Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

Is death by lethal injection a cruel and unusual punishment?
Find answers to your legal question.





Is death by lethal injection a cruel and unusual punishment?

If murder is such a serious crime then why does the state do it?


    




agamegrl
i think the same thing
u know that the us is up there with iraq, pakistan, iran and other troubled middle eastern countries in the highest amount of executions
keeping good company, aren't we?


Mary Jo W
it is not as cruel as the death the victim suffered


Peanut Butter
Well, for those who murder, what goes around comes around. Yes I believe those who kill, should be killed. They took an innocent human life and deserved to have their life taken as well.


surfer1
Rating
Well who cares because wasn't murdering someone cruel and unusual punishment to the victim???


♥~C.J~♥
Rating
to me its to tame!! they are sleepin b4 the lethal dose goes in!!!


Joe M
Rating
Lethal injection is neither cruel OR unusual. They stick a needle in your arm and you go to sleep. The criminal dies in a much more peaceful manner than their victim did.


Top dawg
Rating
Is death by rape and stabbing a cruel and unusual punishment? I have no sympathy for the vermin who took it upon themselves to play God. Let them take their medicine.


Just ask me
If someone kills another person. they should die by the same means that they killed their victom.


Dirk D
Rating
People should be punished for their crimes.

There are no innocent people in prison (yeah right), hence no innocent people have ever been given the death sentence (yeah right again).

I would not go so far as to say the lethal injection is cruel. or unusual, but it is final.

Guess that screws up your chances of a successful appeal though.

(on the other hand, when the person is truly guilty it may give the family of the victim some closure, but I doubt that is true).


I♥Choir
Rating
no


The OB King
It should be used more widely in the world! It is not cruel.


dead
Yes.

The rates of murder in the USA where the death penalty is enforced, is HIGHER than in states where the death penalty doesn't exist.

Incredible, but true.

This proves the death penalty is not only pointless, but therefore doubly cruel and disgusting - and I am ashamed that America still has this policy of hypocrisy.

You don't preach to no man of the 'wrongs' of murder, if by doing this, you follow their same sin - murder!


Taz
People who kill people and are sentenced to death,
Should be put to death the same way that they killed...

Why should us taxpayers have to support these Convicts while they get a higher education on our tax dollars...

I am all for capitol punishment....


I_Walk_Point
Rating
No. Lethal injection is not cruel or unusual, particularly since it is used so sparingly. The state does not commit murder since the individual who is being killed is losing his/her life as a consequence for committing a horrible crime. The act is neither arbitrary nor capricious. They have had a chance to appeal, the appeals have failed, now they have their sentence imposed.

Maybe they should have considered the consequence before committing the crime.


margarita
Electrocution, firing squad or hanging would be more cruel and unusual than lethal injection.


prettygal32002
they inject that when they know a person hasn't got long to live anyway.its to stop them suffering i guess. but wen a person murders someone there taking there whole life away..

its not punishment. they see it as the best for them.

like my mum she was ill for a very long time and in feb just gone she was admitted to hospital but those few days she was there she was adiment she was not giving up,but it got to much for her and couldn't take the pain anymore so she asked the doctors for the morphine after giving that injection she lasted for a further 2 days. then she passed on 17th feb..

at the time i thought the injection was a bad idea but lookin bak on it now.its better to know she didnt have to suffer anymore...


poopsie
Rating
if someone rapes and murders children, they should have the same done to them, injections, are the sissy way out, and it's mainly gay rights, that's against the death penalty, I say an eye for an eye, that's the way it should be, the fair way,and take the corrupt judge's right along with them,


daljack -a girl
Rating
I think capital punishment is wrong.....I think if you kill someone you should have to stay in jail until you die.

To me that's worse than dying.


Adeptus Astartes
Rating
Its stupid yeah! Why spend hundreds of dollars on poison when a damn machete would do the job just fine.
And what the hell is all that about putting alcohol on the needle! So you get an infecton big effing deal your gonna be dead in 5 minutes who cares if you get a little rash.
Your gonna die either way!


Ava
Rating
Anyone that gets the death sentence has done something really bad. I think lethal injection is to good for some of them.L/I is a much easier death then their victims were given I'm sure.Cruel and unusual punishment? You have got to be kidding. Should they be kept in a prison for the rest of their life so they can enjoy cable TV. a workout gym,laying around most of the day and being taken care of by the state?I don't think so. They should be put to death right away and stop wasting the states money. If they get back out( which most of them do) many just go back and commit their crimes again.Think of hanging or the electric chair. These are much worse. Even then, they deserve to be put down. Just like any other animal that has gone mad and killed someone.


davetherave
Rating
The method of execution,is not the punish-meant for the killer. Knowing Where,When,and How is the true Penalty!


Yo it's Me
Rating
I think being chopped up into pieces in an industrial shredder with your family watching (like Saddam use to do to people) is cruel and unusual. Or any of the crazy things the Brits use to do, like drawing and quartering.

