Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

I don't understand...murder & abortion?
Find answers to your legal question.





I don't understand...murder & abortion?

OK IF MURDER is the killing of another human being under conditions specifically covered in law THEN WHAT'S ABORTION?
Is it the same or something and if so why isn't abortion illegal as well?


    




JIm F
abortion is terminating an unwanted or harmful pregnancy, murder is taking someones life


Jasmine
because what if you got raped and cant afford to take care of a childd. plus its not like you just take the baby out when its 7 months its only up to 3 months you can get it so its not a full baby yet. theres an abundance of kids without homes as it is. im not saying get an abortion whenever im just saying if you have to then you have to


CHAR L
Rating
Abortion is not illegal because we gave women the right to choose,
I have see women choose to use abortion as a form of birth control because we gave them the right to choose.. I have seen 20 year olds on their 7th abortion because she did not want to take the Pill, Patch or IUD.

I am in the Medical Field and I am against abortion


Just ME
Rating
THEY, meaning the lawmakers, claim the baby hasn't been born yet so it isn't human. However I know that baby is human and alive and would never do that. Until the law changes that is what happens..


laughter_every_day
Rating
Because the Supreme Court has recognized the distinction between a person and potential person. Many of the anti-abortion crowd base their position on what they consider the undeniable fact that a two-cell zygote is indeed a person. What they fail to recognize is that the definition of a person is a question of law, not of opinion. Right now, the law recognizes the distinction and so the Supreme Court has ruled that the states cannot completely outlaw abortion. Only when the fetus becomes viable can the state's act.


Beetroot Yourself
The debate you're attempting to refer to is; at which point does a human foetus become a "person"?, some say not until birth, some say from the point of conception. It's up to you to draw your own conclusions.

I am pro-choice myself although the time scale should be shortened.


Dear prudence,
Sadly, abortion isn't illegal (in most areas.) Abortion is MURDERING a baby that you are shamefully not wanting or can't even take the time to try and handle yourself. I think abortion isn't the answer, nor adoption but i think it is much better then killing an innocent life.


chkwoo
Rating
Sorry, but this is a very big question to be asking on this website. Also, it is a boring debate, one that has been going on for ages with no closure on the issue. Your question captures the exact debate that has been going on for decades and the answer is largely down to the opinion of the various 'camps'.


NARC
Rating
Well ultimately it comes down to whether or not you consider an aborted fetus something you can kill or not. Is it property or a person? Is it in the category of a tumor to have removed because it affects your life negatively or is it once created a being a living organism that has an inherit life and rights to exist.


St.Toad
This is not a popular opinion, by any means, but I accept that abortion is murder. I won't try to justify it any other way. I also think it's a violation of human rights to make abortion illegal. Telling anyone how to handle their own biological functions is the most oppressive thing I can imagine. I hope you don't think this means I don't value human life. Making abortions illegal would only create worse horrors. I hope you don't think anyone deserves horrors in their lives.


Jeff Hardy x raw
Rating
wat dont you understand about it


gunplumber_462
Rating
You're right, you don't understand. A fetus isn't considered a person under the law. It isn't murder, it's a medical procedure.


nelie g
thats the million dollar question...but we live in a society with out morals and standards.


Frxshkidd
many ppl think abortion is something bad but actually its is something beneficial for the kid and the mother.when the parents of the unborn child suffer for the birth of the child and they have it the child will be unwanted and suffer emotional stress later in life when the parents of the child dont have resources to take care of it they rather abort insted of letting the baby suffer from mistreatment.when the baby is autistic the parents might nt want for them to have 2 suffer to watch their child suffer


neonlights1971
Well neither one is legal sorry to say...
Murder is but its not the same as abortion I don't think, I'd say murder is being at the wrong place at the wrong time.. And abortion, people know willingly that they are going to get an abortion... so I'd say honestly arg.. That would be the difference.. I guess???


It's a boy! 9/9/09
abortion is not murder b/c of certain beliefs. some people believe that a fetus is not human until it passes from the birth canal. others believe that a fetus is human while in the womb. it can not be outlawed based on religious beliefs.


Sarah M
it only murder when the fetus has left the womb in which case it becomes a baby who has rights


Mark D
I take it that you have never heard of the Supreme Court's decision in Roe v. Wade.

It'd be nice if all laws were perfectly logical and perfectly symmetrical. But laws aren't always as perfect as you think they should be.

If the government had always viewed life as beginning at the moment of conception, then the government would have always been in a real pickle with the situation of putting pregnant women in jail, because the fetuses within could have validly "complained" (via an attorney) that their right to due process was violated given that the fetus did not commit a crime. Think about that.


baby
Rating
it is stupid asking a question like that on Yahoo answers
its an ethical debate so everyone is going to have a conflicting point of view, you have to think about these things and make your own mind up, you cant let anyone else tell you whats right or wrong


Cookie is a Wabbit
Abortion is killing a fetus, NOT a baby. It is NOT murder.
Is killing an egg the same thing as killing a living chick?
NO


railroad dave
capitol punishment = post natal abortion . bush signed over two hundred death warrants .


