Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

Is it legal to make your own currency?
Find answers to your legal question.





Is it legal to make your own currency?

I saw something a while back on TLC, Discovery, or The History Channel on currency and heard them say that you are legally allowed to make your own currency, but it is up to the place you try to use it at to actually accept it or not. I have a friend, however, who says he saw something on one of the same channels stating that you can not make your own currency. If anyone has an answer, can you leave me a link to some solid evidence.

OK, this is my second post because I didn't phrase it best the first time. What I mean is to create my own currency not copy the american dollar, since that is counterfeiting and highly illegal. Example: I make a coin named the whatchamacallit that bares no resemblance to any US coin and take it to a mom and pop store to buy a soda. They ring up the soda and say that'll be $1.19. Then I say how about I give you 1 whatchamacallit instead. If they accept it, then my 1 whatchamacallit is equal to $1.19 US dollars there.


    




corwynwulfhund
Rating
Ever heard of Disney money? Monopoly money? You can make it, just so long as it doesn't resemble official money from any country. That doesn't mean that it will be accepted because it is not legal tender. You can try using your whatchamacallit, or an apple, or a dirt clod, or a bar of gold. That doesn't mean that they will accept it (they may take the bar of gold...lol).

The value of anything is what it can be traded for. This includes legal tender, though that tends to be a bit more standardized.


ruth
Rating
I don' t have a link to solid answer, but I am supposing that in US, since the Fed has pre-empted the issue by issuing its own currency, I would suggest that you would only be able to issue your own "non-legal tender," such as businesses might use as coupons, etc.

Oh, and there has not been actual gold or silver backing US money for quite a few years now (it's the literal cause of inflation).

Thanks, Pam, but don't forget, folks, bartering is still to be considered as income for tax purposes!


aflownes
Rating
well okay this is kinda tricky. Yes you can make your own currency, but you have to have in place people who will accept it, kinda like the pepsi or coke caps you redeem to get a free coke some will take it others wont.


Jack S
Yeah you can. But the only reason why USD is worth anything is because the US Gov. says it is. If one were to make money more than likely its not going to be worth much b/c other ppl wouldnt care what you say its worth.


Tom W
Rating
Everyone thinks this means making U.S. Currency but the question is can you make a currency that has value and can be used to buy goods? Yeah, coupons are like currency in that you can use them to purchase items. Precious metals are like currency in that you can trade them in for U.S. or any other country. Coal mines used to pay in company currency that could only be used at company stores and it was a way of controlling the work force and keep them in debt. I don't think you can make a standard currency and distribute it to everyone to use in place of regular money. No one would take it anyhow.


Pam
The constitution:

Article I, Section 8, Clause 5. The Congress shall have Power…To coin Money, regulate the Value thereof, and of foreign Coin, and fix the Standard of Weights and Measures.

You are certainly free to barter your goods for other services. If you're a mechanic, you can fix someone's car if they install your toilet for you, for example. Bartaring is legal.


cherox
Yes you can make your own currency provided you do not pass it of as the regular currency. In your example, you are using your currency instead of the dollar. That is within the purview of counterfeiting.

Instead of buying with it, make a deal or barter or exchange. You can use anything for exchange or barter.


crossstitchkelly
The key words are, "if they accept it." If they realize that it's not legal tender (put out by the government), but they accept it in change, it would be the same as bartering--I'll take this in exchange for that.


chris42050
Rating
No Purlce you are wrong. The United States along with most of the world WAS on the Gold Standard. We have since dissolved the gold standard. Money is no longer associated with gold in that way. Look it up.


Love always, Kortnei
You can make your own currency as long as ur not duplicating legal tender...but I doubt many people would accept your currency


bluffmike
Your watchumacallit has to be redeemable for goods and services. The last time I heard of people making their own script was to get around some IRS bartering laws.


dukalink6000
Rating
Trick question.

You obviously cannot print your own currency that looks like US money.

If you wish to engage in a barter system, or make your own money, as long as they are willing to agree to it, it is OK.

ther was a man who made his money as artwork and used it as barter, but it was a tough sell. (I saw this on TV, but I can't remeember where)


2eighty8
Rating
You probably can, but it won't be worth any more than the piece of paper it's printed on.


d2pain
Rating
I dont know for sure but if you try to use it, you'll see a boat load of secret service agents at your door


boykin0308
Rating
It is legal but you have to pay taxes on it.


kapute2
Rating
it's called counterfeiting, the reason the secret service exists is to arrest those guys


nbr660
Rating
Keep dreamin'


Heather
Rating
hmm..I've not heard of this....doesn't seem quite right to me, otherwise I think someone would have done it b4 now...


purelce
Rating
I just had this discussion with my boyfriend.

