Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

If someone tried to burgal your house, what sort of self defence is ok.?
Find answers to your legal question.





If someone tried to burgal your house, what sort of self defence is ok.?

If someone tried to burgal your house, what sort of self defence is ok. also can you answers these aswell

1) What happens if you kill him.
2) What happens if you put him in hospital.
Would i go to jail


    




Lillian
Rating
It's called self defense and you shoot them.


Huge
What you have to remember in the UK is that it is not legal to kill anyone unless they pose the same threat to you or your family. If you do kill the chances are that you will be arrested but may not be charged if the Police and the CPS are satisfied that it was self defence. Basically you can use reasonable force against someone who poses a threat to you in your home. That means if he punches you can punch back but you cannot beat him to a pulp or kill - especially if the thief is a small teenager and you are a 16 stone ultra fit boxer or similar. If you do you will end up in court on charges of GBH


Aberdeen Tyke
The official UK police line is you may kill him in self defence if he is posing a direct threat. If he runs off and you kill him in retribution, then thats a no-no.

Tip, keep a metal golf club under your bed - just in case.
Alipatta is wrong. The law has moved on since Tony Martin.


sensible_man
Rating
If they were not threatening your life and you killed them, you would be in big trouble. As far as inflicting injury, you cannot go overboard. Not that I agree with the laws but too many home invaders have won lawsuits for the property owner getting overzealous in their attempt to thwart being a victim. Not fair, but still the law.


Outspoken but Honest
The official term in the UK is minimum force.
If you kill him it could be murder or culpable homicide

You would be jailed as it happens all the time.


chimp
Rating
why have you done something? i would stab them in self defence, but yes you would probably go to jail!!!


Faith ((Ninja and Ducky))
citizens arrest - "stop in the name of the law!" - ((yeah right!))

Peace

xx


Gerry Atrix
Coming in or already in beat the bezazz out of him.
Going out you cannot touch him.


mbspringer133b
Rating
2 guys broke in while i was sleeping on the couch
The left in an ambulance
At the time i lived in Massachusetts.
I could have killed them and gotten away with it.
Armed home invasion , you can kill them.
in Massachusetts. if you are home.


Paul G
It all depends. The law states you can use 'reasonable force'. In all honesty each case has to be identified individually. If for example you shot someone in the back like that farmer did a few years ago then you may go to prison for a few years. If however you were defending your self or you gave the f***** a couple of licks to the head i think you would be OK.

It is a very difficult situation because 'what is reasonable force'.

If you kill him you will definately be arrested until they can establish the evidence.

The way i see it- if someone has broken into your home you should be able to do what you like. The law protects the criminals too much not the victims!


shitebird
Rating
the dead can nae testify agin you laddie..

who could prove the knife of gun in their cold dead hands was put there by anyone but them selves.

well sorted ehh


kuc2215
shoot to kill, i have 2 kids i will protect so i really won't take a chance..


majeed_tahiyyah
Rating
Each state is different. You have the right to defend your property. If said person has not been invited to your home and appears to be a threat, you have the right to defend yourself and your property. Try to asses the situation first before you start shooting or beating them down.


Lurch
If you feel you are in imminent danger it is legal to use lethal force. Tip: dead men tell no tales...


Alipatta
In the UK you aren't actually allowed to use any form of attack as defence... there have been plenty of cases to prove this.
Can't remember the full name of the farmer who was constantly attacked by burglars/junkies - Mr. Martin I think. He ended up in jail cause he shot them, killing one and injuring the other. If you're in the states however, you just shoot 'em and be done with it.


pin ball
Rating
in england it is ok to keep a cricket bat by your bed, and you can whack a burglar with it but only if you have a ball to go with it. this ball proves you had the bat to play cricket with and it was not a weapon.


cleakyboi
Rating
pretty much anything as long as its not repetitive. E.g you catch a robber in your house you (in court you'd say he went for you, attacked you etc etc) then you swing with you bat an catch him flush on his temple knock him out he falls into a coma and he dies. That would be fine. If you catch a robber and then grab a knife an repetitively stab him him several times killing or seriously injuring him then you'd be in trouble.
Have fun!


