Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

How do you feel about your DNA added to the goverment database?
Find answers to your legal question.





How do you feel about your DNA added to the goverment database?

Regardless if you have a criminal record, or not.
Additional Details
For all those who say that they have nothing to hide..

Would you also feel happy with a goverment camera in your front room or a microchip in your arm?


    




FAI
Rating
I am not in favour of my DNA being added to the goverment data base. Some things needs to remain private especially if there is no reason for the goverment to have this information. The big brother thingy is taken a bit too far nowadays. Our freedom is limited by these intiatives. There will always be a level of risk for any person and we have to be allowed to take these risks. Giving in to these intiatives makes our world smaller every day. I can understand that this may be needed once you've done something that requires this (criminal etc) there are no need for the goverment to know more than what they already know...it is indeed a need to know situation I think..and in my case they do not need to know.


joe b
They wont get mine its just big brother yet again and the great british public say YES you can have mine .you gotta think about it before you let them have it dna is not 100 per cent true and how long before the database gets hacked??


Alowishus B
I'm honestly more afraid of the government than I am terrorism.


constapato #2
Looks like an eventual case of us against them, them against us. I say we act now before they get any stronger.


smedrik
Invasion of my privacy.

The government has no right to any of my information outside of what is necessary to tax me. I am a law abiding citizen and have done nothing to forfeit my right to privacy.


Stevie
Rating
They already have my DNA but i don't worry,they have probably lost the record of it anyway like they lose everything else personal


book worm
I used to be in agreement with DNA being taken at birth - along with all of the other bloods - thinking that it would be a great idea that everyone's DNA would be on record in case of future crimes. I also thought that cameras on all street corners were a good idea to help prevent criminal activity and that Identity Cards were a great concept too. And then I realised that innocent people were increasingly being treated more like criminals and having their rights ignored and taken away. Children in many UK schools now have to thumb-scan for registration and meals. There are discussions regarding the use of 'lie detectors' on people who claim benefits and few of our security cameras appear to capture sufficient footage to convict offenders and yet we continue to lie back and accept more and more restrictions. What became of being 'innocent until proven guilty' I wonder? And more importantly, where will it all end?


notgnal
Rating
Everyone should be DNA registered at birth.....wouldnt it make crime easier to solve..?..only the criminals would have anything to fear...
and anyone who bleats right to privacy is a selfish p...lock..!


agreeable
Totally against.


Gor H
little bastureds are takin everfin, first our money now our dna


greybeard
I hate the idea, I also hate all of the surveillance that we are under these days.
It`s no more than an annoyance at present. BUT if in the future we get a totallitarian goverment- not beyond the realms of possibilty. Think of Germany in the 30s- everything is in place for them to control the population.
Don`t mock it. It could happen sooner than you think.


ukmolly
It bothers me a bit; a step towards a Big Brother state? It's a very hard question


wolfatthedoor
Rating
I don't think its about whether I have anything to hide or not. I believe this is more a matter of infringing on my fourth amendment. I do not like people pissing on my rights.

*note* if everyone above me really has no problem with it, then the Bill of Rights means nothing to them I guess. Perhaps we should scratch The 4th, or maybe we should just throw the whole thing out.


tnfarmgirl
Dude, if they can mange to get everyone they arrest into the system then I might start to worry about them getting my DNA.
Here in TN, they introduced legislation stating that DNA samples are to be taken at every arrest and entered into a database- well all of law enforcement is not collecting those samples because the law is so vague no one can figure out who is really responsible- the arresting officer (whether it be city or county) , the booking officer or the jailer.
Then the TBI who would handle all the samples that have been collected is so far behind it'll take 6 months or more for the samples they have to be processed and maybe more than a year for them to be cataloged.

I don't think it bothers me to have my DNA added to the database that information could be used to identify my dead body one day..


ADD: Only if the microchip emitted slimming vibes would I even consider it.


Barbie V
If it will help to catch more criminals more easily I do not have a problem with it


robert c
I personally have no objection whatsoever!!


frenchy
To the 1st part of your question, I beleive we should ALL have our DNA in the government database. That would help to solve crime more easily, prove it easily in court and prevent crime too as criminal would think twice before killing/raping/stealing...

But within our home, we shouldn't have camera. That's our private life.

Ever see movie "minority report"? That is extreme on detecting crime before it happen, but the fact to be all tagged at some point is really reassuring.

Somehow, we are "spied on", if government wants, as with technology, anyone can be traced but detecting mobile phone signals, even if switch off. Each time anyone use credit/debit card, it's recorded time and place, registration of the car on cctv...