Being put to sleep doesn't seem too cruel, I've had several needles in the past few years, and they hardly hurt at all. As for being unusual, it seems to be the favored and most common (usual) form of capital punishment so not unusual at all.


Benn :]
Why do we kill people who kill people to show that killing people is wrong?


m3styles
Rating
Nope you die like if your going to sleep so next time you sleep make sure there is nothing in your arm


Korky
An eye for an eye, cut out all the paraphernalia,
if its first degree then a shot in the head is cheap and all they deserve


Samm
Rating
Not at all.


lymanspond
The standard needs to change from reasonable doubt at the trial to guilty to an absolute certainty......then the death penalty should be sought at that point....
If the crime is so heinous, cruel and the perp(aka Skell) is guilty
why can't the US Constitution be used as a shield for the victims..........when this person enters jail, is he likely to change for the better?probably not .....so other people in jail are at risk of death at his hands.....throw the switch and move on....


THE DAWG.
nope Kill And Be Killed Good Deal


Jason S
Not at all. There is nothing cruel about letting you fall asleep and then drift off to your death. I hope I die in my sleep personally when the time comes.


atypical
Rating
yes


Sasha
No, it is not cruel. What about the victims that were murdered? It is less painful. I think when a murderer is convicted. They should take him to the room and get it over with. We pay for these criminals to sit in jail.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Why is there a law that if you are 14 and your boyfriend is 18 y will he be arrested?
...


 AM i RELATED TO THIS GIRL?
know i asked this before , i got different answers so i dont know who to believe

i don't want you to tell me what you think , i want you to tell me the truth , someone said im her ...


 Hanging should they bring it back?
should they bring back hanging for child molesters and muderers???...


 I need advice because my neighbors (I think below me) are smoking pot and it comes up into my apartment.?
Short of taping up my vents, I don't know what to do. Should I tell the landlord? The police? I am just affraid of retaliation....


 Why do you think that gay marriage was legalized in california butnot in other states?
...


 Im 18 and received an illegal consumption ticket I blew a .243 is there anyway to get this off my record?
I'm trying to avoid telling my parents. I received a ticket for underage drinking. I blew the .243 and am fine with the ticket but was wondering if I could get this off my record. Thanks for ...


 I don't think I am going to participate in this any longer!!?
Most the people who answer questions on here are either overtly racist and have no concept of other religions or cultures, or are just completely unaware of anything past their nose. I thought this ...


 What should I do about my contractor building next door and has torn down my fence?
The contractor who built my home is now developing a complex , behind my home.,of 15-18 townhomes to sell. He went past the property line the city just surveyed , with a back hoe he knocked my fence ...


 Should overweight Americans be allowed to sue junk food vendors?
explain please. sources??...


 What punishment should a convict get for killing a 9 month pregnant women?
http://en.wikipedia.org/...


 What punishment do you think rapists should get?
What country r u from and what punishment do they get in your country? Do you think its too leneant? If yes, what do you think they should get? I personally think they should be castrated.. Then put ...


 Ok... is it illegal to marry someone when there is a 27 year difference?
ok also: do not ask me what age we are because it does not matter... i am simply asking if it is illegal or legal
Additional Details
ok i am only 13 now and its a celebrity haha but im DE...


 If someone steals money from an unlocked drawer is that a crime?
I stay in a dorm. I have a roommate, I do not know him. We have seperate rooms, almost like an apartment but no doors leading into the bedrooms.

One day I had gone out to class for most ...


 Do you think states should have the right to stop people from smoking in their own homes and vehicles ??
I can understand in a public place and all but this is a question for smokers and non-smokers because if your telling someone that you cannot smoke in your own home then why not tell someone that ...


 If you heard a noisy couple in your apt complex fighting and arguing..should you...?
stay out of their business or decide to intervine (call cops) because you think there might have been violence/abuse included. Just curious. Thanks for your answers.
Additional Details
I...


 Are You For Or Against The Death Penalty? ?
Im doing a class project and needed to get some answers to this question by a few anonymous people. Please explain why your for or against it. :)...


 Should all alcoholic drink be banned in the UK until we can sort out the under age drinking issue ?
I believe that the care and welfare of our children should come before any other concern for peoples right to have a drink.
Additional Details
I wish people would read the question ...


 What do you think this sign mean?
There was a sign we saw and just couldn't figure out what it meant, we were going to park there for a baseball game, but decided not to risk it. The sign said:

No Parking (it was ...


 A speed camera caught me doing 63mph through a 30 zone, I hate speed cameras, shouldn't they be banned?
I was late for work, I needed to go that fast
This country is turning into a police ...


 What would you do if you were being held up?...?
A criminal says" GIVE ME YOUR WALLET"!, it is midnight no one around,no place to run,the attacker has a large knife,you are carrying a legal concealed weapon.What do you do?
A...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.084