Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

Do you think it is right that some states are making it illegal to talk on cell phones while driving??
Find answers to your legal question.





Do you think it is right that some states are making it illegal to talk on cell phones while driving??


Additional Details
Do you think that people should be able to talk on the phone at any time. What if it is an emergency. What if your driving and someone shot you in the side is it then okay to make a call??


    




BobbyR
Rating
Guess I'll be the lone dissenter. No, it's not. There are already laws in place against reckless driving, so for those drivers who are such bad drivers that they are distracted, the laws in place should cover it. Thus, it's redundant.

Personally, I think if you can't drive and talk at the same time, you have no business driving in the first place.

While it's true that cell phones are a distraction, so are: smoking, drinking coffee, eating, changing the radio station, or CD's, checking your GPS, etc, etc. Until all of those activities are banned, a ban on cell phones is pointless.


Pat R
Rating
Yes I do,it is already illegal in the UK.

Thousands of accidents are caused through it each year.


brian
Rating
yes.

you're about 4 times more likely to be in a car accident while using a cell phone.


browneyedgirl623
Rating
I absolutely agree with this legislation. Talking on a cell phone, with or without handsfree devices, takes the driver's attention away from the task at hand, which should be driving. I've witnessed dozens of near misses where one or both drivers were chatting while driving.


brk
Rating
yes. majority of time you get cut off, or someones driving strange its someone on the cell phone who is only paying half their attention to driving.


Angela C
Rating
Yes, people need to pay attention to the roads, not their phones!!!


Deathwish
Rating
Its illegal in the UK and that doesn't seem such a bad thing so why not?


mungbean
it is completely illegal in the UK to talk on your mobile phone whilst driving. a hands free kit is needed. i think this is sensible and the right thing to do, because both hands and minimum distraction are needed whilst driving.


Fordman
Rating
A study was done that showed that you are more likely to be in an accident talking on the phone than if you are driving drunk.

I think most people have had some close call with a person talking on the phone while driving. I know I've had several myself. So yes, for public safety make the law.


Lol...
Rating
Yes. Here in england it is complately banned. This is due to the number of accidents caused by people using their cell phones while driving. As they went paying attention to the road. Around 30% of road ccidents are caused by people o the phone.


Severance
Yes. And the argument that it's like talking to someone next to you in the car is specious. A mobile phone is distracting, has been proven to be so, sadly by a multitude of deaths. Having had the dubious pleasure of driving in the land of the free I'd say you need all the help you can get.

Here's a little article on the subject

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/1885775.stm


don c
yes

how many people are killed every year by drivers that think they are capable of handling autos that weigh 3800# while multi tasking !!


douglas m
yes I do, most people can't drive as it is, nevermind when they are distracted by a phone stuck to their head. There's no reason to be talking on a phone while driving, the call can wait.


chnuna
I totaly approve.
My twin sister was caught driving and on the phone and the policeman (who was young and probably gave in to her amazing eyes) let her off with a warning.
I was pissed.
I know that yes, it is possible to drive and speak, but you can never know, for 1 second you are distracted and another man is dead for life.
Car accidents are the biggest source of unnatural deaths.
In my country new drivers are allowed only one passenger in the car as to be less distracted...

I think that car accidents and road safety should be taken more seriously!


Hockeyfan
Yes, there are thousands of accidents that can be attributed to cell phone use. When your attention is distracted you are not as safe behind the wheel. This is one thing that can be controlled.


Some studies suggest the use of cell phone actually quadruple your chance of an accident. In 2003 there were 2600 traffic fatalities and 330,000 injuries attributed to cell phone usage/distractions.


Atavacron
Yes. It's right.

There are hands-free set ups. Options.

It's just a huge, stupid distraction.

The fact that we got along for decades without the ability to chat with our friends on the phone while driving proves that we can. You'd think that'd show us something.


Frostycat
Rating
Absolutely. Its already illegal throughout the UK. If you need to talk that desperately that you can't take a second to pull over, buy a hands-free kit.


LYNNSGARETHS
it is already illegal in the uk and should be worldwide.


llittle mama
Rating
YES YES YES
What is so important that someone cannot either pull over and talk or wait a few minutes to get to where they are going?
I have seen a man driving in front of me weaving all over the road and when I finally was able to pass him I saw he was on the phone with one hand, drinking coffee with the other and steering with his knees.


Carolina
Rating
It should be illegal everywhere. Far too many accidents are caused by people not concentrating on the road but on their phone. Here in the UK it is already illegal - unfortunately, not many people seem to realise this. I often see people driving whilst using their phone/smoking/drinking/reading map.


judyarb1945
Even with a hands free phone, it is dangerous because you are talking to someone not in the car and it is still distracting. Sometimes, just talking to someone right there in the car is distracting, so down with cell phones in the car, unless it is an emergency, like a breakdown, or wreck!!!!


smedrik
Yes, cell phones are a huge distraction and too many drivers refuse to invest in a $30 hands free set that would make driving and talking safe.

I am not sure about you, however when I am on the road, I do prefer to share it with drivers who are paying attention to what they are doing.

If you need to take a call you can pull over, invest in a hands free set or call back later. There is no call important enough to put fellow drivers in danger.


Red Panda
Rating
yes, because many people I saw in pictures and my dad lecturing to me is that many of those are teenagers who get into car accidents, its a way of distraction while driving mostly in the freeway.


Chef
What is so damn important to talk about that it can't wait until you are parked somewhere?

It's like a war zone out there with those damn things, and I rage at all the azzholes that are driving stupidly while talking on the phone.

