Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

If a school confiscates your phone 1 for the wrong reason, and loses it, aren't they entitled to pay for it?
Find answers to your legal question.





If a school confiscates your phone 1 for the wrong reason, and loses it, aren't they entitled to pay for it?

My phone was off and it fell out my pocket, I picke dit up and put it back in my pocket, that's when a teacher walked in and saw it and took it. I then found out the next day that they lost it, shouldn't they pay for it. The skool lets you have a cell phone, as long as it's off.


    




iagd1
Just threatening them with legal action might get you a new phone out of them. They should definitely get you a new one but it will be a hard battle.


Kate
Rating
I would say yes to that...they have the right to take that stuff away if it is being used against the rules...but because you own it they have no right to keep it and definetely no excuse for losing it...they owe you a new one


Susan B
YES THEY SHOULD. that really pisses me off. they owe you a cell phone.


LALALindsy
the teacher probably thought you had it on, and thats why they took it. but if they lost your phone, then they should definitely pay for it.


Espresso
Rating
i think they should. espescally cause they took it 4 a bad reson.


candleinthewind7579
Rating
Yes...when they take your property...they are responsible for what happens to it


gurtzinator
Rating
Yes! Tha's crazy and the school definitely needs to pay for that. Take it to court. No I was kidding, don't, it's a waste of money. Just have your parents talk to them and try to work something out and if that doesn't work get the media involved and they'll be obligated to buy you a new one.


chy[cola]
Rating
totallly.
do i hear a lawsuit coming on.
i think soo.
make the school pay.
i am soo on your side hun.


Iggy's Cabbage Patch Gang
Rating
Yes they are liable for the phone......and have to pay you for it, call an attorney or have your parents call the principal and demand payment.,,,the teacher lost it, so the teacher is liable, the teacher is employed by the school board and therefore making the school district liable for the teachers actions....


Paralegal (19) yrs


NONAME
Rating
I agree! See an attorney!


Tsunami
i thought you would get it back by end of the year i am not sure what your rules are but i would get folks into this one.


Eagiusti
I would say YES. That is ridiculous. I hate schools. Thank God I've been done for 5 years.


Dani
Rating
Yes they should pay for it


fukingruvin76118
They should have given you a reciept for the phone, but that depends on your district policy. You need to have your parents go up there and talk to the principle and raise hell.


Nickname
Heck yeah they should pay for it!
They're supposed to keep it in safe keeping,
and give it back to you.
If they took it and intended to give it back,
they should follow through.


phantom.obsession
Rating
hell yes, especially if it was off.
that's just irresponsible. seriously, that's ridiculous that they would lose that. don't trust that school.


cat
Rating
I would talk to the principal of your school and get your parents involved and find out what can be done about it. If you do nothing about it then nothing will happen, so talk to anyone you can at the school about the issue and see if there's something they can do.


TAS
I think they should have to replace it. That's stupid. My sister takes her cell to school all the time and it's the same rules as where you are. As long as it is off it's fine. You should talk to someone to find out what you need to do to get them to pay for it. I'm sorry! Good Luck!


Lemon Paper
Yea. Of course they need to get you the same phone new. Sounds like something my school would do. We aren't even supposed to have cell phones in class at all but people still text in class.


sillysylly
Rating
yeah they should pay for it. lucky they dont lose u lot kids eh lol


madds
Rating
i believe they should


PinkLady
Rating
YES, irregardless of why it was taken, if it is lost then they are liable to pay to replace it.

or The teacher who took it may be held responsible for it.


Blessed
The school lost it and should pay for it. You may have to file a claim with the school board or get legal counsel. Talk to the principal or have your parents do it. They may make a more serious impression. You may want to sue the teacher that actually took posession of it from you since you probably have eye wittnesses to state that fact.


Jeff
Fisrt off, phones don't fall out of pockets. Second thing is that you need to look up the meaning of entitled. Third is more of a clarifacation of your question; but what good is a cell phone if it is off. What you telling us here is that you where lugging aroung a cell phone for no reason, that was off. Then phone then just fell from your pocket without any help from anything but gravity! Lets try a little bit of common sence here instead of your fiction. A) You were using your phone and came up with this lame story for your parents as to why it is gone after it was taken by the teacher. B) You lost the phone and again came up with the gravity defying phone story. Either way, you need a better story. I am no super slueth and I know that something is amiss with your work of fiction. Good luck!


Dud
If I was in a similar situation I would ask nicely at first for my phone back. Then bring your parents into it, ask your cell phone company for what they think you should do. Talk to your Principal and explain the situation. A cell phone is an important part of people lives in this day and age. You should be able to get your cell phone back or replaced.


