Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

Do you think it would be a good idea if alcohol was banned permanety?
Find answers to your legal question.





Do you think it would be a good idea if alcohol was banned permanety?



    




malter
Why? It is a billion dollar business and over 99.9% of the people that consume alcohol do so very responsibly and contribute to society.

Your issue is with the one tenth of one percent that does not. That is their personal issue and their personal demon. If they did not have alcohol to abuse they would be abusing something else...and then what do we do....take that away as well? What happens if they start abusing corn products? Do we ban corn products for the sake of the one tenth?

Doesn't make much sense does it that society should pay for the inability of a small percentage of people who are not able to get it together.


katjha2005
on your search tool type in Prohibition.... we learn from our mistakes.. we don't repeat them


wizjp
Rating
Didn't work so hot last time.


N. Cognito
We already tried it, and it was a disaster. We're currently doing the same thing with the same results in regards to several other substances, and it's as much of a disaster as it was the first time. Let's not dig our holes too deep, especially while we're standing in them.


The_Doc_Man
Silly idea. All you'll do is make people criminals when they start going around such a stupid law to get their booze.

OR, far worse, you'll invite people to find some other buzz of choice. THINK next time you offer a well meaning idea that has many negative consequences. Then read up on the Volstead act in history so you will actually learn something relevant to this question.


garrisonbight
Rating
NOPE... Prohibition didn't work in the 1920's any more than the supposed 'war' on drugs is working now.

If you want to make a lot of people rich, then all the government has to do is make it illegal.. but AmeriKans can't seem to understand this.


firewomen
Rating
No. What good would that do. Wasn't that tried before....


cllem
how well did that idea work for prohibition it didn't


Al
Government makes too much money off of alcohol taxes, dui fines and other related taxes.....so its a money machine.....thats why cigarretts are nearly 5 bucks a pack.
sin tax is profitable.


Taylor! =]
no, it would be a terrible idea.

it could result in the same consequences as prohibition, i think it was the 18th amendment.
it caused a rise in organized crime (al capone, the "first" gangster made his business from selling illegal alcohol).
and most of all, its just a part of our culture and you can't cut out a part of culture. people will most likely follow the laws of their culture than the laws of the government.

like the caste system in india, for example.


Sigi H
It can never be done, will never be successful. Alcohol has been around for as long as mankind existed. Even the gods loved beer and wine.


allen555
Rating
Nope, enjoy my whiskey far too much to ban it.


pms
No. Many folks enjoy a drink. Why should millions of people be deprived of something they enjoy just because some idiots can't hold their liquor?

P.S. Its because of Probation that the Mafias and all other gangster got such o hold on America.


crazy_crats
Seriously, what would the Kennedy family do?


Max50
We try that once.

If you think alcohol is so bad pack your bags and move to Muslim country that has alcohol ban see if it is your cup of tea.


eⒶt_urself ▐▌▐▌▐▌ ◄▼►
Rating
No theres enough prohibitions as it is. Statistically use of any substance increases immediately following a ban. Also, i should not have to punished because somebody else can't drink responsibly. Some worry alcohol may lead to accidents but so does driving. Maybe driving should be banned too. Sure alcohol has its problems but NOTHING in life is 100% problem free. If alcohol can be banned to make life safer than so can other things (as many already have) and pretty soon it will be forbidden to have much of a life to bother protecting in the first place. There should be no laws telling people what they can or can't put in their own bodies. Such laws are invasive and aggressive assaults against the individual. Prohibition was already tried once and it failed.


SCUZE-ME
Rating
No. Not really. Did you know in Germany the drinking age is 16 and they have far less drinking related fatalities and far less crime? If something is prohibited it just makes people want to do it more. Take marajuana for example. It's illegal, it's not that much different than alcohol, but it is regularly used but a lot of people. I think EDUCATION is the key. People need to know what they're putting in their bodies whether it's alcohol, marajuana, pills, and even fatty food. INFORMATION IS POWER.


badkarma033
Rating
I'm sure most women do.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 What are some proposed solutions to overpopulation ?
from an ethical perspective, why is there countrovery surronding ideas?...


 Have you ever been arrested?
If so, why?...


 Can you get in trouble for sneaking into a R rated movie?
my friends and i sneak into R rated movies all the time, and we've been caught and thrown out by security officers before too. last saterday we got thrown out of the theater by the manager and ...


 They say Speed kills and I say Speed dont Kill it the driver who kills?
...


 Does the goverment have the right to make a law that will definitely kill innocent people?
that would otherwise live if they were not obaying the law?


There will be another part to this question added later
Additional Details
A cop once told me that the ...


 Does this prison sentence seem absurd to you at all?
My dad was sentenced to 30 years in prison for trafficking Cocaine.

In my opinion, that is a ridiculously lengthy sentence
for selling drugs.

I know guys that have ...


 Does it worry you ??
Yet, again another pheadophile have been released because the jails are full. It makes me sick when i read and hear things like this. Wonder how they would feel if one of their children was one of ...


 Is it legal for my employer to fine me money?
...


 How long can the police keep your fingerprints/DNA samples?
Convicted of assault and got 12 months....


 Do you know any of the Ten Commandments?
Have you kept them?
Additional Details
Have you kept them. Try this great test at http://www.livingwaters. to find the answers....


 If you're an adult when you turn 18 why can't you drink alcohol until you're 21?
...


 Time to bring back capital punishment?
when (and notice i did not say IF) the McCanns are foudn guilty of the murder of their daughter do some ppl wish it had happened in a country where they would have been killed for carrying out such a ...


 Legally can a man be sued for dating a married woman?
They have ben seperated for four weeks and starting a divorce.Nothing happened till after she left.Can I be sued for this ....


 Do you think us(Americans) take A LOT of what we have for granted??
...


 Which is worse for you alcohol or marijuana?
why is marijuana illegal and alcohol legal? should alcohol be illegal or marijuana be legal? why?...


 How fair is it when a man can work all his life then some woman marries him and gets half?
Like I say, you work to produce world famous music, you donate millions to charity, you live a good and wholesome life, then some woman comes along, gets you hooked, marries you, divorces you two ...


 Why is it illegal in New Jersey to...?
pump your own gas?...


 Do you approve or disapprove of the Patriot Act?

Additional Details
Thanks for the first star J...


 Why are peodphiles allowed to walk free?
there is definately something wrong with the government, why cant they be given an injection like a sick dog and be put down?!?...


 Teacher abuse...?
My bad for the last question. I guess it didn't go through. anyways. A friend of mine's son was hit (backhanded) by a teacher last week. What can be done about that and whats the max that ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.044