No, you can't make your own currency because the american currency has gold behind every penny, nickel, dime, quarter and dollar.

If anybody could make their own money, don't you think we'd all do it? If we could do that we wouldn't have anybody poor, and everyone would be richer then crap.

You have to have something behind a currency to create it. That's why the US is so rich, because we were the land of gold. Gold is the standard currency, but we print money instead of using the gold.


Sammmy
Well as far as currency used in stores, I work for a major department store chain (the largest) and as rewards they give out their in store currency that we can use to purchase items in the store. Each one is worth 1 US Dollar. Legal or not, I dont know but we do it.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Can you be held responsible?
I am a member of a swim and tennis club. On some holiday's the club might provide one batch of frozen alcoholic drinks. Then other members chip in and buy some more. If someone has too much to ...


 Pre-employment drug test?
I got a job as a security guard for a private security company in NJ....they told me that i have to come back tomorrow to take a drug test in the office.....Is it even legal for them to make me take ...


 Is it legal to tazor someone with handcuffs on?
my friend is 17 and the other nite he was walkin home and the police stopped him and asked him where he was goin. he said he was heading home then the officer asked to search him. he did and found he ...


 I'm like everyone else, I nick stuff from work, what about you?
Some survey or other revealed most people didn't regard stealing things from work as a crime.
My dad nicked stuff (in spite of being a strong believer in law and order),
I nick stuff.<...


 For or against death penalty?

Additional Details
reasons y you are for or against? please help me!!!!...


 Is this an over-the-top arrest for a 'trifling' crime?
I mean covering fruit with custard never got Fanny Craddock in trouble with the police!

http://uk.news.yahoo.com
...


 Council housing?
I am a single, 26 year old on a low income, I have no dependents, I am born in the Uk and have no disabilities, am I entitled to Council Housing? If not is there any other way I can get housing?...


 One of the muslims in my school said "i'll blow you up". Im mad about it.. should i report him to the FBI?
we were argueing and then he said "i'll blow you up" and he is muslim..and he looks like an arab. Will it ruin his life if i report him to the FBI? I would like to do that..
A...


 Abortion = murder : Murder of a pregnant woman = double homicide?
Think about this.
Additional Details
I believe abortion isnt murder but killing a pregnant woman is double homicide. Wierd huh?...


 What do you think can be done about the crime situation in America? Where would you begin to solve our problem
What do you think can be done about the crime situation in America? Where would you begin to solve our problems? What do you think are the most important places to begin battling this tremendous ...


 Given his past ethics with the Clintons,. do you feel offended the Nobel Committee awarded Al Gore a prize?

Additional Details
you liberals really give me a good bellylaugh...HE WAS THE VICE PRESIDENT for god sakes...you dont think he had anything to do with travelgate, filegate, whitewater, ...


 Can I sue?
I hired a pet sitter who was supposed to come 4 times a day and only came twice a day. She did take care of my dog, he was fed, watered, etc. but did not give him the agreed upon times. Can I sue ...


 Do you believe everyone is equal in the court of law?
...


 How do you feel about THE SUPREME COURT RULING ON GUNS?
Opinions, thoughts, input and your feelings?
Additional Details
I found it interesting that 4 of 9 voted against it. That is actually a frightening thought.

So let me get ...


 Is it not time we brought back hanging.?
We are all ways being told we live in a caring society. I don’t think so. It is not much comfort to the family of the police officer who was murdered yesterday in the line of duty, to know his killer ...


 Why do they use alcohol swabs for lethal injections?
...


 Is it illegal to fake your own death?
...


 If my boss threatens to put a spear through the back of my head on a regular basis should I get a lawyer?
...


 Why is it "illegal" to remove those tags from pillows and mattresses?
According to those tags, it is a legal violation to remove those tags. Why on earth would that be?
Additional Details
Haha, yes, this is a hard-hitting, thought-provoking question. I ...


 Whats your opinion on the death penalty?
...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.034