Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

If it is now illegal to discriminate over age why can shops give discount to pensioners ?
Find answers to your legal question.





If it is now illegal to discriminate over age why can shops give discount to pensioners ?

My local diy store gives pensioners 10% discount one day a week this means I am getting charged 10% more for a purchase just because of my age. Isn't this age discrimination and illegal ?


    




nita
there are more wealthy pensioners in this country than poor ones be live me they plead poverty I'm only a pensioner but don't for get all the other benefits they can claim attendance allowance mobility allowance income support no TV licences over 75 £200 every winter towards fuel costs now don't get me wrong I'm not saying they shouldn't have it but they are all ways pleading poverty there are no poor pensioners in this country but there are a lot of very greedy ones its the young ones that have it hard these days price of property mortgages not to mention heating and all the other house hold bills it take both husband and wife to go out to work these days just to make ends meat and the young ones are even being told to save for a pension out of what there's nothing left to save if any one should get the 10per cent discount it should be the young and a lot of the pensioners should be a shamed of them selves for taking it


on the wagon
nice one


gina
tell me about it! we have a local cafe for the over 50s. if i was to open a cafe for under 30s there would be riots


Deb
Rating
That's a good point, but descrimination only applies to hiring someone for a job and things along those lines. They are not descriminating because you are white, black, etc. When you reach the age, you will get the discount too. It's a courtesy the store is offering. If someone were to take them to court over it all they would accomplish is to hurt the senior citizens as the store would just drop ALL discounts regardless of age. Then you'll get screwed when you get older too. Wait and be patient. Your turn will come.


frasier
Rating
Discrimination law works on the basis of what is decided in the courts on a case by case basis...Therefore, when a new piece of legislation comes into force...the true meaning and significance of the 'act' is only determined by the precedents that are set by the courts.

What all this means is...you may well be right in your interpretation of the act...but it will need to be confirmed by a judicial decision that your opinion does actually represent the meaning of the law.


keny
Rating
it`s a disgrace considering how obsessed with DIY these pensioners are i see them all the time where i live building extensions on there house running around on the roof with their satalite dishes and new aerials
do me a favour how much is 10% off the price of a new plug for their kettle


Mr Sceptic
Rating
Being really pedantic, you're not paying 10% more, you're paying 11.1% more.

If you pay £100, pensioner pays £90 with discount, so you pay £10 more - £10 is 11.1% of £90.


Citizen DeCat
Rating
Ethically, I believe you are correct, but legally it has to be tested in court.

You could maybe ask a pensioner to buy something for you, then give them the money. Do a good deed in return.


guzzlegob
I run a market stall. I give little people a discount if they buy from their own pocket money.
It's an incentive to spend.

And i recoup my losses by charging the adults more on a few select items. It balances the books :-)


Indy500
Rating
Hmmm...you have made me think about petitioning the govenment to pay me my pension immediately. I think it's outrageous that you have to wait until you are 65...


goulash
I agree - but if something like this does end up setting a precedent in court, then by the same token, children will end up having to pay full price for everything too e.g. entrance tickets, bus fares, no more more 'kids go free' offers on holidays. You can bet that we'd end up paying full price for children on everything rather than an average lower price.


Timothy M
The age-discrimination laws only prevent you from offering a service or a job on the grounds of age.

In other words your local DIY store couldn't refuse to sell DIY goods to a person because they thought they were too old.

They are, however, able to offer incentives, like the 10% discount (in just the same way as some nightclubs have one night a week discounted for students).


heeeelp
Rating
I think it is an incentive to get us to spend some of our pittance one day a week. They have to get us to the store in the first place, and personally I would only use the place if I was desperate! It costs more in fuel costs to get there, than the 10% discount and Tuesday is the only day that we are allowed to shop with the discount. There is not a suitable bus service from where we live, so could not use my bus pass and I don't think the driver would like a kitchen cabinet or new door on his bus! Not many pensioners are able to use the facility, so that is why they offer the discount!
Don't worry, you will all be pensioners one day! Wow, and you will get the 10% too.


fangtaiyang
Rating
Actually you are not being charged any more than you would otherwise be charged. The discount is due to pensioners having generally fixed incomes. It is not age discrimination to give them a discount. You are not receiving a penalty for being young.


twism
A business can give stuff away if they choose. Or raise the price or lower it. They cannot discriminate in their hiring is all. Business have the right to give the service.


bob
Rating
nope, a shop can give a discount to anyone they choose


smartypants
Rating
The age discrimination laws currently in effect only apply when a person is discriminated against due to their old age. therefore it is legal to require a minimum age for anything whether discounts jobs admission etc, but a maximum age limit is illegal. Not necessarily fair but thats how it works.


frank S
No. I think it is intended for employers not to discriminate against employees on the basis of age.

