Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

Is it legal to videotape a group of people without them knowing it?
Find answers to your legal question.





Is it legal to videotape a group of people without them knowing it?



    




theperson
Rating
i say go for it


Caprikorn
Hey, if it's on public property then all is fair!


-^Chris^-
No, it's not illegal to video tape people in PUBLIC places.
Even if they ask you to stop filming them, you don't have to.
How do you think the Paparazzi make such a good living?
But, it would be better & safer for yourself to get a signed consent form, just to cover your own bases.


~The*Sexy*Girl*Downstairs~
Only if they are outside already in public view.


Selentic
Media and movies do it all the time.


barrmulio
it's not illegal

It's constitutionally protected right under the First Amendment to photograph and video in a public place. These rights are rooted in the First Amendment's strong protection of speech within "public forums." A "public forum" refers to a public place historically associated with free expression. The most commonly recognized examples include streets, sidewalks and parks. Within these areas, the government's ability to limit the public's speech is extremely limited.


Eldude
Rating
Depends on your state law.... Here in New York, you can if your taping from your own property or in a public place. Such as a ball game, motorcycle rally, historical reenactment, etc. However you may run into problems if you wish to use said tape for profit or commercial reasons.

If your setting your camera to invade a persons privacy, such as "up skirt" or cleavage shots. You may be in violation of the law.


?
I believe so, as long as you are in public anyway. How else can you explain those paparazzi? Photos, videos it's all the same. I look at it this way, if it is something I don't want other to see, I don't do it in public.


rogueriverbob
Rating
the supreme Court has ruled, that in public, you have no expectation of privacy,....but if the people you are video taping are in their home, that could be another story,.....


Georgia
Rating
Yes, but it is illegal to record the sound without them knowing.


Lucky Charmz
Rating
Quite frankly, NO!!!


A K
Rating
it depends on what state u live in what u'll do with the info.


Darby
Rating
I think it depends on where the people are and what you end up doing with the videotape.


sensible_man
Depends on what they are doing and where they are at. You could be arrested for invasion of privacy.


Mz_Monroe
No but it depends on what the people are doing and where they are and what you're going to do with the video tape.


Marshall MMMDCCLXXXVIII
Rating
No
Unless they are breaking the law


pdc5200
I dont think so aslong you are not doing anything bad


imissmahboo
if its in a public place yes - as long as they are all over the age of 18 - inside your house its legal also - as long as they are over 18 -

they had a thing on tv one time where the girls father had a video camera in her room hooked up to the internet - and you could go to a link and watch her and she didnt know - the police said they couldnt do anything - because she is over 18 and they are in his house - crazy sick shyt -


Runa
Rating
It depends. In public they are free game. In the privacy of their homes, filming them would likely get you sued.


hensleyclaw
Yes it is against the law to video tape a person without DISCLOSURE. That is why when you drive into the parking lot of your favorite store, you see a sign up saying that security cameras are in use. This puts you on notice that you are being taped.

Keep that in mind when your kid needs a spanking, wait till you get home or it will be on the national news.


Jazmine
noo of course not!!


Jim H
Of course it is illegal. Every time there is a Houston Astros baseball game the people in the stands are taped. Some little guy runs around and gets every one of the 38,000 people attending it to sign permission.
Or when the Boston Marathon is run, all 200,000 people watching it have given permission.
Unless of course you are trying to hide something you are up to. Is that what you meant?
My best answer is this: How the heck would anyone on here know the answer to that for every state?


allure
Rating
It is just as long as you don't use it for something they're totally not gonna like..


I'M NOT ON A DIET!!!
that's really weird and creepy.

please answer my question:
http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20070914200316AAgqKTH&pa=FYd1D2bwHTHwLLNuFu84SO42u265VaKg2miURUtafMNISFI_W8nVh0qRSnVNkLlgQx8nvqvyhTC2jw--&paid=asked&msgr_status=


Tyler M
kinda, thats kind of sick?


