone i love then i would want revenge!!

but dont do it unless your sure its them that killed your loved one! and if someone has killed someone you love, then im sorry to hear.


scottclear
Nope, that is called revenge. And you could be wrong about who did it. Then you would have murdered an innocent person.

Best left to the Court system. That is what it is there for.


ELIZABETH N
Rating
no


Citizen1984
No.


shadowman
No, but you should be able to. I think I would get on with doing what had to be done without talking about it.


Bob b
nope


hawk
no


Wendy H
No.

I can understand why people do it though, or think about doing it, but two wrongs dont make a right and by lowering yourself to their level wont bring back the person you love.


True American
No, the only exception is defense
(if you are defending that person from someone who is trying to kill them)


prince_henry
no,


Laurence B
Obviously not, as that would come under murder.

Then both of you would end up in prison for a LONG time.

Human rights do not include justification of murder, silly.


agreeable
Rating
Pleading 'human rights' for killing a person is tantamount to trying to use illegality as the back door of the law to commit your crime.

It is against the law to commit murder, irrespective of reasons you may hold dear.

Nice try though!


Pascha
No, even if the justice system does not work.
If you killed that person, would someone who loved them think it was their human right to kill you? That could start a war.


Joe W
Human rights whatever that is may allow this.
However, the State will probably execute you for it.
You do not have the legal or even moral, right to kill someone because you beleive he deserves it.
That's what judges and juries are for.
Our criminal justice system does not allow vigilante justice.
You want to make yourself Judge, Jury and Executioner.
If everyone did that we'd be in one hell of a fix.


ben.t@rogers.com
Rating
Revenge killing is the worst kind of retaliation. Killing with any kind of premeditation should not occur because it was thought out extensively, during which the knowledge of knowing it is wrong did occur. Killing of any kind is wrong.


meckah
Rating
human right do not allow anyone to kill for any reason, excluding capitol punishment which is only used in some countries.


jerseycoturegirl104
no .and u shouldnt be killing anyone even if u do lose the one u love.(sorry) but it doesnt give u the right to kill someone. think about how u must feel when u lost that person. think about there family too. u may think its horrible how ur love one got killed. but if u do something bad u will be doing that same horrible act.good luck:)


?
No,, get a bloody grip eh





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 How do you stop a pedophile that is using this service?
An individual that goes byt he name of Chester the Molester has been using this service to ask questions about becoming a Big Brother,his attraction to a 14 year old when he usually likes 6 year olds,...


 Do you think killing an endangered species for hunt should be punished by the death penalty?
Humans shouldn't be dumb enough to want to exterminate a species for money. We should just start killing these hunters off.

http://news.yahoo.com/s/...


 If I am a minor, but I am with my parents at a restaurant, can I order alcohol in the State of Texas?
The law makes reference to minors being allowed to consume alcohol when in the direct supervision of their parents, but does this only allow them to drink alcohol in their parents' home or can ...


 Why do people believe Marijuana is a horrible "gateway" drug?
I smoke Marijuana myself, have for many years. I havn't become this drug hungry junkie living on the streets, as so many believe it leads to. It is souly a recreational drug for me and the main ...


 Is whistleblowing ethical?

Additional Details
Sorry for asking so many business questions, but I often find people have really formidable opinions and aid my understanding....


 If marijuana was legal for recreational use would you smoke it?
even if no won would ever know it

no won had od from smokeing weed to my knoledge

most people who smoke or drink would even if they wont admit it
Additional Details<...


 Do you agree with these people who say that our Immigration Laws are too strict?
http://www.socialistwork...


 If an employee has been in a current job for 4 months. Can an employer give them one months notice without sta
If an employee has been in a current job for 4 months. Can an employer give them one months notice without stating why? The employee is not guilty of any gross misconduct. Doesn't the employer ...


 Is there any way homemakers could get paid?
I dont know much about state law, government, and all that. I was just wondering if I could actually get paid for all the hard work I do. I work just as hard as my salaried husband. AND I dont get ...


 Can men do anything by themselves? In 2007?
Or do they need help with everything ?...


 Does anyone believe that smoking marijuana is immoral or wrong?
Does anyone believe that because you are breaking the law means you are doing something wrong? What makes smoking marijuana wrong?
Additional Details
No i am conservative but just ...


 Whats people's views on the 12yr old girl wh died from a gunshot to the head by her brother?
The "powerful" firearm was in their house, to me it was an accident waiting to happen
Additional Details
Sorry yes think he is being questioned, even if he did do it I don'...


 Are we living in a namby pamby nation?
Here are a few examples of sheer stupidity i come across.

Under the Gambling Act, children are no longer able to win soft toys over the value of £5.Not only could "too cuddly" ...


 Do you think Gay Marriage should be allowed? Why do you think this way?
I think it should stay the way it is now!!!!!!!...


 Fat people discrimination law?
The news was talking about a state (Mass.) who wants to pass a law that states, fat people can sue for discrimination in a workplace if they feel they were discriminated against because they are ...


 Should we remove boundaries of nation and go for an integrated world governance?
...


 Are states invading the poors right to practice religion through the school systems?
There are those of us who take our belief in God very seriously and feel very strongly that God is not something just to be tossed aside for when there is time for him. Some of us feel that God ...


 My landlord has tampered with the original lease. What should i do?
When i gave them my 30 day notice, i noticed that the date on the lease had been scratched out and a new much later date put on top. I never intialed this area or was ever aware of this change. The ...


 How much weed would you smoke if it was legal and cost was not an issue?
...


 Why are republicans saying that gay marriage is a sin? isn't that mixing politics and religion?
Shouldn't churches be able to decide for themselves? I just don't get it!! When a politician stops two people from being married they are a politician playing a role in religion. Isn't ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.024