I have recently seen a job application form and nowhere on it do they ask for birthdate and age. However they do ask for your driver licence number. This number includes your birthdate. So whatever legislation is brought out it is possible to find a way of getting round it.


silly gorbie
This is a very good point indeed and I see it as age discrimination.

However, the only real way to establish whether the laws sees it in this way is by taking the matter to court and letting a judge decide.


dragonsaphira13
Rating
It doesn't mean you're getting discriminated against. The store is helping people and trying to get more customers.


valda54
Rating
leave the oap's alone.. there's an enough trouble in the world without picking on them. ageism is for the workers only





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 I can sui my business partner if he breks promise, y cant i do so wn my gf breks promise of doing sx vd me?
...


 Can i complain of "emotional distress" when my employer imposes "merry christmas" stuff and the works on me?

Additional Details
add: where are the politically correct brothers of mine when i needed them? help me out here!...


 Have you ever been verbally or physically abused by a policeman?
Me NO and I don’t think I have ever seen a policeman be abusive, lippy yes and over the top but not aggressive or over ...


 Prescription medication privacy?
if i'm over the age of 18, does my father have the right to call my doctor and find out what medication i am on, when it was last refilled, etc? can they legally give this information away?
<...


 Do you tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth OR are you a lair, lair pants on fire!?
...


 I have been summoned to Court for a Child support motion?
My Ex has summoned me to Court to get her Child support reduced

Can I make a motion to get her evaluated mentally for her Anorexia, Bulimia, abuse of laxatives, and her erratic behavior
...


 Poligamy what is your take?
should poligamy be legal.. should a guy have as many as 3 wives.. and woman have 3 husbands? is it any of the governments buisness?

i think it should be.. and i think that it should have a ...


 Do u believe on the death penalty?
if u do why??

and if u don't why not??...


 Why would you need a gun in a civil society?
Isn't that the job of institutions to protect you. Like the police, the army, the judicial system....


 Whats the difference between homicide, suicide and murder?
...


 Do you think average citizens of any state should have the right to bear weapons (e.g. guns)?
With the recent shooting in Virginia, the topic of gun control has come up again. Many people on Y! answers in America still feel citizens should have the right to bear arms. I'm curious what ...


 Uk police?
who thinks the uk police are starting to act like american police and beating people down, me & my friend got punched & kicked the other day and all my ribs and legs are bruised, And before ...


 Is it lawful for an employer to pay by contract instead of hourly wage?
I have a friend (adult in mid's) who works so many hours and also earns about 16 thousand a month. He apparently gets paid by contract. If he were to get paid per hourly wage, he were to earn a ...


 What will happen if you get caught caught illegal downloading...?
I already got a letter from my isp saying that i've been caught downloading illegal software and I should delete it from my harddrive. What if they catch me again. What will happen?...


 Can you be fired for just _being_ a racist?
Similar to my previous question... but can you be fired from a job simply for being a racist? Like if you don't even say anything, but your boss just finds out you're a racist. Or if asked ...


 Is it illegal to audiotape someone without their knowlege? Could the tape be used against them in a court????
In the state of NY is it illegal to audiotape someone without their knowlege? If they say something incriminating could it be used against them in a court of law??? Or would the person who ...


 Why do I keep receiving emails telling me that I have won a great deal of money when I do not play lotteries?
I get these almost every day. Can somebody tell me who is doing this? How can I get it stopped?...


 What happens with this smoking ban if a tradesman comes to your house to do some work.....?
does he now have the right to tell you not to smoke as it is his/her ...


 Smoking ban?
As a tradesman & non smoker I work a lot in private homes. If the customer is a smoker where do my rights lay? Does the private home become a place of work? I've tried looking at various web ...


 If you could guarantee world peace at the price of the free will of all humans, would you do it?
i.e.: Everyone's actions are controlled to prevent war, disease, famine, genocide, etc. No one can choose to harm someone else or make choices that could lead to a disruption of the world's ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.004