Hasn't Maxine Carr suffered enough?

kinning_park

She should. She had nothing to do with the killings, and however stupid she was to have agreed to his demands for an alibi, she confessed in the end.

There are some people who truly do relish the idea of killing other people, often in horrific ways, as a quick scroll through the replies to this question will show.

The ONLY difference between them and Ian Huntley is in the choice of victims. By focussing their killing fantasies on the likes of Maxine Carr, they can revel in violence fantasies without being troubled by the moral repugnance of their own consciences.

EDIT

"UK prisons are not exactly places of suffering you know?"

- - - - - - - - - -

Are you writing from personal experience?

ChocLover

Shame that Holly and Jessica can't do that though

richard_beckham2001

No she should rot in hell along with Ian Huntley. They are both as guilty as each other.

Gradis

She was never involved in the crime as at the time she was clubbing with her bit on the side.
Her mistake was lying to the police trying to cover for for her then boyfriend even though she was taking his word and lying for him.

It didn't work well though as police had him in a matter of days.

As for her right to rebuild her life? I don't feel any sympathy for her what so ever. Her best bet it move abroad if she wants any life as the Brit public will despise her.

BoyRacer

I think not, ask Holly and Jessica's parents what they think....

referee

She should get her just deserts.

Bex

Not not really I don't think she can, nor should she, expect to live in peace while she stays in this country and people know who she is.

And I don't think she should be aloowed to change her identity. She made her choice, a stupid one, but her choice, now she has to deal with it.

That is my opinion anyway

Beastie

Any possibility you just asked this question to get a reaction?

Well done... you are now officially a complete tosspot.

Incidentally, she got a new identity because so many people made death threats against her she'd probably be dead by now if she hadn't.

And in this country you don't get a long term in jail for lying in court which, when you actually get some perspective on it, was all she did.

Tizzie

Not a hope.

ÛžÛžÛžÛžÛžÛžÛžÛž

w t f are you for real people like that should be shot between the eye's they should bring back hanging.

chomby

No, she will never suffer enough. Holly and Jessica lost their lives and their parents have had to bury a child each,no parent should go through that. She should still be in prison as she was covering up Huntleys crime so she is just as guilty,she got off lightly.

Part Time Cynic

UK prisons are not exactly places of suffering you know?

purplemoon0101

No she hasn't, and I agree with the person that said Holly and Jessica will never be able to.

Also why should she be given a new identity in order that she can get on with her life.

I say bring back hanging. She should never have been allowed out of prison.She's just as bad as Huntley.

Joe Bloggs

The photo of those 2 girls... taken like an hour before they met the hands of Huntley........ really really makes me sad.

http://img.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2007/03_02/hollywellsDM2803_468x322.jpg

Everything to look forward to....... only to trust Huntley and tricked in to his house. Carr should feel absolute guilt for her part in it...... she should have been forced to move from the UK to another country.

coffee

What about the parents and extended families and friendsof Holly and Jessica?? They still suffer a loss which cannot be made up. Why should someone who has been complicit in murder be allowed to rebuild their life when they have shattered the lives of so many around them?

Richard B

That depends on whether you see the penal system as a tool of justice or a means of revenge. I think that in this country the system is geared more toward revenge.

Emma B

How do you know she hasn't been able to rebuild her life?
Do you know where she is?
She could well be living it up abroad and having a great time.

The One

Not for what she did

dickiep8607

no, she hasnt, she's evil!

kit

There is no prison sentence long enough for what they did

I'm On a Boat Mudafucka....

she didnt give holly and jessica that option...she should suffer in prison for the rest of her life.....an eye for an eye, a life for a life

Morrissey

Was she a Borstal Girl?

roger.williams20@btinternet.com

If she was guilty of assisting her partner then she deserves further suffering.

oohermissus

No. Let her rot in prison

NO!.

Holly and Jessica have no such option.....why should she?.

But to give her a chane ....throw her off the White Cliffs od Dover...if she can fly let her go...

if she goes thud/splatt...tough.

Northernscum

Quite possibly, after all she has got ginger hair.

Enter Your Message or Comment

User Name:
User Email:
Post a comment: