I sent some boots back, for exchange they refunded my card, they then sent the boots as well. Can I keep them?
Find answers to your legal question.
I sent some boots back, for exchange they refunded my card, they then sent the boots as well. Can I keep them?
|

aunty m
 |
KEEP THEM.IF THEY WANT THEM BACK YOU CAN ALWAYS RETURN THEM AGAIN. |
|

Anarchy99
 |
Try a little honesty! |
|

EMMA©
|
Yea...Merry Christmas!!! |
|

Alfred E. Newman
 |
i wont say anything if you dont. |
|

Freak Boy
|
Honesty is the best policy here. Regardless of what some others have written here, you should return them. BUT, you should not have to pay for shipping to get them back to the place that sent them. Give them a call, tell them the situation let them know that you are not willing to pay for return shipping. Ask them to send a Call Tag. The delivery driver will return in the next few days and take the box. Here is why you should return them and not listen to the others:
PRICES GO UP AS A RESULT OF MISTAKES LIKE THIS!
Everyone who managed to get something for nothing, such as in your situation, contributes to rising costs. The reason game consoles are so expensive is because trucks full of them get stolen. Stores are stolen from. All of these things force the retailer to raise their prices to recoup their losses - they dont just eat the loss. So for all of you children who think its cool to steal from a store, and then complain about high prices--it's YOUR fault!
Now here is the good part: Shipping is expensive nowadays. There is a good possibility that the store will tell you just to keep the boots. Because by the time they pay for the return shipping, there profit may have been eaten up anyway. The difference between keeping the boots with no phone call and making the call is huge for the retailer. If they know the boots are missing (because you called them), they can defray their costs. If they dont know, they will find out during an inventory count, and by that time it may be too late to recoup.
Do the right thing and call them. Let them decide how they wish to handle it. Remember, the boots currently belong to them. If the roles were reversed, what would you do?
As a retailer, I would say "Merry Christmas, enjoy your boots," but thats just me.
Merry Christmas to you |
|

Nirmala
 |
please contact them. they may have intentionally sent them back, in which case you can use them without any guilt. |
|

victorschool1
|
To take both would be unethical, immoral, bad karma and theft, other than that no problem. |
|

cajadman
 |
I guess they made a mistake.Call them and let them know of their mistake and see what they say. |
|

julia
|
Yeh, keep 'em, it's their mistake not yours! Merry Christmas. |
|

x
|
Yes and No.
You should tell them you have them and ask them to arrange for their collection.
If they do nothing in, say, three months I think you are entitled to keep them.
On the other hand it seems you wanted to exchange the boots and you now have what you want, but they have made the refund in error.
This being the case they may recharge your card and there is not much you can do about it. |
|

alan t
|
no you cant. you have to tell them that they have made a mistake,if you dint you can be prosecuted for theft. |
|

m
 |
well why did you send the boots back? if its because you didnt like them, give them to someone who does, you then need not feel guilty for keeping them and you have not spent any money but you have made someone happy, if its because of another reason and you dont have a guilty conscience then i dont see the harm!! x |
|

flyboss1107
 |
I believe that legally you can...however because someone made a mistake, you should let them know.
If you sent the boots back, then you either didn't like them or they didn't fit....or they were the wrong colour...or they were damaged...
Question: why would you want to keep them?
My opinion is that you should morally send the boots back (not prepaid...but collect) and phone the company to let them know about the mistake...they MAY just say to keep them..and THEN, you won't have anything on your mind about doing something wrong...morally. |
|

John Hightower
|
If you worked as a cashier and made a mistake by giving somebody too much money - would you want them top give it back? Or would you prefer to have it taken from your pay?
If you owned a business, would you want them to give it back?
As a customer, would you want the business to raise the prices they charge you so somebody else could take something for "free"?
And, if you contacted the business and told them of their mistake - they probably would tell you to just keep the boots. And you will stay a loyal customer of theirs for years. |
|

Red Rooster
 |
When you try them on, they have been contaminated,so they wanted you to keep them, did not they say money back gaurantee? |
|

Emily
 |
phone the company and see what they say. If they say you can keep them, they're a nice company, Merry Xmas. If not, send them back and don't shop there again! (just kidding!) |
|

