Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

Do you think that those who burn flags are anti-American & unpatriotic?
Find answers to your legal question.





Do you think that those who burn flags are anti-American & unpatriotic?

I mean when they burn the flags they say they are using the freedom of speech, not when they burn it when it is old and tattered.


    




Gaspode
Yes it is unpatriotic.

One of the basics of rule by law, one that seems to be slipping from people's minds is that without the freedom to do things that we disagree with strongly, like flag burning, the rest of us loose freedom too. One of the prices of liberty is putting up with a lot of ashwholes that we don't like. Only idiots want to react by limiting freedom.

Dedication to protecting the Constitution has been very unpopular the last 6 years in particular.

It is not "just a piece of paper".


pompanopete0
Rating
Its more a matter of intent.
Burning it in anger is considered a direct insult to our country and its traditions, tends to achieve the desired affect ,
, anger Americans

Burning it with Honor, usually done by military veterans, is a tradition of respect for those that died defending it.


Forrest C
Rating
People have every right to burn a flag in America. To say otherwise goes against the right of freedom of speech, and means that you hate America.


MeanKitty
Rating
Yes they are. It is abominable that anyone could burn the symbol of what so many people have fought and died for.
You don't deserve the freedom that you have in this country if you don't appreciate where it came from and how we got it.


whitehairblueeyes
Rating
Disposing of unserviceable flags by the proper method is traditional. The people who burn the flag are not doing so to exercise their right to free speech; but in site the people and nation that it represents. There are other ways to exercise your right to free speech that doesn't involve disrespecting the very freedom that people died for to give them the right to do so. The very act of flag burning gives way to anger that overrides anything that needs to be said.


infidel-louie
Rating
Yes to both. They're dissin' those who have servred & sacrificed their lives so these morons can get a photo-op. Thay are without honor.


irishman
The flag is the ultimate symbol of America, and all that it represents. So to burn it is anti- American.


Terry
About 4 flag burnings a year occur at demonstrations. This is an extreme, and to many, a distasteful exhibition of free speech. It is also what makes America the greatest country in the world. The fact that we have laws allowing extreme protests shows just how free and vibrant our democracy is.

Protecting popular free speech is easy; no one's going to want to throw you in jail for saying America is great. But protecting UNPOPULAR free speech; now that is a rarity in the Western world. We are so fortunate to have that protection.


Kenny Ray
Rating
Protesters who burn old glory are anti-American and pathetic traitors. They should not be allowed to enjoy the freedoms they despise.


BJ
The right of dissent is supported by our laws. Burning the flag has been a symbol of dissent and protest since the first flag was made. It will continue to be so. It has nothing to do with patriotism or the lack of it.

And, it is not nearly as bad as what some "patriotic" citizens do with our Standard. Did you know that if you are going to display the Flag outside 24 hours a day that it must be lit up? How's this one - if it isn't lit, it must be removed before sunset and not risen again until dawn. Another - the only time a Flag can be displayed on the outside of an authomobile is on the Presidential Car and the cars of our diplomats overseas....not flying from your radio antenna..... One more? When a Flag becomes tattered and worn, it should be taken down, trifolded and given to a Veterans organization for disposal? Last - of many - when flying a Flag at half-staff, it should first be briskly raised to the top of the flagpole, then slowly brought down to the half-way mark...when lowered, it should again be taken briskly to the top and lowered slowly.

Those who know nothing about Flag protocol shouldn't talk about disrespect of it.


Mercadies2000
Yes it is. I'm sorry but at one time the flag was something we all were proud of, it represented our great country. Have you noticed that they don't do this in other countries?? In a rare protest maybe but not to often. I think this says something about us.


LadyNTex
Rating
The American Flag is a symbol of the freedoms which this country was founded. Many American soldiers have served and given their lives to defend what the American Flag stands for. I don't believe burning our countries flag should be freedom of speech. If you have a grip, do something constructive to solve the problem not throw a tantrum and burn the flag because you are unhappy. Burning the flag is disrespectful to our country. If a person does not like life in America then they should exercise the freedom of moving to a place that operates the way they are trying to force the USA to change to. Burning the flag in anti-war protest only gives those countries who dislike us more prower. If you don't like the way things are going VOTE, run for office turn that flag burning energy into something productive.


volleyballchick
No.

