Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

I called the police when I found a dog locked in a car on a hot Texas day.The owner was angry.Was I wrong?
Find answers to your legal question.





I called the police when I found a dog locked in a car on a hot Texas day.The owner was angry.Was I wrong?

I own a small grooming shop in a shopping strip.The car was outside my shop is why I noticed it in the first place.I see them pull up with the dog and leave the dog inside I thought they were just running in and out of one of the other offices.20 minutes later the car and dog are still there.the dog is sticking its nose out the cracked window as best it could.My shop is sorounded by Doctors offices and could not find the owner.Why would someone bring a with them while they see a Doctor is beyond me.The dog was in the locked car for at least 20 minutes before I called the police.
The owner was gone almost an hour for their appointment.I don't think the dog would have lived.The owner was fureous and thinks I should mind my own buisness.
Was it wrong of me ?


    




xenypoo
Rating
You were not wrong, and the "owner" is a Moron.
I wish more people had the gumption you showed to help the weak when they can't themselves, whether it is an animal, or a child.

There are some REAL Idiots who leave babies in hot cars, as well, and the consequences have been hypothermia and death.

I am proud to call you an American, and Bless you!


I'm Old Gregg.
No this was the right thing to do. The dog could have died.
You did the right thing.


Sadie C
Rating
yes ive seen that too many times. You did the right thing. You should be very proud of yourself for being such a good citizen. That is very much animal abuse and people need to stop that even if its unintentioal. When I left my dog in a car, I at least roll the window down half way if the dog is big enough where he can't get out.


Will the typical white guy II
Rating
good thing it was you that found the dog instead of me. I would have busted the window out. I'm also a big time animal lover. I'd sooner run over BO than an anilmal


northernhick
Of course not.

Of course the owner's going to be angry with you, too - it's perfectly normal to dislike the idea of being reported to the police - but it sounds like he was in the wrong, and the dog needed the assistance.

Even if you were wrong that the dog needed help, you made the right call nonetheless. If you'd just gone ahead and broken the window yourself, or something like that, I might have some reservations about that sort of behaviour. But calling the police and letting them decide what further actions are appropriate...well, it's very rarely the wrong decision.


Windy
You did a great job. The dog is alive because of you. Just think if it was a child instead. People should just leave their animals at home when they go out, especially when they have appointments. The guy is mad because he got caught. I hope the cops gave him a ticket for being stupid. PETA will love you. Good Job!


yeloowbus657
Rating
NOOOOOOOOOOOOO ! i would have done the same thing good for you !


Fonz
Rating
You did the right thing.. Some people should not have pets..


The Wise One
Nope - great move! I commend you my friend


Bee Bee
For the little doggie, let me say thank you. That is so sad. as the little fellow could not even ask for help. People need to stop and think real hard , if they love their pet.


Chief Scout
You saved the dogs life. the person should have been charged with felony animal abuse. thank you for thinking
of the little dog.


Sound Labs
you did the right thing. The owner should have been charged for it, period.


TexasCop
You were exactly right. If it had been my call, I would have taken steps to file a cruelty case against the owner and have the dog impounded.

That's nearly as bad as leaving a child in a car.


bullwinkle
Rating
No. You were right. Rest easy. You did "The Right Thing."


Roz
Rating
Hope you were in Houston, we might get to see that on Animal Planet. You did exactly what you should have done, if the owner gives you any more BS contact your ASPCA, I'm surprised they didn't respond and pick the dog up. Animal Cruelty is against the law in Texas, punishable by a fine and often jail time. They may still be investigating it or may have filed charges and you don't know it.


Nell of the Jungle
No, it was not wrong of you to do that. First you are in the business of grooming dogs, and seeing the dog, in a hot car, and left unattended, it was certainly okay for you to do that.
I have seen two adult dogs left in a hot car. One dog died and the other one went mad because of dehydration and was biting the owner and police officers. And was shot at the scene. It was tragic and everyone was upset about it and the owner felt really bad, but it was too late, no one bothered to report it.
I'm proud of you, you did the right thing, and the dogs are very thankful.


POLARIS
Rating
You did the right thing. I hope that nitwit is fined for animal cruelty.


canam
Rating
You were absolutely right. Maybe the dog owner will think before doing that again. Any moron knows it is unsafe to leave a dog in a hot car.


blackmule
No. You did the right thing.


u_bin_called
Rating
you did the right thing....

of course the owner was angry....he/she is obviously self-centered and only cares about himself/herself...

