Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

If you'd secretly filmed the police beating up a black man, would you release it knowing it could cause a riot
Find answers to your legal question.





If you'd secretly filmed the police beating up a black man, would you release it knowing it could cause a riot

A race riot in which hundreds of people could be injured or killed just like what happened with the L.A. riots after the Rodney King film was seen.
Additional Details
Yes, I know that the riots happened after the police were acquitted, but the fact is that the riots would not have happened had that tape not been seen by the public. (Why were they beating up totally innocent white people? That's racism on their part)

I wrote "release it" as I didn't have the space to say "put it on the internet on YouTube" or something. The Rodney King tape ended up on TV news shows, now it would go straight onto the Internet, the effect would be immediate and you'd have no control over what would happen after it was seen.


    




Mutt
Rating
First, the showing of the tape was not what caused the riots. It was the verdict from the trial of the officers that caused the riots (they were acquitted). And because of the riots, the federal government stepped in and tried the officers on federal offenses (violating his civil rights). Two of the officers were found guilty and sentenced to 30 months in prison.

Would I release a tape? Yes. I would want to see that the officers that did this faced their day in court and that they get what they deserve.


Bystander
Without a doubt.

What am I supposed to do? Let those police just beat up who they like, anytime they wanted to?


Dont Hate Me Coz U Cant Add Me
worse if kept hidden.


Lisa
Rating
The riots didn't happen until the police were found "not guilty" at the Rodney King trial so it probably wouldn't cause a riot if the police were punished for their crimes.

I would release it.


GOD
Rating
I would sell it to the papers and make a load of money out of it, it would then be up to the papers to decide what to do afterwards, yes I am shallow and selfish but I would have thousands of pounds to spend, would`nt I.
THUMB`S AT THE READY.


Pfo
Rating
I would turn in a copy of it to that police office's internal affairs. If I didn't see results, then I'd send the FBI a copy. No, I would not use it to incite riots, two wrongs never made a right.


joan k
I wouldn't release it because I would think of all the innocent victims who could be injured or killed in the riots.


ezeikiel
Certainly I would if I wanted to get innocent people killed, other people being beaten, robbery arson, and maybe a few rapes. Not to mention destruction of property and festering hatred against white people, (If the police involved were white of course) After all, it is not every day that thugs can come out into the open mob handed, create merry hell and have a bloody good laugh in daylight is it? Any excuse for a party, and they could all do with a bit of loot to swap for crack.
Incidentaly, if you filmed a bunch of black guys beating up a white man, would you put that on air too? Or isn't that news any more?


Sherilynne B
Yes. The police get away with that sort of thing too often. One man being beaten may seem like a small thing but I bet it isn't a small thing to that man.


Pleasant Peter Perkins
Release assumes a lot in your scenario!

I would pass it to the proper authorities for investigation, but I wouldn't seek to generate a riot.


david b
no, i would destroy it. Black people riot every time they need a new TV.


Freethinker
Rating
I sure would. There needs to be more accountability for law enforcement.


Dont get Infected
Rating
the race riot started after the trial because people felt the officers didnt get what they diserved and the government started saying the case was a racial issue when it had nothing to do with race and thats what pretty much started the whole race thing. people thought white officers got off easy.


UTOPIA OR BUST,
Rating
If i saw the police beating anyone up i would send it the video to the best human right lawyer of the time so they could forward it to the best orginisation. i would not just send it to some news company to show.


tnfarmgirl
I'd take it to the cops- not the TV


karen w
WHY WOULD YOU FILM IT INSTEAD OF HELPING OUT A FELLOW CITIZEN?


LadyMoonlight!!
Rating
Yes if an innocent civillian had been the victim of police brutality I would not be able to live with myself if I had proof of this but chose to withhold it. I would want to see justice done.


just little old me
I would post it all over the net NOT to cause a riot but to show that the police don't treat everyone the same (like they say they do) but then on the other hand if it was definitely going to cause a riot doing it then i would go to my lawyer and let them advise me.
Regards
J.L.O.M :)


PENDRAGON
Sure would.


Duirmuid
Yes, if the film was the truth and showed the whole story I would think it needs to be aired.However, what I would say is that during the "secret" filming why wasnt that person filming helping the black guy against the police beating. Why didnt they step out and try to protect the black guy? Were they afraid or trying to set something up?
People may not riot, they may just want answers and an investigation into the beating.


han2313
i would give it to the police and they could sort it out


thebigm57
I'd give the film to the FEDS and let them deal with that particular police agency. PEACE!


tricky0000
Fighting does not resolve fighting. This very seriuous matter needs to be dealt with by the police themselves. Approach a different policing area and inform them, ask their advice on the matter and how to proceed further.