Mr Shady
Rating
This is my self defence - my attempts at ju-jitsu followed by a complete iron bar battering just to make sure they get the jist of what i'm saying


falconson5000
Rating
in this country we have too much Human Rights. If some commits a crime, intent on causing damage etc... then they should lose their rights.

Me, if a idiot tried to burgle my home, I would get rid of it of one way or another, if I had a weapon to hand, I would certainly give him a nasty wound.


Sal*UK
Rating
1) yes you go to jail, particularly if you used something like a shotgun.

2) probably be done for aggravated assault.

Not good - it seems the best thing to do is to let them burgle you!





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Serious question about marijuana?
ok so i don't smoke marijuana and i don't drink so i am unbiased. But i am wondering why marijuana is illegal and alcohol isn't? So marijuana is bad because it dulls the brain, affects ...


 Is this legal?
I have noticed that a person on my street has started putting a wallpaper table and a wheelie bin on the road in front of their house so that no one can park there
When i first saw it I presumed ...


 How can our prisons be full?
Surely if you took out the TVs, game consols and whatever else they have, you could fit 10 to 12 scumbags in a cell!!!
Then they may think twice about re-...


 Do you agree with Capital Punishment?? ?
For either side you choose, please argue your point, be opinionated and argue your case!!!...


 911 - If you don't believe that there was ANY wrongdoing at all by our government, what do you base that on?
Truth seekers of 911 are asking us who understand critical thinking, to research on our own before blindly falling into line by simply accepting what the U.S. Government says about 911 just because ...


 Should we replace ASBO's with a return of the Stocks or Pillory's and public humiliation for some crimes

Additional Details
elmo45, that is so what I had in mind thanx!...


 Do you think that the old lady who uses Cannabis for pain relief?
Should have been prosecuted for intent to supply? to OTHER people with constant pain!
Additional Details
I don't think she was selling it ...


 If in a business partnership of two people one dies is the remaining partner the sole owner?
...


 Should Death Row be eliminated?
It's a fact that it cost more to keep an inmate on Death row than in the general population prisons....


 Why do american's think they should decide if women are allowed to have n abortion?
isnt it supposed to be a democratic country?
its a very private issue n i dont think any country should tell it's ppl wheather they can go through abortion or force them to have a ...


 HI i REALLY need some help here on Underage drinking. Can you help me?
I am 18, I do not go to parties but i was convinced to go to one and a friend got me to try his beer, I had 1 sip. (hated it)... anyway the cops came and I told them that I had one sip. They gave me ...


 In your opinion, is freedom of speech a right or a privilege?

Additional Details
Of course it should be a right, I don't disagree with that aspect.......


 My girlfriend's exboyfriend is thretening us, can we file a lawsuit?
this person is out of his mind...where do we have to go? and what kind of protection can we get?...


 Are you for or against the death penalty.?
...


 Is there some kind of law against opening letters that are not addressed to you?
I've heard mixed opinions on this. My Mother is constantly opening my letters. I live at her address but I am always the last person to know I have post and by the time I do know, it has already ...


 If you were allowed to, would you...?
...walk into a china shop and wreck up the place?
Additional Details
well, i won't ask any of you to join me on my next trip to the high street ...


 I havent gotten payed since before christmas! is this legal?
Well, i have been working in an office for about 8 months already, few times before i have had trouble not getting my paycheck on time, howver now its just anoying. they have not payed me for 92 ...


 Is it time now in the UK to seriously consider bringing back flogging?
Nothing else seems to be working - so how about a good public flogging?...


 Why do the British people not stand up for themselves and their rights a lot more?
The MP's should be forced to bring in stricter laws towards these young hooligans.Increase age limit for alcohol,make them join the forces.If they insist in killing people let them kill the ...


 Can i brake in his house...he is in out of town?
I am still on the lease, no restraining order. I had been calling the police to go with me in (our)apartment. I left the important papers like birth certificate, my 1 nice pair of shoes, and car ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.034