I was fired for "gross misconduct" because of excessive absenteeism. I was denied unemployment. Can I appeal?
Find answers to your legal question.
I was fired for "gross misconduct" because of excessive absenteeism. I was denied unemployment. Can I appeal?
|
They made me sign a statement when they fired me, which I did not receive an opportunity to read, nor would they explain it to me when asked. I have known other coworkers to remain working for them with more absenteeism than my own, and I was considered an excellent employee in all of my reviews.
Also, many of my absences were due to an ongoing health problem, though I don't have documentation to that affect.
According to the Determination I received:
The claimant was discharged or suspended as a disciplinary measure by (my employter) on 1/30/2007 because of excessive absenteeism. Information has been presented showing the claimant continued to miss time in spite of warnings and that the claimant was aware that continued absences would mean loss of his/her job. The claimant's conduct was a series of repeated violations of employment rules proving that the claimant regularly and wantonly disregarded obligations to the employer.
|
|

Gaspode
|
Signatures given under duress are never valid.
Of course you can appeal. |
|

Lisa A
 |
You can appeal all you want. It will be a waste of your time and money though. You were fired for cause. You don't get unemployment if you were fired for cause.
And a word of advice. NEVER sign anything you have not read and understood. |
|

wo_manifest
|
How did they "make you" sign a statement? Get a lawyer. Anything signed under duress is not enforceable. |
|

U Think U Know Me
 |
Stop signing stuff without reading it first. Unemployment will probably not grant you anything. |
|

Common Sense
|
Yes, of course you can appeal...
It does not mean that you will win the appeal... |
|

ascendent2
 |
Yes, you can appeal but I doubt you will win. As for documentation your doctor bills and a letter stating your illness would help. But your employer should have known what was going on so they could have made other arrangements to take your place when you were not there. People hire you to come to work and when your not there your out. Why should they suffer when you were hired to do the job. You were also warned. Why didn't you tell them then. There seems to be more to this then a couple of missed days of work due to illness. Also by signing paper you openly admitted guilt so there you screwed yourself. Sorry but I think you better look for another job. |
|

johncondo2001
 |
first you sign a statement under duress than appeal it and get a statement from you doctor that you were sick if you have copy of your reviews make copy of them did you have written warning,or did thy than made them up,ask the state unemployment to refer you to a free legal aid service,the company will try to pull anything off |
|

K_Seeks4Answers
|
You can appeal the unemployment departments decision, and it shouldn't cost you anything, I believe it is a right. But you will need some good proof to support your reasoning that it wasn't true. That is the problem for working with companies that are at will employment, they can fire you for any reason. |
|

?
|
you will not win., Sorry |
|

tim_klein2001
 |
You can only win if you can document your medical history |
|

Mr Bellows
|
Yes,you can appeal but I doubt you will get anywhere.It sounds like if you had some documentation on your ongoing health problem,you might have a chance of winning but without it,your employer will use their documentation of your absenteeism and you will lose.Sorry. I hope your health problem is not serious. |
|

Y. Answer.
|
Same thing happend at our store.But there was not a damn thing a Trailer Park Employee could do...She lsot and so you will B_Y_T_C_H!!!!!! |
|

pretender59321
|
You can appeal. You will lose, but you can appeal. Find another Job and try to show up for it! |
|

Scrubber
|
If you don't want to work, then why bother. There are plenty of others who do want to! |
|

steph2738
 |
nope... they had a valid reason to fire you... you chose not to go to work so they chose to fire you and replace you with a person to fill the job who is willing to work... the only way you can do anything is if you have proof of your illness meaning doc excuses and medical records stating you needed time from work.. just the common cold excuse Will no work anyone can and use that excuse |
|

John 16
|
It sounds like discrimination to me. Try to get together as much documentation as you can and definitely appeal if your state will let you.
Call your doctor and get the dates you were there. Get him or her to write a letter. Since all you want to do is collect and not get your job back, I think you got a case unlike these other guys.
Call the unemployment office and ask them what you will need to do. They will be glad to help you.
I would.
A friend of mine was asked to sign something like that and she refused. She still works there but can be fired at any time they told her. But they don't have her sig on that paper.
The girl above is right. You should not have signed it. You should have demanded a copy and told them you will think about it.
They seemed to need it for something. That's a clue right there. Based on my friend's situation, I will act similarly if I am in the same situation myself. |
|

