Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

If you heard a noisy couple in your apt complex fighting and arguing..should you...?
Find answers to your legal question.





If you heard a noisy couple in your apt complex fighting and arguing..should you...?

stay out of their business or decide to intervine (call cops) because you think there might have been violence/abuse included. Just curious. Thanks for your answers.
Additional Details
It happens once in a while and gets pretty loud such as woman sobbing, loud noises.


    




Dual String Finance
Rating
I would definitely get the police involved if you think there might be violence or if it occurs frequently. Every couple argues or disagrees on matters, but if they are not keeping it civil, they need some wake up call to let them know their lack of control is an issue.


LaDeeDa
If you suspect that the woman has been physically assaulted, then YES. You have a civic duty to call the police.

You can read in the paper all the time about a woman who was murdered by her own husband during a "domestic squabble" that had been going on for years, and "nobody wanted to get involved."

When the police show up, the husband faces the reality that IT IS AGAINST THE LAW TO STRIKE ANOTHER PERSON.

Do it.

Make the call. And do NOT be apologetic on the phone, either. Don't treat it lightly.


mcrosstheboss
if you hear him hitting or her hitting then you call the cops


dont you just love apartments


Nyanna
Rating
If it gets really loud or too much violence going on, i'd call the police and give it as an anonymous call.


So0 In Love!
Rating
report it.


imkevlar (boycott ignorance)
Rating
If it sounds like she's getting beat you should call the cops.


GlassHalfFull
Rating
If you're worried about it, calling the cops wouldn't hurt. You won't get in trouble, they'll come check it out, they won't tell the couple who called, and maybe they'll think twice next time before getting in a big fight.


Bored Guy
You should complain to the complex manager. If they get enough complaints, they'll be evicted & have to move


AALLIISS
Rating
Call the cops, as she may be too frightened to.


tractorsturnmeon
Personally if it sounded like abuse I would call the cops...you could save someone's life and if that's not the case, it's better to be safe than sorry.


ann.natalie
I would call the cops for her sake! She may be getting abused


princesssss
report it.. by maybe it can be the woman fault. i dont know


Rockstar
Rating
i would call the cops if it happened more than once or twice.


Lusty Lush
Rating
well if you hear banging on the walls or you happen to see her with bruises.... then yes i could call the cops...


gabby =^..^=
Just call the cops


SleeplessSuz
Rating
The other answers are reasonable, it's a fine line. She's an adult and theoretically can make her own decisions, but if you feel she's been hurt, you should call the police. And, more importantly, if there are children in that home, you should call Child Protective Services. It doesn't mean they'll take the kids away, they'll need many and more exact reports, but it means they are aware that kids may be at risk (even being exposed to violence is considered abuse). Kids don't choose those environments and if their own parents won't shelter them from that than you should. My opinion.


bodmodangel
You should call the police. Say you want to remain annonymus. (don't give them your name or address). . Just say you heard it and want them to check out the situation. I have done that many times b/c of my neighbors.


Billy Ireland79
Rating
I'd ask them to keep it down at first. If they do it again, I would have someone or the cops intervene.


danaluana
I would call the police even if there is an inkling that there may be violence; you may be saving someones life. If this has been frequent happening, then there is definitely a violent/abusive pattern going on. I think you would be right to intervene. I believe it is your duty.


Xuphoria
Rating
I'd go over there with my broom and basball bat.


ashley_nunya
id be more likely to call the cops if it was disturbing everyone else..unless u thought there was violence...then dont wait too long..but its a tough call...


m1ss.underst00d
report it


janine o
Rating
I was in this situation and I called the cops every single time (5-10 times within a 2 month period). My boyfriend at the time tried to tell me to stay out of it because it wasn't my business, but I figure that if it wasn't my business, they wouldn't have been fighting so loudly to the point that I could hear them.


rtperry2
Rating
One time, my husband and I were living in a place where the couple across from us did this all the time.

Finally, we couldn't take it anymore, and called the cops. Turns out the guy had broken the woman's arm and was trying to strangle her.

Unfortunately, calling the cops is all you can do for a woman in this situation; you cannot make her leave the abuser she is with.

You have a right to live peacefully -- that should be your primary concern in this matter. If the noise bothers you, call.


8 * Second * Ride
call the cops


Zeuxis
Call local police next time it starts and tell them they make allot you hear them fighting and it happens often. They will investigate it.

Make sure you call them during the argument, otherwise there might be no point.

And for the best tell Police you want to stay anonymous.


Twilight
You need to make certain that calling the police will at least temporarily fix the problem. Unfortunately if you call the police, they arrive, and there are no visible signs of physical abuse the police can do nothing but warn them. That could in fact, lead to more violence later down the road.

