Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

Do you think lethal injection is the best method for capital punishment?
Find answers to your legal question.





Do you think lethal injection is the best method for capital punishment?

Will the criminals really be "punished"? Is it too passive for them?
If yes, why?


    




cybersharque
Rating
What do you mean, best? Do you mean tortured so as to die in unspeakable agony? 'Cos that's what the Missouri Protocol does, and most US States follow that procedure. Not enough pentothal to keep the victim unconscious. But the second drug paralyzes the body without removing sensation; and the high-dosage KCl that kills produces the most agonizing sensation as it courses through the veins and perfuses the coronary circulation.

If I were facing the death penalty, I'd rather have a short drop hanging than lethal injection.


silvergirl
I don't think lethal injection is the best method. "Best" as in worst punishment. It simply ends their life and they no longer have to think about their wrong doing. To me, its like there is no consequence.

I think Life in Prison With No Parole is the worst punishment anyone can ever endure. But I do not think this should be available for crimes committed by youths under age 18.


Curtis
I prefer the firing squad.


freedom first
Its not so quick and painless as its made out to be. In most cases, they can't get a real doctor to do the weight analysis and chemical mixing.

Anyway, I don't trust the state so I'm sort of against the death penalty. A firing squad is probably the quickest and most dignified method.


glavendale
i say bring back public hanging and death by firing squad.


Ladybug
I have so many mixed feeling about the death penalty. What about the innocent people who were wrongly convicted and went to their deaths for crimes they did not commit. And we all know it HAS happened. Yet when a child is victimized and perpetrator is actually caught, I feel that even I could pull that switch or push that button or strangle him with my own hands! I would not make a good jury member on a capital crime.


Lynn M
Rating
I think punishing criminals by death is a very bad idea because it legitimizes the state's right to kill. However, life sentences are worse, and most people support the death penalty, so lethal injection would be the best method, because it is least painful.


Susan S
Rating
One of your answerers thinks that the cost of lethal injections is why the death penalty is so expensive. The death penalty costs so much because of the legal process.

Why do we allow the legal process to go on so long?
More than 50 of the 124 innocent people released from death row had already served over a decade. Speeding up the process will guarantee we execute innocent people.

BTW, DNA is available at less than 10% of all homicide scenes. It is not a guarantee that innocent people won't be executed.


Ferddaword
I believe it's the most humane method of 'putting someone down'. Of course, killing a person as a result of their actions seems hypocritical. I mean if joe schmoe kills someone and then the judicial systems then turns and sentences him to death why is the executioner not killed? Ok I know the answer why but you might take a minute to see my point. I think people that have commited serious crimes, crimes that are unforgiveable should be sentenced to life in prison, solitary confinement. That'd be alot more frightening than getting a painless injection and then having it all be over.


tab1
Rating
It is way to passive. We give murder's an easier way out then how the punished their victims. And on top of this, we often give them choices on how they wish to die. They never give this option to the people they have killed.

I think we should bring back firing ranges and public hangings.

This country has become to politically correct. And we don't truly punish those who commit the most evil of crimes.


bitsy
Rating
I don't believe in capital punishment at all. Only The Lord can take a life. If the system kills another human being, it just becomes another form of murder. Just a legal one. Actually, if a person did such a horrible crime that he gets the death sentence, then let him suffer the rest of his life. Make him pay every day, not just sitting in a cell but hard labor for the rest of his or her life.


Steel Rain
No, lethal injection is not cost effective. The ultimate price is punishment. A 50 cent bullet in the right place would get the job done.


ahmosis3
Hangin' was good enough for the old west, and its good enough for me!
And televise it to, our desensitized public needs some real reality programing to get then to watch, and send the right message.


allen
Rating
yes, well why not, look at our constitution rules out cruel and unusual punishment.
they might not "suffer" but we must be civilized people and follow our constitution


booman17
The punishment is the loss of your life, not the pain of having it taken. Lethal injection is the way I would want to go if I was to be executed.


noy
Rating
yes, the best brains have come up with this kind of humane punishment.Who am I to say no.


rajan l
Yes if it does not give any pain. It is better when somebody dies without pain.


Ken
No. I prefer Gas Chamber. It is more painful.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Why are people allowed to live on "death row" for so many years?
And why do some states not have the death penalty?

This idiot kid that shot and killed his principal needs a speedy trial (like on Monday), and a public hanging on Tuesday. Sorry...that...


 What is your opinon on Gun Control in the U.S.?
...


 Do you smoke? And... what do you think about the new laws most states have or are adopting?
Most states have made it unlawful to smoke in public places. What do you think about the new laws that say you can't smoke in restaurants or even bars and not within 25 feet of the entrance ...


 If smoking's so bad for you, why don't they ban the manufacturing rather than tax the ones who are addicted?
...


 Which is more of a tragedy; The death of an adult or the death of a child?
Which is more of a tragedy; The death of an adult(who knew they could possibly die in combat and choose to join the military anyway) or the death of a child(that you were too p#ssy to try to take ...


 IS this an assault?
If you put your hand on somebodies shoulder, just to say "no hard feelings" is this assault
Additional Details
I have been arrested for it ...


 If guns should be outlawed because they cause crime should spoons be outlawed for making people fat?
...


 My brother had abuse me 20 to 30 years thinking of bringing charges against him you think I should?
what I want to know has my limation to bring changes against my brother for domestic violence and abuse. This all happen 20 to 30 years ago he has hurt others, I know it is not my job to clean up the ...


 What does freedom means to you?
...


 Should it be legal to burn the American flag? I don't believe burning a flag is freedom of speech?
just because the Supreme court says it is.The flag represents not only our nation, but our hope, our future, our unity, and our patriotism. If people want to protest something the government is doing ...


 What right does anyone have to criticize a woman for having an abortion?
If it isnt your kid, it isnt your problem. YOU have no right to tell someone what they can do to their body. and until the kid comes out, its still her ...


 Can i date 2 men at the same time because if one hurts you one will be there for you.Because of my past experi
...


 Why are tobacco smokers facing fines when a pot smoker only gets a caution?
...


 5 nurses and a doctor in libya gave 400 children HIV ON PURPOSE. do they deserve the death penalty?
5 bulgarian nurses and a bulgarian doctor have been sentenced to death for purposely infecting over 400 small children with HIV. the EU and the US are both condemning libya for being "too harsh&...


 How to make smoking in public places be allowed??
...


 What happens when a Lawyer dies nearing the end of a criminal case?
Say this Lawyer is against the criminal and he has enough evidence to lock him away, but then he dies, what happens?...


 VERY IMPORTANT assault question, please help?
is screaming in someone's ear intentionally considered assault? like, if someone came up to you and let out a high pitched scream right into your ear for spite....


 The guy who slashed the horse with a meat cleaver?, should people like this go to prison?
Im sure most people from the uk have heard about it, makes me sick! is 5months in a detention centre enough for this sicko?...im sure he will be out before then, should there be longer sentances for ...


 Do I have a case?
I was fired on 4/11 for being absent from work. I had received a written warning, but the policy stated suspension after a written warning. I never was suspended, just fired. I never received my ...


 Is it fair to be acquitted of a criminal charge and then found guilty in a civil court of the same charge?
...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.034