It shouldn't need to be a law. It should be common sense.


chef79geoff
yes,its illegal here in ireland so people use blue tooth technology,blue tooth is fairly cheap and a hell of alot cheaper than the life of a human, scum included.deaths are down here which can only be a good thing.my dad died on the roads -not his fault-so any prevention can only be a good thing


fiona m
You know the answer to this you burk. If your child was run over by a car because the driver was distracted by the phone conversation he was having. (Would you be asking this question at all)


Danielle
Rating
Some states!! They should make it illegal in all states.

Uk it is illegal to talk on your mobile whilst driving, buy a handsfree kit and save lives!

xx


rabidchipmunk
Rating
Absolutely Fair all states should implement this. You can not pay attention to the road and your phone at the same time. Studies have been done that show cell phone drivers are just as dangerous as drunk drivers.
In these studies one test group was drinking the other talking on cell phones. The cell phone drivers hit more cones and posed a larger threat in some studies than the drunk driver.
In other studies they hit just as many cones and posed just as lethal a threat.
None of the studies deemed them safe to operate a vehicle while speaking on a cell phone.
Nothing is so important that you can not pull over to side of the road to talk.
Not to mention your ridiculous argument of "what if someone shot me while I was driving?"
If that really happened there is a 90% Chance that you would no longer be able to operate your vehicle much less your cell phone. In the case of an emergency it is suggested that you pull over to where it is safe and call 911 so that you do not add to an already horrible situation.
Cell phones do come with voice mail you can call who ever it is back.


Sunidaze
Rating
I certainly do. Very rarely do I talk on mine while driving and actually I normally have the ringer off. I see way too many drivers paying zero attention to everything going on around them while they are on the phone. Not to mention, a few years back in this area, a young woman was too busy searching for her ringing cell phone while driving and didn't notice the stopped bus with flashing red lights until she nailed (and killed) a little boy getting off the bus.

Added scenario you put out there - let's see...someone shot me in the side...so, not only am I being distracted by talking on the cell phone while driving...I've also got this tremendous pain in my side to keep my mind somewhere else besides the road. Sure thing. Not only am I putting myself at risk, but all those around me.


effenel
Rating
Over here in the UK it is illegal to use any hand held device whilst driving.

I do think it is a good thing. Have a look at this link and listen to the radio advert that proved to be very popular and effective.

http://perso.orange.fr/absolutenglish-972/notes/mobile_phones/ad_campaign.htm





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Do you think suicide should be legal?
I personally think if some wants to die then that's their business and he should be allowed to do so and not be looked at has someone who's crazy....


 If you could murder somebody and get away with it, who would it be?
...


 Is this a serious offense?
Holding a door so a security guard so they could not come into the locker room to stop a fight. I did not do this my friend and he has a hearing in court could he go to jail
Additional D...


 What are some good ways to get revenge on a neighbor who constantly takes your parking spot?
My neighbor, whom I call Ladysuit (because she looks like Robin Williams in Mrs. Doubtfire), INSISTS on parking RIGHT IN THE MIDDLE the two parking spaces in front of our apartment building. This ...


 Why on Earth do people still support the death penalty?
...


 Can Iegally force my wife to get an abortion?
...


 Does this mean marijuana is legal to consume?
I was watching on the news and it said
"Adults who smoke marijuana at home privatly cannot be arrested, the reason is there are more important crimes"

Does this in fact ...


 People have numerous opinions when it comes to ABORTION.When do you think having an abortion is a good idea?
Are you against or for abortions
Do you think ABORTION should be illegal or legal?...


 I work at a retirement home and an old man made me an indecent proposal?
But im 21 and could really use the $1000 for school and its just an old man, so what should i do?...


 Do you believe in the Death Penalty? Why or Why Not?
Personally, while I understand why the families of victims would want to seek retribution, I believe that we should not base our legal system on the raw emotions of traumatized people.
A...


 Isn't it time to free Charles Manson?
He's just a harmless old man....


 Why is marijauana illegal?
...


 What are your views on Abortion?
I think it should be made illegal. It is so wrong to kill innocent babies.

But what do you think?
Additional Details
Even of a woman is raped, it is STILL wrong. No matter ...


 Smoking bans question?
I read in the paper yesterday that some people think smoking should be also banned outside. How many of you agree or disagree and why?...


 Did saddam deserve to be hanged?? or left in high security jail???
...


 Do you think that harsher sentencing would reduce crime?
should the punishment for a crime should act just as much as a deterrent? i mean criminals probably assess the risk of commiting a crime to decide whether it is worth the possibility of getting ...


 If a father decides he doesn't want the baby before it is born should he be forced to pay.?
Since it is legally ok for a woman to kill her baby if she doesn't want it, why should a father be forced to pay child support on a child he doesn't want.
Additional Details
F...


 Is it right for employers to ask for candidates to send their picture when applying for a job?
Employers are so hypocritical. They talk about wanting a smart, hardworking person in their ad when advertising for a job then they want you to send a picture of your self. If the person fits all the ...


 Incident at Walmart - offered a $50 giftcard as a gesture of good faith - should I accept or seek more?
Recently in Walmart I bought a bottle of chocolate milk. I opened it and started drinking it on my way home. After the second sip there was a potent taste and smell of bleach all around the rim of ...


 DO YOU americans pretend that you are the best in the world??
that is the impression most europeans believe
Additional Details
I FIND most of your answers as bad as you really are.AS FAR AS speaking english it comes from the world england which is ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.084