So unless you can tell there is violence going on your best bet would be to notify your landlord or landlady first about the situation and let them determine what is best to do next.


Penguin
Rating
Always check to see if the walls are sound-proof before you rent. I would never get involved in someones personal business, nonetheless I would 'only' tell the landlord about MY problem and let him take whatever action he deems appropriate!


Patience
Rating
I'd call the police especially if it occurs often. I've put up with neighbors like that for several months. Couples disagree from time to time, but when I hear her crying and he becomes quite prolific with the F word I call the police.


womponoag
Rating
I would call the Apartment Manager and have him speak to them, while he is talking to them he may be able to get some insight as to whether there was abuse taking place, (i.e. brusies, blood, scratches, etc.) on either party and the decision would be up to him to call the police.


Penny Lane
Rating
honestly yeah because if ther eis some abuse going on, someone needs to do something about it. before you call the cops though, tell the person who runs the place. let them take the proper measures.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 What is your view on execution?
I think that anyone that goes to prison for murder should be sentenced to death. But not by expensive electric chairs and needles with injection fluid that costs thousands of dollars. By a bullet or ...


 My girlfriend has threatened to get a restraining order against me if I tell her Dad she is on Crystal Meth?
My drug addict girlfriend ( I just found out last week) has threatened to get a restraining order on me if I reveal to her father that she is addicted to crystal meth. Everyone I talked to says I ...


 Why do people think i am evil because i smoke.?
I want to thank all the people who answered my question on smoking ban, I am stll the same person i don't smoke where other people are i smoke in my car or home i hurt no one but myself, but ...


 Twelve year old boy, kills grandparents, sentenced to thirty years in prison. Thoughts?
Do you think that he should have been tried as a minor? He shot both of his grandparents with a shotgun as they slept, and then set fire to the house. The story is on Yahoos main page.

W...


 Pro-choice or Pro-life?
...


 How do lawyers live with themselves?
They stand up in court and try to slur and undermine honest, hardworking public officicals who are trying to make this a better country to live in, in order to get their scumbag client off the hook, ...


 Why do people still wave the confederate flag?
im not trying to be rude or ignorant, but why do people still wave that thing, yes i know its a symbol of the south but being an african american i get scared sometimes. does anyone else?...


 Do I have to tell employers if I use Medical Marijuana?
Would my employer be able to find out if I am a medical marijuana user?
Additional Details
I would NOT be under the influence while on the job....


 I thought this was a free country "y" does the president have to quit smoking?
We are supposed to be a free country and if you think about it.... we have to wear a seat belt or we get a ticket, and now we cant even have the choice to smoke or not? next we will have a curfew and ...


 Can someone please explain to me the difference between a 17 year old and 18 year old?
?
Additional Details
why is there a variation? If you are subject to the same penalty's under the law. 17 year olds should have the same rights....


 Would you spend a year in a middle-eastern prison being tortured if you think you may be compensated later?
Four years after he was tortured in a Syrian prison, a Canadian resident (Maher Arar) has finally received an official apology and $10.5 million in compensation from the Canadian government for its ...


 Can you help me settle an argument please?
I was arguing with my friend about having a tattoo on your wrist and how it would affect getting a job? Can someone choose not to hire you simply because you have a visable tattoo? Surely thats not ...


 I might be in trouble?
6 months ago a guy broke in to my home while we were asleep
i caught him in my living room when he saw me he pointed a gun at me and i shot him now he is parapligic and his family wants to sue ...


 How do I go about selling highest quality olive oil from Italy in the States?
What regulations and papers do I have to make sure to have and were and how should I sell it? It is highest quality olive oil directly from Italy, so it will be imported....


 Do you agree or disagree with the death penalty?
And how do you justify your opinion? Also, out of interest, can you say what nationality you are?...


 Should i cry to get out of a speeding ticket?
...


 Am I a hypocrite? I am a vegetarian, but last night I swallowed?
the worm in my tequila. Does that make me a hypocrite, or does a worm even count?
Additional Details
I'm pretty sure I did it on purpose, based on reading my questions from last ...


 How many other people think this is wrong....?
so i work in retail and it gets busy around this time of year like everyone knows. WELL last night i started to get a bad headache and i figured it would go away with sleep.. it didnt, i woke up at 3...


 Abortion, do you think it's ok?
If you don't think a fetus should have the same rights as everyone else, tell me why.
Additional Details
I got pregnant at age 15 and my parents adopted him.

I got ...


 What is your view on death penalty?
i was asked by someone and couldn't answer... can u? what is your opinion on the matter? i'm a 15 year old girl who is looking for answers... i'd be curious to know yours... let me ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.084