Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

I just went to donate blood today, but because i'm gay, i wasnt allowed to. IS THAT LEGAL!!?!?!?!?!?!?!?
Find answers to your legal question.





I just went to donate blood today, but because i'm gay, i wasnt allowed to. IS THAT LEGAL!!?!?!?!?!?!?!?



    




firefly
I've never heard of that. Surely it cant be legal.


Paul W
Rating
i can tell you that it's not just being gay that would stop them from taking your blood, the place i go to is very tight on rules, if you have a visable scab or a cut they will not take your blood. they will not take your blood if you have been out side the USA in the last year and they will not take your blood if you have been in jail ever. the list goes on...
being gay is just one on many things on the list, for the record yes it is legal to refuse a DONATION from anyone for any reason, if i gave blood and had a problem with my blood they would refuse to disclose my name to the reciving party and would have to take on the liability if any themselves.


cornfunkel
Rating
Why wouldn't it be legal? They're just trying to keep AIDS infested blood out of the blood supply. They screen all of it, but the less they have to dispose of, the easier their job is. Percentage-wise, way more gay people have AIDS than straight people. Plus, packing the poop chute is a good way to spread other blood borne diseases, too.


dumplingmuffin
Rating
yes it is perfectly legal why shouldnt it be?You are a verisk Hiv and Aids carrier,why would anyone want your infected blood


silverblack12345
Rating
wow, really? That is discrimination at it's worst I would think. I know HIV is very prominent in that gay community, but you still can't stereotype all gays like that, im shocked and im against that lifestyle!


fredthedog52
Yes it's legal. we are trying to stop the spread of AIDS. You may not have it personally but it is very prevalent in gays.


zen
Rating
It is not simply because you are gay, and yes, it is legal. The American Red Cross has a whole list of screening questions.

I am a blood donor, and ANYONE, including gay people, who engages in certain high risk behaviors is ineligible to donate.

It is to protect the blood supply.

They have a whole list of health, behavior, and travel questions. They are trying to err on the side of caution, I think.


mo-z
no way can that be legal, thats insane!!! Do you live in kentucky or something?


prkswllflwr
Unfortunately, yes.

I'm gay also, but female. This past year, a bunch of my gay guy friends at my University protested the law, but unfortunately, it's national.

The reason for this is simply that the law was made back in the 80s, when AIDS was FIRST becoming an epidemic in this country, and it was known as the gay cancer *at the time*.

Something that people should know is that today, African-American women have the highest statistics of being HIV+. Not gay men.

The law should obviously be changed. I don't see the Red Cross banning black people's blood...


druid
Rating
If that were true, it would not be (directly) because you were gay, but because of your STD risk factors (which are, unfortunately, much higher among gays).


papa bear
they should both be illegal,,,,donating blood and being gay !!!!!!!!!


Daisy
Rating
I certainly hope so! Gays are far more likely to have HIV or AIDS than nongays!


Loli*Q
i guess that is discrimination but maybe you should as a legal advisor i dont know the law at your place.


just julie
Rating
I have no idea. You need to contact the Better Business Bureau and give them the name and address of the blood bank to find out. They will know. You could possibly have a discrimination law suit in result of this. Again, I do not know, so just check with them and find out. Good luck and at least you tried.

I just read other peoples answers a minute after posting mine.

MO-Z**********!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!...
I do not appreciate the
INSULT AGAINST PEOPLE IN KENTUCKY
THAT IS SO INAPPROPRIATE. THERE ARE MENTALLY CHALLENGED PEOPLE EVERYWHERE AND MAYBE YOU FIT IN THAT CATEGORY.
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!...


Melissa B
Rating
Nope it isn't....they can only denied u if u teste postitive for any ill borne blood patogens, hepitits, HIV, anemia etc etc., recent tattoos and piercings...recent surgeries, illness like a cold or flu...but not for being gay...so if u mention u had any of those during ur screening then that's the reason u were denied.


Karmically Screwed
Rating
If you haven't been tested- it is legal for them to turn you down. A guy (who's not gay fyi) friend of mine was turned down because he hadn't been tested.
If they we're just like- 'get out you queer' for no reason, then let me know and I'll go in there and slap them right across the face for you hun.