Mr_Bman
 |
Get yourself a lawyer--in many cases a little arm twisting by a decent lawyer works wonders. They have insurance for that so it's easier for them to allow your claim than to try to fight it. |
|

curious_One
|
be sure to document your health problems at your next job. also don't ever sign anything that you are not allowed to read first. that's ridiculous. |
|

Tam Tam
|
You can always appeal, but unless you have some way to prove WHY it was impossible for you to come to work, you most likely won't win.
If you have a true medical problem surely you must have SOMETHING that will prove it. ( a letter from a Dr stating your condition?)
It never hurts to appeal, however. It can't possibly get any worse. |
|

automatictomatoman
 |
You can appeal all you want but is that the honest thing to do? You didnt show up to work most of the time. Why should you recieve unemployment for being lazy? You have no documentation of your health problems which doesnt sound right. Where are your benefits records of paying medical bills or checks written out for medicine or doctors visits? Sounds more like you are just lazy and have a bad case of hypocondriacism. |
|

tymkoijn1
|
i am going through the same thing. i had to miss work because of health problems. i would call in in the morning ten go to the emergency room i brought all my excuses to work and i even have it on m application. they fired me today and te company i work for has a tendency to fight any claim |
|

|
|
|
|
Should fireworks be only for organised events? |
| with Novemember 5th on sunday "bonfire night"should the sale of fireworks to the public be banned? ..I mean after all fireworks are explosives, they are no better than a gun. around where I ... |
|
Can a store clerk legally refuse to take a bunch of pennies? |
| I had saved $87 in pennies - 8700 pennies... and then I came to a local liquor store and dumped all the pennies all over the counter for the idiot to count... My purchase came to $85 or so, so I knew ... |
|
Do you think abortion should be legal? |
| I obviously have my own opinion, because I'm catholic. But does anybody else think it should be legal. In my opinion, it shouldn't be a woman's choice, whether they are risking ... |
|
One something is thrown into the trash, can anyone legally take it? |
One something is thrown into the trash, can anyone legally take it?
I can't seem to find the info on the internet... Additional Details Are there any links I could look ... |
|
Is having an abortion murder? |
| Some people believe it is murder, some do not. One thing is clear though, it either is or it isn't. State your opinions.... |
|
Is this racial profiling? |
| When 80% of the people who get arrested are black, in cities where 80% of the population is black is it racial profiling or the Law of Probability?... |
|
I got caught speeding! 70 in a 55. Is it worth it to go to court? |
| The ticket was issued in Wisconsin. About 6 months ago I was caught speeding in Illinois, this was my first ticket. I chose to take a defensive driving course to get the ticket taken off my record. I... |
|
Do you think Al Sharpton's....? |
| 15 minutes are up? I do! First he's yammering about Imus, and ( yes, it was wrong what Imus said to the Rutger's team but he shouldn't have gotten fired over it.) NOW, Mr. Sharpton is ... |
|
What is the worst crime / illegal act you are willing to admit to? |
| I read an article that law-abiding citizens, people from so-called 'respectable backgrounds' are/have committed crimes or illegal acts in the same rate and manner as the paupers, rif-raf, ... |
|
Are you more worried about the 4 burned flags or the 50 million Americans who can't see a doctor? |
Last year, four flags were burned. 50 million couldn't see a doc.
Should the US be able to provide the services to its legal citizens that Canada somehow is able to provide?... |
|
A friend of mine died yesterday. What can his roommate do regarding the other half of his rent? |
Who's typically obligated to pay it and is there anything the roommate can do about it? We've taken up a collection for him, but is there a more permanent answer? Additional Details
|
|
Can I be charged for resisting arrest? |
If I am not being arrested?
Lets say I get pulled over and the cop goes back to his car to write a ticket and I begin to resist arrest in my car then stop when he comes back.... |
|
Whats your thoughts on abortion? |
| i'm not talking about relgiously, im talking about politically... i have my own opinion, and i was just looking to see what other people thought... like for those who are against it... why do ... |
|
If your boss walked in to your office right now and fired you, how long would it take you to pack your office? |
Would you need more then one box?
I'm looking around and I must practically live here because so much of the stuff in this office is mine. It would take me half a day to sort through ... |
|
Blacks vs.White.... White vs Black?? People get real? |
| I just sent a "?" regarding why white people get angry...I am not racis at all! I was not talking about all white people, but there are some! Let the truth be told people pretend to like ... |
|
Should writing a short story about a school shooting warrent expulsion? |
even when the kid i am talking about didnt use any names and didnt even bring the story to school. his mom found it and called the cops who told the school who expelled him. Additional Details
|
|
|