Devilskillz
Rating
sure its even illigal to take a pic of someone without him knowing it, thats why ur phone camera has to make a noise when u take a pic & u cant turn the sound off


Serena Muze
yea it is its against they're rights especially if its going on the internet or put in a movie etc


Dan S
No that is an invasion of privacy.

It can be done if you are trying to record illegal activity, but without a warrant that tape is not admissible in a court of law.

You could post a sign saying, "Warning Video Cameras are in use on this Property" that would be a valid warning if the sign is clearly posted and then you can use the film to support a legal case. It will still be hard to get it admitted as evidence in a court though.


stumpedinphx
Rating
It is definitely illegal.


warez
Rating
it is illegal...you could get arrested so don't you perv!!!





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 What do you think about the legalization of Gay marriage in California?
Do you accept and support this, or do you condemn and abhor it. How do you think this will affect the future of Gay rights for the United States? Will other states follow California's path? How ...


 Is Suicide Illegal? You can't punish someone who's dead, and a failed suicide isn't suicide. What say You?
...


 What is your dream country to live in, and why?
ive always wondered about this. where other people want to be!!...


 What is the silliest thing that someone has sued over?
...


 I just went to donate blood today, but because i'm gay, i wasnt allowed to. IS THAT LEGAL!!?!?!?!?!?!?!?
...


 Can police go in home with no warrant?
in my question earlier i failed to say that his 16 year old daughter did NOT let them in ... she heard a knock and unlocked the door assuming it was us but NEVER said come in !...


 I got my friend arrested and now feel guilty?
I was in Harvey Nichols with a friend yesterday and and we were trying on clothes that we couldn't afford. The problem was that I saw this fantastic argyle sweater, and knew that I HAD to have ...


 What would happen if California broke away from America?
California by itself is larger than France. loll.
We make all the movies that the whole country watches.
We legalize medical weed but we ban smoking indoors and soon all the other states ...


 Have you ever STALKED someone?

Additional Details
no, i'm not a stalker and i've never been ...


 I had my husband arrested for assault and it now has to go to court i want to drop the charges do i still go?
Do i still have to go to court if i want to drop the charges against him and we already have a court ...


 Should smoking be made illegal?
the government want people to stop smoking why just not make it illegal? i know its unlikely as they would loose millions in tax but they would loose that money anyway if people stop by themselfs. ...


 I was arrested the other night with 23 grams of marijuana in alabama. I also had some paraphenalia, any time?
I also had some papers, a one hitter, and a dugout. Will I do time?...


 Legally can a hospital refuse to take a patient?
My mother was taken to an emergency room with a head injury. The ER/hospital didn't have a head trauma unit and began making the necessary calls to transfer her to another hospital. After an ...


 Do you think banning smoking in resturants is unconstitutional?
i think it is, in the constitution, it says that government can't mess with business, and now the government is telling us that we have to go 15 feel away from any window door or air intake? ...


 What nationality is my daughter?
my daughter was born last october in London but I am french and my husband dual french/algerian.we have been in the UK for 11 and 10 years respectively.my husband got permanent residence since ...


 Do I have a case against the Mars company?
I want to sue them for false advertising. I recently found a fun sized bag of M&Ms on my desk at work. Well, i was like, OOH! M&Ms!. However, upon reaching the last M&M, I realized that I ...


 Smoking ban?
I read in the paper today, the government were trying to stop smoking in our own homes/////////
What do you think about this?...


 Do you think 9-11 was an inside job?
Just curious - I'm not stating my opinion either way.
Additional Details
Hmm..I'm just watching something on the History channel, don't know why asking a poll type ...


 Do you believe that prison rehabilitates criminals?
i think not......


 My daughter just told me a terrrible, terrible secret....who do I go to?
My daughter just told me that her friend at school who is 11 is pregnant by her father.....and that this is the second time this has happened. She told me the girl is abused by both her mother and ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.024