Celestial Dragon
I have donated blood for close to 25 years and I cant ever remember being asked if I was gay. This sounds like a personal problem to me


BBQribs
Gay blood has too much testosterone in it.


lovelyladypoet
Wow, that really doesn't make sense. I believe it is illegal and if it isn't it should be!


Clarence Q
First, I want to say that I resent the comment by Mo-z. I am from Kentucky and very well educated.

As for the question, I am sure that no one kicked you out and refused your blood because you are gay unless you have a disease or other compelling reasons. Please do not give us your gay hatred crap just to make us feel sorry for you. Some of my best friends are gay and they certainly do not blame every problem that they face in life on being gay. Here's reality: If you can't stand the punishment do not do the crime and if you wish to be gay do not whine when someone does not bow down and kiss your a##. You are not going to get any special treatment because you are gay.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Do I have a case against the Mars company?
I want to sue them for false advertising. I recently found a fun sized bag of M&Ms on my desk at work. Well, i was like, OOH! M&Ms!. However, upon reaching the last M&M, I realized that I ...


 Smoking ban?
I read in the paper today, the government were trying to stop smoking in our own homes/////////
What do you think about this?...


 Do you think 9-11 was an inside job?
Just curious - I'm not stating my opinion either way.
Additional Details
Hmm..I'm just watching something on the History channel, don't know why asking a poll type ...


 Do you believe that prison rehabilitates criminals?
i think not......


 My daughter just told me a terrrible, terrible secret....who do I go to?
My daughter just told me that her friend at school who is 11 is pregnant by her father.....and that this is the second time this has happened. She told me the girl is abused by both her mother and ...


 Should the dealth penalty be bought back in to the uk?

Additional Details
rich you're a tw*t...il leave it simple so you can comprehend.... ok??...


 How much right does a girl have to have an abortion without the baby's father's consent?
Can the father take legal action against the mother if she chooses to have an abortion without his consent?...


 How do you feel about that guy getting tased when Kerry was speaking?
Did that cop or security officer or whatever he was laugh or act like it was funny after they tased him or am i just seeing things?
How do you feel about free speech in this country now? How do ...


 My freind keeps trying to get with my pregnant partner!?
I was at a party with my pregnant partner and my freind. He started trying to touch my partner,me thinking he was extremely drunk just told him to leave it. He told me at work today that he has ...


 I don't understand...murder & abortion?
OK IF MURDER is the killing of another human being under conditions specifically covered in law THEN WHAT'S ABORTION?
Is it the same or something and if so why isn't abortion illegal ...


 If you found 30 thousand dollars, would you turn it in for someone to claim?
Think about a wad of bills with a rubberband wrapped around it.
Additional Details
My thinking is 30K is too much cash for some person to be carrying around unless it was made through ...


 Should my wife and I conceive to provide my son with a much needed kidney?
What are your thoughts on this....


 Is it against the law to kill your self?
wouldnt it be considered murder and how can u be punished if your dead???...


 My friend gave me her ipods a month ago and her mom wants me to give them back.?
My friend was getting a 180gig or around that ipod and she didn't need her ipods anymore so she gave them to me. That was around a month ago. The ipods were givin to my friend by her mom around ...


 Valerie Plame was in the CIA. What is the big deal about leaking her name?
What did she do for the CIA?...


 Can I be given a written warning for being late to work by 28 seconds?
I have been put on a written warning for being late twice to work once 9 seconds and the next 28 seconds?...


 Is it legal to be a cannibal in the united states?
...


 Can a cop do this?
okay so my bf came over i'm 15 turning 16 in october and he's 17 turning 18 in march. Well my parents are not home and he came over and then this cop showed up and made him leave. Can he do ...


 Let's see, marijuana is illegal. Should we make broccoli illegal? How about cabbage?
Shouldn't marijuana be sold fresh in the supermarket next to the lettuce?
Additional Details
Let's EAT it! Like a salad with croutons and ranch dressing....


 Are you against death penalty? Why?
Hi there! I am doing a research on death penalty and would like to know what you folks out there think about the issue. I am mostly looking for people who are against death penalty. Tell me, why do ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.034