Only criminal refuse safety measures


Peardrop Explodes
Rating
I'm ok with that, I think its a good idea. That's how the Suffolk murderer got caught....his DNA was on the database for nicking money. I would not feel happy about a government camera in my home nor a chip on my arm but hey... if I was a criminal then I wouldn't have too much to say on the matter.


unrepentant poster
sounds good to me.


golden
Rating
They have mine already and i am not worried


?
To be honest I don't really have a problem. I'm sure it will only worry people that have something to hide. It's the same with Id cards, but people don't realise they appear on cctv over 300 times a day anyway.


fourofsix2003
I have nothing to hide,so I dont really care.

awwwwww,i feel so special i could just throw up!!!! I see that the tin foil hat wearin government conspiracy freaks are hiiting this page and giving all who answered"it doesnt matter to me etc" a thumbs down!! you freaks need to adjust your reynolds aluminum hats and stay away from microwaves and high voltage power lines,and the headaches and voices will cease,i promise !!
HAHA smedrik,the jokes on you,TAxing you is the illegal part,wingnut,the DNA is a vouluntary act,god forbid there is another 911 and theres 3000 + bodies or body parts to identify,give that some thought before you go off on the government and your rights,Id sure as hell want my family to know if i were among a mass of dead or not,asap,woudnt you?or to be excluded from a crime,without reproach??HMMMMM???but i forgot,its all about your "rights",god forbid the government or anyone else for that matter try to protect your life and well being,that would be unheard of!!


wizjp
got no problem with it.


Santa claus
Rating
they already have it so wot what have u got to hide


Shaggy
Not a problem

BELOW...wolfatthedoor...get off here YANK ..the 4th????


Dr Sardonicus
Rating
they have it anyway....but I am not a criminal,nor do I plan on being one..so...have at it guys





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Is this illegal or legal????
if you could have a liscense plate that had swear words on it.
i was just curious if it was or not....


 What is more important to you as an American? Security, Freedom, Social Welfare.?
...


 Is this rape?
me and my friend went out to this guys house party. She got completely wasted, i was pretty drunk but not so bad as her.
Anyway, this guys older brother started hitting on her and trying to snog ...


 Why do drive on the left In Great Brittan?
...


 How are you on Abortion? For it or against?
I am totally against it! You can't kill a baby because he or she will be inconvient for you! Also you can't do things without having consiquences! If you have a debate that you think can ...


 If you got caught with drugs at school as a child does it go on your record?

Additional Details
i had tobacco and pot and gave it to my friend at age 10. got suspended for a day and had to go to court. yea...stupid me. they only knew about the tobacco though....


 3 years in jail for hurling a shoe at George Bush?
Isn't that a bit harsh?...


 Is it illegal for a man to try on lingerie at a store?
So the other day I was minding my own business trying on some lingerie at Victoria's Secret (I love the lace!) and then they had security kick me out of the store, apparently they didn't ...


 Who actually thinks marijuana is bad?
-smoking a lot of weed doesn't make you lazy, lazy people smoke a lot of weed. I have a 4.0 and a 2030 (1360) sat, and will go to college next year. That is a lot better than plenty of people ...


 Why is weed illegal?...?
is our gov't so ****'d up that they will make things like moonshine and weed illegal only because its untaxable? i know its not due to the "toxins" in it.. look at legal beer.. ...


 What is the legal age a child can leave home without their parents permission?
...


 A different moral problem?
I am doing an ethics essay and need a moral problem to discuss but would like something different, ie not the usual euthanasia, abortion, death penalty or war stuff. Any different ideas? Bearing in ...


 Does anyone else think law is to soft on criminals and police should be harder on criminals?
...


 Can I legally smash the window of this car and then roll it out the way?
I pay for a secure underground parking in the City.... with my own space in an underground car park. It's £165 pm which is a lot of money.. but only about £25 pm more than the public car parks, ...


 Can you move out at sixteen?
I am 15 right now, but I will be sixteen within a few months. I was planning on graduating early, but I need to get out sooner. I am looking to move to California. I have looked into emancipation ...


 What do you call a gov. that lies, cheats, steals from and murders their own citizens?
...


 Isn't Against the Law?
I just heard this story about this boy finding out someone made a fake Myspace page of him, saying that he had attempted to rape several girls and was a pothead. He went to the police, and the ...


 Military Boyfriend Coming Back Home. Something A little fishy?
My boyfriend was supposed 2 be coming back tonight from a 3month stay out of state. But then out the blue his family suprised him and he is spending any extra day. I don't know much about the ...


 Statistically what are the chances of me being caught if I don't pay the TV licence ?
...


 How can i continue to live if i want to die?
It is better to die and rest than to living. so why would i live and destroy....




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.044