I hope the owner was cited so that if it happens again the dog can be taken away and given to a caring owner...


guanete42
No dogs should be treated with respect, they love us, we need to show respect, and love them back, Would the owner have left a family member in the car!!! 10 lashes with a wet noodle, for being just plain stupid!!!!!!!!!!


jelle
Rating
I would have done the same thing. Poor dog! It was the right thing to do.


mufasa1023
Rating
you were right....maybe just maybe this will serve notice on this person that other people don't agree with their style of taking care of animals

doubt it though, sorry some people are just born, live and die @$$holes


bennyrude
Rating
Not at all. You probably saved the poor animals life. I have a friend who once broke the window out of a car with his skateboard when he noticed a dog in distress.


sirbobby98121
Rating
Would you feel badly if it were a child in a carseat?


j10jan
You didn't say how far the window was cracked open, or how hot it really was, but even if it was only in the 80's, being in a closed vehicle would increase the temperature measurably. I'm supposing the temperature was higher than that on a normal Texas day. Why people drive around with their pets with them is also beyond me. The only reason I can see to transport an animal is to the vet or to visit someone or such. Not just to go shopping or riding around. No animal should be left unattended in a car. In my opinion, that borders on animal cruelty. You did the right thing.


dnvbroncos307
Rating
No it was not wrong for you to call the police you were looking out for the dog and its health. I think the owner was mad because he had the police called on them about leaving it in there. IT WOULD BE BETTER FOR YOU TO CALL THE POLICE AND SAVE THE DOG AND HAVE THE OWNER BE MAD THEN TO NOT CALL THE POLICE AND HAVE THE DOG END UP DIEING. Therefore you did the right thing.


porquemoi
You did the right thing. I don't know what teh law says, but I would feel justified in throwing a brick through one of the car windows to save the dog.


Barry C
Rating
No you were right.

TX is waaay behind the times if this is not a crime. It is in "civilized" states, and the dog would be taken away immediately.

Sadly dogs, and children, die every year this way.

If the outside temp goes up much over 70, we all know how hot it gets inside, and cracking a window helps not at all.

Anyone disagrees with me, next time it is 85 or more where you live, go park in the sun, crack the windows and sit in your car for an hour or more and see how it feels.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Who thinks euthanasia is acceptable in this case?
There is a 102 year old man who is blind, deaf, paralysed from the neck down and is doubly incontinent.
Hes also perfectly mentally capable and knows whats going on
Who thinks it is right?...


 Do people only become doctors to get paid huge salaries?
I am increasingly beginning to believe this.
My brother went to the hospital a few weeks back with a back complaint. the doctor asked him what he did for a living and he said he drove cars for a ...


 What's the bet way to punish Osama Bin Laden ?
and his followers. Is it fair to punish him by killing all of his children ? Without any offspring. He's a dead end. In terms of the future genetic make up of humanity. This is somehting ...


 Is dress code a violation of students rights?
...


 Will i go to jail for driving with no license and no insurance no vaid tag?
im not a drunk driver i cant drive for medical reasons i have not had a ticket in fifeteen years but had to drive to hospital when child was hurt playing ball school called said child was injured and ...


 Should Marijuana be illegal?

Additional Details
to doingthedishes...

That is NOT the reason it is illegal.. if that were true you'd know it. The simple fact is that most americans are uneducated ...


 Why don't we have real freedom in the USA?
The USA isn't that great of a place to live. Look at this. 46 million without health care. 22,678 shot to dead in crime. Many jobs only pay 9 dollars per hour. If one gets arrested and you are ...


 Should i cooperate with police or get Lawyer ??
-------i dont need any smart answers please
-- I reside in california
1. arrested for sales of pills..( 20 of them)
2. unprecidented act- it was first time selling...
3.no prior ...


 What is the horrific act of terrorism ever performed on American soil?
...


 If a person hits another person without any reason, can that person be sue?
...


 Do all pro-abortion arguments ignore the fact that the woman has a child inside of her?
"It is her body, she can do what she wants with it". I can agree with that, it sounds like an argument for suicide.

But would it make sense for me to say "it's my body,...


 Do you think marijuana should be legal?
Why is it that only the government can make and sell drugs?? And drugs that have way worse side effects than weed! Prescription drugs that cause blood clots, heart attack, liver damage, stroke. A...


 What are your views on animal rights?
For school we have to write somthing for animal rights. Most of my class is for animal testing but im for animal rights. I understand alot of their point of views i just dont know what to write for ...


 Injured on my landlords property and they wont return my calls, landlord told me to f off, what should i do?
...


 Do vending machines check ID in the UK?
Okay, so i'm sixteen and i smoke (Oh my. I KNOW its bad for me, i don't care, so don't bother warning me against it). I was all happy last year because i was going to be of age to ...


 Should guns be banned from civilian use?!?
Do you think that there should be a law stating that civilians should not be able to own guns?...


 I need a defence for county court for bank charge reclaim?
I have been trying for a long time now like many others to reclaim bank charges and did it online. Now it has been transfered to WALSALL COUNTY COURT on the 10th JULY @ 10am and due to me having a ...


 Have you ever talked your way out of a ticket?
How did you do so? Details please, I need something that I can use if I get pulled over today!
Additional Details
rachellynn200...because I drive fast, I dont obey laws and get pulled ...


 If gay marraige becomes legal should they make polygamy legal?
it seems like the reason these things are illegal are because theyre immoral so if 1 becomes legal the other should too,,even marrying animals or underage
Additional Details
ok well the ...


 Do you think smoking pot makes you a bad person?
Now, I am not talking about the effects of pot. I mean, would you think of a person you once respected as a bad person after you found out they smoke pot? I think people judge people who smoke way to ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.074