I think that when they do this, they are only symbolizing their dissatisfaction with the country's politics. The flag becomes a symbol of the government at that point, not them renouncing their citizenship. They are using symbolizm to get their point across.

I don't agree with doing such a thing, but in limiting that very act, one would limit freedom of speech and freedom of expression, both of which have to be absolute or they will crumble. So one has to allow the idiots their time in the spotlight, too.


unicornfarie1
Yes I think that they are Unpatriotic and against America.
Freedom of speech has nothing to do with burning a flag. Freedom of speech is something that comes out of your mouth not an act that you do. Speech does mean a voice. Burning a flag is an act.


MaryBeth
Rating
Yes--burning a flag in good condition is uncalled-for.


Abdul Hassan
Yes. But it's their right to be. You don't HAVE to love your country. You can just live in it.


x
Rating
Burning the flag is the same thing as burning America. Anyone burning the flag is a communist anti-American scumbag.


-·~¹'JET FUEL GENIUS
Burning flags is a right and if it is anti american and unpatriotic when its the American flag.. If its the flag of Iran or syria and its an american who is starting it on fire... its very patriotic...





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 They say Speed kills and I say Speed dont Kill it the driver who kills?
...


 Does the goverment have the right to make a law that will definitely kill innocent people?
that would otherwise live if they were not obaying the law?


There will be another part to this question added later
Additional Details
A cop once told me that the ...


 Does this prison sentence seem absurd to you at all?
My dad was sentenced to 30 years in prison for trafficking Cocaine.

In my opinion, that is a ridiculously lengthy sentence
for selling drugs.

I know guys that have ...


 Does it worry you ??
Yet, again another pheadophile have been released because the jails are full. It makes me sick when i read and hear things like this. Wonder how they would feel if one of their children was one of ...


 Is it legal for my employer to fine me money?
...


 How long can the police keep your fingerprints/DNA samples?
Convicted of assault and got 12 months....


 Do you know any of the Ten Commandments?
Have you kept them?
Additional Details
Have you kept them. Try this great test at http://www.livingwaters. to find the answers....


 If you're an adult when you turn 18 why can't you drink alcohol until you're 21?
...


 Time to bring back capital punishment?
when (and notice i did not say IF) the McCanns are foudn guilty of the murder of their daughter do some ppl wish it had happened in a country where they would have been killed for carrying out such a ...


 Legally can a man be sued for dating a married woman?
They have ben seperated for four weeks and starting a divorce.Nothing happened till after she left.Can I be sued for this ....


 Do you think us(Americans) take A LOT of what we have for granted??
...


 Which is worse for you alcohol or marijuana?
why is marijuana illegal and alcohol legal? should alcohol be illegal or marijuana be legal? why?...


 How fair is it when a man can work all his life then some woman marries him and gets half?
Like I say, you work to produce world famous music, you donate millions to charity, you live a good and wholesome life, then some woman comes along, gets you hooked, marries you, divorces you two ...


 Why is it illegal in New Jersey to...?
pump your own gas?...


 Do you approve or disapprove of the Patriot Act?

Additional Details
Thanks for the first star J...


 Why are peodphiles allowed to walk free?
there is definately something wrong with the government, why cant they be given an injection like a sick dog and be put down?!?...


 Teacher abuse...?
My bad for the last question. I guess it didn't go through. anyways. A friend of mine's son was hit (backhanded) by a teacher last week. What can be done about that and whats the max that ...


 A beagle keeps offering me cheap cigarettes, should I buy off him?
...


 If an abortion is killing a baby and doctors take the hypocratic oath how can doctors perform an abortion?
The hypocratic oath is an oath that doctor's take never to kill a human no matter how much they or there family might beg....


 Law can i kick my child out of home who is 16yrs old and also has ADHD a mental health problem?
he is rude aggresive vile and is spliting my family up what is the law on my ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.024