PARKERD
Rating
I would learn how to spell school, before I tried to sue anyone.


Manny
Rating
HI

NO THEY DON'T BECAUSE SCHOOLS HAVE RIGHTS TO CONFISCATED YOUR CELL PHONES EVEN IF THEY LOSE IT. I THINK IT'S TOO BAD! THEY AREN'T RESPONSIBLE IF THEY CONFISCATED AND LOOSES IT!


United American Socialist States
The only thing they owe you is an education but you are too entitled and pathetic to actually bother to learn. I doubt it just fell out and I'm fairly sure you are lying about all the details. You lost it, grow up and take responsibility.


nekogui
Rating
first, you must prove to them or show evidence that it was all a misunderstanding. you were just picking your phone up and you were not using it. if you can prove that, you would be innocent and maybe you can ask the school to take responsibility. of course, this cannot be done if the school does not allow bringing cellphones. however, by asking them to take responsibility (paying for it), you might end up having a conflict with your teacher so please be careful.


Merryberry
You should check on it. Our school is okay w/phones that are off but they also have to be out of sight at all times. If that is the case, it's your fault for not being more careful with it. If this is not the rule, I'd definitely inform your parents and get them involved.


Cubanmami
Rating
BOY SUE THEM!!! YOU NEVER KNOW YOU MAY CHANGE THERE POLICY AND KIDS EVERYWHERE WILL BE SCREAMING YOUR NAME SAYING YOUR THE MAN!!!





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Someone spat in my face the other day because i was rude to them what could i have done legally?
can i make citizens arrest how much force can be ...


 Would it be wrong for me to report benefit theft?
My step sister has been committing benefit fraud and thinks it really funny to brag about all the money she has and what she spends it on. Would it be wrong of me to report her, as i think its really ...


 Statutory rape?
ok a guy friend of mine is 18 and his 15 yr old gf is pregnant her mom is charging him with statutory rape anyone have any idea how much troulbe he is going to be in. his record isnt the best. we ...


 Police: Do what I say not what I do?
If you’re caught speeding, you’re very likely to be fined, receive points on your licence or even banned if you’re caught going fast enough.

This may be fair enough in most cases, but ...


 Should kids get cained at school?
When I was a kid, I was always cained at School. I found it hard to concentrate but overall I am glad I was cained at school.

Is it still cool to be cained at school?
Additional D...


 Can someone help me in my moral dilemma?
OK, this is the situation;

I am right now a math/philosophy major, work study student, working, of all places, the philosophy office. Now, the secretary told me not to worry about coming ...


 How to get marajuana out of your system in three days?
I have to take a drug test to get a job. So, I need something that works for real, because of course I only get one chance....


 What does "freedom of speech" mean to you personally?
Any limits, responsibilities?...


 I got kicked out of the bar for just drinking a coke. Is this considered loitering?
The bar tender made me leave the bar because I was only drinking a coke and didn’t spend a lot. He thought I was loitering because I was by myself and only drinking a coke but then didn’t order ...


 Should the UK bring back Hanging for people like Huntley who murder inocent children?
where there is no question of inocence and horrific crimes have been commited, surely it would be better and more economical for the country to hang offenders rather than give them free board and ...


 What would happen if an underaged person.....?
was caught smoking?
Like a cigarett?
like a 13yr old.
Thanks!
Sincerely, ME!
=-]]]]]]
Additional Details
By the ...


 Straight or Gay?
I'm doing a college research paper on the public's opinion of gay marriage. What's your view...are you for it or against it?

Thanks for you help with my paper....


 When Does Child Support End?
Is there ever a time when child support ends when the ex-wife gets remarried or even then does the ex-husband still have to pay? Because I am just curious that my friend's parents are divorced ...


 Guns....Yes or No?
Do you think that a person should be allowed to own a gun if the person is liscensed and the gun is registered ? I think they should....


 Who thinks maryjuana should be legal in califorina?
i smoke weed and i think that it is horrable that it is illigal oh im 15 years ...


 Is it illegal to bury people in your garden?
i am just wondering if a person is declared dead is it legal to bury them in your back garden??...


 When a kid gets arrested are they put in the same holding cell as adults?
...


 IS this REALLY stealing?
Its been about three times already that I have gone to the store and the cashier forgets to scan and charge me for certain items. The items are in plain sight not hidden or stuffed somewhere. I am ...


 Hello what happens if you dont eat food for 1 whole day?????
help help ...


 Which do you view as worse: Pot or Liquor?
Yes, pot is illegal, and liquor isn't, but don't you think there's another reason for that? Think about it: People die from alcohol poisoning all the time. How many people have EVER ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.074