ClemsonFan
Rating
Abortion is what democrates use to try and get dirt on republicans. But to be serious I mean you really shouldnt have to use abortion unless you were raped because a bunch of irresposible kids have to learn lessons.


Your Silly Prince
Rating
Well, what about your period, your letting that egg in you die, that was a human being. You should go get pregnant so that it doesn't die you killer.

Also, if you have a miscarriage then you should be charged with murder.


♥Shake it like a pom-pom♥
Rating
Abortion isn't murder. Its just a cell. u can make another one.


Eric H
Rating
Murder is the killing of another PERSON.

A fetus doesn't have status as a person until it survives a "live birth"


Red
Rating
Abortion is the removal of a virus on a womans body, this virus lives off it's host, slowing down and weaking the host body, feeding off it for months.

Murder doesn't cover a virus.

Now give me thumbs down, mwahahahaha, I crave it!


Sass
omg aboprtian isnt murder, ITS JUST A CELL not even life. dont judge if youve never been in their shoes.


Myleen P
Rating
Abortion and murder isn't the same thing because you are only allowed to abort a baby when it is under 5 months, and that's when it's still a foetus. Abortion over 5 months is illegal, due to the fact it has grown into a baby!


eelaiina
i think the abortion should be illegal unless the girl was raped.


poppy
a fetus is only considered a human being after its born.


sliceoffriedgold
Well, murder is only supposed to be used if it is your life or theres, abortion is not defending your self at all.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Since abortion is legal...?
Shouldn't we legalize such crimes as rape and murder? After all people commit them anyway, and isn't that one of the left's most popular reasons for abortion?

People claim ...


 Should tobacco products be banned?
do you think tobacco products should be banned?
if yes why? if no why?...


 Should Marijuana be legalized in the United States?
YES or NO answers ...


 If a man kills, cooks and possibly eats his girlfriend should he receive the death penalty or the mental ward?
TYLER, Texas (AP) -- A man killed his girlfriend, then filleted and cooked parts of her body before calling police to tell them what he was doing, authorities said Sunday.

Christopher Lee M...


 If i buy my 16 year old gf a cell phone can they get me for child enticement?
hello im 19 and i bought my 16 y/o girlfriend a cell phone. well her parents got mad at that and reported it. can they get me for child enticement (in texas) since i bought it and there are text ...


 Do you believe the death penalty should be brought back to Britain?
If so why and fo which sort of crimes? Murder only or do other crimes deserve death?

If not, why not?...


 In your opinion, public officials taking oath on the quran, should we allow it?
I say..heck no!

I wouldnt touch the thing except to hold a match to it....


 If you are arrested do you get a criminal record?
...


 Y exctly iz it ilgl to txt while drivng?

Additional Details
But Drowning, u did answr my ...


 Black people, get over it?
Slavery was abolished more than 50 years ago, get over it, you want reparations, how about the mass amount of money you've taken using fraud from welfare?...


 Are you happy that the UK lets people from barbaric cultures into this country?
If you read about Sharia law, Islamic law etc, and you are what is considered in this part of the world (UK) civilised, you will be shocked and sickened by the barbarism, i.e. 16 year old girl ...


 Help! This woman I was seeing found out I have a GF and some how found out where we live and?
the woman sent my GF a long letter telling her about us. I dont know how she found me. I'm not even sure of her last name. What can I do? Call the police? Get a restraining order? Just tell her ...


 What do you think about the death penalty?
I'm writing a speech on why we should abolish it, and I was wondering what you think and why.
Keep it clean.
Thanks in advance!
--Cam
Additional Details
Layla--No. S...


 Should Terrorists be given the death sentance if found guilty?
...


 If asked to - would you take up arms to defend your country?
Or are you one of those who would ask the person charging towards you with a gun if they would like a cup of tea and an open debate?...


 Neighbor keeps opening gates to my driveway saying it's her land and we cannot close the gates?
My neighbor who is mentally ill is claiming that our driveway is part of her property. We have been closing our gates for the last couple of weeks to keep her vicious dog out so that our ...


 Should the government get rid of the penny?
...


 How would you deal with it?
You buy rental property over the internet and haven't seen it. The location is 2000 mile from you. You later discover that it was a bad deal. You receive letters from that town's ...


 Whats your thoughts on the new smoking ban?
...


 Isn't abortion worse than the hallocaust?
i wonder if you counted how many people died in the hallocaust, and how many die in abortions, wouldn't abortions out number the hallocaust?...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.084