It may also be an idea to consult a solicitor or your local MP ao even a citizens advice bureau


wingshooter08
Rating
YEP


SIMON G
Rating
after a football match near my house i was returning home and the police were abusive to me and said i should go home i then said well i am and they said go away and were all out for trouble because they were cops i again said i would like to go home they said no go home are all cops thick yes i would hand in the tape but not to the cops or the government as they are all prats i would make sure that the TV got it and aired it as some of us should show what the state is turning into


j2j
Rating
yes you would do the right thing


george_graham_crayford
Rating
yeah because they never beat up white men, and black people never beat up white men, and asians never beat up white men





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Should I SUE?
I am not the type of person who sues at the drop of a hat. Some of the things I see on TV frustrates me because I think a lot of people are just money hungry and a waste of the courts time. But ...


 Can my upstairs neighbor forbid me from smoking outside on my own private porch?
We used to smoke inside with permission from our landloard who also smokes inside even though our apartment was listed as a non-smoking apartment. We used an exhaust fan and only smoked in one room ...


 Who believes in abortion?
I don't because abortion shows a woman that if she jumps in bed with a guy then she can cover up her mistake. I understand if the person was raped but it is worng!...


 Honest Question; How many more school shootings do we need?
Before we pass tougher gun control legislation.

Not to be confused with "banning all the guns" you lunatics, god forbid you think we would take your guns away!

Isn...


 If my paperboy tells me he will keep leaving my paper in a puddle unless I tip him, can I sue for extortion?
Could I have him charged with felony extortion?...


 My daughter's dad was just ordered to pay over $500 in child support per month!?
We have never been married. She basically met him when she was 5 years old. She has always lived with me. I provide her with a stable home. I work and go to school. I do not use drugs. My ...


 Why do Americans insist they have the right to own a gun because of the constitution??
The Constitution says you have the right to bear arms not own them. If you look in the dictionary Oxford or if you prefer Webster's dictionary the word bare does not have in any of its ...


 Is it illegal to smoke canniabas?
loads of peeps smoke it and dont get in trouble
Additional Details
o i cant spell a dont want to take ...


 I'm 15 he's 18; expecting our first baby, what can I do?
Me and my boyfriend have been dating for over a year, we were recently excited to find out that we will be expecting our first child in feburary. I know this doesn't sound like much of a problem,...


 I caught a pick pocket and got arrested.?
I have just gotton back from a day trip to London. I was near the underground and there was a crowd gathering watching a street magician so I went to have a look. I saw a man aged about 20 unzip a ...


 I just got fired from my job Sunday 17th of September for sitting on my knees oustide of Taco Bell, praying. ?
Anybody who has a good resource or a word of advice would be much appreciated.
Additional Details
mind you i wasn't flat on my face sobbering and screaming repent at people. just ...


 I pay 250 dollars a month in child support but I pay it in pennys and nickels. Can I get into trouble for that
My ex gf said she is going back to the judge and tell him what I'm doing. Am I doing anything legal.
Additional Details
am i doing anything ...


 Why do countries still use capital punishment when it clearly does not work?
It has been proven that it does not work as a general or specific deterrent and with all the legal costs, it ends up costing more than it would to lock someone up for life....


 Why does a country like the US with tens of thousands of gunshot deaths every year allow gun ownership?
...


 Men- what is your stance on abortion?
For some reason, I've noticed that a vast majority of men seem to be anti-abortion. (Not that they'll ever be faced with being pregnant- the father could walk away any time he wanted to) W...


 What do you think about abortion?
I want to know what you think.

if you have myspace leave your comments here so everyone can see them... THANK!!!
Additional Details
Er, Thanks!...


 Can you get fired for doing drugs at work?
a friend did it 2 weeks ago,he smoked a little pot with 2 guys is he paranoid or if this got out could they sack him with little evidence?...


 What 2 do about constant vandalism to my car??
My Car was keyed severly in last summer and I've had 3 slashed tires in the last 6 mos. and just last month someone tried to remove my drivers side door handle...I CAN'T TAKE IT ANYMORE! I...


 Should people on welfare be allowed to have babies and maintain their wefare status.?
...


 I thought smoking cigarettes under age 18 is illegal!?
how come at almost every high school you go to there is always a group of kids ages 13-17 smoking outside? i though it was illegal! how come the school lets them do that? if they were to do drugs ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.054