Baby Dolls
|
~You can keep them, but they'll more than likely catch it later. Do you want your credit ruined over a pair of boots?
Merry Christmas~ |
|

Jeffery C
 |
What would you want your customer to do if you were the business owner and you accidently refunded the customer's money and sent the boots? |
|

mstrywmn
|
The key word here is "exchange". Did they send the same boots back or a different pair? Some companies give you your money back & then rebill you when you do an exchange. If you want to keep them, expect another bill. If you're not sure, give them a call. |
|

dean
|
der |
|

ontopoftheworld
|
that`s wot santa had in-store 4 ya, ,merry Christmas enjoy |
|

Scotty
 |
I suppose so, but you might get charged for them |
|

kartir2500
 |
why not? be a devil!!!!!! |
|

liya79
|
clearly someone wants you to have them |
|

Huff G
 |
Did you have to sign for the boots when they sent them??? If not then they have no proof of you recieving them so i would keep them. Very dishonest i know but oh well. |
|

My name's MUD
 |
Read a pair of boots?
Yes of course, it's a 'good will gesture', they can't sell them as second hand so they would only go on the rubbish tip anyway. |
|

Boothster
 |
Yeah, but you can't read them,i suggest use them as doorsteps |
|

Well, said Alberto
|
Yes. But doing so will make you a thieving b*stard. |
|

|
|
|
|
You find an attache case full of money.? |
| Imagine you are in Central London or any major city in the U.K. You hail a taxi. As you are settling down in the back of the taxi you see a smart leather attache case on the floor. Surreptitiously, ... |
|
Should Abortion be legal in the United States? |
| In over 90% of the world, abortion is illegal.... |
|
AM I RELATED TO THIS GIRLLLLl?? |
i get weird answers , am i related or not , if so please explain
im thinking of marrying this girl , will it be weirf
this is how me and he are related
my dads ... |
|
Would this turn someone off an abortion? |
If you show the mother a sonograph thing with her baby alive and moving?
or if you describe abortion in a horrible but obviously not true way (e.g.first they smash the skull then drain out the ... |
|
Is it illegal to carry a gun in the US? |
| I was carrying a handgun on my holster in downtown city in Arizona and some tourists started yelling at me and said they were going to call the police I laughed at them. Since when is it illegal to ... |
|
Is it illegal for my boss to ask why 'm requesting a day off? |
| My manager recently told me that the main boss wants to know why we are requesting days off. We already have a rule of putting in request 2 weeks ahead of time for approval. I have been following ... |
|
If there was a vote on the death penalty would you support it or reject it and why? |
Additional Details Example crimes are murder, rape, and crimes along these lines.... |
|
Abortion question? |
what is your opinion
good, bad, okay in some cases (which ones)
why do you think that
thanks
8]... |
|
4 years of serious harrassment from an ex, had enough, what can I do? |
at this point even a prison sentence would be worth it just for some time off, should I flip out and give the evil little shite what for?
I need a break from her bitterness and spite.... |
|
I told my boss I was taking a breather and he fired me? |
| I had a stash of paperwork waiting on my desk and I thought I'd go to the movies to have some fun so I left him a note on my desk telling that I was taking a breather and asking him to kindly ... |
|
Isn't from the sidewalk down in a neighborhood public property? |
| So if I was to back out of my driveway and come like one foot into the neighbor across from me's driveway would be on public property and not illegal correct?... |
|
Death Penalty? |
| People sometimes enter death penalty questions on here about whether or not it's moral, and I'm just surprised how many people say that it is moral. Does anybody remember that death penalty ... |
|
Do I have the legal right to chase away Jehovah's witnesses off my property with a bat? |
| Of course I wouldn't hit them or chase them past my property but do I have a legal right to chase these annoying people off my property?... |
|
Can this guy actually sue me over this? |
| I had a lot of stuff up on Ebay for a buy it now of $300. The sale ended with no takers - it was a pick-up only sale due to size. A guy emailed after and said he could come and pickup Tue. or Wed., ... |
|
Against banning smoking in public places? |
| do you think they should have banned it?... |
|
Illegal to smoke whilst driving.............? |
| Can you beleive a stupid law has now been introduced to stop you smoking whilst driving your own car. Personally I haven't bothered with the new law but find myself hiding my cigarette if ... |
|
|