Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

If we ever create a being with aritificial intelligence, should it be given citizenship?
Find answers to your legal question.





If we ever create a being with aritificial intelligence, should it be given citizenship?

Okay, so you Trek geeks out there know that this was covered in the episode on Data. There's also "Bicentennial Man". Then there's the Isaac Asimov "I, Robot" writings. What I'm wondering is what y'all think of the idea... (after all, it may come sooner than we expect).
Additional Details
While it's a bit late w/the details... Perhaps I should have said if we create a *'sentient'* being using A.I., should it get citizenship? My point would be that the AI could pass whatever tests we give humans in their citizenship test, and be recognized as being 'aware' of itself. Sorry that wasn't clear from the question (it was implied by the examples from science fiction, but perhaps I shouldn't have assumed people were familiar w/my examples ;-)...


    




DS143
Rating
Talk about your illegal aliens.


freebird
Rating
It will be trickier than that. Assuming when you say A.I., you're also referring to a sense of ethics by which they understand right and wrong, can feel pain and loss, have a sense of mortality, and meet the legal definition of mental fitness, the problem will arise long before an android is created.

Such intelligence will develop first as a bodiless mass of software. This entity will first exist as a virtual pet, a fancy SIM city if you will. As such, the traditional definitions as "body", "life", and "person" will have to be addressed long before that intelligence will inhabit an individual vessel or body. In fact, in all likelyhood, said intelligence will probably also be used in cohabitation with humans long before they are given independence as androids. Uses such as intelligent prosthetics and disease-fighting nanotechnology will probably employ A.I. first.

By today's standard, no,they won't be given citizenship any more than a dog or a cat. But as A.I. evolves, who knows how our future generations will view the ethical consideration of artificial life.


coragryph
Humans (as a species) are not emotionally mature enough to recognize and respect a non-human intelligence. Heck, it's hard enough for them to give equal rights to other humans who happen to have different skin color or dating preferences.

While I agree that rights of citizenship should be granted to any sentient being who reaches a certain threshold of cognitive ability, in reality the open-mindedness that it would require is much farther away than the technical breakthroughs.


I am therefore I think
Rating
Who says an electronic thinking entity will want to be part of a biological thinking society? Humans and fish inhibit the same planet on different levels of intelligence but nobody is suggesting we give the fish citizenship. What if electronic intelligence surpasses biological human intelligence to the point we are fish to the "Robots"? Will they give us citizenship? will we want it?


Warren D
We have real beings with real intelligence who aren't citizens. Why bump an android the the head of the line?

Seriously, if a being with artificial intelligence were created and were given rights it could be allowed to apply for citizenship or be granted citizenship on the same basis we humans are given citizenship--but that would be a decision for people well above my pay grade to make.


nellie
Rating
already did and if they change the law governer arnold will be president ill b back....


Naazneen D
Rating
Yes! If we have a large living-unintelligent population then we do need to have artificial-intelligent people.


yourdoneandover
If your talking about a cloned human it would have as much of a soul as you. If its a machine we could program them to not be bribed and make them congressmen.


moebiusfox
Well,they would have to have special licenses,these robots.The robot class would be slow to develop,but it
is possible,(I think even beneficial )for mankind.


CraZyCaT
Rating
Not citizenship.....Ownership.


daydoom
Rating
Yes it should be given residency on the planet of its choice, but not the USA their would be no intelligent life to compare it's intelligence level too.


Ironball
You could classify it as a new life form.


bats_fanfilm
If robots ever become sentient, it should be well understood that they were created by us for our own convenience. They have no more rights than a screwdriver.


heyrobo
Computers have artificial intelligence--should we give our PC's and Macs citizenship?


a TRUE AMERICAN and proud to be!
Rating
yes, if we change your gov with stupid robots, probably u will have a better country...


Negrodeus
Rating
As a possession it doesn't need citizenship because it is not human....


Hollybug
Rating
that really depends. but whos knows


MARK B
Rating
NO. There is still EMOTION. Pain, joy, happiness, etc. You can teach action, reaction and stimulation but not emotion...





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 With the crap law system in the u.k should people start taking the law into there own hands?

Additional Details
to teach people a real lesson?...


 What would be your final meal if you were on death row ? Should tax payers pay for it ?
It's for a paper I'm writing....


 What is the term "Squatting" and why is it illegal in the United States?
I was reading about types of housing and an article I read refered to a type of housing as squatting. lol, I had no idea what it was talking about but all I know is that it said squatting was illegal ...


 Should we (America) legalize marijuana ? ?
I personally believe we should legalize it for private use within ones home, a natural herb that is impossible to overdose on and proven to be non habit forming. So what do you guys think? Agree? D...


 R they goin after Michael Vick because he's a black man ?
so what he killed a few dogs. What about people that work in a cow slaughtering plant ? no difference !...


 I recently saw an add for a post office job for 20 dollars an hour when i called they said i have to take an?
exam and that they can send me practise exams for a 100 fee just wandering if this is real or a ...


 Do you believe that Marijuana should be legalized ?
Please don't use the prase "it's the gateway drug" that one is old and incorrect, I live in a state where medical use is legal....


 Is it illegal to Eskimo Kiss a child as an adult?
So I was in a heated debattle with a friend of mine over the hot button issue of Eskimo Kissing children who don't belong to you.

My friend thinks that it would be illegal. Although I...


 Should I allow visitation?
My son is almost four and his father has been in and out since he was born. Last year we set up a verbal arrangement for my son to go to his father's house (lives with his mom) on tues and thurs ...


 What do you think about death penalty?
...


 When will marijuana be legalized?
when do you think it will? if ...


 Ok, was oj guilty?
why do people think they know?

I find it really scary when people decide things like that for themselves and don't even believe the courts or evidence or due process or anything.
...


 I got fingered by my Doctor during a so-called Prostate exam, can I sue for Rape?
...


 How can I dispute an 11 year old bill that was just recently sent to me from a collection agency.?
It has been 11 years and we are just now hearing about this bill. Will it affect my credit rating? It has not been on any of my credit reports. How do I prove that I do not owe for this bill?...


 Hire someone to give self lethal injection to commit suicide. Has anyone ever heard of this or thought of this
A friend of mine who seems quite depressed but also has an offbeat sense of humor has said this before ... that he'd like to pay someone to give him a lethal injection because he was too afraid ...


 I found 600 dollars in the park,now what?
I was on my bike down by the lakeshore in a wooded area.
This was the third time i have passed a brown backpack somewhere 20 feet away from me covered by rocks.
After the third day i ...


 Child Support question that's really bothering me.?
My ex-wife has recently taken me back to court for more child support. I already give her 394.00 a month and pay 50% of my sons medical bills. She has picked up public aid for my son without ...


 Who do I contact in local government when my ex employer does not pay me what they owe me?
Left my previous employer in June. I have not been paid for the Benefit hours I earned under their Earned Time Off program....


 Case dismissed?? what that means?
I got a judgment and as a result of that, there was a wage garnishment against me. Then I filled up an exception petition and in the exception I agreed to pay $80 each month. The other party does ...


 What law prevents gay marriage?
Can you please give me a link or actual wording of any law that prevents gay marriage within the United States?
Additional Details
Let me rephrase because I am looking for an intelligent ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.024